题名

民主和平論與非民主和平論之經驗檢證：政治制度相似性的關鍵作用

并列篇名

An Empirical Analysis of the Democratic Peace and Non-democratic Peace Theses: The Critical Effects of Political Institutional Similarity

作者

張文揚(Wen-Yang Chang)

关键词

民主和平 ； 非民主和平 ； 制度相似性 ； 制度研究 ； democratic peace ； non-democratic peace ； institutional similarity ； institutional studies

期刊名称

人文及社會科學集刊

卷期/出版年月

26卷1期（2014 / 03 / 01）

页次

1 - 39

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

自「民主國家之間比較不會發生戰爭」的論述經由理論與實證研究確認以來，民主和平論受到西方國際關係學界，特別是衝突研究社群以及政策實踐者的歡迎，並成為西方國家外交政策的一部分。然而，自1990年代中期以來，「非民主國家之間也有可能和平」的說法也獲得學者驗證，這讓衝突研究社群在探討政治制度與軍事衝突的連結上，無法統一看法與提供政策建議。本文認為，過去對「政治體制－軍事衝突」的研究，過度強調與比較民主和非民主政體的優劣以及這些體制特徵對於國際和平的影響，進而忽略了國內政治制度本身如何直接影響國際關係。本文主張，由於制度相似性提供區別敵我、加強溝通以及傳遞訊息的作用，讓制度類似的國家面臨軍事衝突前，提高解決衝突的效率以避免外交危機升級或國際摩擦，並進一步解釋為何民主國家之間與非民主國家之間發生衝突的機率不高。利用1950年到2001年的數據資料，本文透過實證的方式確認這個關係。
英文摘要

