题名

Residential Real Estate in the U.S. Financial Crisis, the Great Recession, and their Aftermath

并列篇名

住宅不動產市場：美國金融危機、大衰退及其後果

DOI

10.6277/TER.2017.451.1

作者

Stephen Malpezzi

关键词

financial crisis ； recession ； leverage ； housing price volatility ； government policy ； 金融危機 ； 經濟衰退 ； 槓桿 ； 房價波動 ； 政府政策

期刊名称

經濟論文叢刊

卷期/出版年月

45卷1期（2017 / 03 / 01）

页次

5 - 56

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

Circa 2007 through 2009, the United States experienced a financial crisis, and a recession, that by many measures was the largest adverse economic event the U.S. has experienced since the Great Depression of the 1930s. Furthermore, these events had large negative repercussions on other economies around the world. The Great Financial Crisis and Great Recession were complex, and scholars will be arguing over important details of their causes and effects for decades to come. This paper reviews a number of contributing elements, focusing especially on two fundamentals of the twin ＂Greats:＂ excessive leverage, and excessive volatility in housing prices. The paper includes a package of 10 proposed reforms in real estate and financial markets that can mitigate the costs of future real estate-related downturns.
英文摘要

大約從2007年至2009年，美國經歷了金融危機與經濟衰退，就諸多衡量標準而言，這是美國自1930年代大蕭條以來所經歷最嚴重的經濟倒退。同時，此事件對世界其他經濟體也造成巨大的負面影響。此次「大金融危機」與隨之而來的「大衰退」，其前因後果相當複雜，學者們對其原因和影響重要細節的爭論將會持續幾十年。本文回顧了一些可能的原因，特別著重過度槓桿和房價過度波動這兩個根本的因素。本文也提供關於房地產和金融市場的10項改革建議，可望減少未來與房地產市場相關的衰退所造成的成本。
主题分类 社會科學 > 經濟學
参考文献
  1. Bertaud, Alain (2010), “LandMarkets, Government Interventions, and Housing Affordability,” Working Paper, Brookings Institution
  2. Duca, John V. and David C. Ling (2015), “The Other (Commercial) Real Estate Boom and Bust: The Effects of Risk Premia and Regulatory Capital Arbitrage,” SSRN Working Paper, No. 2663194.
  3. Liang, Yongping and Stephen Malpezzi (2005), “Housing Price Dynamics: Can We Pick the Turning Points?” Working Paper.
  4. Vasel, Kathryn (2015), “Is It Time to Worry About Another Housing Bubble?”CNN Money, May 4.
  5. La Monica, Paul R. (2015), “Warning Signs in the Housing Market,” CNN Money, March 25.
  6. Foote, Chris, Jeff Fuhrer, EileenMauskopf, and PaulWillen (2009), “A Proposal toHelpDistressedHomeowners: A Government Payment-Sharing Plan,” URL: http://www.bos.frb.org/economic/ppb/2009/ppb091.htm.
  7. Eisinger, Jesse and Jake Bernstein (2010), “The Magnetar Trade: How One Hedge Fund Helped Keep the Bubble Going,” ProPublica, April 9.
  8. Davis, Morris A., Stephen Malpezzi, and François Ortalo-Magné (2009),“TheWisconsin Foreclosure and Unemployment Relief Plan (Wi-Fur),”James A. Graaskamp Center for Real Estate, URL: http://www.bus.wisc.edu/realestate/wi-fur/.
  9. Cole, Marine (2015), “Get Ready for Another Real Estate Bubble,” Fiscal Times, March, 3, 2015.
  10. Pozsar, Zoltan, Tobias Adrian, Adam B. Ashcraft, and Haley Boesky (2010),“Shadow Banking,” SSRN Working Paper, No. 1640545.
  11. Mollenkamp, Carrick, Susanne Craig, Serena Ng, and Aaron Lucchetti (2008),“Lehman Files for Bankruptcy,Merrill Sold, Aig Seeks Cash,”Wall Street Journal, September 16.
  12. Frey, William H., Jill H. Wilson, Alan Berube, and Audrey Singer (2004), “Tracking Metropolitan America into the 21st Century: A Field Guide to theNewMetropolitan and Micropolitan Defintions,”Working Paper, The Brookings Institution.
  13. Malpezzi, Stephen(1999b), “The Regulation of Urban Development: Lessons from International Experience,” background paper for the 1999 World Development Report, World Bank.
  14. Corcoran, Barbara (2015), “NY Real Estate May be in a New Bubble,”Bloomberg Business, April 30.
  15. Fischel,William A. (1990), “Do Growth Controls Matter?”Working Paper, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
  16. Leung, Charles Ka Yui and Chung-Yi Tse (2012), “Flippers inHousingMarket Search,” Working Paper.
  17. Meltzer, Allan H. (2002), “Rational and Irrational Bubbles,”Working Paper.
  18. Durden, Tyler (2015), “Bad News for America's Biggest Housing Bubble: San Francisco Home Prices Suffer Biggest Drop in Three Years,” Zero Hedge, March 31.
