公民教育的知識效果：一項定群追蹤的探索性研究

The Knowledge Effect of Civic Education: A Pilot Study Using Panel Data

邱師儀(Albert Shihyi Chiu)

公民教育 ； 政治知識 ； 學校教育 ； 臺中 ； 高中 ； civic education ； political knowledge ； school education ； Taichung ； high school

人文及社會科學集刊

29卷1期（2017 / 03 / 01）

127 - 171

繁體中文

政治知識為構成政治文化的內涵之一，而「公民教育」的目的，為提升受教者的政治知識程度。然而，所謂的「公民教育效果有限論」是學界的主流論述，一直到了1990 年代後，才逐漸有公民教育能增進學生政治知識的實證研究，但國內這方面的研究仍舊缺乏。本文針對中部一所高中，以相同題目進行一年共兩波的定群追蹤調查，並採取固定與隨機效果混合併用法，有兩項發現：第一、公民教育能增進高中生部分的政治知識項目；第二、父親低學歷組與父親高學歷組的知識差距，在某些情況下被公民教育彌合是有可能的。這些發現均有民主意義，將在文中逐一討論。

One of the goals of civic education is to enhance political knowledge. Practically, however, the question remains as to whether or not civic education enhances political knowledge. The research questions are two-fold. First, does civic education cause political knowledge? Second, does civic education have the function of diminishing the knowledge gap between the students from higher socioeconomic backgrounds and those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds? A panel analysis was conducted on data from interviews of students in Taichung in 2012 and 2013. The major finding is that, in some cases, the students who did not have equally good socioeconomic backgrounds were able to catch up with their more advantaged counterparts in terms of political knowledge by taking a course on civic education. The democratic implications of these findings are discussed.

