傅柯論權力與主體

Michel Foucault on Power and Subject

10.6350/JSSP.200403.0117

林淑芬(Shu-Fen Lin)

主體 ； 權力 ； 現代性 ； 抵抗 ； 政治 ； subject ； power ； modernity ； resistance ； the political

人文及社會科學集刊

16卷1期（2004 / 03 / 01）

117 - 150

繁體中文

本文以傅柯(Michel Foucault)對超驗主體(transcendental subject)的質疑，知識／權力及主體形構(subject formation)的交互關聯，和其所涉及的細緻的規訓(disciplinary)、律化(regulatory)力量網絡的詮釋，及系譜學分析所強調的歷史脈絡及偶然性(contingency)，提出對「國家」與「公民」的一種嘗試性的解讀方式。亦即以「權力關係」取代「國家」、以「主體」置換對於「公民」的討論，並勾勒出系譜政治想像的輪廓。本文最後則針對前述系譜政治所隱藏的「去政治化」等問題提出補充說明。

This essay attempts to provide an alternative reading of ”citizen” and ”state”. It draws on Foucault's interrogation/de-construction of the ”transcendental subject”, knowledge power/subject relationship, as well as his analysis of the disciplinary and regulatory power networks. Based on this, the essay displaces classical discussions of ”state” with ”power relations”; ”citizen” with ”subject”. In so doing, the essay clarifies the meaning of ”genealogical politics” and brings into light the latter's radical potentials when reflecting on contemporary political condtions. Finally, the essay reflects on the tendency of 'de-politicization' in genealogical politics, and suggests ”reactivating” politics with categories such as ”articulation” and ”hegemony”.

