题名

貿易開放對經濟成長的影響－整合分析之應用

并列篇名

TRADE OPENNESS AND ECONOMIC GROWTH: A META-ANALYSIS

作者

林馨怡(Hsin-Yi Lin)；王靖筑(Ching-Chu Wang)

关键词

貿易開放 ； 經濟成長 ； 整合分析 ； Trade openness ； Economic growth ； Meta-analysis

期刊名称

經濟論文

卷期/出版年月

46卷4期（2018 / 12 / 01）

页次

555 - 596

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本文使用整合分析（meta-analysis）方法探討貿易開放對經濟成長之影響，以分析現有文獻對此議題的爭論。我們納入所有與主題相關文獻，整合分析後發現，一國貿易開放顯著地有助於經濟成長，但貿易開放效果會依資料類型、文章是否已發表、文章使用何種貿易開放指標、以及研究對象有所不同。以非洲國家為樣本的文獻指出，貿易開放對經濟成長的重要性遠高於其他國家樣本，亦即，窮困落後國家的貿易開放政策對其國家經濟成長扮演重要角色。此外，此議題之樣本文獻具有異質性與出版偏誤問題，經由整合迴歸分析後，我們發現文章使用的貿易開放指標、資料型態、國家數目、或樣本數不同皆可能是造成樣本文獻變異來源，而非洲國家或開發中國家的貿易開放效果可能被過度放大。
英文摘要