1. Huang, Chi,Wang, Hung-chung,Lin, Chang-chih(2013).Knowledge of the Electoral System and Voting: Taiwan's 2008 and 2012 Legislative Elections.Issues & Studies,49(4),1-45.
   連結：
2. 林聰吉、王淑華(2007)。台灣民眾政治知識的變遷與來源。東吳政治學報，25(3)，93-129。
   連結：
3. 林瓊珠(2005)。台灣民眾的政治知識：1992~2000 年的變動。選舉研究，12(1)，147-171。
   連結：
4. 梁福鎮(2009)。全球化脈絡下臺灣公民教育的挑戰與回應。教育科學期刊，8(1)，63-86。
   連結：
5. 郭銘峰、王鼎銘(2014)。小泉執政時期眾參兩院選舉之定群追蹤分析：固定與隨機效果並用法之應用。選舉研究，21(1)，127-167。
   連結：
6. 黃秀端、徐永明、林瓊珠(2014)。政治知識的測量。選舉研究，21(1)，89-126。
   連結：
7. 劉嘉薇、黃紀(2012)。父母政黨偏好組合對大學生政黨偏好之影響—定群追蹤之研究。臺灣民主季刊，9(3)，37-84。
   連結：
8. 劉嘉薇、黃紀(2010)。持續與變遷—政治資訊對大學生政治信任感影響之定群追蹤研究。政治學報，50，111-146。
   連結：
9. 教育部 2006　《95 普通高級中學課程暫行綱要》。2006 年1 月24 日，取自http://www3.cnsh.mlc. edu.tw/~aao/ruels/edurules/95curriculum.htm (Ministry of Education, 2006, The Temporary Curriculum Protocol for High Schools Students in 2006. Retrieved January 24, 2006, from http://www3.cnsh.mlc.edu.tw/~aao/ruels/edurules/95curriculum.htm)
10. Skinner, Rebecca and Chris Chapman1999 “Service-Learning and Community Service in K–12 Public Schools,” NCES 1999–043. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
11. 曾韋禎2006　〈有激情無思想的學運〉。中時電子報，2006 年7 月28 日，取自http://forums.chinatimes.com/report/2006depose/forum/95072801.htm (Tzeng, Wei-jen, 2006, “The Student Protest That Goes without Theory,” Chinatimes, Retrieved July 28, 2006, from http://forums.chinatimes.com/report/2006depose/forum/95072801.htm)
12. Allison, Paul D.(2009).Fixed Effects Regression Models.Newbury Park, CA:Sage Publishing.
13. Barabas, Jason,Jerit, Jennifer(2009).Estimating the Causal Effects of Media Coverage on Policy-Specific Knowledge.American Journal of Political Science,53(1),73-89.
14. Bennett, S. C.(1995).A Statistical Study of Rhamphorhynchus from the Solnhofen Limestone of Germany: Year-Classes of a Single Large Species.Journal of Paleontology,69(3),569-580.
15. Blau, Peter M.,Duncan, Otis Dudley(1967).The American Occupational Structure.New York:Wiley.
16. Campbell, Angus(ed.),Converse, Philip E.(ed.)(1972).The Human Meaning of Social Change.New York:Russell Sage Foundation.
17. Campbell, David E.(2009).Civic Engagement and Education: An Empirical Test of the Sorting Model.American Journal of Political Science,53(4),771-786.
18. Carpini, Michael X. Delli,Keeter, Scott(1991).Stability and Change in the U.S. Public's Knowledge of Politics.Public Opinion Quarterly,55(4),583-612.
19. Carpini, Michael X. Delli,Keeter, Scott(1996).What Americans Know about Politics and Why It Matters.New Haven, CT:Yale University Press.
20. Chan, Tak Wing,Goldthorpe, John H.(2007).Social Status and Newspaper Readership.American Journal of Sociology,112(4),1095-1134.
21. CQ Researcher(ed.)(2009).Issues for Debate in American Public Policy: Selections from CQ Researcher.Washington, DC:Congressional Quarterly Inc..
22. Elkin, Stephen L.(ed.),Soltan, Karol Edward(ed.)(1999).Citizen Competence and Democratic Institutions.University Park:Pennsylvania State University Press.
23. Elvestad, Eiri,Blekesaune, Arild(2008).Newspaper Readers in Europe: A Multilevel Study of Individual and National Differences.European Journal of Communication,23(4),425-447.
24. Finkel, Steven E.(2003).Can Democracy Be Taught?.Journal of Democracy,14(4),137-151.
25. Finkel, Steven E.,Smith, Amy Erica(2011).Civic Education, Political Discussion, and the Social Transmission of Democratic Knowledge and Values in a New Democracy: Kenya 2002.American Journal of Political Science,55(2),417-435.
26. Fraile, Marta(2011).Widening or Reducing the Knowledge Gap? Testing the Media Effects on Political Knowledge in Spain (2004-2006).The International Journal of Press/Politics,16(2),163-184.
27. Galston, William A.(2001).Political Knowledge, Political Engagement, and Civic Education.Annual Review of Political Science,4,217-234.
28. Hauser, Robert M.,Tsai, Shu-Ling,Sewell, William H.(1983).A Model of Stratification with Response Error in Social and Psychological Variables.Sociology of Education,56(1),20-46.
29. Jennings, M. Kent(1996).Political Knowledge over Time and across Generations.Public Opinion Quarterly,60(2),228-252.
30. Langton, Kenneth P.,Jennings, M. Kent(1968).Political Socialization and the High School Civics Curriculum in the United States.American Political Science Review,62(3),852-867.
31. Leming, Robert S.(1996).We the People-The Citizen and the Constitution.Bloomington, IN:ERIC Digest.
32. Litt, Edgar(1963).Civic Education, Community Norms, and Political Indoctrination.American Sociological Review,28(1),69-75.
33. McDonnell, Lorraine M.(ed.),Timpane, P. Michael(ed.),Benjamin, Roger(ed.)(2000).Rediscovering the Democratic Purposes of Education.Kansas:University Press of Kansas.
34. Morduchowicz, Roxana,Catterberg, Edgardo,Niemi, Richard G.,Bell, Frank(1996).Teaching Political Information and Democratic Values in a New Democracy: An Argentine Experiment.Comparative Politics,28(4),465-476.
35. Neuhaus, J. M.,Kalbfleisch, J. D.(1998).Between- and Within-Cluster Covariate Effects in the Analysis of Clustered Data.Biometrics,54(2),638-645.
36. Nie, Norman H.,Junn, Jane,Stehlik-Barry, Kenneth(1996).Education and Democratic Citizenship in America.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
37. Niemi, Richard G.,Junn, Jane(1998).Civic Education: What Makes Students Learn.New Haven, CT:Yale University Press.
38. Putnam, Robert D.(2000).Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York:Simon & Schuster.
39. Rabe-Hesketh, Sophia,Skrondal, Anders(2008).Multilevel and Longitudinal Modeling Using Stata.College Station:Stata Press.
40. Slomczynski, Kazimierz M.,Shabad, Goldie(1998).Can Support for Democracy and Market Be Learned in School? A Natural Experiment in Post-Communist Poland.Political Psychology,19(4),749-779.
41. Smith, Kevin B.(2003).The Ideology of Education: The Commonwealth, the Market, and America's Schools.Albany, NY:State University of New York Press.
42. Teachman, Jay D.(1987).Family Background, Educational Resources, and Educational Attainment.American Sociological Review,52(4),548-557.
43. Tichenor, P. J.,Donohue, G. A.,Olien, C. N.(1970).Mass Media Flow and Differential Growth in Knowledge.Public Opinion Quarterly,34(2),159-170.
44. Torney-Purta, Judith,Lehmann, Rainer,Oswald, Hans,Schulz, Wolfram(2001).Citizenship and Education in Twenty-eight Countries: Civic Knowledge and Engagement at Age Fourteen.Amsterdam:The International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement.
45. Verba, Sidney,Schlozman, Kay L.,Brady, Henry E.(1995).Voice and Equality: Civic Voluntarism in American Politics.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
46. Wolfinger, Raymond E.,Rosenstone, Steven J.(1980).Who Votes?.New Haven, CT:Yale University Press.
47. 孫清山、黃毅志(1996)。補習教育、文化資本與教育取得。臺灣社會學刊，19，95-139。
48. 張茂桂(2009)。再探公民：反思高中《公民與社會》新課綱之訂定。公民訓育學報，20，1-31。
49. 陳義彥、陳陸輝(2006)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,臺北=Taipei:行政院國家科學委員會=National Science Council, Executive Yuan。
50. 黃毅志(1990)。臺灣地區教育機會之不平等性。思與言，28(1)，93-125。
51. 廖添富、劉美慧、董秀蘭(1998)。我國師範院校學生「公民參與態度」與「公民教育觀點」相關性之研究。公民訓育學報，7，1-26。
52. 蕭揚基(2000)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,臺北=Taipei:行政院國家科學委員會=National Science Council, Executive Yuan。

1. 楊佩榮(2018)。高中學校經驗與青少年公民態度的關聯性。公民教育與活動領導學報，25，1-41。
2. (2021)。高職的公民培力微課程發展。教育學刊，56，83-119。