The popularity of the democratic peace theory-democracies rarely fight against each other-is derived from its theoretical and empirical support. However, since the 1990s the ”dictatorial peace” argument, proposing that non-democracies are also less likely to engage in militarized disputes with each other, has emerged. Failing to provide a unified approach to explain why both regime types account for peace prevents us from advancing a unified explanation for the polity-conflict nexus. This paper proposes that it is the institutional characteristics, rather than regime characteristics, that determine the likelihood of conflict onset among institutionally similar states in political terms. Institutional similarity helps states identify friends or adversaries, provides information for behavior prediction, and reduces communication costs. Using the data of the period spanning 1950-2001, this paper confirms that political institutional similarity reduces the incidence of conflict.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 朱雪瑛(2005)。「民主和平論」之分析與美國「推廣民主」戰略。臺灣民主季刊，2(1)，123-158。
    連結：
  2. 黃旻華(2001)。「民主和平」研究的方法論：「聽眾成本」概念之辨析。問題與研究，40(1)，87-107。
    連結：
  3. 黎寶文(2011)。單一政黨威權政體間和平肇因之商榷。問題與研究，50(3)，75-103。
    連結：
  4. Barbieri, Katherine and Omar M. G. Keshk 2012 “Correlates of War Project Trade Data Set Codebook, Version 3.0,” Retrieved December 19, 2012, from http://correlatesofwar.org
  5. Freedom House 2013 “Methodology,” Retrieved June 12, 2013, from http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world-2012/methodology
  6. Bush, George W. 2004 “President and Prime Minister Blair Discussed Iraq, Middle East,” Retrieved December 22, 2012, from http://georgewbushwhitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2004/11/20041112-5.html
  7. Obama, Barack H. 2009 “Nobel Lecture-A Just and Lasting Peace,” Retrieved December 22, 2012, from http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/peace/laureates/2009/obama-lecture_en.html
  8. Center for International Comparisons of Production, University of Pennsylvania 2013 “About PWT,” Retrieved June 12, 2013, from http://pwt.econ.upenn.edu/php_site/pwt_index.php
  9. Correlates of War Project 2011 “State System Membership List, v2011,” Retrieved November 18, 2012, from http://correlatesofwar.org/
  10. 中華人民共和國商務部美洲大洋洲司 2013 〈中國與委內瑞拉經貿關係簡況〉。2013 年 6 月 17 日，取自 http://mds.mofcom.gov.cn/article/Nocategory/200812/20081205968707.shtml (Department of American and Oceanian Affairs, Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China, 2013, “China-Venezuela's Economic and Trade Relations: Brief Introduction,” Retrieved June 17, 2013, from http://mds.mofcom.gov.cn/article/Nocategory/200812/20081205968707.shtml)
  11. Ghosn, Faten and Scott Bennett 2003 “Codebook for the Dyadic Militarized Interstate Incident Data, Version 3.10,” Retrieved December 24, 2012, from http://correlatesofwar.org
  12. Clinton, William 1994 “1994 State of the Union Address,” Retrieved December 22, 2012, from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/states/docs/sou94.htm
  13. Hiro, Dilip 2006 “Shanghai Surprise: The Summit of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Reveals How Power Is Shifting in the World,” The Guardian, June 16. Retrieved June 20, 2013, from http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2006/jun/16/shanghaisurprise
  14. Correlates of War Project 2006 “Direct Contiguity Data, 1816-2006, Version 3.1,” Retrieved December 24, 2012, from http://correlatesofwar.org/
  15. 石之瑜 2010 〈民主和平論所到，戰爭所到〉。中國評論新聞網，9 月 5 日。2011 年 3 月 29 日，取自 http://www.chinareviewnews.com/doc/1014/3/5/2/101435272.html?coluid=33&kindid=2411&docid=101435272&mdate=0905002640 (Shih, Chih-yu, 2010, “War Follows Democratic Peace Theory,” China Review News, September 5. Retrieved March 29, 2011, from http://www.chinareviewnews.com/doc/1014/3/5/2/101435272.html?coluid=33&kindid=2411&docid=101435272&mdate=0905002640)
  16. Heston, Alan, Robert Summers, and Bettina Aten 2012 “Penn World Table Version 7.1,” Retrieved November 18, 2012, from https://pwt.sas.upenn.edu/
  17. Babst, Dean V.(1964).Elective Governments-A Force for Peace.The Wisconsin Sociologist,3(1),9-14.
  18. Babst, Dean V.(1972).A Force for Peace.Industrial Research,14,55-58.
  19. Barbieri, Katherine(1996).Economic Interdependence: A Path to Peace or a Source of Interstate Conflict?.Journal of Peace Research,33(1),29-49.
