题名

「每場有正當理由的戰爭都是義戰」：格勞秀斯《論捕獲法》的論述策略及其政治思想運用

并列篇名

＂Every War Derived Entirely from Just Causes, Is a Just War＂: Hugo Grotius's Discursive Strategy and Political Thought in De Jure Praedae

作者

賴芸儀(Yun-I Lai)

关键词

格勞秀斯 ； 《論捕獲法》 ； 《論海洋自由》 ； 荷蘭獨立運動 ； Hugo Grotius ； De Jure Praedae ； Mare Liberum ； Dutch independent movement

期刊名称

人文及社會科學集刊

卷期/出版年月

33卷2期（2021 / 06 / 01）

页次

179 - 219

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本文試圖探討荷蘭法學者格勞秀斯如何將他身處的國際現實反映在他的思想發展上，呈現以世俗化角度，將運用武力維護貿易與航海自由正當化，乃至於世俗化國家之政治論述。格勞秀斯以同意為一切人世間法秩序運作之基礎，構成荷蘭反抗西班牙統治之正當性與合法性。藉由比較《論捕獲法》與早先著作，顯示為聯合東印度公司處理劫掠法律問題的經驗，相當程度地影響了格勞秀斯日後看待國家以及國家主權之概念，而逐漸脫離傳統共和思想從理性或德行的面向，開展出以同意論為核心的共和思想與國家論述。
英文摘要

