题名

台灣金融控股公司經營主體、多角化經營與經營效率之關聯性研究－兼論公司治理之角色

并列篇名

Relationship between Major Business Units, Diversification, and Operational Efficiency of Taiwan's Financial Holding Companies: The Role of Corporate Governance

DOI

10.6552/JOAR.2017.65.4

作者

邱垂昌(Chei-Chang Chiou)；蔡欣伶(Sing-Ling Tsai)；林瑞雲(Grace J.Y. Lin)

关键词

金融控股公司經營效率 ； 經營主體 ； 多角化經營 ； 公司治理 ； Operating efficiency of financial holding company ； Major business unit ； Diversification ； Corporate governance

期刊名称

會計評論

卷期/出版年月

65期（2017 / 07 / 01）

页次

117 - 172

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究首先採用資料包絡分析法分析台灣2003-2010年14家金融控股公 司的經營效率，相對營運效率值之計算係採用Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes (1978)的DEA-CCR模式。研究結果發現14家金融控股公司之經營效率平均約有42%的改善空間，而經營無效率之主因係來自純技術無效率與規模無效率。其次，針對影響金融控股公司經營效率之因素進行分析，結果顯示金融控股公司以銀行業為經營主體者，其經營效率較以壽險業與證券業為經營主體者為差，而經營主體營收占整體營收比重愈高者，其經營效率愈佳；在2008年金融風暴前，以銀行業及證券業為經營主體之金控公司多角化經營程度與其經營效率呈顯著正向關係，但在2008年金融風暴後，多角化經營程度與金控公司經營效率之正向關係逐漸消失。本研究再進一步針對公司治理之角色進行分析，發現在2008年金融風暴前，董事會規模對多角化經營程度與經營效率之關係具有調節效果，但在2008年金融風暴後，董事會規模對多角化經營程度與經營效率之關係具有正向影響。而官股持股比率之結果正好相反。
英文摘要