  20. Barbieri, Katherine,Keshk, Omar M. G.,Pollins, Brian M.(2009).Trading Data: Evaluating Our Assumptions and Coding Rules.Conflict Management and Peace Science,26(5),471-491.
  21. Barkawi, Tarak,Laffey, Mark(1999).The Imperial Peace: Democracy, Force and Globalization.European Journal of International Relations,5(4),403-434.
  22. Beck, Nathaniel,Katz, Jonathan N.(1995).What to Do (and Not to Do) with Time-Series Cross-Section Data.American Political Science Review,89(3),634-647.
  23. Bennett, D. Scott(2006).Toward a Continuous Specification of the Democracy-Autocracy Connection.International Studies Quarterly,50(2),313-338.
  24. Bennett, D. Scott,Stam, Allan C.(2000).EUGene: A Conceptual Manual.International Interactions,26(2),179-204.
  25. Boehmer, Charles R.,Sobek, David(2005).Violent Adolescence: State Development and the Propensity for Militarized Interstate Conflict.Journal of Peace Research,42(1),5-26.
  26. Boix, Carles,Miller, Michael,Rosato, Sebastian(2013).A Complete Data Set of Political Regimes, 1800-2007.Comparative Political Studies,46(12),1523-1554.
  27. Bollen, Kenneth A.,Paxton, Pamela(2000).Subjective Measures of Liberal Democracy.Comparative Political Studies,33(1),58-86.
  28. Bowman, Kirk,Lehoucq, Fabrice,Mahoney, James(2005).Measuring Political Democracy: Case Expertise, Data Adequacy, and Central America.Comparative Political Studies,38(8),939-970.
  29. Bremer, Stuart A.(1992).Dangerous Dyads: Conditions Affecting the Likelihood of Interstate War, 1816-1965.Journal of Conflict Resolution,36(2),309-341.
  30. Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce,Koch, Michael T.,Siverson, Randolph M.(2004).Testing Competing Institutional Explanations of the Democratic Peace: The Case of Dispute Duration.Conflict Management and Peace Science,21(4),255-267.
  31. Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce,Morrow, James D.,Siverson, Randolph M.,Smith, Alastair(1999).An Institutional Explanation of the Democratic Peace.American Political Science Review,93(4),791-807.
  32. Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce,Smith, Alastair,Siverson, Randolph M.,Morrow, James D.(2003).The Logic of Political Survival.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
  33. Buhaug, Halvard(2005).Dangerous Dyads Revisited: Democracies May Not Be That Peaceful after All.Conflict Management and Peace Science,22(2),95-111.
  34. Cederman, Lars-Erik,Hug, Simon,Krebs, Lutz F.(2010).Democratization and Civil War: Empirical Evidence.Journal of Peace Research,47(4),377-394.
  35. Conrad, Justin,Souva, Mark(2011).Regime Similarity and Rivalry.International Interactions,37(1),1-28.
  36. Dafoe, Allan,Oneal, John R.,Russett, Bruce(2013).The Democratic Peace: Weighing the Evidence and Cautious Inference.International Studies Quarterly,57(1),201-214.
  37. Dahl, Robert A.(1972).Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition.New Haven, CT:Yale University Press.
  38. Denzau, Arthur T.,North, Douglass C.(1994).Shared Mental Models: Ideologies and Institutions.Kyklos,47(1),3-31.
  39. Dixon, William J.(1994).Democracy and the Peaceful Settlement of International Conflict.American Political Science Review,88(1),14-32.
  40. Fearon, James D.(1994).Domestic Political Audiences and the Escalation of International Disputes.American Political Science Review,88(3),577-592.
  41. Ferejohn, John,Rosenbluth, Frances McCall(2008).Warlike Democracies.Journal of Conflict Resolution,52(1),3-38.
  42. Freedom House(2012).,New York:Freedom House.
  43. Gartzke, Erik,Weisiger, Alex(2013).Permanent Friends? Dynamic Difference and the Democratic Peace.International Studies Quarterly,57(1),171-185.
  44. Gasiorowski, Mark J.(1996).An Overview of the Political Regime Change Dataset.Comparative Political Studies,29(4),469-483.
  45. Geddes, Barbara(1999).Authoritarian Breakdown: Empirical Test of a Game Theoretic Argument.95th Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association,Atlanta, GA:
  46. Ghosn, Faten,Palmer, Glenn,Bremer, Stuart A.(2004).The MID3 Data Set, 1993-2001: Procedures, Coding Rules, and Description.Conflict Management and Peace Science,21(2),133-154.
  47. Gleditsch, Nils Petter,Wallensteen, Peter,Eriksson, Mikael,Sollenberg, Margareta,Strand, Håvard(2002).Armed Conflict 1946-2001: A New Dataset.Journal of Peace Research,39(5),615-637.
  48. Gochman, Charles S.(1991).Interstate Metrics: Conceptualizing, Operationalizing, and Measuring the Geographic Proximity of States since the Congress of Vienna.International Interactions,17(1),93-112.
