题名

空間再層域化和國家：改革開放後的中國空間發展策略

并列篇名

Rescaling, State, and Spatial Development Strategy in Post-Reform China

DOI

10.6350/JSSP.200603.0077

作者

簡博秀(Titan Bo-Xiu Jian)；周志龍(Tze-Lung Zhou)

关键词

全球化 ； 國家 ； 空間層域化和中國 ； Globalization ； State ； Rescaling ； and China

期刊名称

人文及社會科學集刊

卷期/出版年月

18卷1期（2006 / 03 / 01）

页次

77 - 118

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

正當許多對全球化的研究都將焦點聚集在國家的終結、或是能力的腐蝕上，來說明國家領域將被全球化的經濟活動所支解的同時，本研究則將重心仍放置在一個國家主義的論述中－認為國家對空間層級的操弄，其實是一個領域化的策略，而真正的目的仍擺脫不掉一個國家為創造資本累積的空間邏輯。因此，在全球化的衝擊下，國家的角色並沒有因此而功能減弱，反而在空間的形塑上更具有影響力。這對改革開放後的中國大陸的國家空間策略描述而言，尤其明顯－自早期沿海開放政策、經濟特區和開放城市的設立，到九○年代的浦東開發和高新技術開發區的設置，莫不是以這個思維的邏輯進行空間的規劃。所以，本研究將爰用改革開放後中國大陸的國家做為範本，以經濟特區和高新技術園區做為例子，藉此來說明在經濟全球化的衝擊下，國家將如何應用空間層級的概念和再領域化的策略，來達到吸引外資和創造國家財富的最終目的。
英文摘要