  19. Kusisto, Laura (2015), “Housing Bubble? Despite Rising Prices,Most Economists Still Say No,” Wall Street Journal, May 26.
  20. Henderson, Neil (2006), “Key Federal Rate Raised to 5.25%, a 5-YearHigh,”Washington Post, June 30.
  21. Davis, Morris A., Stephen D. Oliner, and Edward J. Pinto (2014), “House Prices and Land Prices under theMicroscope: A Property-Level Analysis for the Washington, DC Area,” Working Paper, American Enterprise Institute.
  22. Bokhari, Sheharyar, Walter Torous, and William Wheaton (2013), “Why Did Household Mortgage Leverage Rise from the Mid-1980s until the Great Recession?” Working Paper.
  23. Follain, James R. and Seth H. Giertz (2012), “A Look at Us House Price Bubbles from 1980–2010 and the Role of Local Market Conditions,” Working Paper, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
  24. Malpezzi, Stephen(2014), “The Savings and Loan Crisis of the 1980s: Prequel to the Great Financial Crisis,” class lecture notes..
  25. Pinto, Edward (2010), “Government Housing Policies in the Lead-up to the Financial Crisis: A Forensic Study,” SSRNWorking Paper,No. 1675959.
  26. Yezer Anthony, M. J. (2013), “Current Financial Reform Has Failed Because It Has Not Considered the Fundamental Cause of the Financial Crisis,” Working Paper.
  27. Green, Richard K. and Andrew Reschovsky (2001), “Using Tax Policy to Increase Homeownership among Low-and Moderate-Income Households,”Working Paper.
  28. Renaud, Bertrand(2000),“Real Estate Booms and Banking Busts: The Asian Experience,”Working Paper.
  29. Admati, Anat R.,DeMarzo, Peter M.,Hellwig, Martin F.,Pfleiderer, Paul C.(2011).,未出版
  30. Admati, Anat,Hellwig, Martin(2014).The Bankers' New Clothes: What's Wrong with Bsnking and What to Do About it.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  31. Adrian, Tobias,Shin, Hyun Song(2010).Liquidity and Leverage.Journal of Financial Intermediation,19,418-437.
  32. Allen, Franklin,Gale, Douglas(2000).Financial Contagion.Journal of Political Economy,108,1-33.
  33. Ambrose, Brent W.,Eichholtz, Piet,Lindenthal, Thies(2013).House Prices and Fundamentals: 355 Years of Evidence.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,45,477-491.
  34. Bair, Sheila(2012).Bull by the Horns: Fighting to Save Main Street from Wall Street and Wall Street from Itself.New York:Free Press.
  35. Ball, Laurence(2016).The Fed and Lehman Brothers.Cambridge:National Bureau of Economic Research.
  36. Benmelech, Efraim,Dlugosz, Jennifer(2010).The Credit Rating Crisis.NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2009,Chicago:
  37. Benoit, Sylvain,Colletaz, Gilbert,Hurlin, Christophe,Pérignon, Christophe(2013).HEC Paris Research PaperHEC Paris Research Paper,未出版
  38. Bernanke, Ben S.(2015).The Courage to Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and Its Aftermath.New York:Norton.
  39. Blinder, Alan S.(2010).After the Music Stopped: The Financial Crisis, the Response, and the Work Ahead.New York:Penguin Books.
  40. Borio, Claudio,McGuire, Patrick(2004).Twin Peaks in Equity and Housing Prices?.BIS Quarterly Review,7,79-96.
  41. Bottazzi, Jean-Marc,Luque, Jaime,Páscoa, Mário R(2012).Securities Market Theory: Possession, Repo and Rehypothecation.Journal of Economic Theory,147,477-500.
  42. Bruner, Robert F.,Carr, Sean D.(2008).The Panic of 1907: Lessons Learned from the Market's Perfect Storm.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
  43. Bucks, Brian,Pence, Karen(2008).Do Borrowers Know Their Mortgage Terms?.Journal of Urban Economics,64,218-233.
  44. Calomiris, Charles W.,Haber, Stephen H.(2014).Fragile by Design: The Political Origins of Banking Crises and Scarce Credit.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  45. Carey, Mark(ed.),Kashyap, Anil(ed.),Rajan, Raghuram(ed.),Stulz, René(ed.)(2010).Market Institutions and Financial Market Risk.Chicago:National Bureau of Economic Research.