  49. Goemans, H. E.(2000).Fighting for Survival: The Fate of Leaders and the Duration of War.Journal of Conflict Resolution,44(5),555-579.
  50. Goemans, H. E.(2000).War and Punishment: The Causes of War Termination and the First World War.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  51. Gowa, Joanne(1999).Ballots and Bullets: The Elusive Democratic Peace.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  52. Hegre, Havard,Ellingsen, Tanja,Gates, Scott,Gleditsch, Nils Petter(2001).Toward a Democratic Civil Peace? Democracy, Political Change, and Civil War, 1816-1992.American Political Science Review,95(1),33-48.
  53. Hobson, Christopher(2009).Beyond the End of History: The Need for a 'Radical Historicisation' of Democracy in International Relations.Millennium,37(3),631-657.
  54. Hufbauer, Gary Clyde,Schott, Jeffrey J.,Elliott, Kimberly Ann,Oegg, Barbara(2007).Economic Sanctions Reconsidered.Washington, DC:Peterson Institute for International Economics.
  55. Huntington, Samuel P.(1993).The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late 20th Century.Norman, OK:University of Oklahoma Press.
  56. International Interactions(2010).Special Issue: A Capitalist Peace?.International Interactions,36(2),107-213.
  57. Johnston, Alastair Iain(2008).Social States: China in International Institutions, 1980-2000.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  58. Jones, Daniel M.,Bremer, Stuart A.,Singer, J. David(1996).Militarized Interstate Disputes, 1816-1992: Rationale, Coding Rules, and Empirical Patterns.Conflict Management and Peace Science,15(2),163-213.
  59. Kant, Immanuel(1957).Perpetual Peace.New York:Liberal Arts Press.
  60. Kinne, Brandon,Marinov, Nikolay(2013).Electoral Authoritarianism and Credible Signaling in International Crises.Journal of Conflict Resolution,57(3),359-386.
  61. Lai, Brian,Slater, Dan(2006).Institutions of the Offensive: Domestic Sources of Dispute Initiation in Authoritarian Regimes, 1950-1992.American Journal of Political Science,50(1),113-126.
  62. Liang, Kung-yee,Zeger, Scott L.(1986).Longitudinal Data Analysis Using Generalized Linear Models.Biometrika,73(1),13-22.
  63. Mansfield, Edward D.(ed.),Pollins, Brian M.(ed.)(2003).Economic Interdependence and International Conflict: New Perspectives on an Enduring Debate.Ann Arbor, MI:University of Michigan Press.
  64. Mansfield, Edward D.,Pollins, Brian M.(2001).The Study of Interdependence and Conflict: Recent Advances, Open Questions, and Directions for Future Research.Journal of Conflict Resolution,45(6),834-859.
  65. Mansfield, Edward D.,Snyder, Jack L.(2005).Electing to Fight: Why Emerging Democracies Go to War.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
  66. Mansfield, Edward D.,Snyder, Jack L.(2002).Democratic Transitions, Institutional Strength, and War.International Organization,56(2),297-337.
  67. Maoz, Zeev,Russett, Bruce(1993).Normative and Structural Causes of Democratic Peace, 1946-1986.American Political Science Review,87(3),624-638.
  68. Marshall, Monty G.,Jaggers, Keith,Gurr, Ted Robert(2010).Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800-2010: Dataset Users' Manual.Vienna, VA:Center for Systemic Peace.
  69. McHenry, Dean E.(2000).Quantitative Measures of Democracy in Africa: An Assessment.Democratization,7(2),168-185.
  70. McHenry, Dean E.,Mady, Abdel-Fattah(2006).A Critique of Quantitative Measures of the Degree of Democracy in Israel.Democratization,13(2),256-282.
  71. Mousseau, Michael(2009).The Social Market Roots of Democratic Peace.International Security,33(4),52-86.
  72. Mousseau, Michael(2013).The Democratic Peace Unraveled: It's the Economy.International Studies Quarterly,57(1),186-197.
  73. North, Douglass C.(1991).Institutions.Journal of Economic Perspectives,5(1),97-112.
  74. Park, Johann(2013).Forward to the Future? The Democratic Peace after the Cold War.Conflict Management and Peace Science,30(2),178-194.
  75. Peceny, Mark,Beer, Caroline C.(2003).Peaceful Parties and Puzzling Personalists.American Political Science Review,97(2),339-342.
  76. Peceny, Mark,Beer, Caroline C.,Sanchez-Terry, Shannon(2002).Dictatorial Peace?.American Political Science Review,96(1),15-26.
  77. Peceny, Mark,Butler, Christopher K.(2004).The Conflict Behavior of Authoritarian Regimes.International Politics,41(4),565-581.
  78. Ray, James Lee(2013).War on Democratic Peace.International Studies Quarterly,57(1),198-200.