This study investigates the operational efficiency of 14 financial holding companies operating in Taiwan from 2003 to 2010. The DEA-CCR method developed by Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes (1978) is used to measure the relative operational efficiency of financial holding companies. The empirical results indicate that a 42% improvement in the operational efficiency of the companies is necessary in the study sample. The main reasons for operating inefficiency were pure technical and scale inefficiencies. This study also examines the determinants of the operational efficiency of financial holding companies. The results show that financial holding companies with a major business unit, most often a bank, have lower operational efficiency in comparison with life insurance and securities firms. The ratio of revenues from a major business unit to total revenues from the financial holding company positively and significantly affects operational efficiency. The relationship between the diversification level and operational efficiency is significantly positive for the period before the 2008 financial crisis and significantly negative for the period after the 2008 financial crisis. Furthermore, this study analyzes the role of corporate governance and finds that for the period before the 2008 crisis, board size moderates the relationship between diversification level and operational efficiency. However, for the period after the 2008 crisis, board size positively affects the relationship between diversification level and operational efficiency. However, the shareholding ratio of government has the opposite results in terms of board size.
主题分类 社會科學 > 財金及會計學
参考文献
  1. Chen, Y. K.,Hsu, C. L.(2014).Are bank capital buffers cyclical? Evidence for developed and developing Countries.Journal of Financial Studies,22,27-56.
    連結：
  2. 王克陸、彭雅惠、陳美燁(2007)。台灣金控子銀行經營績效之評估—使用DEA方法。科技管理學刊，12(2)，1-17。
    連結：
  3. 王儷玲、彭金隆、張義宏(2006)。我國壽險業銀行保險業務參與度與經營效率分析。台大管理論叢，17(1)，59-90。
    連結：
  4. 邱垂昌、王育民、魏嘉伶、張簡婷(2011)。創新、人力資本投入與企業經營效率─以我國IC 設計業為例。中山管理評論，19(2)，343-385。
    連結：
  5. 倪衍森、黃寶玉、康唯珍(2011)。公司治理會增強或削弱競爭力與多角化對公司價值影響？。商管科技季刊，12(2)，175-208。
    連結：
  6. 曹壽民、金成隆、呂學典(2011)。股權結構與多角化。台大管理論叢，22(1)，165-198。
    連結：
  7. 趙莊敏、戴德昇(2006)。台灣銀行股權結構、董事會特性與其經營成本效率之相關性研究。台灣金融財務季刊，7(3)，95-125。
    連結：
  8. 遲淑華(2010)。公司治理是否會影響台灣銀行業的合併效率？。台灣金融財務季刊，11(3)，61-87。
    連結：
  9. Byrd, J. W., D. R. Fraser, D. S. Lee, and T. G. E. Williams. 2001. Financial crises, natural selection and governance structure: Evidence from the thrift crisis. Working Paper, Texas A&M University.
  10. 金融控股公司法， 2001 ， 證券暨期貨法令判解查詢系統，http://www.selaw.com.tw/LawArticle.aspx?LawID=G0060250 。 (Financial Holding Company Act. 2001. Law Source Retrieving System of Stock Exchange and Futures Trading.)
  11. Klein, P. G., and M. R. Saidenberg.. 1998. Diversification, organization, and efficiency: Evidence from bank holding companies. Working paper, Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=98653. Accessed: May 6, 2011.
  12. 陳健銘，2003，金控公司會造成另一波overbanking的問題嗎？，工商時報，第9版。(Chen J. M. 2003. Will financial holding companies cause another wave overbanking problem?. Business Times, 9th edition.)
  13. 李庸三，2002.2.7，金控家數多寡，市場決定，中國時報。(Lee Y. S. 2002.2.7. The number of financial holding companies, market decision. China Times.)
  14. Al-Hussain, A. H.,Johnson, R. L.(2009).Relationship between corporate governance efficiency and Saudi banks' performance.The Business Review, Cambridge,14,111-117.
  15. Barth, J. R.,Caprio, G.,Lavine, R.(2004).Bank regulation and supervision: What works best?.Journal of Financial Intermediation,13,205-248.
  16. Battese, G. E.,Coelli, T. J.(1992).Frontiers production function, technical efficiency and panel data: With application to paddy farmers in India.Journal of Productivity Analysis,3,153-169.
  17. Battese, G. E.,Coelli, T. J.(1995).A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data.Empirical Economics,20,325-332.
  18. Bauer, P. W.,Berger, A. N.,Ferrier, G. D.,Humphrey, D. B.(1998).Consistency conditions for regulatory analysis of financial institutions: A comparison of frontier efficiency methods.Journal of Economics and Business,50,85-114.