This article reconstructs the intellectual context of the Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius' (1583-1645) De Jure Praedae, in particular, the relation between Grotius' political thought and the political reality with the Dutch Republic faced at the time, including its international politics as well as the developing political discourse of a secular state. It emphasizes the changing conceptions of the lawful use of force to maintain free trade and navigation right from the perspective of political secularization. For Grotius, consent is the foundation of all human laws and it provides the legitimacy for and legality of the right to resist the Spanish rule. By comparing his early works and De Jure Praedae, this article shows how Grotius's republicanism and his thoughts on the political state gradually moves from the traditional republican conceptions, such as reason and virtue, toward consent theory.
主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. Akhtar, Jawaid(1995).Gujarati Merchants and the VOC: Conflict and Collaboration in South-East Asia during the 17th Century.Proceedings of the Indian History Congress,56,413-417.
  2. Andaya, Barbara Watson(1993).Cash Cropping and Upstream-Downstream Tensions: The Case of Jambi in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries.Southeast Asia in the Early Modern Era: Trade, Power, and Belief,Ithaca:
  3. Arasaratnam, S.(1969).Some Notes on the Dutch in Malacca and the Indo-Malayan Trade 1641– 1670.Journal of Southeast Asian History,10(3),480-490.
  4. Armitage, David(2008).The Declaration of Independence: A Global History.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
  5. Armitage, David(ed.),Grotius, Hugo,Hakluyt, Richard(trans.)(2004).The Free Sea.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  6. Bailyn, Bernard(1967).The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution.Cambridge:Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
  7. Baird, Rachel(1996).Political and Commercial Interests as Influences in the Development of the Doctrine of the Freedom of the High Seas.QUT Law Review,12,274-291.
  8. Bakker, J. I.(2004).The Execution of Oldenbarnevelt: The ‘Means of Coercion’ (Weber) in Comparative-Historical Perspective (Part II).Michigan Sociological Review,18,191-211.
  9. Baumgartner, Frederic J.(2011).Declaring War in Early Modern Europe.New York:Palgrave Macmillan.
  10. Bellia, Anthony J., Jr.(2012).The Law of Nations as Constitutional Law.Virginia Law Review,98(4),729-838.
  11. Benton, Lauren,Straumann, Benjamin(2010).Acquiring Empire by Law: From Roman Doctrine to Early Modern European Practice.Law and History Review,28(1),1-38.
  12. Bloemendal, Jan(2002).Hugo Grotius (1583–1645): Jurist, Philologist, and Theologian. A Christian Humanist, His Works, and His Correspondence.Nederlands archief voor kerkgeschiedenis,82(2),342-349.
  13. Blom, Andrew(2015).Grotius and Aristotle: The Justice of Taking Too Little.History of Political Thought,36(1),84-112.
  14. Borschberg, Peter(1999).Hugo Grotius, East India Trade and the King of Johor.Journal of Southeast Asian Studies,30(2),225-248.
  15. Borschberg, Peter(2005).Hugo Grotius’ Theory of Trans-Oceanic Trade Regulation: Revisiting Mare Liberum (1609).Itinerario,29(3),31-53.
  16. Borschberg, Peter(2003).A Luso-Dutch Naval Confrontation in the Johor River Delta 1603.Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft,153(1),157-175.
  17. Borschberg, Peter(2014).From Self-Defense to an Instrument of War: Dutch Privateering around the Malay Peninsula in the Early Seventeenth Century.Piracy and Surreptitious Activities in the Malay Archipelago and Adjacent Seas, 1600– 1840,Singapore:
  18. Buckland, W. W.(1975).A Text-Book of Roman Law from Augustus to Justinian, 3rd ed.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  19. Burrish, Onslow 1742 Batavia Illustrata: Or, a View of the Policy and Commerce of the United Provinces. London: Printed for J. Osborn.
  20. Carletti, Francesco,Weinstock, Herbert(trans.)(1964).My Voyage around the World.New York:Pantheon Books.
  21. Clegg, Cyndia Susan(2004).Press Censorship Jacobean Eengland.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  22. Clulow, Adam(2006).Pirating in the Shogun’s Waters: The Dutch East India Company and the Santo António Incident.Bulletin of Portuguese-Japanese Studies,13,65-80.
  23. Coutre, Jacques de,Borschberg, Peter(ed.)(2015).Jacques De Coutre’s Singapore and Johor 1594-c.1625.Singapore:NUS Press.
  24. Dijk, Wil O.(2002).The VOC’s Trade in Indian Textiles with Burma, 1634– 80.Journal of Southeast Asian Studies,33(3),495-515.
  25. Edmundson, George 1922 History of Holland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  26. Feenstra, Robert(ed.)(2009).Hugo Grotius: Mare Liberum 1609– 2009.Leiden:Brill.
  27. Fenn, Percy Thomas Jr. 1926 “Origins of the Theory of Territorial Waters,” American Journal of International Law 20(3): 465– 482.
  28. Fletcher, Eric G. M. 1933 “John Selden (Author of Mare Clausum) and His Contribution to International Law,” Transactions of the Grotius Society 19: 1–12.
  29. Gentelli, Liesel(2016).Provenance Determination of Silver Artefacts from the 1629 VOC Wreck Batavia Using LA-ICP-MS.Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports,9,536-542.
  30. Geyl, Pieter 1926 “Grotius,” Transactions of the Grotius Society 12: 81–97.