  46. Carrillo, Paul E.(2011).Testing for Fraud in the Residential Mortgage Market: How Much Did Early-Payment-Defaults Overpay for Housing?.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,13,1-29.
  47. Chen, Nan-Kuang,Leung, Charles Ka Yui(2008).Asset Price Spillover, Collateral and Crises: With an Application to Property Market Policy.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,37,351-385.
  48. Cheshire, Paul,Sheppard, Stephen(2005).Land Markets and Land Market Regulation: Progress Towards Understanding.Regional Science and Urban Economics,34,619-637.
  49. Christopher, Henderson,Julapa, Jagtiani(2013).Can Banks Circumvent Minimum Capital Requirements? The Case of Mortgage Portfolio under Basel II.Journal of Mathematical Finance,3,60-68.
  50. Christopoulos, Apostolos G.,Mylonakis, John,Diktapanidis, Pavlos(2011).Could Lehman Brothers' Collapse Be Anticipated? An Examination Using Camels Rating System.International Business Research,4,11-19.
  51. Collins, J. Michael(2007).Exploring the Design of Financial Counseling for Mortgage Borrowers in Default.Journal of Family and Economic Issues,28,207-226.
  52. Corbae, Dean,Quintin, Erwan(2015).Leverage and the Foreclosure Crisis.Journal of Political Economy,123,1-65.
  53. Davidoff, Thomas(2013).Supply Elasticity and the Housing Cycle of the 2000s.Real Estate Economics,41,793-813.
  54. Davis, Morris A.,Heathcote, Jonathan(2007).The Price and Quantity of Residential Land in the United States.Journal of Monetary Economics,54,2595-2620.
  55. Davis, Morris A.,Palumbo, Michael G.(2001).,Washington, DC:Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
  56. Demirguc-Kunt, Asli,Detragiache, Enrica,Merrouche, Ouarda(2013).Bank Capital: Lessons from the Financial Crisis.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,45,1147-1164.
  57. Duca, J. V.,Muellbauer, J.,Murphy, A.(2010).Housing Markets and the Financial Crisis of 2007-2009: Lessons for the Future.Journal of Financial Stability,6,203-217.
  58. Dullien, Sebastian,Kotte, Detlef J.,Márquez, Alejandro,Priewe, Jan(2010).The Financial and Economic Crisis of 2008-2009 and Developing Countries.
  59. Englund, Peter(1999).The Swedish Banking Crisis: Roots and Consequences.Oxford Review of Economic Policy,15,80-97.
  60. Fama, Eugene F.(2014).Two Pillars of Asset Pricing.American Economic Review,104,1467-1485.
  61. Foote, Christopher L.,Gerardi, Kristopher,Goette, Lorenz,Willen, Paul S.(2008).Just the Facts: An Initial Analysis of Subprime's Role in the Housing Crisis.Journal of Housing Economics,17,291-305.
  62. Francis, Louise(2010).Banking on Robbery: The Role of Fraud in the Financial Crisis.Casualty Actuarial Society E-Forum
  63. Freixas, Xavier,Parigi, Bruno M.,Rochet, Jean-Charles(2000).Systemic Risk, Interbank Relations, and Liquidity Provision by the Central Bank.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,611-638.
  64. Gatzlaff, Dean H.(1994).Excess Returns, Inflation and the Efficiency of the Housing Market.Real Estate Economics,22,553-581.
  65. Geanakoplos, John(2010).The Leverage Cycle.NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2009,Chicago:
  66. Geithner, Timothy F.(2015).Stress Test: Reflections on Financial Crises.New York:Broadway Books.
  67. Gerardi, Kristopher,Foote, Christopher L,Willen, Paul(2010).Reasonable People Did Disagree: Optimism and Pessimism About the Us Housing Market before the Crash.FRB of Boston Public Policy Discussion Paper,10-15
  68. Ghent, Andra C.,Owyang, Michael T.(2010).Is Housing the Business Cycle? Evidence from Us Cities.Journal of Urban Economics,67,336-351.
  69. Glaeser, Edward L.,Gottlieb, Joshua D.,Gyourko, Joseph(2013).Can Cheap Credit Explain the Housing Boom?.Housing and the Financial Crisis,Chicago:
  70. Glaeser, Edward L.,Gyourko, Joseph,Saks, Raven E.(2005).Why Have Housing Prices Gone Up?.American Economic Review,95,329-333.
  71. Goodhart, Charles,Hofmann, Boris(2001).Asset Prices and the Conduct of Monetary Policy.conference on Asset Prices, Exchange Rates, and Monetary Policy