Recent studies of the globalization confirm the absence of the state, or the contraction of the state, as the global scale expands. By contrast, this paper examines the changing relationship between state and globalization, then postulate that state scale is not being eroded, but rather, the state is being rearticulated and reterritorialized in relation to other scales, particularly both sub- and supra-state scales. Importantly, state re-scaling is a major accumulation strategy through which these transformed ”glocal” territorial states attempt to promote the global competitive advantage of their major urban region, as state face the violent challenge from globalization. With this in mind, we turn to Post-reform China. We select two examples, the Special Economic Zones (SEZS) and, High-and New Technology Development Zones (HNTDZs), to illustrate the forces at work in the China, this paper of intent is to show how the state deployed a spatial scalar and re-territorialization strategy to attract foreign direct investment and create national wealth under the influence of global economy; and we view these two spatial strategies as the process of state-rescaling.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. Beresford, M.,B. Mcfarlane(1995).Regional Inequality and Regionalism in Vietnam and China.Journal of Contemporary Asia,25,50-72.
  2. Binn, T.(1991).Shanghai's Pudong Development Project.Geography,76,362-365.
  3. Brenner, N.(1998).Global Cities, Global States: Global City Formation and State Territorial Restructuring in Contemporary Europe.Review of International Political Economy,5,1-37.
  4. Brenner, N.(1999).Beyond State-centrism? Space, Territoriality, and Geographical Scale in Globalization Studies.Theory and Society,28,39-78.
  5. Brenner, N.(2002).Decoding the Newest "Metropolitan Regionalism.Cities,19(1),3-21.
  6. Brenner, N.(1998).Between Fixity and Motion: Accumulation, Territorial Organization and the Historical Geography of Spatial Scales.Environment and Planning D,16,459-481.
  7. Brenner, N.(2000).The Urban Question as a Scale Question: Reflections on Henri Lefebvre,Urban Theory and the Politics of Scale.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,24(2),361-378.
  8. Brenner, N.(1997).Global, Fragmented, Hierarchical: Henri Lefevre's Geographies of Globalization.Public Culture,10,137-169.
  9. Brenner, N.(1997).State Territorial Restructuring and the Production of Spatial Scale: Urban and Regional Planning in the Federal Republic of Germany, 1960-1990.Political Geography,16(4),273-306.
  10. Brenner, N.(1999).Globalisation as Reterritorialisation: The Rescaling of Urban Governance in the European Union.Urban Studies,36(3),431-451.
  11. Brenner, N.,B. Jessop, M. Jones,G. MacLeod(2003).State/Space: A Reader.Oxford:Oxford.
  12. Chan, R. C. K.(1996).Urban Development Strategy in an Era of Global Competition: The Case of South China.Habitat International,20(4),509-523.
  13. Chen, X.(1995).The Evolution of Free Economic Zones and Recent Development of Crossnational Growth Zone.International Journey of Urban and Regional Research,19(4),591-621.
  14. Cox, K.(1996).The Difference That Scale Makes.Political Geography,15(8),667-670.
  15. Cox, K.(1998).Space of Dependence, Space of Engagement and the Politics of Scale, or:Looking for Local Politics.Political Geography,17,1-24.
  16. Crane, G. T.(1995).Of Belts and Ladders: State Policy and Uneven Regional Development in Post-Mao China.Annals of the Association of American Geography,85,421-449.
  17. Crane, G. T.(1990).The Political Economy of China's Special Economic Zones.New York:M.E Sharpe..
  18. Crane, G. T.(1997).Uneven Development and Beyond: Regional Development Theory in PostMao China.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,21(4),620-639.
  19. Friedmann J.(1986).The World City Hypothesis.Development and Change,17(1),69-83.
  20. Friedmann J.(1995).World Cities: In a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press..
  21. Friedmann, J.,G. Wolff(1982).World City Formation: An Agenda for Research and Action.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,6(3),309-344.
  22. Fu,Z.(1999).Paper Presented at a Conference on The Future of Chinese Cities: A Research Agenda for the 21th Century.Shanghai:Shanghai Academy of Social Science.
  23. Goodman, D. S. G.(2004).Open Up the West: National, Provincial-level and Local Perspective.China Quarterly,178,317-334.
  24. Hirst, P.,G. Thompson(1995).Globalization and the Future of the Nation State.Economy and Society,24(3),408-442.
  25. Hirst, P.,G. Thompson(1996).Globalization In Question.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  26. Huan, G.(1986).China's Open Door Policy, 1978-1984.Journal of International Affairs,39(2),1-18.