  31. Grotius, Hugo 1610 Liber De Antiquitate Reipublicae Batavicae. Lugduni Batavorum: Raphelengius.
  32. Grotius, Hugo 1649 A Treatise of the Antiquity of the Commonwealth of the Battavers, Which Is Now the Hollanders First Written in Latin by Hugo Grotius, Advocat Fiscall of Holland, Zealand, and Westfriesland, & C, Thomas Woods (trans.). London: Printed for Iohn Walker, at the signe of the Starre in Popes Head Alley.
  33. Grotius, Hugo(2006).Commentary on the Law of Prize and Booty.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  34. Grotius, Hugo(2005).The Rights of War and Peace, Book One.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  35. Grotius, Hugo 1658 Annales Et Historiae De Rebus Belgicis. Amstelaedami [Amsterdam]: Joannis Blaeu.
  36. Grotius, Hugo,Waszink, Jan(trans.)(2000).The Antiquity of the Batavian Republic.Assen:Van Gorcum.
  37. Guicciardini, Lodovico 1567 Descrittione Di Lodovico Guicciardini Patritio Fiorentino Di Tutti I Paesi Bassi Altrimenti Detti Germania Inferiore. Anversa [Antwerpen]: Apresso Guglielmo Siluio, Stampatore Regio.
  38. Hackett, Kimberly J.(2014).The English Reception of Oldenbarnevelt’s Fall.Huntington Library Quarterly,77(2),157-176.
  39. Hutchins, Todd Emerson(2011).Structuring a Sustainable Letters of Marque Regime: How Commissioning Privateers Can Defeat the Somali Pirates.California Law Review,99(3),819-884.
  40. Israel, Jonathan(1995).The Dutch Republic: Its Rise, Greatness, and Fall.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
  41. Knaap, Gerrit J.(1992).Crisis and Failure: War and Revolt in the Ambon Islands, 1636–1637.Cakalele,3,1-26.
  42. Ladner, Gerhart B.(1975).Justinian’s Theory of Law and the Renewal Ideology of the ‘Leges Barbarorum’.Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society,119(3),191-200.
  43. Lee, R. Warden 1945 “Grotius: The Last Phase, 1635–45,” Transactions of the Grotius Society 31: 193–215.
  44. Leeb, I. Leonard(1973).The Ideological Origins of the Batavian Revolution: History and Politics in the Dutch Republic 1747– 1800.The Hague:Martinus Nijhoff.
  45. Leeson, Peter T.(2009).The Invisible Hook: The Hidden Economics of Pirates.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  46. Lofgren, Charles A.(1972).War-Making under the Constitution: The Original Understanding.The Yale Law Journal,81(4),672-702.
  47. Loureiro, Rui Manuel(2017).Early Portuguese Perceptions of the ‘Dutch Threat’ in Asia.Rivalry and Conflict: European Traders and Asian Trading Networks in the 16th and 17th Centuries,Leiden:
  48. MacRae, Leslie M.(1983).Customary International Law and the United Nations’ Law of the Sea Treaty.California Western International Law Journal,13(2),181-222.
  49. Maloni, Ruby(2007).Experience and Environment: The Dutch in 17th Century Gujarat.Proceedings of the Indian History Congress,67,275-285.
  50. Marshall, C. Kevin(1997).Putting Privateers in Their Place: The Applicability of the Marque and Reprisal Clause to Undeclared Wars.University of Chicago Law Review,64(3),953-981.
  51. Meilink-Roelofsz, Marie Antoinette Petronella(1962).Asian Trade and European Influence: In the Indonesian Archipelago between 1500 and about 1630.The Hague:Martinus Nijhoff.
  52. Mitrasing, Ingrid S.(2014).Negotiating a New Order in the Straits of Malacca (1500–1700).KEMANUSIAAN,21(2),55-77.
  53. Nellen, H. J. M.(2005).Codes of Confidentiality in Hugo Grotius’s Correspondence (1594–1645).Text,17,251-264.
  54. Pearson, Michael Naylor(1976).Merchants and Rulers in Gujarat: The Response to the Portuguese in the Sixteenth Century.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  55. Reid, Anthony(2009).Southeast Asian Consumption of India and British Cotton Cloth, 1600–1850.How India Clothed the World: The World of South Asian Textiles, 1500– 1850,Leiden:
  56. Riker, William H.(1957).Dutch and American Federalism.Journal of the History of Ideas,18(4),495-521.
  57. Roelofsen, Cornelius G.(1989).The Freedom of the Seas: An Asian Inspiration for Mare Liberum.Legal Record and Historical Reality: Proceedings of the Eight British Legal History Conference, Cardiff, 1987,London:
  58. Roelofsen, Cornelius G.(1990).Grotius and the International Politics of the Seventeenth Century.Hugo Grotius and International Relations,Oxford:
  59. Rommen, Heinrich A.(1998).The Natural Law: A Study in Legal and Social History and Philosophy.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  60. Schnurmann, Claudia(2003).‘Wherever Profit Leads Us, to Every Sea and Shore. . . ’: The VOC, the WIC, and Dutch Methods of Globalization in the Seventeenth Century.Renaissance Studies,17(3),474-493.
  61. Selden, John 1635 Ioannis Seldeni Mare Clausum Seu De Dominio Maris Libri Duo Primo, Mare, Ex Iure Naturae Seu Gentium, Omnium Hominum Non Esse Commune, Sed Dominii Privati Seu Proprietatis Capax, Pariter Ac Tellurem, Esse Demonstratur. Secundo, Serenissimum Magnae Britanniae Regem Maris Circumflui, Ut Individuae Atque Perpetuae Imperii Britannici Appendicis, Dominum Esse, Asseritur. Londini: Excudebat Will. Stanesbeius, pro Richardo Meighen.
  62. Selden, John 1653 Ioannis Seldeni Vindiciae Secundùm Integritatem Existimationis Suae. Londini: apud Cornelium Bee.
  63. Souza, George Bryan(1986).The Survival of Empire: Portuguese Trade and Society in China and the South China Sea, 1630– 1754.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  64. Straumann, Benjamin(2007).Natural Rights and Roman Law in Hugo Grotius’s Theses LVI, De Iure Praedae and Defensio Capitis Quinti Maris Liberi.Grotiana,26(1),341-365.