  72. Goodman Jr, John L.(1995).Interest Rates and Housing Demand, 1933-1995: Common Sense Versus Econometrics.Paper presented to the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,Washington D.C.:
  73. Green, Richard K.(1997).Follow the Leader: How Changes in Residential and Non-Residential Investment Predict Changes in GDP.Real Estate Economics,25,253-270.
  74. Green, Richard K.,Malpezzi, Stephen(2003).A Primer on U.S. Housing Markets and Housing Policy.Washington, D.C.:Urban Institute Press.
  75. Green, Richard K.,Malpezzi, Stephen,Mayo, Stephen K.(2005).Metropolitan-Specific Estimates of the Price Elasticity of Supply of Housing, and Their Sources.American Economic Review,95,334-339.
  76. Green, Richard K.,Wachter, Susan M.(2005).The AmericanMortgage in Historical and International Context.Journal of Economic Perspectives,19,93-114.
  77. Hastings, Justine S.,Madrian, Brigitte C.,Skimmyhorn, William L.(2013).Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Economic Outcomes.Annual Review of Economics,5,347-373.
  78. Herndon, Thomas,Ash, Michael,Pollin, Robert(2013).Does High Public Debt Consistently Stifle Economic Growth? A Critique of Reinhart and Rogoff.Cambridge Journal of Economics Advance
  79. Holly, Sean M.,Pesaran, Hashem,Yamagata, Takashi(2011).The Spatial and Temporal Diffusion of House Prices in the UK.Journal of Urban Economics,69,2-23.
  80. Hördahl, Peter,King, Michael R.(2008).Developments in Repo Markets During the Financial Turmoil.BIS Quarterly,December,37-52.
  81. Jorgenson, Dale W.(2009).A New Architecture for the U.S. National Accounts.Review of Income and Wealth,55,1-42.
  82. Kalemli-Ozcan, Sebnem,Sorensen, Bent,Yesiltas, Sevcan(2012).Leverage across Firms, Banks, and Countries.Journal of International Economics,88,284-298.
  83. Klingebiel, Daniela(ed.),Laeven, Lud(ed.)(2002).Managing the Real and Fiscal Effects of Banking Crises.Washington, DC:World Bank.
  84. LaCour-Little, Michael,Malpezzi, Stephen(2003).Appraisal Quality and Residential Mortgage Default: Evidence from Alaska.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,27,211-233.
  85. Lang, William W.,Jagtiani, Julapa A.(2010).The Mortgage and Financial Crises: The Role of Credit Risk Management and Corporate Governance.Atlantic Economic Journal,38,123-144.
  86. Laux, Christian,Leuz, Christian(2010).Did Fair-Value Accounting Contribute to the Financial Crisis?.Journal of Economic Perspectives,24,93-118.
  87. Leamer, Edward E.(2007).Housing Is the Business Cycle.Proceedings of the Economic Policy Symposium
  88. Leung, Charles Ka Yui(2004).Macroeconomics and Housing: A Review of the Literature.Journal of Housing Economics,13,249-267.
  89. Levitin, Adam J.,Twomey, Tara(2011).Mortgage Servicing.Yale Journal on Regulation,28(1)
  90. Lin, Che-Chun,Prather, Larry J.,Chu, Ting-Heng,Tsay, Jing-Tang(2013).DifferentialDefault Risk among Traditional andNon-TraditionalMortgage Products and Capital Adequacy Standards.International Review of Financial Analysis,27,115-122.
  91. Lo, Andrew W.(2012).Reading About the Financial Crisis: A Twenty-One-Book Review.Journal of Economic Literature,151-178.
  92. Loutskina, Elena,Strahan, Philip E.(2011).Informed and Uninformed Investment in Housing: The Downside of Diversification.Review of Financial Studies,24,1447-1480.
  93. Luttrell, David,Atkinson, Tyler,Rosenblum, Harvey(2013).Assessing the Costs and Consequences of the 2007-09 Financial Crisis and Its Aftermath.Economic Letters,8(7)
  94. Mählmann, Thomas(2013).Hedge Funds, Cdos and the Financial Crisis: An Empirical Investigation of the "Magnetar Trade".Journal of Banking and Finance,37,537-548.
  95. Malpezzi, Stephen(1996).Housing Prices, Externalities, and Regulation in U.S. Metropolitan Areas.Journal of Housing Research,7,209-241.
  96. Malpezzi, Stephen(1999).A Simple Error Correction Model of House Prices.Journal of Housing Economics,8,27-62.
  97. Malpezzi, Stephen,Maclennan, Duncan(2001).The Long-Run Price Elasticity of Supply of New Residential Construction in the United States and the United Kingdom.Journal of Housing Economics,10,278-306.
  98. Malpezzi, Stephen,Wachter, Susan M.(2005).The Role of Speculation in Real Estate Cycles.Journal of Real Estate Literature,13,143-164.
  99. Mera, Koichi,Renaud, Bertrand(2000).Asia's Financial Crisis and the Role of Real Estate.New York:ME Sharpe Inc..
  100. Mian, Atif,Sufi, Amir(2010).Household Leverage and the Recession of 2007-09.IMF Economic Review,58,74-117.
  101. Mian, Atif,Sufi, Amir(2014).House of Debt: How They (and You) Caused the Great Recession, and How We Can Prevent It from Happening Again.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  102. Mills, Ewin S.(1957).The Theory of Inventory Decisions.Econometrica,25,222-238.
  103. National Research Council(2008).Rebuilding the Research Capacity at Hud.Washington, D.C.:National Academies Press.
  104. Paulson, Henry M., Jr.(2013).On the Brink: Inside the Race to Stop the Collapse of the Global Financial System.New York:Business Plus.
  105. Pollakowski, Henry O.,Wachter, Susan M.(1990).The Effects of Land-Use Constraints on Housing Prices.Land Economics,315-324.
  106. Pozdena, Randall(1990).Do Interest Rates Still Affect Housing?.Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Economic Review,Summer,3-14.
  107. Quercia, Roberto G.,Stegman, Michael A.(1992).Residential Mortgage Default: A Review of the Literature.Journal of Housing Research,3,341-379.
  108. Quercia, Roberto,Spader, Jonathan(2008).Does Homeownership Counseling Affect the Prepayment and Default Behavior of AffordableMortgage Borrowers?.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,27,304-325.
  109. Quigley, John M.,Rosenthal, Larry A.(2005).The Effects of Land Use Regulation on the Price of Housing: What Do We Know? What Can We Learn?.Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research,8,69-110.
  110. Reinhart, Carmen M.,Rogoff, Kenneth(2009).This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  111. Renaud, Bertrand(1999).The Financing of Social Housing in Integrating Financial Markets: A View from Developing Countries.Urban Studies,36,755-773.
  112. Riddel, Mary(1999).Fundamentals, Feedback Trading, and Housing Market Speculation: Evidence from California.Journal of Housing Economics,8,272-284.
  113. Saiz, Albert(2010).The Geographic Determinants of Housing Supply.Quarterly Journal of Economics,125,1253-1296.
  114. Schwab, Robert M.(1983).Real and Nominal Interest Rates and the Demand for Housing.Journal of Urban Economics,13,181-195.
  115. Shiller, Robert J.(2008).Historic Turning Points in Real Estate.Eastern economic journal,34,1-13.
  116. Shiller, Robert J.(2014).Speculative Asset Prices.American Economic Review,104,1486-1517.
  117. Shiller, Robert J.(2015).Irrational Exuberance.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  118. Shin(2009).Financial Intermediation and the Post-Crisis Financial System.8th BIS Annual Conference
  119. Sjostrom, William K., Jr.(2009).The AIG Bailout.Washington & Lee Law Review,66,943.
  120. Sorkin, Andrew Ross(2009).Too Big To fall.New York:Viking Press.
  121. Vandell, Kerry D.(2003).Handing over the Keys: A Perspective on Mortgage Default Research.Real Estate Economics,21,211-246.
  122. Wachter, Susan(ed.),Cho, Man(ed.),Tcha, Moon Joong(ed.)(2014).The Global Financial Crisis and Housing: A New Policy Paradigm.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
  123. Wallison, Peter J.(2008).Fair Value Accounting: A Critique.AEI Financial Services Outlook,July
  124. Whalen, R. C.(2008).Subprime Crisis-Cause, Effect and Consequences.Journal of Affordable Housing and Community Development,17,219.
  125. Wheaton, William C.(1999).Real Estate "Cycles": Some Fundamentals.Real Estate Economics,27,209-211.
  126. Willis, Lauren E.(2011).The Financial Education Fallacy.American Economic Review,101,429-434.
  127. Yellen, Janet(2013).,Washington, DC:Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
被引用次数
  1. (2020).Why is the Hong Kong housing market unaffordable? Some stylized facts and estimations*.中央銀行季刊,42(1),5-58.
print cancel