This paper uses a meta-analysis to investigate the relationship between trade openness and economic growth. Our results reveal that there is a significant genuine effect of openness on growth. This effect depends on the type of data, openness indicators, and countries of the articles used. For example, the impact of openness on growth is higher in the African countries, which implies that the trade policy is far more important in poor countries. We also find evidence of problems of heterogeneity and publication bias in the literature. The resulting meta-regression results show that the studies considered are different with respect to the openness indicator used, the type of data, the number of countries, and the sample of countries. The openness effects in African and other developing countries may be over magnified.
主题分类 社會科學 > 經濟學
参考文献
  1. 林馨怡、陳佩玗(2010)。通貨膨脹與貿易開放性之關係－分量迴歸於追蹤資料的應用。經濟論文，38(1)，1-32。
    連結：
  2. Adhikary, B. K.(2015).Dynamic Effects of FDI, Trade Openness, Capital Formation and Human Capital on the Economic Growth Rate in the Least Developed Economies: Evidence from Nepal.International Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance,6(1),1-7.
  3. Ahmed, A. D.(2016).Integration of Financial Markets, Financial Development and Growth: Is Africa Different?.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,42,43-59.
  4. Andriamananjara, S.,Nash, J.(1997).Policy Research Working PaperPolicy Research Working Paper,未出版
  5. Anzures-Cabrera, J.,Higgins, J.(2010).Graphical Displays for Meta-Analysis: An Overview with Suggestions for Practice.Research Synthesis Methods,1,66-80.
  6. Asfaw, H. A.(2015).Trade Policy and Economic Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Panel Data Approach.American Journal of Trade and Policy,2(1),7-14.
  7. Ashenfelter, O.,Harmon, C.,Oosterbeek, H.(1999).A Review of Estimates of the Schooling/ Earnings Relationship, with Tests for Publication Bias.Labour Economics,6,453-470.
  8. Auguste, B. G.(1997).The Economics of International Payments Unions and Clearing Houses.London:Palgrave Macmillan.
  9. Barro, R. J.(2003).Determinants of Economic Growth in a Panel of Countries.Annals of Economics and Finance,4,231-274.
  10. Batten, J. A.,Vo, X. V.(2009).An Analysis of the Relationship between Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth.Applied Economics,41,1621-1641.
  11. Bernanke, B. S.(ed.),Rogoff, K.(ed.)(2001).NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2000.Boston, MA:MIT Press.
  12. Bonnal, M.,Yaya, M. E.(2015).Political Institutions, Trade Openness, and Economic Growth: New Evidence.Emerging Markets Finance & Trade,51,1276-1291.
  13. Cabral, R.,Mollick, A. V.(2012).Convergence Rates to Output Growth in a Global World: The Roles of Openness and Government Size.The International Trade Journal,26,201-222.
  14. Calderón, C.,Fuentes, R.(2006).Complementarities between Institutions and Openness in Economic Development: Evidence for a Panel of Countries.Cuadernos De Economía,43,49-80.
  15. Cieślik, A.,Tarsalewska, M.(2011).External Openness and Economic Growth in Developing Countries.Review of Development Economics,15(4),729-744.
  16. Coxhead. I.(ed.)(2014).Handbook of Southeast Asian Development.Cheltenham:Elgar.
  17. Daumal, M.,Özyurt, S.(2011).The Impact of International Trade Flows on Economic Growth in Brazilian States.Review of Economics and Institutions,2(1)
  18. de Groot, M. A. H.,Florax, R.(2005).Meta-Analysis of Beta-Convergence: The Legendary 2%.Journal of Economic Surveys,19(3),389-420.
  19. Dean, J.,Desai, S.,Riedel, J.(1994).Trade Policy Reform in Developing Countries Since 1985: A Review of the Evidence.World Bank.
  20. Didia, D.,Freeman, P.,Assad, J.,Yuan, J.(2015).Foreign Capital, Domestic Policy, and Economic Growth: The Case of Nigeria.Journal of Applied Economics and Business Research,5(4),233-244.
  21. Ding, S. and J. Knight (2008), “Why Has China Grown so Fast? The Role of Structural Change,” Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of Oxford.
  22. Dollar, D.(1992).Outward-Oriented Developing Economies Really Do Grow More Rapidly: Evidence from 95 LDCs, 1976-1985.Economic Development and Cultural Change,40(3),523-544.
  23. Dollar, D.,Kraay, A.(2004).Trade, Growth, and Poverty.The Economic Journal,114(493),F22-F49.
  24. Doucouliagos, C.(2005).Publication Bias in the Economic Freedom and Economic Growth Literature.Journal of Economic Surveys,19(3),367-387.
  25. Doucouliagos, H.,Stanley, T. D.(2009).Publication Selection Bias in Minimum-Wage Research? A Meta-Regression Analysis.British Journal of Industrial Relations,47(2),406-428.
  26. Doucouliagos, H.,Ulubasoglu, M. A.(2008).Democracy and Economic Growth: A Meta-Analysis.American Journal of Political Science,52(1),61-83.
  27. Dufrenot, G.,Mignon, V.,Tsangarides, C.(2009).CEPII Working PapersCEPII Working Papers,未出版
  28. Edwards, S.(1998).Openness Productivity and Growth: What Do We Really Know?.The Economic Journal,108(447),383-398.
  29. Fernández Puente, A. C.,Calvo, M. Bengoa,Poncela, A. Carrera(2009).How Changes in International Trade Affect African Growth?.Economic Analysis Working Papers,8(1),1-17.
  30. Frankel, J. A.,Romer, D.(1999).Does Trade Cause Growth?.American Economic Review,89(3),379-399.
  31. Gilbert, N.(2004).Working Paper, CERDIWorking Paper, CERDI,未出版
  32. Glass, G. V.(1976).Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research.Educational Researcher,5(10),3-8.
  33. Greenway, D.,Morgan, W.,Wright, P.(1998).Trade Reform, Adjustment and Growth: What Does the Evidence Tell Us?.The Economic Journal,108(450),1547-1561.
  34. Harrison, A.(1996).Openness and Growth: A Time-Series, Cross-Country Analysis for Developing Countries.Journal of Development Economics,48,419-447.