  79. Reiter, Dan,Stam, Allan C.(2003).Identifying the Culprit: Democracy, Dictatorship, and Dispute Initiation.American Political Science Review,97(2),333-337.
  80. Richards, Diana(2001).Coordination and Shared Mental Models.American Journal of Political Science,45(2),259-276.
  81. Risse-Kappen, Thomas(1995).Democratic Peace-Warlike Democracies? A Social Constructivist Interpretation of the Liberal Argument.European Journal of International Relations,1(4),491-517.
  82. Rosato, Sebastian(2003).The Flawed Logic of Democratic Peace Theory.American Political Science Review,97(4),585-602.
  83. Russett, Bruce M.(1993).Grasping the Democratic Peace: Principles for a Post-Cold War World.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  84. Russett, Bruce M.,Oneal, John R.(2001).Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations.New York:W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.
  85. Singer, J. David(1988).Reconstructing the Correlates of War Dataset on Material Capabilities of States, 1816-1985.International Interactions,14(2),115-132.
  86. Singer, J. David,Bremer, Stuart,Stuckey, John(1972).Capability Distribution, Uncertainty, and Major Power War, 1820-1965.Peace, War, and Numbers,Beverly Hills, CA:
  87. Solansky, Stephanie T.,Duchon, Dennis,Plowman, Donde Ashmos,Martinez, Patricia G.(2008).On the Same Page: The Value of Paid and Volunteer Leaders Sharing Mental Models in Churches.Nonprofit Management and Leadership,19(2),203-219.
  88. Souva, Mark(2004).Institutional Similarity and Interstate Conflict.International Interactions,30(3),263-280.
  89. Stinnett, Douglas M.,Tir, Jaroslav,Diehl, Paul F.,Schafer, Philip,Gochman, Charles(2002).The Correlates of War (Cow) Project Direct Contiguity Data, Version 3.0.Conflict Management and Peace Science,19(2),59-67.
  90. Tammen, Ronald L.,Kugler, Jacek,Lemke, Douglas,Stam, Allan C., III,Alsharabati, Carole,Abdollahian, Mark Andrew,Efird, Brian,Organski, A. F. K.(2000).Power Transitions: Strategies for the 21th Century.New York:Chatham House Publishers.
  91. Themnér, Lotta,Wallensteen, Peter(2012).Armed Conflicts, 1946-2011.Journal of Peace Research,49(4),565-575.
  92. Tomz, Michael R.,Weeks, Jessica L. P.(2013).Public Opinion and the Democratic Peace.American Political Science Review,107(4),849-865.
  93. Valentino, Benjamin A.,Huth, Paul K.,Croco, Sarah E.(2010).Bear Any Burden? How Democracies Minimize the Costs of War.Journal of Politics,72(2),528-544.
  94. Vanhanen, Tatu(2000).A New Dataset for Measuring Democracy, 1810-1998.Journal of Peace Research,37(2),251-265.
  95. Weeks, Jessica L.(2012).Strongmen and Straw Men: Authoritarian Regimes and the Initiation of International Conflict.American Political Science Review,106(2),326-347.
  96. Weeks, Jessica L.(2008).Autocratic Audience Costs: Regime Type and Signaling Resolve.International Organization,62(1),35-64.
  97. Weingast, Barry R.(1995).A Rational Choice Perspective on the Role of Ideas: Shared Belief Systems and State Sovereignty in International Cooperation.Politics & Society,23(4),449-464.
  98. Werner, Suzanne(2000).The Effects of Political Similarity on the Onset of Militarized Disputes, 1816-1985.Political Research Quarterly,53(2),343-374.
  99. Werner, Suzanne,Lemke, Douglas(1997).Opposites Do Not Attract: The Impact of Domestic Institutions, Power, and Prior Commitments on Alignment Choices.International Studies Quarterly,41(3),529-546.
  100. Zeger, Scott L.,Liang, Kung-yee(1986).Longitudinal Data Analysis for Discrete and Continuous Outcomes.Biometrics,42(1),121-130.
  101. Zorn, Christopher J. W.(2001).Generalized Estimating Equation Models for Correlated Data: A Review with Applications.American Journal of Political Science,45(2),470-490.
  102. Zorn, Christopher J. W.(2006).Comparing GEE and Robust Standard Errors for Conditionally Dependent Data.Political Research Quarterly,59(3),329-341.
  103. 向駿(2013)。後查維茲時代之「中」委關係。亞太和平月刊，5(4)
  104. 羅致政(1997)。美國「擴展民主」戰略的理論與實踐。台灣政治學刊，2(1)，191-232。
被引用次数
  1. 蔡榮祥(2020)。因果機制和政治解釋：民主和平論和現實主義的論辯。問題與研究，59(4)，143-180。
  2. 黎寶文(2020)。印度在美中互動的槓桿角色。人文及社會科學集刊，32(4)，559-605。
  3. 平思寧(2015)。自然資源與國內衝突：權力轉移理論的應用。人文及社會科學集刊，27(3)，471-506。
  4. 薛健吾(2023)。「制度相似效果」或「選擇效果」？再探民主和平論中「政治制度相似性」與「軍事衝突發生機率」之間的關係。人文及社會科學集刊，35(2)，303-349。
  5. 張文揚(2014)。民主與環境治理─一個遴選集團理論的解釋。臺灣民主季刊，11(3)，1-39。
  6. 莊易霖(2014)。高中公民與社會課程綱要之和平教育內涵與議題的分析。彰化師大教育學報，25，1-62。
  7. (2021)。為何記者持續遭殺害？探索菲律賓記者遭殺害的問題及社會構成（1986-2019）。中華傳播學刊，40，145-190。
print cancel