A Revisit to Tax Policy and Stability in a Model with Sector-Specific Externalities

部門特定外部性下的稅收政策與安定性之再探討

王韋能(Wei-Neng Wang)

tax policy ； aggregate (in)stability ； government spending ； sector-specific externality ； 稅收政策 ； 總體（不）安定 ； 政府支出 ； 部門特定外部性

人文及社會科學集刊

33卷4期（2021 / 12 / 01）

619 - 643

英文

This study re-visits the stabilization of income tax policies proposed by Guo and Harrison (2001, Review of Economic Dynamics). I show that given an empirically relevant extent of sector-specific externality, both progressive and regressive tax schedules can stabilize the economy against sunspot fluctuations, if the government's tax revenues are used to purchase goods as public services, rather than to return them to households as lump-sum transfers. A progressive tax schedule is more robust than a regressive tax schedule in terms of suppressing the belief-driven fluctuations. I also find that income taxes are more likely to suppress the sunspot fluctuations, if the government uses its revenues to purchase an investment good, instead of a consumption good. These results sharply differ from Guo and Harrison's (2001) propositions. Thus, our study complements Guo and Harrison's (2001) analysis and provides new policy implications to the literature.

本文重新審視Guo and Harrison（2001，Review of Economic Dynamics）所提出的所得稅率安定政策。本文的研究發現，當特定產業存在部門外部性，若政府將稅收用於購買商品來做爲公共服務使用，而不是移轉性支付給家計單位的話，累進與累退的所得稅政策都能使經濟體系更爲穩定；且累進稅比累退稅的所得稅政策更具有安定效果。同時，本文也發現政府購買投資財比購買消費財具有更佳的安定效果。這些結果與Guo and Harrison（2001）的主張截然不同，因此，本文的結果補充了Guo and Harrison（2001）的分析，並且爲文獻提供了新的政策意涵。

1. Benhabib, Jess,Farmer, Roger(1996).Indeterminacy and Sector-Specific Externalities.Journal of Monetary Economics,37(3),421-443.
2. Benhabib, Jess,Farmer, Roger(1994).Indeterminacy and Increasing Returns.Journal of Economic Theory,63(1),19-41.
3. Bond, Eric Wirths,Wang, Ping,Yip, Chong Kee(1996).A General Two-Sector Model of Endogenous Growth with Human and Physical Capital: Balanced Growth and Transitional Dynamics.Journal of Economic Theory,68(1),149-173.
4. Chang, Juin-Jen,Guo, Jang-Ting,Shieh, Jhy-Yuan,Wang, Wei-Neng(2015).Sectoral Composition of Government Spending and Macroeconomic (In)stability.Economic Inquiry,53(1),23-33.
5. Chang, Juin-Jen,Guo, Jang-Ting,Shieh, Jhy-Yuan,Wang, Wei-Neng(2019).Sectoral Composition of Government Spending, Distortionary Income Taxation, and Macroeconomic (In)stability.International Journal of Economic Theory,15(1),95-107.
6. Christiano, Lawrence Joseph,Harrison, Sharon Grossberg(1999).Chaos, Sunspots, and Automatic Stabilizers.Journal of Monetary Economics,44(1),3-31.
7. Dromel, Nicolas,Pintus, Patrick(2008).Are Progressive Income Taxes Stabilizing?.Journal of Public Economic Theory,10(3),329-349.
8. Dromel, Nicolas,Pintus, Patrick(2007).Linearly Progressive Income Taxes and Stabilization.Research in Economics,61(1),25-29.
9. Farmer, Roger,Guo, Jang-Ting(1994).Real Business Cycles and the Animal Spirits Hypothesis.Journal of Economic Theory,63(1),42-72.
10. Guo, Jang-Ting and Sharon Grossberg Harrison 2011 “Corrigendum: Tax Policy and Stability in a Model with Sector-Specific Externalities,” Working Paper.
11. Guo, Jang-Ting,Harrison, Sharon Grossberg(2008).Useful Government Spending and Macroeconomic (In)stability under Balanced-Budget Rules.Journal of Public Economic Theory,10(3),383-397.
12. Guo, Jang-Ting,Harrison, Sharon Grossberg(2001).Tax Policy and Stability in a Model with Sector-Specific Externalities.Review of Economic Dynamics,4(1),75-89.
13. Guo, Jang-Ting,Lansing, Kevin(1998).Indeterminacy and Stabilization Policy.Journal of Economic Theory,82(2),481-490.
14. Harrison, Sharon Grossberg(2003).Returns to Scale and Externalities in the Consumption and Investment Sectors.Review of Economic Dynamics,6(4),963-976.
15. Kneller, Richard,Bleaney, Michael Francis,Gemmell, Norman(1999).Fiscal Policy and Growth: Evidence from OECD Countries.Journal of Public Economics,74(2),171-190.
16. Linnemann, Ludger(2008).Balanced-Budget Rules and Macroeconomic Stability with Non-Separable Utility.Journal of Macroeconomics,30(1),199-215.
17. Pintus, Patrick(2008).Note on Convergence under Income Tax Progressivity.Macroeconomic Dynamics,12(2),286-299.
18. Raurich, Xavier(2001).Indeterminacy and Government Spending in a Two-Sector Model of Endogenous Growth.Review of Economic Dynamics,4(1),210-229.
19. Turnovsky, Stephen John(1995).Methods of Macroeconomic Dynamics.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
20. Wagstaff, Adam,van Doorslaer, Eddy,van der Burg, Hattem,Calonge, Samuel,Christiansen, Terkel,Citonie, Guido,Gerdtham, Ulf-Göran,Gerfing, Michael,Gross, Lorna,Häkinnen, Unto,John, Jürgen,Johnson, Paul,Klavus, Jan,Lachaud, Claire,Lauridesn, Jørgen,Leu, Robert,Nolan, Brian,Peran, Encarna,Propper, Carol,Puffer, Frank,Rochaix, Lise,Rodríguez, Marisol,Schellhorn, Martin,Sundberg, Gun,Winkelhake, Olaf(1999).Redistributive Effect, Progressivity and Differential Tax Treatment: Personal Income Taxes in Twelve OECD Countries.Journal of Public Economics,72(1),73-98.