中國大中型鋼鐵企業表現差異及其決定因素

Factors Determining Differences in Performance between the Large and Medium Chinese Steel Enterprises

張嘉麟(Chia-lin Chang)；瞿宛文(Wan-wen Chu)

國企改革 ； 企業表現 ； 中國產業 ； 鋼鐵產業 ； SOE reform ； enterprise performance ； Chinese industry ； steel industry

人文及社會科學集刊

30卷3期（2018 / 09 / 01）

435 - 483

繁體中文

中國在經歷90年代國企改革之後，國企在一些包括鋼鐵業的重工業仍占有主導性的地位，本文欲探究這些國企維持其領導性地位之原因，因此探討主導中國鋼鐵業發展的大中型企業之間的表現差異，及導致差異的來源和因素。結果發現，雖然中國鋼鐵國企普遍承擔較多社會責任，財務負擔較高，以致獲利能力較私企低，然而大型國企因有較高的規模經濟生產優勢，並容易受到中央政府的支持，使其擁有較中型國企和其他大中型私企高的生產效率；中型國企則因較無規模優勢，又有沉重的財務負擔，因此企業表現排名居末；而改制企業的企業表現已能接近於私企。

After China pushed through a massive reform of the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in the late I990s, some SOEs still dominate heavy industries, including the steel industry. To study the reasons why these SOEs have been able to maintain their leading position, we investigate the difference in the performance of the large and medium steel enterprises in terms of ownership and scale, and analyze the causes of the difference in performance. Our results reveal that although some leading state-owned steel enterprises in China have higher financial burdens, probably due to their greater social responsibilities, they still have higher productivity because of their greater advantage of economies of scale, and they are more likely to be supported by the central government. The medium-sized SOEs perform worst because they don't have the advantage of economies of scale and have higher financial burdens. In addition, the privatized enterprises perform like the private ones.