  27. Huang, F.(1991).Planning in Shanghai.Habitat International,15(3),87-98.
  28. Jacobs, J. B.,L. Hong(1994).China Deconstructs: Politics, Trade and Regionalism.New York:Routledge.
  29. Jarvey, D.(1982).The Limits to Capital.New York:Oxford University Press.
  30. Jarvey, D.(1985).Social Relations and Spatial Structures.London:Macmillan.
  31. Jessop, B.(1994).Post-Fordism.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  32. Jessop, B.(1998).Globalisation and the Asia-Pacific.London:Routledge.
  33. Jessop, B.(2002).The Future of the Capitalist State.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  34. Jessop, B.(2000).The Crisis of the National Spatio-temporal Fix and the Tendential Ecological dominance of Globalizing Capitalism.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,24(2),232-260.
  35. Jessop, B.,N. Sum(2000).An Entrepreneurial City in Action: Hong Kong's Emerging Strategies in and for(inter) Urban Competition.Urban Studies,37(12),2287-2313.
  36. Kemenade, W. V.(1998).China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Inc: The Dynamics of a Ne'w Empire..
  37. Knox, P. L.(1995).World Cities in a World-system.Cambridge:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  38. Lardy, N. R.(1995).The Role of Foreign Trade and Investment in China's Economic Transformation.China Quarterly,144,1065-1082.
  39. Lefebvre, H.(1991).The Production of Space.MA:Blackwell.
  40. Lin, G. C. S.(1997).Red Capitalism in South China.Vancouver:University of British Columbia Press.
  41. Lin, G. C. S.(1999).State Policy and Spatial Restructuring in Post-reform China, 1978-95.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,23(4),670-696.
  42. Lin, G. C. S.(1999).Transportation and Metropolitan Development in China's Pearl River Delta:The Experience of Panyu.Habitat International,23(2),249-270.
  43. Lipietz, A.(1994).Transcending the State-global Divide.Lynne Reinner:Boulder.
  44. Ma, L. J. C.(2002).Urban Transformation in China, 1949-2000: A Review and Research Agenda.Environment and Planning A,34(9),1545-1569.
  45. Machimura, T.(1992).The Urban Restructuring Process in Tokyo in the 1980s: Transforming Tokyo into a World City.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,16(1),114-128.
  46. MacLeod, G.,M. Goodwin(1999).Space, Scale and State Strategy: Rethinking Urban and Regional Governance.Progress in Human Geography,23(4),503-527.
  47. MacLeod, G.,M. Goodwin(1999).Reconstructing an Urban and Regional Political Economy: On the State,Politics, Scale, and Explanation.Political Geography,18,697-730.
  48. Mann,M.(1997).Has Globalization Ended the Rise and Rise of the Nation-state?.Review of International Political Economy,4,472-496.
  49. Mansfield, B.(2001).Thinking through scale: The role of state governance in globalizing North Pacific fisheries.Environment and Planning A,33,1807-1827.
  50. Massey, D.(1993).Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures, Global Change.London:Routledge.
  51. Mittelman, J. H.(1996).Globalization:Critical Reflections.Boulder CO:Lynne Rienner.
  52. Ng, M. K.(2000).Planning for a Better Urban Living Environment in Asia.Aldershot:Ashgate.
  53. Ohmae, K.(1995).The End of the Nation State.New York:Free Press.
  54. Oi, J. C.(1995).The Role of the Local State in China's Transitional Economy.China Quarterly,144,1132-1149.
  55. Oi, J. C.(1992).Fiscal Reform and the Economic Foundations of Local State Corporatism.World Politics,45(1),99-126.
  56. Olds, K.(1997).Globalizing Shanghai: The "Global Intelligence Crops and the Building of Pudong".Cities,14(2),109-123.
  57. Olds, K.(1995).Globalization and the Production of New Urban Space: Pacific Rim Mega Projects in the 20th Century.Environment and Planning A,27,1713-1743.
  58. O''Neil, P. M.(1997).Geographies of Economics.London:Arnold.
  59. Park,J.(1997).The Special Economic Zones of China and Their Impact on Its Economic Development.London:Praeger.
  60. Pryke, M.(1991).An International City Going 'Global': Spatial Change in the City of London.Environment and Planning D,9,197-222.
  61. Reich, R. H.(1992).The Work of Nations.New York:Vintage.
  62. Ruggie, J. G.(1993).Territoriality and Beyond: Problematising Modernity in International Relation.International Organization,47,139-174.
  63. Saito, A.(2003).Global City Formation in a Capitalist Developmental State: Tokyo and Waterfront Sub-centre Project.Urban Studies,40(2),283-308.
  64. Sassen S.(1999).States and Sovereignty in the Global Economy.London:Routledge.
  65. Sassen S.(2001).The Global City.NJ:Princeton University Press.
