貿易報復下的資源錯置分析－以中國太陽能產業為例

RESOURCE MISALLOCATION UNDER TRADE RETALIATIONS: CASE OF CHINESE SOLAR ENERGY INDUSTRY

李文傑(Wen-Chieh Lee)；李浩仲(Hao-Chung Li)；王信實(Shinn-Shyr Wang)

「雙反」（反傾銷、反補貼） ； 資源錯置 ； 總要素生產力 ； Antidumping duty ； Countervailing duties ； Resource misallocation ； Total factor productivity

經濟論文

49卷2期（2021 / 06 / 01）

245 - 283

繁體中文

以太陽能替代傳統化石能源發電一直為中國政府的產業政策重點，然而政府的強力介入也引發2011年「反傾銷」和「反補貼」的「雙反」調查。本文建立中國太陽能光電企業資料庫，並藉由計算中國太陽能廠商資源配置扭曲，將個別廠商資源投入扭曲程度加總成太陽能產業內的總資源錯置程度。計算結果顯示，中國太陽能產業在政府的保護補貼下存在相當程度的資源配置扭曲。實證結果也顯示，在「雙反」事件後，資源配置扭曲當中的「產出扭曲」分布改善，然而主要影響產業生產力的「資本投入扭曲」並無顯著變化，這樣的改變同時存在於國營與民營企業。總的來說，雖然「雙反」後產出扭曲改善，並減低資源錯置程度且提升產業生產力，但降低資本投入扭曲仍應是後續改善資源錯置問題的政策重點。

Solar energy has been the Chinese government's prime candidate to replace fossil fuels for electricity generation. To bolster the solar energy industry, the Chinese government set up a menu of incentive policies that led Chinese firms to expand production aggressively. Within several years, China swiftly dominated the global solar energy production market. However, Chinese firms' predatory pricing provoked retaliation from the U.S. and the EU with ＂anti-dumping＂ and ＂countervailing＂ investigations beginning in 2011. This paper constructed a firm-level panel dataset and measured the extent of resource misallocation prevalent in the Chinese solar industry between 2009 and 2014. Our results suggested that although substantial resource misallocation existed in 2009 and 2010, the Chinese solar industry's misallocation had improved afterward. This occurred mainly because of the improvement in output distortion patterns among Chinese firms. However, through our decomposition exercise, we found that capital distortions played a more critical role in explaining the Chinese solar industry's production loss. This suggested that to advance its solar energy industry further, focusing on curtailing capital distortions should be the Chinese government's priority.

1. Chen, C. S.,Kao, K. F.(2016).Anti-Dumping Policy and Anti-Dumping Retaliation.Academia Economic Papers,44(3),387-412.
   連結：
2. 林家慶, C.-C.(2019)。台灣廠商躍過反傾銷稅直接投資之實證分析。經濟論文，47(4)，651-679。
   連結：
3. 林家慶, C.-C.,陳坤銘, K.-M.(2017)。躍過反傾銷稅直接投資與匯率波動—實質選擇權分析法。經濟論文，45(4)，599-628。
   連結：
4. 黃智輝, C.-H.(2008)。銅版紙課徵反傾銷稅經濟效果與國家整體利益分析。台灣經濟預測與政策，39(1)，69-96。
   連結：
5. 黃智輝, C.-H.(2008)。水泥課徵反傾銷稅的政策效果與競爭力分析—台灣實證分析。台灣經濟預測與政策，38(2)，1-30。
   連結：
6. Adamopoulos, T.,Restuccia, D.(2020).Land Reform and Productivity: A Quantitative Analysis with Micro Data.American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics,12,1-39.
7. Bahk, B.,Gort, M.(1993).Decomposing Learning by Doing in New Plants.Journal of Political Economy,101,561-583.
8. Bai, C. E.,Hsieh, C. T.,Song, Z. M.(2016).NBER Working PaperNBER Working Paper,未出版
9. Baily, M. N.,Hulten, C.,Campbell, D.(1992).The Distribution of Productivity in Manufacturing Plants.Brookings Papers: Microeconomics,Washington, DC:
10. Baldwin, R. E.(1969).The Case against Infant-Industry Tariff Protection.Journal of Political Economy,77,295-305.
11. Baldwin, R.,Evenett, S.(2009).The Collapse of Global Trade, Murky Protectionism and the Crisis: Recommendations for the G20.London:Centre for Economic Policy Research.
12. Banerjee, A. V.,Moll, B.(2010).Why Does Misallocation Persist?.American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics,2,189-206.
13. Bartelsman, E. J.,Dhrymes, P. J.(1998).Productivity Dynamics: US Manufacturing Plants, 1972–1986.Journal of Productivity Analysis,9,5-34.
14. Basu, S.(1996).Procyclical Productivity: Increasing Returns or Cyclical Utilization?.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,111,719-751.
15. Basu, S.,Fernald, J. G.(1995).Are Apparent Productive Spillovers a Figment of Specification Error?.Journal of Monetary Economics,36,165-188.
16. Basu, S.,Kimball, M. S.(1997).NBER Working PaperNBER Working Paper,未出版
17. Bazilian, M.,Onyeji, I.,Liebreich, M.,MacGill, I.,Chase, J.,Shah, J.,Gielen, D.,Arent, D.,Landfear, D,Zhengrong, S.(2013).Re-Considering the Economics of Photovoltaic Power.Renewable Energy,53,329-338.
18. Biello, D. (2008), “China’s Big Push for Renewable Energy,” https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinas-big-push-for-renewable-energy/.
19. Bown, C. P.,Crowley, M. A.(2007).Trade Deflection and Trade Depression.Journal of International Economics,72,176-201.
20. Buera, F. J.,Kaboski, J. P.,Shin, Y.(2011).Finance and Development: A Tale of Two Sectors.American Economic Review,101,1964-2002.
21. Cardwell, D. (2013), “China’s Feud with West on Solar Leads to Tax,” New York Times, July 18, 2013.
22. Chen, G.(2015).From Mercantile Strategy to Domestic Demand Stimulation: Changes in China’s Solar PV Subsidies.Asia Pacific Business Review,21,96-112.
23. Clemhout, S.,Wan, H. Y.(1970).Learning-by-Doing and Infant Industry Protection.The Review of Economic Studies,37,33-56.
24. Darby, M.(2014).Duke University.
25. David, J.,Venkateswaran, V.(2019).The Sources of Capital Misallocation.American Economic Review,109,2531-2567.
26. Department of Commerce (2012), “Issues and Decision Memorandum for the Final Determination in the Countervailing Duty Investigation of Crystalline Silicon Photovoltaic Cells, Whether or Not Assembled into Modules, from the People’s Republic of China,” http://enforcement.trade.gov/frn/summary/prc/2012-25564-1.pdf.
27. Dunford, M.,Lee, K. H.,Liu, W.,Yeung, G.(2013).Geographical Interdependence, International Trade and Economic Dynamics: The Chinese and German Solar Energy Industries.European Urban and Regional Studies,20,14-36.
28. Durling, J. P.,Prusa, T. J.(2006).The Trade Effects Associated with an Antidumping Epidemic: The Hot-Rolled Steel Market, 1996–2001.European Journal of Political Economy,22,675-695.
29. Feinberg, R. M.(2013).Antidumping and Industrial Organization.Review of Industrial Organization,42,365-368.
30. Felbermayr, G.,Sandkamp, A.(2020).The Trade Effects of Anti-Dumping Duties: FirmLevel Evidence from China.European Economic Review,122,103367.
31. Grau, T.,Huo, M.,Neuhoff, K.(2012).Survey of Photovoltaic Industry and Policy in Germany and China.Energy Policy,51,20-37.
32. Haley, U.,Haley, G.(2013).How Chinese Subsidies Changed the World?.Harvard Business Review
33. Hart, M. (2012), “What Does the Solar Trade Dispute Mean? Shining a Light on U.S.-China Clean Energy Cooperation,” https://archive.thinkprogress.org/climate/.
34. Hsieh, C. T.,Hurst, E.,Jones, C. I.,Klenow, P. J.(2019).The Allocation of Talent and U.S. Economic Growth.Econometrica,87,1439-1474.
35. Hsieh, C. T.,Klenow, P. J.(2009).Misallocation and Manufacturing TFP in China and India.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,124,1403-1448.
36. Hsieh, C. T.,Moretti, E.(2019).Housing Constraints and Spatial Misallocation.American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics,11,1-39.
37. Hsieh, C. T.,Song, Z. M.(2015).NBER Working PaperNBER Working Paper,未出版
38. IEA-PVPS, P. V. P. S.(2015).Snapshot of Global PV Markets 1992–2014.Paris:International Energy Agency.
39. Jovanovic, B.(2014).Misallocation and Growth.American Economic Review,104,1149-1171.
40. Lane, J.,Broadman, H. G.,Singh, I.(1998).Labor Flexibility, Ownership and Firm Performance in China.Review of Industrial Organization,13,621-635.
41. Leal Ordóñez, J. C.(2014).Tax Collection, the Informal Sector, and Productivity.Review of Economic Dynamics,17,262-286.
42. Lin, S.(2000).Resource Allocation and Economic Growth in China.Economic Inquiry,38,515-526.
43. Lu, Y.,Tao, Z.,Zhang, Y.(2013).How Do Exporters Respond to Antidumping Investigations?.Journal of International Economics,91,290-300.
44. Lund, P. D.(2009).Effects of Energy Policies on Industry Expansion in Renewable Energy.Renewable Energy,34,53-64.
45. Mcguckin, R. H.,Nguyen, S. V.(1993).Post-Reform Industrial Productivity Performance of China: New Evidence from the 1985 Industrial Census Data.Economic Inquiry,31,323-341.
46. Midrigan, V.,Xu, D. Y.(2014).Finance and Misallocation: Evidence from Plant-Level Data.American Economic Review,104,422-458.
47. Moll, B.(2014).Productivity Losses from Financial Frictions: Can Self-Financing Undo Capital Misallocation?.American Economic Review,104,3186-3221.
48. Nahm, J.,Steinfeld, E. S.(2014).Scale-Up Nation: China’s Specialization in Innovative Manufacturing.World Development,54,288-300.
49. Olley, G. S.,Pakes, A.(1996).The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment Industry.Econometrica,64,1263-1298.
50. Park, S.(2009).The Trade Depressing and Trade Diversion Effects of Antidumping Actions: The Case of China.China Economic Review,20,542-548.
51. Pierce, J. R.(2013).Antidumping Duties and Plant-Level Restructuring.Review of Industrial Organization,42,435-447.
52. Quitzow, R.(2015).Dynamics of a Policy-Driven Market: The Co-Evolution of Technological Innovation Systems for Solar Photovoltaics in China and Germany.Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions,17,126-148.
53. Restuccia, D.,Rogerson, R.(2017).The Causes and Costs of Misallocation.Journal of Economic Perspectives,31,151-174.
54. Shen, G.,Fu, X.(2014).The Trade Effects of US Antidumping Actions against China Post-WTO Entry.World Economy,37,86-105.
55. Stigler, G. J.(1971).The Theory of Economic Regulation.The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science,2,3-21.
56. Uras, B.(2014).Corporate Financial Structure, Misallocation and Total Factor Productivity.Journal of Banking and Finance,39,177-191.
57. Vandenbussche, H.,Zanardi, M.(2010).The Chilling Trade Effects of Antidumping Proliferation.European Economic Review,54,760-777.
58. Veugelers, R.,Vandenbussche, H.(1999).European Anti-Dumping Policy and the Profitability of National and International Collusion.European Economic Review,43,1-28.
59. Xu, B.(2006).Infant Industry and Political Economy of Trade Protection.Pacific Economic Review,11,363-378.
60. Xu, X.,Chen, H. H.,Feng, Y.,Tang, J.(2018).The Production Efficiency of Renewable Energy Generation and Its Influencing Factors: Evidence from 20 Countries.Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy,10,025901.
61. Zeng, S.,Jiang, C.,Ma, C.,Su, B.(2018).Investment Efficiency of the New Energy Industry in China.Energy Economics,70,536-544.
62. Zhang, S.,He, Y.(2013).Analysis on the Development and Policy of Solar PV Power in China.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,21,393-401.