  65. Straumann, Benjamin(2006).Ancient Caesarian Lawyers’ in a State of Nature: Roman Tradition and Natural Rights in Hugo Grotius’s De Iure Praedae.Political Theory,34(3),328-350.
  66. Straumann, Benjamin,Cooper, Belinda(trans.)(2015).Roman Law in the State of Nature: The Classical Foundations of Hugo Grotius’ Natural Law.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  67. Suárez, Thomas(1999).Early Mapping of Southeast Asia: The Epic Story of Seafarers, Adventurers, and Cartographers Who First Mapped the Regions between China and India.Hong Kong:Periplus Editions.
  68. Thomas, Philip(2003).Piracy, Privateering and the United States of the Netherlands.Revue internationale des droits de l’Antiquité,50(3),361-382.
  69. Thornton, Helen(2004).Hugo Grotius and the Freedom of the Seas.International Journal of Maritime History,16(2),17-38.
  70. Tracy, James D.(2008).The Founding of the Dutch Republic: War, Finance, and Politics in Holland, 1572–1588.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  71. Tuck, Richard(2001).The Rights of War and Peace: Political Thought and the International Order from Grotius to Kant.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  72. Tuck, Richard(1993).Philosophy and Government, 1572–1651.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  73. Tuck, Richard(1991).Grotius and Selden.The Cambridge History of Political Thought, 1450–1700,Cambridge:
  74. Tuck, Richard(1979).Natural Rights Theories: Their Origin and Development.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  75. Tuck, Richard(ed.)(2005).The Rights of War and Peace, Book One.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  76. United Provinces of the Netherlands, Staten Generaal 1599 A Proclamation of the Lords the Generall States, of the Vnited Prouinces Whereby the Spaniards and All Their Goods Are Declared to Be Lawfull Prize: As Also Containing a Strickt Defence or Restraint of Sending Any Goods, Wares, or Merchandizes to the Spaniards or Their Adherents, Enemies to the Netherlandes. Faithfully Translated out of the Dutch Coppy Printed at S. Grauen Haghe by Aelbercht Heyndrickson, Printer to the Generall States. London: By [E. Allde for] Iohn Wolfe
  77. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(2003).Hugo Grotius in Context: Van Heemskerck’s Capture of the Santa Catarina and Its Justification in De Jure Praedae.Asian Journal of Social Science,31(3),511-548.
  78. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(2006).Profit and Principle: Hugo Grotius, Natural Rights Theories and the Rise of Dutch Power in the East Indies, 1595– 1615.Leiden:Brill.
  79. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(2010).Mare Liberum in the West Indies?: Hugo Grotius and the Case of the Swimming Lion, a Dutch Pirate in the Caribbean at the Turn of the Seventeenth Century.Itinerario,31(3),59-94.
  80. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(2009).Dating the Manuscript of De Jure Praedae (1604–1608): What Watermarks, Foliation and Quire Divisions Can Tell Us about Hugo Grotius’ Development as a Natural Rights and Natural Law Theorist.History of European Ideas,35(2),125-193.
  81. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(2009).Preparing Mare Liberum for the Press: Hugo Grotius’ Rewriting of Chapter 12 of De Iure Praedae in November-December 1608.Property, Piracy and Punishment: Hugo Grotius on War and Booty in De Iure Praedae—Concepts and Contexts,Leiden:
  82. Van Ittersum, Martine Julia(ed.)(2006).Commentary on the Law of Prize and Booty.Indianapolis:Liberty Fund.
  83. Vieira, Mónica Brito(2003).Mare Liberum vs. Mare Clausum: Grotius, Freitas, and Selden’s Debate on Dominion over the Seas.Journal of the History of Ideas,64(3),361-377.
  84. Williams, Mary Wilhelmine 1922 “The Treaty of Tordesillas and the Argentine-Brazilian Boundary Settlement,” The Hispanic American Historical Review 5(1): 3– 23.
  85. Wilson, Eric(2009).The VOC, Corporate Sovereignty and the Republican Sub-Text of De Iure Praedae.Property, Piracy and Punishment: Hugo Grotius on War and Booty in De Iure Praedae—Concepts and Contexts,Leiden:
  86. Wilson, Eric(2008).Savage Republic: De Indis of Hugo Grotius, Republicanism and Dutch Hegemony within the Early Modern World-System (c. 1600– 1619).Leiden:Brill.
  87. Ziskind, Jonathan(1973).International Law and Ancient Sources: Grotius and Selden.The Review of Politics,35(4),537-559.
  88. Zwalve, W. J.(2009).The Introduction to the Jurisprudence of Holland and the Doctrine of the Free Seas.Grotiana,30(1),49-64.
  89. 余文景（編譯）, Man-king(ed.)(1986).英國法律辭典.臺北=Taipei:南天=Southern Materials Center.
  90. 格勞秀斯, Hugo,馬呈元（譯）, Chengyuan(trans.),譚睿（譯）, Rui(trans.)(2016).論戰爭與和平法,第二卷.北京=Beijing:中國政法大學=China University of Political Science and Law Press.
  91. 格勞秀斯, Hugo,馬呈元（譯）, Chengyuan(trans.),譚睿（譯）, Rui(trans.)(2018).論戰爭與和平法,第一卷.北京=Beijing:中國政法大學=China University of Political Science and Law Press.
  92. 格勞秀斯, Hugo,馬忠法（譯）, Zhongfa(trans.)(2013).論海洋自由.上海=Shanghai:上海世紀=Shanghai Century Publishing House.
  93. 格勞秀斯, Hugo,張乃根（譯）, Naigen(trans.),馬忠法（譯）, Zhongfa(trans.),羅國強（譯）, Guoqiang(trans.),王林彬（譯）, Linbin(trans.),楊毅（譯）, Yi(trans.)(2015).論捕獲法.上海=Shanghai:上海世紀=Shanghai Century Publishing House.
print cancel