1. 張嘉麟、瞿宛文(2015)。地方保護與市場競爭機制之運作—以中國鋼鐵業為例。經濟論文，43(4)，481-533。
   連結：
2. Aw, Bee Yan,Chung, Sukkyun,Roberts, Mark J.(2000).Productivity and Turnover in the Export Market: Micro-level Evidence from the Republic of Korea and Taiwan (China).The World Bank Economic Review,14(1),65-90.
3. Bai, Chong-en,Li, David D.,Tao, Zhigang,Wang, Yijiang(2000).A Multitask Theory of State Enterprise Reform.Journal of Comparative Economics,28(4),716-738.
4. Bai, Chong-en,Li, David D.,Wang, Yijiang(1997).Enterprise Productivity and Efficiency: When Is Up Really Down?.Journal of Comparative Economics,24(3),265-280.
5. Bai, Chong-en,Lu, Jiangyong,Tao, Zhigang(2009).How Does Privatization Work in China?.Journal of Comparative Economics,37(3),453-470.
6. Bai, Chong-en,Lu, Jiangyong,Tao, Zhigang(2006).The Multitask Theory of State Enterprise Reform: Empirical Evidence from China.The American Economic Review,96(2),353-357.
7. Becker-Blease, John R.,Kaen, Fred R.,Etebari, Ahmad,Baumann, Hans(2010).Employees, Firm Size and Profitability in U.S. Manufacturing Industries.Investment Management and Financial Innovations,7(2),7-23.
8. Boycko, Maxim,Shleifer, Andrei,Vishny, Robert W.(1996).A Theory of Privatisation.The Economic Journal,106(435),309-319.
9. Bozec, Richard,Breton, Gaétan,Côté, Louise(2002).The Performance of State-Owned Enterprises Revisited.Financial Accountability & Management,18(4),383-407.
10. Burger, Anže,Jaklič, Andreja,Rojec, Matija(2008).Exporting and Company Performance in Slovenia: Self-Selection and/or Learning by Exporting?.Ekonomický časopis,56(2),131-153.
11. Capon, Noel,Farley, John U.,Hoenig, Scott(1990).Determinants of Financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis.Management Science,36(10),1143-1159.
12. Chang, Ha-joon,Singh, Ajit(1993).Public Enterprises in Developing Countries and Economic Efficiency: A Critical Examination of Analytical, Empirical and Policy Issues.UNCTAD Review,4,45-82.
13. Chang, Hsihui,Fernando, Guy D.,Srinivasan, Dhinu,Tripathy, Arindam(2013).A Re-Examination of Diversification and Firm Productivity.Journal of Management Accounting Research,25(1),99-118.
14. Chen, Gongmeng,Firth, Michael,Rui, Oliver(2006).Have China's Enterprise Reforms Led to Improved Efficiency and Profitability?.Emerging Markets Review,7(1),82-109.
15. Chen, Gongmeng,Firth, Michael,Xu, Liping(2009).Does the Type of Ownership Control Matter? Evidence from China's Listed Companies.Journal of Banking & Finance,33(1),171-181.
16. De Loecker, Jan(2007).Do Exports Generate Higher Productivity? Evidence from Slovenia.Journal of International Economics,73(1),69-98.
17. Hay, Donald,Morris, Derek,Liu, Guy,Yao, Shujie(1994).Economic Reform and State-Owned Enterprises in China 1979-87.New York:Oxford University Press.
18. He, Feng,Zhang, Qingzhi,Lei, Jiasu,Fu, Weihui,Xu, Xiaoning(2013).Energy Efficiency and Productivity Change of China's Iron and Steel Industry: Accounting for Undesirable Outputs.Energy Policy,54,204-213.
19. Jefferson, Gary H.,Rawski, Thomas G.(1994).Enterprise Reform in Chinese Industry.The Journal of Economic Perspectives,8(2),47-70.
20. Jefferson, Gary H.,Rawski, Thomas G.,Li, Wang,Zheng, Yuxin(2000).Ownership, Productivity Change, and Financial Performance in Chinese Industry.Journal of Comparative Economics,28(4),786-813.
21. Jefferson, Gary H.,Su, Jian(2006).Privatization and Restructuring in China: Evidence from Shareholding Ownership, 1995-2001.Journal of Comparative Economics,34(1),146-166.
22. Jiang, Feitao,Chen, Weigang,Huang, Jianbai(2010).Limitations and Negative Results of Investment Regulation Policies: Based on Research into the Chinese Iron and Steel Industry.The Chinese Economy,43(4),30-48.
23. Jørgensen, Finn,Pedersen, Pål A.,Volden, Rolf(1997).Estimating the Inefficiency in the Norwegian Bus Industry from Stochastic Cost Frontier Models.Transportation,24(4),421-433.
24. Kang, Young-sam,Kim, Byung-yeon(2012).Ownership Structure and Firm Performance: Evidence from the Chinese Corporate Reform.China Economic Review,23(2),471-481.
25. Kole, Stacey R.,Mulherin, J. Harold(1997).The Government as a Shareholder: A Case from the United States.The Journal of Law & Economics,40(1),1-22.
26. Levinsohn, James,Petrin, Amil(2003).Estimating Production Functions Using Inputs to Control for Unobservables.The Review of Economic Studies,70(2),317-341.
27. Lin, Chen,Ma, Yue,Su, Dongwei(2009).Corporate Governance and Firm Efficiency: Evidence from China's Publicly Listed Firms.Managerial and Decision Economics,30(3),193-209.
28. Martin, Stephen,Parker, David(1995).Privatization and Economic Performance throughout the UK Business Cycle.Managerial and Decision Economics,16(3),225-237.
