Unexpected Earnings, Abnormal Accruals, and Changes in CEO Bonuses

10.6552/JOAR.2007.45.s.2

Chih-Ying Chen；Jia-Wen Liang；Stephen Lin

Executive compensation ； Earnings surprises ； Abnormal accruals ； Pay-for-performance sensitivity

會計評論

45_s期（2007 / 05 / 01）

25 - 50

英文

Prior research has found that the market premium for positive unexpected earnings is greater than the penalty for negative unexpected earnings and that the earnings response coefficients for positive (negative) unexpected earnings are lower (higher) if abnormal accruals are income-increasing. In this study, we investigate whether the relation between changes in CEO bonuses and unexpected earnings (the pay-for-performance sensitivity) varies in a manner consistent with the differential market reactions described above. Based on a sample of US firms during 1993-2004, we find that the pay-for-performance sensitivity is higher when unexpected earnings are positive than when they are negative. For observations with small positive unexpected earnings, the pay-for-performance sensitivity is lower if the abnormal accruals are income-increasing. For observations with negative unexpected earnings, the pay-for-performance sensitivity is higher if the abnormal accruals are income-increasing. Further analysis shows that only the observations from the post-Enron period exhibit differential pay-for-performance sensitivities conditional on the sign of the abnormal accruals. Collectively, our results suggest that compensation committees increase the pay-for-performance sensitivity and discount the performance achieved by using income-increasing abnormal accruals in response to increased scrutiny of executive compensation.

