盧梭、康德與永久和平

Rousseau, Kant and Perpetual Peace

周家瑜(Chia-Yu Chou)

永久和平 ； 自由國際聯盟 ； 憲政共和主義 ； 民主共和主義 ； 共和主義 ； perpetual peace ； federation of free states ； constitutional republicanism ； democratic republicanism ； republicanism

人文及社會科學集刊

26卷4期（2014 / 12 / 01）

621 - 657

繁體中文

在當代國際政治理論中，康德對國際政治的看法是經常被引用之權威，然而對此一文本本身的解讀仍有不少爭議，其中一個最主要爭議，就是要如何去理解康德所提出的國際問題的解答一一即「自由國家聯盟」（Federation of Free States），這樣的一個解答讓許多康德的追隨者相當困惑，認為是康德之理論對現實的妥協，但筆者以為康德所提出的這個論點背後有更深意涵，並非出於經驗考畫，本文藉由與盧梭所整理出版的法國聖皮耶教士原初永久和平計畫的文本之比較，為康德對國際關係問題所提出的解答提出一個可能的詮釋。

While Immanuel Kant's influential essay on his plan for perpetual peace has been an important resource for contemporary studies on international relations, due to the obscurity of the text itself there still remain some unresolved interpretive difficulties. One main difficulty lies in understanding the solution that Kant proposed in his plan for perpetual peace, namely the federation of free states. Since what Kant proposed is a federation which member states are allowed to join or withdraw from freely, it leads to the criticism that lack of coercive force is very likely to lead to the collapse of the federation. Moreover, to contemporary cosmopolitans, Kant 's proposal also seems to fail to go beyond the limits of national states, and therefore can be considered outdated. The main aim of this essay is to re-interpret Kant's proposal of free federation by comparing Kant's theory of international relations with J.J. Rousseau's revision of Abbé Saint-Pierre 's well-known project for perpetual peace. I argue that by putting Kant's proposal into the context of Rousseau's revision of Abbé Saint-Pierre's project, it can be seen that rather than being outdated, Kant further develops and completes Rousseau's unfinished revision by transforming Rousseau's democratic republicanism into constitutional republicanism.