29. Nolan, Peter(2002).China and the Global Business Revolution.Cambridge Journal of Economics,26(1),119-137.
30. Olley, G. Steven,Pakes, Ariel(1996).The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment Industry.Econometrica,64(6),1263-1297.
31. Reeves, Eoin,Ryan, James(1998).A Benchmark Analysis of the Performance of State Owned Enterprises in Ireland.International Journal of Public Administration,21(11),1577-1602.
32. Rousseau, Peter L.,Xiao, Sheng(2008).Change of Control and the Success of China's Share-issue Privatization.China Economic Review,19(4),605-613.
33. Scheffler, Raimund,Hartwig, Karl-Hans,Malina, Robert(2013).The Effects of Ownership Structure, Competition, and Cross-Subsidisation on the Efficiency of Public Bus Transport: Empirical Evidence from Germany.Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,47(3),371-386.
34. Sheng, Yu,Song, Ligang(2013).Re-estimation of Firms' Total Factor Productivity in China's Iron and Steel Industry.China Economic Review,24,177-188.
35. Song, Ligang(ed.),Liu, Haimin(ed.)(2012).The Chinese Steel Industry's Transformation: Structural Change, Performance and Demand on Resources.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar Publishing.
36. Sun, Pei(2007).Is the State-led Industrial Restructuring Effective in Transition China? Evidence from the Steel Sector.Cambridge Journal of Economics,31(4),601-624.
37. Sun, Qian,Tong, Wilson H. S.,Tong, Jing(2002).How Does Government Ownership Affect Firm Performance? Evidence from China's Privatization Experience.Journal of Business Finance & Accounting,29(1-2),1-27.
38. Syverson, Chad(2004).Product Substitutability and Productivity Dispersion.The Review of Economics and Statistics,86(2),534-550.
39. Syverson, Chad(2011).What Determines Productivity?.Journal of Economic Literature,49(2),326-365.
40. Taube, Markus,in der Heiden, Thomas(2009).The State-Business Nexus in China's Steel Industry-Chinese Market Distortions in Domestic and International Perspective.European Confederation of Iron and Steel Industries,Munich:
41. Temouri, Yama,Vogel, Alexander,Wagner, Joachim(2013).Self-selection into Export Markets by Business Services Firms-Evidence from France, Germany and the United Kingdom.Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,25,146-158.
42. Van Biesebroeck, Johannes(2005).Exporting Raises Productivity in Sub-Saharan African Manufacturing Firms.Journal of International Economics,67(2),373-391.
43. Vickers, John,Yarrow, George(1991).Economic Perspectives on Privatization.The Journal of Economic Perspectives,5(2),111-132.
44. Walder, Andrew G.(1995).Local Governments as Industrial Firms: An Organizational Analysis of China's Transitional Economy.American Journal of Sociology,101(2),263-301.
45. Yang, Hsiao-shan(2011).Department of Economics, State University of New York at Buffalo.
46. Zhang, Anming,Zhang, Yimin,Zhao, Ronald(2002).Profitability and Productivity of Chinese Industrial Firms: Measurement and Ownership Implications.China Economic Review,13(1),65-88.
47. 中國鋼鐵工業年鑑編輯委員會編(1998)。中國鋼鐵工業年鑑。北京=Beijing:冶金工業出版社=Metallurgical Industry Press。
48. 王荊陽 2014 〈鋼鐵行業積患終成疾 減產只是個傳說〉。證券日報，10 月15 日。(Wang, Jingyang, 2014, “Accumulating Troubles in the Steel Industry Would Finally Become Illness, Output Reduction Is Only a Myth,” Securities Daily, October 15.)
49. 北京大學中國經濟研究中心(1998)。北京大學中國經濟研究中心 1998-2007 《中國規模以上工業企業資料庫》。臺北：漢珍數位圖書股份有限公司。(China Center for Economic Research, 1998-2007, The Database of China's Large and Mediumsized Industrial Enterprises. Taipei: Transmission Books & Microinfo Co. Ltd.)。
50. 姚洋(1998)。非國有經濟成分對我國工業企業技術效率的影響。經濟研究，1998(12)，29-35。
51. 胡一帆、宋敏、張俊喜(2006)。中國國有企業民營化績效研究。經濟研究，2006(7)，49-60。
52. 張軍(2008)。中國企業的轉型道路。上海=Shanghai:格致出版社=Truth and Wisdom Press。
53. 張嘉麟、瞿宛文(2014)。中國鋼鐵業近年來高速增長之成因。世界經濟文匯，2014(4)，1-19。
54. 項安波、張文魁(2013)。中國產業政策的特點、評估與政策調整建議。中國發展觀察，2013(12)，19-21。
55. 董輔礽編、康宗焜編、杜海燕編(1995)。中國國有企業制度變革研究。北京=Beijing:人民出版社=People's Publishing House。
56. 劉小玄(2000)。中國工業企業的所有制結構對效率差異的影響—1995 年全國工業企業普查數據的實證分析。經濟研究，2000(2)，17-25。
57. 劉世錦 2015 〈國務院官員：減產很難 政府不願讓企業關門〉，2015 年4 月18 日，取自http://news.sohu.com/20150418/n411472640.shtml (Liu, Shi-jin, 2015, “The Officials of the State Council: Reducing Production Was Very Hard, the Governments Were Not Willing to Close down the Enterprises,” Retrieved April 18, 2015, from http://news.sohu.com/20150418/n411472640.shtml)
58. 劉航 2013 〈鋼鐵產量逆勢增長的背後〉，中國冶金報，7 月13 日，第1 版。(Liu, Hang, 2013, “The Implicit Reasons for the Increase of Steel Production against the Trend,” Csteelnews, July 13, p. 1.)