1. 林淑芬(2003)。政治行動的可能性條件。政治與社會哲學評論，4
   連結：
2. Allison,Henry(1983).Kant's Transcendental Idealism: An Interpretation and Defence.New Haven:Yale University Press.
3. Arendt,Hannah(1958).The Human Condition.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press.
4. Arendt,Hannah(1977).Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought.New York:Penguin Books.
5. Arendt,Hannah(1979).The Recovery of the Public Word.New York:St.Martin's Press.
6. Bauman,Zygman(1991).Modernity and Ambivalence.Oxford:Polity Press.
7. Benjamin,Walter(1969).Illuminations.New York:Schoken.
8. Blumenburg,Hans(1983).The Legitimacy of the Modern Age.Mass:MIT Press.
9. Brown,Wendy(1998).The later Foucault.London:Sage.
10. Brown,Wendy(1995).States of Injury:Power and Freedom in Late Modernity.New Jersey:Princeton Univeristy Press.
11. Bulter,Judith(1993).Bodies that Matter:On the Discursive Limits of "Sex".London:Routeldge.
12. Bulter,Judith(2000).Contingency,Hegemony,Universalities:Comtemprary Dialogues on the Left.London:Verso.
13. Bulter,Judith(1997).The Psychic Life of Power.California:Standford University Press.
14. Bulter,Judith(1990).Gender Trouble.London:Routeldge.
15. Connolly,W.E.(1988).Political Theory and Modernity.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
16. Connolly,W.E.(1998).The later Foucault.London:Sage.
17. d''Entreves,A.P.(1951).Natural Law: An Introduction tp Legal Philosophy.London:Hutchinson University Library.
18. Derrida,Jacques(1978).Writing and Difference.London:Routeldge & Kegan Paul.
19. Derrida,Jacques(1981).Position.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
20. Dreyfus L.,Paul Rabinow(1982).Michel Foucault : Beyond Strusturalism and Hermeneutics.
21. Ehrenreich,Barbara,Frances Fox Piven(1983).Alternaltives:Proposal for America from the Democratic Left.New York:Pantheon.
22. Eisentein,Zillah R.(1993).The Radical Future of Liberal Feminism.Boston:Northeastern University Press.
23. Evans,Judith(1995).Feminist theory today:An Introduction to Second-Wave Feminism.London:Sage.
24. Foucault,Michel(1982).Michel Foucault : Beyond Strusturalism and Hermeneutics.
25. Foucault,Michel(1980).Power/Knoweldge.
26. Foucault,Michel(1990).The History of Sexuality;Volume 1.
27. Foucault,Michel(1989).The Archaeology of knowledge.London:Routeldge.
28. Foucault,Michel(2000).Essential Works of Michel Foucault 1954-1984,volume 1.
29. Foucault,Michel(1991).The Foucault Effect.
30. Foucault,Michel(2000).Essential Works of Michel Foucault 1954-1984,volume 3.
31. Foucault,Michel(1980).Power/Knoweldge:Selected Interview and Other Writings1972-1977.
32. Foucault,Michel(2000).Essential Works of Michel Foucault 1954-1984,volume 2.
33. Foucault,Michel(1984).The Foucault Reader.
34. Foucault,Michel(1989).Foucault Live.New York:Semiotext.
35. Foucault,Michel(1992).The Use of Pleasure,The History of Sexuality,volume 2.
36. Foucault,Michel(1994).The Order of Things:An Archaeology of the Human Science.
37. Foucault,Michel(1984).The Foucault Reader: An Introduction to Foualt's Thought.
38. Foucault,Michel(1991).The Foucault Effect.
39. Foucault,Michel(1991).The Foucault Effect.
40. Foucault,Michel(1988).Politics,Philosophy,Culture.New York:Routeldge.
41. Foucault,Michel(1991).Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison.
42. Foucault,Michel(1980).Power/Knoweldge.
43. Fraser,Nancy(1989).Unruly Pratices:Power,Discourse and Gender in Contemporary Social Theory.Cambridge:Polity Press.
44. Freud,Sigmund(1991).On Metapsychology : The Theory of Psychoanalysis.
45. Gordon,Colin(1991).The Foucault Effect.
46. Habermas,Jurgen(1981).Modernity versus Postmodernity.New German Critique
47. Heidegger,Martin(1999).Ontology-The Hermeneutics of Facticity.Indiana University Press:Bloomington&Indianapolis.
48. Howarth,David(2000).Discourse.Cambridge:Open University Press.
49. Kelly,Michael(1994).Critique and Power: Recasting the Foucault/habermas Debate.Mass:The MIT Press.
50. Kolakowski,Leszek(1982).Religion.London:Fontana.
51. Kundera,Milan(1984).The Unbearable Lightness of Being.New York:Harper&Row.
52. Laclau, Ernesto(1990).New Reflections on the Revolution of Our Time.London:Verso.
53. Laclau,Ernesto,Chantal Mouffe(1985).Hegemony & Socialist Strategy: Toward a Radical Democratic Politics.London:Verso.
54. Lyotard,Jean-Francois(1984).The Postmodern Condition:A Report on Knowledge.Minnesota:University of Minnasota Press.
55. Marx,Karl(1978).The Marx-Engels Reader.New York:Norton.
56. Nietzsche,Friedrich(1989).On the Genealogy of Morals.New York:Vintage.
57. Nietzsche,Friedrich(1966).Beyond Good and Evil: Prelude to a Philosophy of Future.New York:Vintage.
58. Nietzsche,Friedrich(1974).The Gay Science: With a Prelude in Rhymes and an appendix of Songs.New York:Vintage.
59. Nietzsche,Friedrich(1969).The Will to Power.New York:Vintage.
60. Staten,Henry(1984).Wittgenstein and Derrida.Lincoln:University of Nebraska Press.
61. Tong,Rosemary Putnam(1998).Feminst Thought: A More Comprehensive Introduction.
62. Villa,Dana(1998).Politics,Philosophy,Terror: Essay on the Thought of Hannah Arendt.New Jersey:Princeton Univeristy Press.
63. Visker,Rudi(1995).Michel Foucault : Genealogy as Critique.London:Verso.
64. 林志明(1998)。古典時代瘋狂史。台北:時報文化。
65. 海德格(1994)。林中路。台北:時報文化。
66. 傅柯。必須保衛社會。上海人民出版社。

1. 馮美滿(2016)。以 Michel Foucault 權力知識理論探究今日臺灣公立國中之教育實務。教育學誌，35，145-197。
2. 林淑芬(2006)。拉克勞(Ernesto Laclau)霸權理論中的敵對與異質性。政治科學論叢，30，97-130。
3. 羅皓誠,蔡素琴,劉淑慧,洪雅鳳(2014)。精緻化的Willig傅柯式論述分析方法：以Gee微觀論述分析劇場與圖像作為雙翼。臺灣諮商心理學報，2(1)，51-75。
4. 王孝勇(2007)。女性主義立場論的主體與權力問題。政治與社會哲學評論，21，89-146。
5. 王孝勇(2011)。Mikhail Bakhtin 狂歡節概念的民主化意涵：從批判取向論述分析的理論困境談起。新聞學研究，108，183-223。
6. 吳彥明(2011)。治理「文化治理」：傅柯、班奈特與王志弘。臺灣社會研究季刊，82，171-204。
7. 趙筱屏(2023)。權力與課程決定之研究：以一所國小課程發展委員會為例。學校行政，145，183-205。
8. 鄭佩芬、黃秋琪、周傳姜(2015)。權力視野下的照顧關係並兼論關懷實踐的意義─長期照護機構照顧服務員的自我敘說探究。生命教育研究，7(2)，27-56。
9. (2005)。傅柯思想的初探及其權力理論對現代教育的啓示。教育研究，13，1-9。
10. (2005)。經義折獄、刑獄治理與傳統法律的文化格局—從朱熹「戊申延和奏劄」談起。政大法學評論，87，1-66。