  19. Berger, A. N.,Humphrey, D. B.,Pulley, L. B.(1996).Do consumers pay for one-stop banking? Evidence from an alternative revenue function.Journal of Banking and Finance,20,1601-1621.
  20. Berger, P. G.,Ofek, E.(1995).Diversification's effect on firm value.Journal of Financial Economics,37,39-65.
  21. Bokpin, G. A.(2013).Ownership structure, corporate governance and bank efficiency: an empirical analysis of panel data from the banking industry in Ghana.Corporate Governance,13,274-287.
  22. Brickley, J. A.,James, C. M.(1987).The takeover market, corporate board composition, and ownership structure: The case of banking.Journal of Law and Economics,30,161-180.
  23. Campa, J. M.,Kedia, S.(2002).Explaining the diversification discount.The Journal of Finance,57,1731-1762.
  24. Caprio, G.,Laeven, L.,Lavine, R.(2007).Governance and bank valuation.Journal of Financial Intermediation,16,584-617.
  25. Chalhoub, M. S.(2009).Relations between dimensions of corporate governance and corporate performance: An empirical study among banks in the Lebanon.International Journal of Management,26,476-488.
  26. Chao, C. M.,Yu, M. M.,Chen, M. C.(2010).Measuring the performance of financial holding companies.The Service Industries Journal,30,811-829.
  27. Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W.,Rhodes, E.(1978).Measuring the efficiency of decision making units.European Journal of Operational Research,2,429-444.
  28. Chiou, C. C.(2009).Effects of financial holding company act on bank efficiency and productivity in Taiwan.Neurocomputing,72,3490-3506.
  29. Coelli, T. J.(1992).A computer program for stochastic frontier production and cost function estimation.Economics Letters,39,39-32.
  30. Coelli, T. J.,Roa, D. S. P.,Battese, G. E.(1988).An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis.Boston, MA:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
  31. Dempere, J. M.(2007).Impact of corporate governance on the pricing and performance of bank IPOs.Review of Business,28,32-44.
  32. Denis, D. J.,Denis, D. K.,Sarin, A.(1997).Agency problems, equity ownership and corporate diversification.The Journal of Finance,52,135-160.
  33. Diamond, D. W.(1984).Financial intermediation and delegated monitoring.The Review of Economic Studies,51,393-414.
  34. Dyson, R. G.,Allen, R.,Camanho, A. S.,Podinorski, V. V.,Sarrico, C. S.,Shale, E. A.(2001).Pitfall and protocols in DEA.European Journal of Operational Research,132,245-259.
  35. Eisenberg, T.,Sundgren, S.,Wells, M. T.(1998).Larger board size and decreasing firm value in small firms.Journal of Financial Economics,48,35-54.
  36. Fama, E. F.(1980).Agency problems and the theory of the firm.Journal of Political Economy,88,288-307.
  37. Fama, E. F.,Jensen, M. C.(1983).Agency problems and residual claims.The Journal of Law and Economics,26,327-349.
  38. Farrell, M. J.(1957).The measurement of productive efficiency.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,120,253-290.
  39. Ferrier, G. D.,Grosskopf, S.,Hayes, K. J.,Yaisawarng, S.(1993).Economies of diversification in the banking industry.Journal of Monetary Economics,31,229-249.
  40. Friedman, L.,Sinuany-Stern, Z.(1998).Combining ranking scales and selecting variables in the DEA context: The case of industrial branches.Computers and operations Research,25,781-791.
  41. Froot, K. A.,Stein, J. C.(1998).Risk management, capital budgeting and capital structure policy for financial institutions: An integrated approach.Journal of Financial Economics,47,55-82.
  42. Fung, M. K.(2006).Scale economies, X-efficiency, and convergence of productivity among bank holding companies.Journal of Banking and Finance,30,2857-2874.
  43. Greene, W. H.(1981).On the asymptotic bias of the ordinary least squares estimator of the Tobit model.Econometrica,49,505-513.
  44. Guo, R.,Langston, V.,Hadley, L.(2012).Business cycle, corporate governance, and bank performance.Research in Business and Economics Journal,5,1-11.