  66. Sassen S.(1994).Cities in a World Economy.CA:Pine Forge Press.
  67. Satio, A.,A. Thornley(2003).Shifts in Tokyo's World City Status and the Urban Planning Response.Urban Studies,40(4),665-685.
  68. Scott, A.(1988).New Industrial Spaces: Flexible Organization and Regional Development in North American and West Europe.London:Pion.
  69. Scott, A. J.(1998).Regions and the World Economy.New York:Oxford University Press.
  70. Shen,J.(2004).Cross-border Urban Governance in Hong Kong: The Role of State in a Globalizing City-region.Professional Geographer,56(4),530-543.
  71. Sit, V. F. S.(1996).Mega-city, Extended Metropolitan Region, Desakota, and Exo-urbanization:An Introduction.Asia Geographer,15(1),1-14.
  72. Smith, N.(1995).Competition European Peripheries.Berlin:Springer Verlag.
  73. Smith, N.(1993).Mapping the Futures: Local Culture, Global Change.London:Routledge.
  74. Storper, M.(1992).The Limits to Globalization: Technology Districts and International Trade.Economic Geography,68,60-93.
  75. Storper, M.(1993).Regional "Worlds" of Production: Learning and Innovation in Technology Districts of France, Italy and the USA.Regional Studies,27,433-455.
  76. Strange, S.(1996).The Retreat of State.New York:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  77. Swyngedouw, E.(1997).Space of Globalization.New York:Guilford Press.
  78. Swyngedouw, E.(1996).Reconstructing Citizenship, the Re-scaling of the State and the New Authoritarianism: Closing the Belgian Miles.Urban Studies,37(12),2287-2313.
  79. Swyngedouw, E.(2000).Authoritarian Governance, Power, and the Politics of Rescaling.Environmetal and Planning D,18,63-76.
  80. Uitermark, J.(2002).Rescaling, 'Scale Fragmentation' and the Regulation of Antagonistic Relationships.Progress in Human Geography,26(6),743-65.
  81. Walder, A. G.(1995).Local Governments as Industrial Firms: An Organizational Analysis of China's Transitional Economy.American Journal of Sociology,101(2),263-301.
  82. Wei, Y.(1998).Economic Reforms and Regional Development in Coastal China.Contemporary Asia,28(4),498-517.
  83. Wei, Y.(1996).Fiscal System and Uneven Regional Development in China, 1978-1991.Geoforum,27(3),329-344.
  84. Weiss, L.(1997).Globalization and the Myth of the Powerless State.New Left Reviezv,225,3-27.
  85. Wu,F.(2003).The (Post-) Social Entrepreneurial City as a State Project: Shanghai's Reglobalization in Question.Urban Studies,40(9),1673-1698.
  86. Wu,F.(2003).Globalization, Place Promotion and Urban Development in Shanghai.Journal of Urban Affairs,25(1),55-78.
  87. Wu,F.(2000).The Global and Local Dimension of Place-making: Remarking Shanghai as a World city.Urban Studies,37(3),1359-1377.
  88. Wu,W.(1999).City Profile: Shanghai.Cities,16(3),207-216.
  89. Yang, D.(1991).China Adjusts to the World Economy: The Political Economy of China's Coastal Development Strategy.Pacific Affair,64,42-64.
  90. Yang, D.(1990).Patterns of China's Regional Development Strategy.China Quarterly,122,230-257.
  91. Yeh, A. G. 0.(1996).Shanghai: Transformation and Modernization under China's Open Door Policy.Hong Kong:The Hong Kong Chinese University Press.
  92. Yeung, H. W-C(1998).Capital, State and Space: Contesting the Borderless World.Transactions of Institute of British Geographer,23,291-309.
  93. Yusuf, S.,W. Wu(2002).Pathways to a World City: Shanghai Rising in an Globalization.Urban Studies,39(7),1213-1240.
  94. 中華人民共和國科學技術部(1999)。中國高新技術產業發展報告。北京:科學出版社。
  95. 王紹光、胡鞍鋼(1994)。中國國家能力報告。香港:牛津大學出版社。
  96. 田江海(1996)。中國開發區綜覽。北京:中國建材工業出版社。
  97. 朱文暉(2003)。走向競合-珠三角與長三角經濟發展比較。北京:清華大學出版社。
  98. 何煉成(2000)。西部大開發-戰略、政策、論證。西安:西北大學出版社。
  99. 吳國光、鄭永包(1995)。論中央-地方關係。香港:牛津大學出版社。
  100. 李京文(2001)。新經濟與中國西部開發。香港:香港中文大學亞太研究所。
  101. 杜平(2000)。西土取經-西部大開發的政策背景與商業機遇。北京:中國言實出版社。
  102. 段樵、伍鳳儀(2004)。發表於中國區域經濟發展與兩岸經貿互動學術研討會。台北:政冶大學國際關係研究中心。
  103. 胡兆量(2000)。中國七個經濟區育評價。經濟地理，1(17)，1-15。
  104. 胡兆量編(1999)。中國區域發展導論。北京:北京大學出版社。
  105. 胡鞍鋼、王紹光、康曉光(1996)。中國地區差異報告。台北:中國歐亞學會。
  106. 張文合(1989)。我國區域經濟發展戰略的轉變與選擇。經濟研究，10，71-76。
  107. 郭彥弘(1997)。香港大都市規畫:前店的規劃。地理研究，2(16)，1-10。
  108. 郭萬達、朱文暉(2003)。中國製造-"世界工廠"正轉向中國。南京:江蘇人民出版社。
  109. 陳述彭(2001)。新經濟與中國西部開發。香港:香港中文大學亞太研究所。
  110. 陳振光(2004)。發表於二十一世紀的城市變化國際學術會議。上海:華東師範大學。
  111. 陳漢欣、李新芬(1999)。邁向廿一世紀的中國-城鄉與區域發展。香港:香港中文大學亞太研究所。
  112. 葉嘉安(1996)。中國區域經濟發展面面觀。臺北:臺灣大學人口研究中心。
  113. 董濱、高小林(2000)。突破-中國特區啟示錄。武漢:武漢出版社。
  114. 劉君德(1993)。中國城市與區域發展:展望廿一世紀。香港:香港中文大學。
  115. 劉勇、高化民(2001)。大論爭-建國以來重要論爭實錄。珠海:珠海出版社。
  116. 龍遠蔚(2000)。西部大開發:時機、機遇和挑戰。民族研究，2，30-33。
  117. 嚴重敏(1993)。區域經濟和城市發展研究。上海:華東師範大學西歐北美地理研究所。
  118. 顧朝林、趙令勛(1998)。中國高技術產業與園區。北京:中信出版社。
被引用次数
  1. 簡博秀(2010)。鐵本事件：新都會區域主義、競爭與區域治理。遠景基金會季刊，11(2)，139-179。
print cancel