1. 陳嘉銘(2013)。盧梭推論戰爭權利的途徑─從共和自由到萬民法。臺灣民主季刊，10(4)，93-136。
   連結：
2. 曾國祥(2004)。憲政主義與民主的衝突：美國政治思想的一個側面。政治與社會哲學評論，11，35-82。
   連結：
3. 蕭高彥(2002)。共和主義與現代政治。政治與社會哲學評論，1，85-116。
   連結：
4. Spector, C. 2011 "The Plan for Perpetual Peace: From Saint-Pierre to Rousseau," Retrieved Sep. 6, 2013, from http://www.journals.elsevier.com/histeuroideas
5. Waluchow,W. J. 2014 "Constitutionalism," Retrieved Mar. 14, 2014, from http://plato.Stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/constitutionalism/
6. Axinn, S.(1989).Kant on World Government.Proceedings of the Sixth International Kant Congress,Washington, DC:
7. Beitz, Charles R.(1979).Political Theory and International Relations.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
8. Bohman, J.(ed.),Lutz-Bachmann, M.(ed.)(1997).Perpetual Peace: Essays on Kant's Cosmopolitan Ideal.Cambridge, MA:The MIT Press.
9. Bull, H.(1977).The Anarchical Society: A Study of Order in World Politics.New York:Palgrave.
10. Carson, T.(1988).Perpetual Peace: What Kant Should Have Said.Social Theory and Practice,14(2),173-214.
11. Cavallar, Georg(1999).Kant and the Theory and Practice of International Right.Cardiff:University of Wales Press.
12. Clark, I.(1989).The Hierarchy of States: Reform and Resistance in the International Order.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
13. Clarks, I.(ed.),Neumann, I.(ed.)(1996).Classical Theories of International Relations.Baingstoke:Macmillan Press.
14. Covell, C.(1998).Kant and the Law of Peace.London:Macmillan Press.
15. Danilovic, V.,Clare, J.(2007).The Kantian Liberal Peace (Revisited).American Journal of Political Science,51(2),397-414.
16. Doyle, M. W.(1983).Kant, Liberal Legacies, and Foreign Affairs.Philosophy & Public Affairs,12(3),205-235.
17. Ellis, E.(2005).Kant's Politics: Provisional Theory for an Uncertain World.New Haven:Yale University Press.
18. Elster, J.(ed.),Slagstad, R.(ed.)(1993).Constitutionalism and Democracy.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
19. Gallie, W. B.(1978).Philosophers of Peace and War.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
20. Gourevitch, V.(ed.)(1997).The Social Contract and Other Later Political Writings.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
21. Gregor, M.(ed.)(1996).The Metaphysics of Morals.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
22. Harrison, E.(2002).Waltz, Kant and Systemic Approaches to International Relations.Review of International Studies,28(1),143-162.
23. Hinsley, F. H.(1963).Power and the Pursuit of Peace.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
24. Höffe, Otfried(2006).Kant's Cosmopolitan Theory of Law and Peace.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
25. Hoffmann, S.(1963).Rousseau on War and Peace.American Political Science Review,57(2),317-333.
26. Hoffmann, S.(1965).The State of War: Essays on the Theory and Practice of International Politics.New York:Praeger.
27. Hoffmann, Stanley(ed.),Fidler, David P.(ed.)(1991).Rousseau on International Relations.New York:Oxford University Press.
28. Holsti, K. J.(1997).The State, War, and the State of War.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
29. Huntley, W.(1996).Kant's Third Image: Systemic Sources of the Liberal Peace.International Studies Quarterly,40(1),45-76.
30. Kant, Immanuel,Gregor, M.(trans. ed.)(1996).The Metaphysics of Morals.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
31. Kant, Immanuel,Reiss, H. S.(ed.)(1991).Political Writings.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
32. Kelly, C.(ed.)(2005).The Plan for Perpetual Peace, On the Government of Poland, and Other Writings on History and Politics.Hanover, NH:Dartmouth College Press.
33. Kelly, C.(ed.),Grace, E.(ed.)(2001).The Collected Writings of Rousseau.Hanover, NH:University Press of New England.
34. Kleingeld, P.(2012).Kant and Cosmopolitanism: The Philosophical Ideal of World Citizenship.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
35. Kleingeld, P.(2004).Approaching Perpetual Peace: Kant's Defence of a League of States and His Ideal of a World Federation.European Journal of Philosophy,12(3),304-325.
36. Kleingeld, P.(1998).Kant's Cosmopolitan Law: World Citizenship for a Global Order.Kantian Review,2,72-90.
37. Maple, D.(ed.),Nardin, T.(ed.)(1998).International Society: Diverse Ethical Perspectives.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
38. Mikalsen, K.(2011).In Defense of Kant's League of States.Law and Philosophy,30(3),291-317.
39. Oberer, H.(ed.)(1996).Kant: Analysen-Probleme-Kritik.Würzburg:Konigshausen und Neumann.
40. Pogge, T.(1983).Kant, Rawls, and Global Justice.Ann Arbor, MI:University Microfilms.
41. Rawls, J.(2002).The Law of Peoples.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
42. Ripstein, A.(2009).Force and Freedom: Kant's Legal and Political Philosophy.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
43. Rousseau, J. J.(1968).The Social Contract.London:Penguin.
44. Teson, F.(1992).The Kantian Theory of International Law.Columbia Law Review,92(1),53-102.
45. Waltz, K.(1959).Man, the State, and War.New York:Columbia University Press.
46. Wight, M.(1987).An Anatomy of International Thought.Review of International Studies,13(3),221-227.
47. Williams, H.(1983).Kant's Political Philosophy.New York:St. Martin's Press.
48. Williams, M. C.(2005).The Realist Tradition and the Limits of International Relations.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
49. 耿曙(2003)。分析層次與國際體系。國際關係總論，臺北=Taipei:
50. 蕭高彥(2013)。西方共和主義思想史論。臺北=Taipei:聯經=Linking Publishing。

1. 謝旭昇(2021)。康德的公共性與超越共同體：都市計劃民衆參與之理論重構。公共行政學報，61，1-40。