  45. Harris, M.,Kriebel, C. H.,Raviv, A.(1982).Asymmetric information, incentives, and interfirm resource allocation.Management Science,28,604-620.
  46. Hu, W. C.,Lai, M. C.,Huang, H. C.(2009).Rating the relative efficiency of financial holding companies in an emerging economy: A multiple DEA approach.Expert Systems with Applications,36,5592-5599.
  47. Huang, L. Y.,Hsiao, T. Y.,Lai, C. G.(2007).Does corporate governance and ownership structure influence performance? Evidence from Taiwan life insurance companies.Journal of Insurance,30,123-151.
  48. Huang, L.Y.,Lai, G. C.,McNamara, M.,Wong, J.(2011).Corporate governance and efficiency: Evidence from U.S. propriety-liability insurance industry.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,78,519-550.
  49. Jensen, M. C.,Meckling, W. H.(1976).Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure.Journal of Financial Economics,3,305-360.
  50. Jensen, M. C.,Murphy, K. J.(1990).Performance pay and top-management incentives.Journal of Political Economy,98,225-264.
  51. Jensen, M. C.,Ruback, R. S.(1983).The market for corporate control: The scientific evidence.Journal of Financial Economics,11,5-50.
  52. Kawaura, A.(2004).Deregulation and governance: plight of Japanese banks in the 1990s.Applied Economics,36,479-484.
  53. Klein, P. G.,Saidenberg, M. R.(2010).Organizational structure and the diversification discount: Evidence from commercial banking.The Journal of Industrial Economics,58,127-155.
  54. Kohers, T.,Huang, M. H.,Kohers, N.(2000).Market perception of efficiency in bank holding company mergers: The roles of the DEA and SFA models in capturing merger potential.Review of Financial Economics,9,101-120.
  55. Kooreman, P.(1994).Data envelopment analysis and parametric frontier estimation: Complementary tools.Journal of Health Economics,13,345-346.
  56. Lewellen, W. G.(1971).A pure financial rationale for the conglomerate merger.The Journal of Finance,26,521-537.
  57. Lin, J. C.,Hu, J. L.,Sung, K. L.(2005).The effect of electronic banking on the cost efficiency of commercial banks: An empirical study.International Journal of Management,22,605-611.
  58. Lo, S. F.,Lu, W. M.(2006).Does size matter? Finding the profitability and marketability benchmark of financial holding companies.Asia-Pacific Journal of Operating Research,23,229-246.
  59. Lo, S. F.,Lu, W. M.(2009).An integrated performance evaluation of financial holding companies in Taiwan.European Journal of Operational Research,198,341-350.
  60. Lu, W. M.,Lo, S. F.(2009).An interactive benchmark model ranking performers - Application to financial holding companies.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,49,172-179.
  61. Miguel, A. D.,Pindado, J.,Torre, C. D. L.(2004).Ownership structure and firm value: New evidence from Spain.Strategic Management Journal,25,1199-1207.
  62. Miller, S. M.,Noulas, A. G.(1996).The technical efficiency of large bank production.Journal of Banking and Finance,20,495-509.
  63. Mishra, C. S.,Nielsen, J. F.(2000).Board independence and compensation policies in large bank holding companies.Financial Management,29,51-69.
  64. Mukherjee, K.,Ray, S. C.,Miller, S. M.(2001).Productivity growth in large US commercial banks: The initial post-deregulation experience.Journal of Banking and Finance,25,913-939.
  65. Olivier, D. J.,Mustafa, D.,Koen, S.(2012).Corporate governance, opaque bank activities, and risk/return efficiency: Pre- and post-crisis evidence from Turkey.Journal of Financial Services Research,41,51-80.
  66. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development=OECD(1999).OECD Principles of Corporate Governance.Meeting of the OCED Council at Ministerial Level
  67. Peni, E.,Vähämaa, S.(2012).Did good corporate governance improve bank performance during the financial crisis?.Journal of Financial Services Research,41,19-35.
  68. Poon, W. C.,Yap, A. K. H.,Lee, T. H.(2013).The outcome of politically connected boards on commercial bank performance in Malaysia.Modern Applied Science,7,35-50.
  69. Rajan, R.,Servaes, H.,Zingales, L.(2000).The cost of diversity: The diversification discount and inefficient investment.The Journal of Finance,55,35-80.
