盤前資訊意涵－開盤前資訊透明化之實證觀察

THE INFORMATION CONTENT OF THE PRE-OPENING LIMIT ORDER BOOK: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF TRANSPARENCY REFORM AT THE OPENING CALL

曾翊恆(Yi-Heng Tseng)

台灣證券交易所 ； 限價簿 ； 盤前資訊 ； 自然人 ； 機構投資人 ； Taiwan stock exchange ； Limit order book ； Pre-opening quotes and depths ； Individual investor ； Institutional investor

經濟論文

49卷4期（2021 / 12 / 01）

569 - 607

繁體中文

台灣證交所於2015年6月29日開始揭露盤前試撮資訊，本文乃以改革前後各80日觀察實施效果。撮合成效方面，開盤報酬率波動加劇，盤前股價加權貢獻度上升，而大型股開盤局部時段作價減少。「價格發現效率」在盤前多數時間呈現下滑，但資訊揭示品質不佳情況會在開盤前五分鐘內大幅改善。試撮成交價格、限價簿最佳一檔價量與均衡股價變化頗為攸關，大型股限價簿最佳第四、五檔價量資訊價值會在競價末五分鐘浮現。透明化改革還「激勵」自然人、機構投資人出價急迫意願，其委託積極度決策對買賣價差敏感度在開盤前後半小時差異顯著，隱含對盤前揭示資訊相對缺乏「信賴感」。此外，文中各項實證發現皆通過盤面走勢穩健性測試。

The adoption of the pre-open disclosure mechanism in June 29, 2015 has made the limit order book (LOB) highly transparent during the opening call. Our study finds that, after this reform, though the close-to-open return volatility becomes higher, the weighted price contribution (WPC) at the opening call still increases and the opening prices are less manipulated in large cap stocks. Although the price discovery efficiency declines most of the time during the opening call, the poor quality of pre-opening quotes and depths disclosed in the LOB has greatly improved since 8:55. Moreover, the reference prices and best 'unexecuted' quotes along with depths are highly related to the changes in equilibrium prices. For large cap stocks, the information content in the 4^(th) and 5^(th) best quotes emerges in the last five minutes of the opening call. This transparency reform also raises the probability of individual and institutional investors submitting aggressive orders. The sensitivity of order aggressiveness to the bid-ask spread variation is significantly different during the half hour before and after the market opening, implying that both types of investors have less confidence in the pre-opening quotes and depths. Our findings pass robustness checks precluding the scenario of market rise or fall.