  35. Iwasaki, I.,Tokunaga, M.(2014).Macroeconomic Impacts of FDI in Transition Economies: A Meta-Analysis.World Development,61,53-69.
  36. Kali, J.,Méndez, F.,Reyes, J.(2007).Trade Structure and Economic Growth.Journal of International Trade & Economic Development,16(2),245-269.
  37. Karras, G.(2003).Trade Openness and Economic Growth Can We Estimate the Precise Effect?.Applied Econometrics and International Development,3(1),7-25.
  38. Klomp, J.,de Haan, J.(2010).Inflation and Central Bank Independence: A Meta-Regression Analysis.Journal of Economic Surveys,24(4),593-621.
  39. Lagares, O. (2013), “Domestic and Imported Capital, Economic Growth and Relative Income Differences in Latin America,” Working Paper, Department of Economics and Related Studies, University of York.
  40. Leamer, E.(1988).Trade Policy Issues and Empirical Analysis.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
  41. Lee, J. W.(1993).International Trade, Distortions, and Long-Run Economic Growth.International Monetary Fund Staff Papers,40(2),299-328.
  42. Levine, R.,Renelt, D.(1992).A Sensitivity Analysis of Cross-Country Growth Regressions.The American Economic Review,82(4),942-963.
  43. Light, R. J.,Smith, P. V.(1971).Accumulating Evidence: Procedures for Resolving Contradictions among Different Research Studies.Harvard Educational Review,41(4),429-471.
  44. Lin, J. Y.(2003).Development Strategy, Viability, and Economic Convergence.Economic Development and Cultural Change,51(2),277-308.
  45. Mckenzie, D. J.(2001).The Impact of Capital Controls on Growth Convergence.Journal of Economic Development,26(1),1-25.
  46. Merikas, A.,Vozilis, G. S.,Merikas, A.(2000).Trade Openness and Economic Growth Revisited.The Journal of Applied Business Research,6(3),75-86.
  47. Muraraṣu, B.,Bobaṣu, A.(2015).Trade Openness and Output Comovement in EU Emerging Countries: A Panel Data Approach.Journal of Eastern Europe Research in Business and Economics,2015
  48. Naude,W. A.(2004).The Effects of Policy, Institutions and Geography on Economic Growth in Africa: An Econometric Study Based on Cross-Section and Panel Data.Journal of International Development,16,821-849.
  49. Nduka, E. K.(2013).Openness and Economic Growth in Nigeria.Journal of Education and Practice,4(1),68-74.
  50. Nguyen, H. T.(2010).University of Colorado at Boulder.
  51. Ogede, J. S.(2013).Openness and Economic Performance in Sub-Saharan African Countries. Evidence from Time-Series and Cross-Sectional Analyses.Journal of Business Management and Applied Economics,2(5),1-16.
  52. Peasah, N. A.,John, B. E.(2016).Analysis of the Nexus between Trade Liberalization and Economic Growth: A Panel Study of Brics Countries.Business and Economic Research,6(2),455-471.
  53. Rahman, M. M.,Shahbaz, M.,Farooq, A.(2015).Financial Development, International Trade and Economic Growth in Australia: New Evidence from Multivariate Framework Analysis.Journal of Asia-Pacific Business,16(1),21-43.
  54. Razmi, M. J.,Refaei, R.(2013).The Effect of Trade Openness and Economic Freedom on Economic Growth: The Case of Middle East and East Asian Countries.International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues,3(2),376-385.
  55. Romer, P. M.(1990).Endogenous Technological Change.Journal of Political Economy,98(5),S71-S102.
  56. Sachs, J. D.,Warner, A.(1995).Economic Reform and the Process of Global Integration.Brooking Papers on Economic Activity,26(1),1-118.
  57. Shahbaz, M.(2012).Does Trade Openness Affect Long Run Growth? Cointegration, Causality and Forecast Error Variance Decomposition Tests for Pakistan.Economic Modelling,29,2325-2339.
  58. Stanley, T. D.(2001).Wheat from Chaff: Meta-Analysis as Quantitative Literature Review.The Journal of Economic Perspectives,15(3),131-150.
  59. Stanley, T. D.(2005).Beyond Publication Bias.Journal of Economic Surveys,19(3),309-345.
  60. Stanley, T. D.(2008).Meta-Regression Methods for Detecting and Estimating Empirical Effects in the Presence of Publication Selection.Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics,70(1),103-127.
  61. Stanley, T. D.,Doucouliagos, C.,Jarrell, S.B.(2008).Meta-regression analysis as the socio-economics of economics research.The Journal of Socio-Economics,37,276-292.
  62. Stanley, T. D.,Jarrell, S. B.(1989).Meta-Regression Analysis: A Quantitative Method of Literature Surveys.Journal of Economic Surveys,19(3),299-308.
  63. Subasat, T.(2003).Does the Dollar Index Really Measure Outward Orientation?.International Review of Applied Economics,17(3),309-326.
  64. Tahir, M.,Azid, T.(2015).The Relationship between International Trade Openness and Economic Growth in the Developing Economies: Some New Dimensions.Journal of Chinese Economic and Foreign Trade Studies,8(2),123-139.
  65. Trued, M. N.,Mikesell, R. F.(1955).Postwar Bilateral Payments Agreements.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  66. Wacziarg, R.(2001).Measuring the Dynamic Gains from Trade.World Bank Economic Review,15(3),393-429.
  67. Wacziarg, R.,Welch, K. H.(2008).Trade Liberalization and Growth: New Evidence.World Bank Economic Review,22(2),187-231.
  68. Warner, A.M. (2003), “OnceMore into the Breach: Economic Growth and Global Integration,” Working Paper, Harvard University.
  69. Wolf, H.(1993).Trade Orientation: Measurement and Consequences.Estudios de Economia,20,49-86.
  70. World Bank(1993).World Development Report 1993.New York:Oxford University Press.
  71. World Bank(1987).World Development Report 1987.New York:Oxford University Press.
  72. Yang, L.,Sobolevski, V.(2016).Jonkoping University..
  73. Yanikkaya, H.(2003).Trade Openness and Economic Growth: A Cross-Country Empirical Investigation.Journal of Development Economics,72,57-89.
print cancel