  70. Rangan, N.,Grabowski, R.,Aly, H. Y.,Pasurka, C.(1988).The technical efficiency of U.S. banks.Economics Letters,28,169-175.
  71. Ray, S. C.,Mukherjee, K.(1996).Decomposition of the Fisher ideal index of productivity: A non-parametric dual analysis of US airlines data.The Economic Journal,106,1659-1678.
  72. Rumelt, R. P.(1982).Diversification strategy and profitability.Strategic Management Journal,3,359-369.
  73. Rumelt, R. P.(1974).Strategy, structure, and economic performance.Boston, M.A.:Harvard Business School Press.
  74. Sathye, M.(2001).X-efficiency in Australian banking: An empirical investigation.Journal of Banking and Finance,25,613-630.
  75. Saunders, A.,Strock, E.,Travlos, N. G.(1990).Ownership structure, deregulation and bank risk taking.The Journal of Finance,45,643-654.
  76. Scharfstein, D. S.,Stein, J. C.(2000).The dark side of internal capital markets: Divisional rent-seeking and inefficient investment.The Journal of Finance,55,2537-2564.
  77. Sealey, C. W.,Lindley, J. T.(1977).Inputs, outputs, and a theory of production and cost at depository financial institutions.The Journal of Finance,32,1251-1266.
  78. Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1997).A survey of corporate governance.The Journal of Finance,52,737-783.
  79. Singh, M.,Davidson, W. N.(2003).Agency costs, ownership structure and corporate governance mechanisms.Journal of Banking & Finance,27,793-816.v.
  80. Staikouras, P. K.,Staikouras, C. K.,Agoraki, M. K.(2007).The effect of board size and composition on European bank performance.European Journal of Law and Economics,23,1-27.
  81. Toshiyuki, Sueyoshi、高強譯、黃旭男譯(2003)。管理績效評估—資料包絡分析法。臺北=Taipei:華泰文化事業公司=Hwa Tai Publishing。
  82. Vennet, R. V.(2002).Cost and profit efficiency of financial conglomerates and universal banks in Europe.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,34,254-282.
  83. Wang, J. L.,Jeng, V.,Peng, J. L.(2007).The Impact of Corporate Governance Structure on the efficiency performance of insurance companies in Taiwan.The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issue and Practice,32,264-282.
  84. Wu, Y. W.,Xiang, B.,Zhang, G.(1996).Ownership structure reform and corporate performance: An empirical evaluation of Chinese shareholding companies.Hong Kong Journal of Business Management,14,53-67.
  85. Yen, G. F.,Yang, Y. H.,Lin, Y. H.,Lee, A. K.(2012).Operating performance analysis of Taiwan's financial holding companies: Using super SBM efficiency model and co-plot analysis.International Journal of Organizational Innovation,5,141-163.
  86. Yue, P.(1992).Data envelopment analysis and commercial bank performance: A primer with applications to Missouri banks.Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review,74,31-45.
  87. Zahra, S. A.,Pearce, J. A.(1989).Boards of directors and corporate financial performance: A review and integrated model.Journal of Management,15,291-334.
  88. 江淑玲、張佳萱(2008)。併入金控公司對銀行業經營效率影響之分析。創新與管理，6(1)，89-117。
  89. 吳佩芬(2007)。國立台灣大學會計學研究所=Nati Taiwan University。
  90. 李世隆(2006)。國立台灣科技大學管理研究所=National Taiwan University of Science and Techonology。
  91. 李雅秋(2006)。國立中正大學會計所=National Chung Cheng University。
  92. 林則江(2002)。國立成功大學會計學系=National Cheng Kung University。
  93. 邱垂昌、林惠美(2007)。水價公平合理與否？以台灣省自來水股份有限公司成本動因與營運效率分析。公平交易季刊，15(3)，105-150。
  94. 翁淑育(2000)。輔仁大學金融研究所=Fu Jen Catholic University。
  95. 張錫介(2005)。金融控股公司法實施對國內銀行經營效率與生產力影響之分析。朝陽商管評論，4(2)，93-126。
  96. 陳淑卿(2009)。長榮大學企業管理學系=Chang Jung Christian University。
  97. 曾芳美、許志承、梁家源(2003)。富邦金融控股公司的經營績效分析。玄奘管理學報，1(1)，39-62。
  98. 賈弘一(2010)。14家金控玩8年資產規模保險金控勝出。金融保險論壇，2，28-29。
  99. 賈弘一(2011)。步步為營俞國華寧慢勿亂集思廣益。金融保險論壇，8，38-39。
  100. 趙莊敏、林培茵(2008)。共同行銷效益與公司治理變數對金融控股公司經營績效之影響—二系統DEA 與超級效率DEA 模型之應用。台北科技大學學報，41(1)，69-88。
  101. 蔣蕙嬣(2004)。國立高雄第一科技大學金融營運所=National Kaohsiung First University of Science and Technology。
  102. 蔡彥卿(2005)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究成果報告,行政院國家科學委員會=National Science Council of the Executive Yuan。
  103. 賴威廷(2004)。東海大學企業管理學系=Tunghai University。
被引用次数
  1. 林玟廷、李佳玲(2018)。成長策略與外部股東資金來源之關係：集團企業之調節效果。管理與系統，25(4)，571-602。
print cancel