1. Abarbanell, J. S.(1991).Do analysts` earnings forecasts incorporate information in prior stock price changes?.Journal of Accounting and Economics,14,147-165.
2. Abarbanell, J.,B. Bushee.(1997).Fundamental analysis, future earnings, and stock prices.Journal of Accounting Research,35,1-24.
3. Antle, R.,A. Smith.(1986).An empirical investigation of the relative performance evaluation of corporate executives.Journal of Accounting Research,24,1-39.
4. Baber, W. R.,S. Kang,K. R. Kumar.(1998).Accounting earnings and executive compensation: The role of earnings persistence.Journal of Accounting and Economics,25,169-193.
5. Baber, W. R.,S. Kang,K. R. Kumar.(1999).The explanatory power of earnings levels vs. earnings changes in the context of executive compensation.The Accounting Review,74,459-472.
6. Baker, G. P.,M. C. Jensen,K. J. Murphy.(1988).Compensation and incentives: Practice versus theory.Journal of Finance,43,593-616.
7. Baldwin, B.(1984).Segment earnings disclosure and the ability of security, analysts to forecast earnings per share.The Accounting Review,59,376-389.
8. Balsam, S.(1998).Discretionary accounting choices and CEO compensation.Contemporary Accounting Research,15,229-252.
9. Bartov, E.,D. Givoly,C. Hayn.(2002).The rewards to meting or beating earnings expectations.Journal of Accounting and Economics,33,173-204.
10. Brown, L. D.,M. S. Rozeff(1978).The superiority of analyst forecasts as measures of expectations: evidence from earnings.Journal of Finance,33,1-16.
11. Brown, L.,P. Griffin,R. Hagerman,M. Zmijecwski(1987).Security analysts superiority relative to univariate time-series models in forecasting quarterly earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,9,61-87.
12. Brown, L.,R Griffin,R. Hagerman,M. Zmijecwski(1987).An evaluation of alternative proxies for the market`s assessment of unexpected earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,9,159-194.
13. Burgstahler, D.,M. Eames.(2003).Earnings management to avoid losses and earnings decreases: Are analysts fooled?.Contemporary Accounting Research,20,253-294.
14. Bushman, R.,E. Engel,A. Smith.(2003).An analysis of the relation between the stewardship and valuation roles of earnings.Journal of Accounting Research,44,53-83.
15. Carter, M. E.,L. J. Lynch,S. L. Zechman.(2005).The relation between executive compensation and earnings management: Changes in the post-Sarbanes-Oxley era.Working paper:University of Pennsylvania.
16. Clinch, G.,J. Magliolo.(1993).CEO compensation and components of earnings in bank holding companies.Journal of Accounting and Economics,16,241-272.
17. Dechow, P. M.(2006).Asymmetric sensitivity of CEO cash compensation to stock returns: A discussion.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42,193-202.
18. DeFond, M. L.,C. W. Park.(2001).The reversal of abnormal accruals and the market valuation of earnings surprises..The Accounting Review,76,375-404.
19. DeFond, M. L.,C. W. Park.(1999).The effect of competition on CEO turnover.Journal of Accounting and Economics,27,35-56.
20. DeFond, M. L.,S. R. Matsunaga,C. W. Park.(2003).An empirical assessment of the consensus analyst forecast as a proxy of CEO performance standards.Working paper:University of Oregon..
21. Degeorge, F.,J. Patel,R. Zeckhauser.(1999).Earnings management to exceed thresholds.The Journal of Business,72,1-33.
22. Fama, E. F.,K. R. French.(1997).Industry costs of equity.Journal of Financial Economics,43,153-193.
23. Farrell, K.,D. Whidbee.(2003).impact of firm performance expectations on CEO turnover and replacement decisions.Journal of Accounting and Economics,36,165-196.
24. Fried, D.,D. Givoly.(1982).Financial analysts` forecast of earnings: A better surrogate for market expectations.Journal of Accounting and Economic,4,85-107.
25. Gayer, J. J.,K. M. Gayer(1998).The relation between nonrecurring accounting transactions and CEO cash compensation.The Accounting Review,73,235-253.
26. Gjesdal, F.(1981).Accounting for stewardship..Journal of Accounting Research,19,208-331.
27. Healy, P.(1985).The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decisions.Journal of Accounting and Economics,7,85-107.
28. Holmstrom, B.(1982).Moral hazard in teams..Bell Journal of Economics,13,324-340.
29. Holmstrom, B.(1979).Moral hazard and observability.Bell Journal of Economics,10,74-91.
30. Holthausen, R. W.,D. F. Larcker,R. Sloan.(1995).Annual bonus schemes and the manipulation of earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,19,29-74.
31. Indjejikian, R. J.,D. J. Nanda.(2002).Executive target bonuses and what they imply about performance standards.The Accounting Review,77,793-819.
32. Janakiraman, S.,R. Lambert,D. Larcker.(1992).An empirical investigation of the relative performance evaluation hypothesis.Journal of Accounting Research,30,53-69.
33. Kasznik, R.,M. F. McNichols(2002).Does meeting earnings expectations matter? Evidence from analyst forecast revisions and share prices..Journal of Accounting Research,40,727-759.
34. Kothari, S. P.,A. J. Leone,C. E. Wasley.(2005).Performance matched discretionary accrual measures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,39,163-197.
35. Kross, W.,B. Ro,D. Schroeder.(1990).Earnings expectations: The analysts` information advantage.The Accounting Review,65,461-476.
36. Lambert, R. A.,D. F. Larcker.(1987).Accounting and market measures of performance.Journal of Accounting Research,85,85-125.
37. Lang, M.,R. Lundholm.(1996).Corporate disclosure policy and analyst behavior.The Accounting Review,71,467-492.
38. Leone, A.,J. Wu.,J. Zimmerman.(2006).Asymmetric sensitivity of CEO cash compensation to stock returns.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42,467-492.
39. Matsumoto, D. A.(2002).Management`s incentives to avoid negative earnings surprises.The Accounting Review,77,483-514.
40. Matsunaga, S. R.,C. W. Park.(2001).The effect of missing a quarterly earnings benchmark on the CEO`s annual bonus.The Accounting Review,76,313-332.
41. Murphy, K. J.(1999).Handbook of Labor Economics.Amsterdam:North-Holland.
42. Murphy, K. J.(2001).Performance standards in incentive contracts.Journal of Accounting and Economics,30,245-278.
43. O`Brien, P.(1988).Analysts` forecasts as expectations.Journal of Accounting and Economics,10,55-83.
44. Puffer, S. M.,J. B. Weintrop.(1991).Corporate performance and CEO turnover: The role of performance expectations.Administrative Science Quarterly,36,1-19.
45. Rogers, W. H.(1993).Regression standard errors in clustered samples.Stata Technical Bulletin,13,19-23.
46. Shivdasani, W.,D. Yermack.(1999).CEO involvement in the selection of new board members: An empirical analysis.Journal of Finance,54,1829-1853.
47. Sloan, R.(1993).Accounting earnings and top executive compensation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,16,55-100.
48. Xie, H.(2001).The mispricing of abnormal accruals..The Accounting Review,76,356-373.