1. Tseng, Y. H.,Chang, C.,Wang, K.(2017).Order Choices, Order Performance, and Price Discovery during Closing Call Auctions: A Case Study of Improved LOB Disclosure in Taiwan Stock Exchange.Journal of Financial Studies,25,105-156.
   連結：
2. Tseng, Y. H.,Chang, C.,Wang, K.(2017).Order Choices, Order Performance, and Price Discovery during Closing Call Auctions: A Case Study of Improved LOB Disclosure in Taiwan Stock Exchange.Journal of Financial Studies,25,105-156.
   連結：
3. Wang, Y. Y.(2019).Strategic Spoofing Order Trading by Different Types of Investors inTaiwan Index Futures Market.Journal of Financial Studies,27,65-103.
   連結：
4. 曾翊恆, Y.-H.(2016)。集合競價、限價簿揭露資訊與委託積極度決策。證券市場發展季刊，28，39-102。
   連結：
5. 曾翊恆, Y.-H.,魏品揚, P.-Y.(2017)。盤前公開資訊、開盤價格發現與投資人委託決策。經濟論文，45，503-598。
   連結：
6. 詹場, C.,李志宏, J.-H.(2014)。市場穩定與競價制度一台灣期貨市場之實證。經濟論文叢刊，42，49-101。
   連結：
7. Aitken, M.,Almeida, N.,deB. Harris, F. H.,McInish, T.(2007).Liquidity Supply in Electronic Markets.Journal of Financial Markets,10,144-168.
8. Anagnostidis, P.,Kanas, A.,Papachristou, G.(2015).Information Revelation in the Greek Exchange Opening Call: Daily and Intraday Evidence.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,38,167-184.
9. Back, K.,Cao, C. H.,Willard, G. A.(2000).Imperfect Competition among Informed Traders.Journal of Finance,55,2117-2155.
10. Bandi, F. M.,Russell, J. R.(2006).Separating Microstructure Noise from Volatility.Journal of Financial Economics,79,655-692.
11. Barber, B. M.,Lee, Y.,Liu, Y.,Odean, T.(2009).Just How Much Do Individual Investors Lose by Trading?.The Review of Financial Studies,22,609-632.
12. Barclay, M. J.,Warner, J. B.(1993).Stealth Trading and Volatility: Which Trades MovePrices?.Journal of Financial Economics,34,281-305.
13. Biais, B.,Hillion, P.,Spatt, C.(1999).Price Discovery and Learning during the Preopening Period in the Paris Bourse.Journal of Political Economy,107,1218-1248.
14. Biais, B.,Hillion, P.,Spatt, C.(1995).An Empirical Analysis of the Limit Order Book andthe Order Flow in the Paris Bourse.Journal of Finance,50,1655-1689.
15. Boehmer, E.,Gideon, S.,Lei, Y.(2005).Lifting the Veil: An Analysis of Pre-Trade Transparency at the NYSE.Journal of Finance,60,783-815.
16. Cao, C.,Ghysels, E.,Hatheway, F.(2000).Price Discovery without Trading: Evidence from the Nasdaq Preopening.Journal of Finance,55,1339-1365.
17. Cao, C.,Hansch, O.,Wang, X.(2009).The Information Content of an Open Limit-OrderBook.Journal of Futures Markets,29,16-41.
18. Cao, C.,Hansch, O.,Wang, X.(2008).Order Placement Strategies in a Pure Limit OrderBook Market.Journal of Financial Research,31,113-140.
19. Chang, R. P.,Rhee, G. S.,Stone, G. R.,Ning, T.(2008).How Does the Call Market Method Affect Price Efficiency? Evidence from the Singapore Stock Market.Journal of Banking and Finance,32,2205-2219.
20. Chiu, J.,Chung, H.,Wang, G. H. K.(2017).Order Aggressiveness, Trading Patience, and Trader Types in a Limit Order Market.Journal of Futures Markets,37,1094-1123.
21. Comerton-Forde, C.,Lau, S. T.,McInish, T.(2007).Opening and Closing Behavior Following the Introduction of All Auctions in Singapore.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,15,18-35.
22. De Winnie, R.,D’hondt, C.(2007).Hide-and-Seek in the Market: Placing and Detecting Hidden Orders.Review of Finance,11,663-692.
23. Dia, M.,Pouget, S.(2011).Sunshine Trading in an African Stock Market.Managerial Finance,37,257-274.
24. Duong, H. N.,Kalev, P. S.,Krishnamurti, C.(2009).Order Aggressiveness of Institutionaland Individual Investors.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,17,533-546.
25. Fong, K. Y. L.,Liu, W.(2010).Limit Order Revisions.Journal of Banking and Finance,34,1873-1885.
26. Foucault, T.(1999).Order Flow Composition and Trading Cost in a Dynamic Limit OrderBook.Journal of Financial Market,2,99-134.
27. Goettler, R. L.,Parlour, C. A.,Rajan, U.(2005).Equilibrium in a Dynamic Limit Order Market.Journal of Finance,5,2149-2192.
28. Griffiths, M. D.,Smith, B. F.,Turnbull, D. A. S.,White, R. W.(2000).The Costs and the Determinants of Order Aggressiveness.Journal of Financial Economics,56,65-88.
29. Ibikunle, G.(2015).Opening and Closing Price Efficiency: Do Financial Markets Need the Call Auction?.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,34,208-227.
30. Kuk, J., W. Lui, and P. K. Pham (2016), “Strategic Order Submission and Cancellation in Pre-Opening Periods and Its Impact on Price Discovery: The Case of IPO Firms,” SSRN Working Paper, No. 1362484.
31. Lee, E. J.,Eom, K. S.,Park, K. S.(2013).Microstructure-Based Manipulation: Strategic Behavior and Performance of Spoofing Traders.Journal of Financial Markets,16,227-252.
32. Lu, T. H.(2014).The Profitability of Candlestick Charting in the Taiwan Stock Market.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,26,65-78.
33. Lyons, R. K.(1996).Optimal Transparency in a Dealer Market with an Application to Foreign Exchange.Journal of Financial Intermediation,5,225-254.
34. Ma, T.,Lin, Y.,Chen, H.(2008).Are Investor More Aggressive in Transparent Market?.Asia-Pacific Journal of Financial Studies,37,343-380.
35. McCloskey, D. N.,Ziliak, S. T.(1996).The Standard Error of Regressions.Journal of Economic Literature,34,97-114.
36. Moshirian, F.,Nguyen, H. G.,Pham, P. K.(2012).Overnight Public Information, Order Placement, and Price Discovery during the Pre-Opening Period.Journal of Banking and Finance,36,2837-2851.
37. Pagano, M.,Röell, A.(1996).Transparency and Liquidity: A Comparison of Auction and Dealer Markets with Informed Trading.Journal of Finance,51,579-611.
38. Parlour, C. A.(1998).Price Dynamics in Limit Order Markets.Review of Financial Studies,11,789-816.
39. Pascual, R.,Veredas, D.(2009).What Pieces of Limit Order Book Information Matter in Explaining Order Choice by Patient and Impatient Traders?.Quantitative Finance,9,527-545.
40. Ranaldo, A.(2004).Order Aggressiveness in Limit Order Book Markets.Journal of Financial Market,7,53-74.
41. Rosu, I.(2009).A Dynamic Model of the Limit Order Book.Review of Financial Studies,22,4601-4641.
42. Tseng, Y. H.,Chen, S. H.(2015).Limit Order Book Transparency and Order Aggressiveness at the Closing Call: Lessons from the TWSE 2012 New Information Disclosure Mechanism.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,35,241-272.
43. Valenzuela, M.,Zer, I.(2013).Competition, Signaling and Non-Walking Through the Book: Effects on Order Choice.Journal of Banking and Finance,37,5421-5435.
44. 蔡佩雯, P.-W.(2010)。我國證券集中交易市場開盤及收盤資訊揭露之規劃建議。證交資料，576，8-20。
45. 顏月珠, Y.-C.(2010).無母數統計方法.台北=Taipei: