台灣親子教育跨代移轉機制之研究

On the Intergenerational Transmission of Parental Education and Learning Achievement to their Children: A Study based on Taiwan Data

10.6277/TER.201906_47(2).0003

徐美(Mei Hsu)；陳明郎(Been-Lon Chen)

分量迴歸模型 ； 教育跨代移轉 ； 教育差異 ； 台灣敎育長期追蹤資料庫 ； quantile regression model ； intergenerational transmission in education ； differential in educational attainment ； TEPS

經濟論文叢刊

47卷2期（2019 / 06 / 01）

217 - 272

繁體中文

本文以分量迴歸模型，運用「台灣敎育長期追蹤資料庫」探究親子教育跨代移轉之假說，並研究父母親教育以及親代教育程度差距，對於子女在校學習能力測驗分數分配變動影響。分量迴歸研究不僅顯示在同一條分數分配上，父母親教育差距衝擊不同分量上子女學習之成效，並可影響子女分數分配之高低差異，這是本研究特色。實證結果顯示，父母親敎育對子女在校學習成就具有顯著正向的影響，證實親子教育跨代移轉機制的存在。學歷越高的父親對於國中子女成績影響越大，子女成績分配之分量位置就越高。父親教育差異造成子女分數分配之差距，國中子女分數分配在低分量上差距大，在高分量上差距小，但擴大了高中子女在高分量上的成績差異。高中子女成績受到父親學歷影響較大，國中子女成績則受到母親學歷影響較高。研究所及以上學歷母親，子女在高分量上成績表現優異。比較相同教育父親和母親，母親對高、國中子女數學成績在高分量上的影響遠超過父親。

Utilizing more efficient estimators from quantile regression models and the reactions in quantile of the whole distribution, we analyze the systematic differences in intergenerational education correlations across the conditional quantiles of pupils' test scores. The key question is whether the bottom of the test score distribution looks different than the top. Our empirical evidence indicates a strong intergenerational transmission of educational inequalities between parental education levels and junior and senior school pupils' learning achievements. Parents with higher education affects pupil's learning in significantly positive ways. The differentials in senior and junior high school pupils' score distribution are positively associated to their father's education. Although these differentials persist in the high tail of these pupils' score distribution, there is convergence in the high tail of junior high school pupils' score distribution. The mother's education has a significantly higher influence on the learning distribution of junior high school pupils' score. By contrast, a father's education has a stronger impact on the learning distribution of senior high counterparts. Given a father, with the same education, a mother significantly and positively affects both junior and senior high school pupils' mathematics scores in the high end of the distribution.

1. Huang, Fung-Mey(2000).Teenage Participation in Economic Activities: True State Dependence or Heterogeneity?.Academia Sinica Papers,28(1),43-66.
   連結：
2. 林忠正, Chung-cheng,黃璀娟, Tsui-chuan(2009)。補習文化。人文及社會科學集刊，21(4)，587-643。
   連結：
3. 張苙雲, Ly-yun(2002)。台灣教育長期追蹤資料庫之簡介。調查研究 — 方法與應用，12，111-118。
   連結：
4. 黃芳玫, Fung-Mey,吳齊殷, Chyi-In(2010)。台灣國中學生個人特質、家庭背景與學業成績— 追蹤調查資料之研究。經濟論文叢刊，38(1)，65-97。
   連結：
5. 銀慶貞, Ching-Chen,陶宏麟, Hung-Lin,洪嘉瑜, Chia-Yu(2012)。補習對考大學真的有用嗎？。經濟論文叢刊，40(1)，73-118。
   連結：
6. 駱明慶, Ming-Ching(2004)。升學機會與家庭背景。經濟論文叢刊，32(4)，417-445。
   連結：
7. Arnold, Fred(1985).Measuring the Effect of Sex Preference on Fertility: The Case of Korea.Demography,22(2),280-288.
8. Aughinbaugh, Alison,Gittleman, Maury(2003).Dose Money Matter? A Comparison of the Effect of Income on Child Development in the United States and Great Britain.Journal of Human Resources,38(2),416-440.
9. Behrman, Jere Richard,Taubman, Paul(1994).Endowments and the Allocation of Schooling in the Family and in the Marriage Market: TheTwins Experiment.Journal of Political Economy,102(6),1131-1174.
10. Behrman, Jere Richard,Taubman, Paul(1989).Is Schooling Mostly in the Genes’? Nature-Nurture Decomposition Using Data on Relatives.Journal of Political Economy,97(6),1425-1446.
11. Björklund, Anders,Jäntti, Markus,Solon, Gary(2007).Nature and Nurture in the Intergenerational Transmission of Socioeconomic Status: Evidence from Swedish Children and Their Biological and Rearing Parents.B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy,7(2),1-23.
12. Björklund, Anders,Lindahl, Mikuel,Plug, Erik(2006).The Origins of Intergenerational Associations: Lessons from Swedish Adoption Data.Quarterly Journal of Economics,121(3),999-1028.
13. Blau, Dvid(1999).The Effect of Income on Child Development.Review of Economics and Statistics,81(2),261-276.
14. Brooks-Gunn, Jeanne,Duncan, Greg,Klebanov, Pamela Kato,Sealand, Naomi(1993).Do Neighbor-hoods Influence Child and Adolescent Development?.American Journal of Sociology,99(2),353-395.
15. Buchinsky, Moshe(1998).Recent Advance in Quantile Regression Models: A Practical Guideline for Empirical Research.Journal of Human Resources,33(1),88-126.
16. Buchinsky, Moshe(1994).Changes in the US Wage Structure 1963-1987: An Application of Qunatile Regression.Econometrica,62(2),405-458.
17. Chang, Ying-Hwa,Yi, Chin-Chun(2004).Cram Schooling and Academic Achievement: A Remedial Strategy, a Proactive Strategy or just a Mimic Behavior.The First Youth Conference of Taiwan Youth Project,Taipei, Taiwan:
18. Chen, Yuyu,Li, Hongbin(2009).Mother's Education and Child Helath: Is there a Nurturing Effect?.Journal of Health Economics,28(2),413-426.
19. Clark, Shelley(2000).Son Preference and Sex Composition of Children: Evidence from India.Demography,37(1),95-108.
20. Corcoran, Mary,Adams, Terry(1993).Corcoran, Mary and Terry Adams (1993), “Race, Poverty, Welfare and Neighborhood Influences on Men's Economic Outcomes,” mimeo, Institute for Social Research, U. of Michigan..
21. Corcoran, Mary,Gordon, Roger,Deboran, Laren,Solon, Gany(1992).The Association between Men's Economic Status and Their Family and Community Origins.Journal of Human Resources,27(4),575-601.
22. Currie, Janet,Moretti, Enrico(2003).Mother's Education and the Intergenerational Transmission of Human Capital: Evidence from College Openings.Quarterly Journal of Economics,118(4),1495-1532.
23. Datcher, Linda(1982).Effects of Community and Family Background on Achievement.Review of Economic Statistics,64(1),32-41.
24. Dustmann, Christian,Frattini, Tommaso,Lanzara, Gianandrea(2012).Educational Achievement of Second Generation Immigrants: An International Comparison.Economic Policy,27(69),143-185.
25. Fryer, G. Roland,Levitt, Steven D.(2004).Understanding the Black-White Test Score Gap in the First Two Years of School.Review of Economics and Statistics,86(2),447-464.
26. Haveman, Roloert,Wolfe, Banbara(1995).The Determinants of Children's Attainments: A Review of Methods and Findings.Journal of Economic Literature,33(4),1829-1878.
27. Hernstein, Richard J.,Murray, Charles A.(1994).Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American Life.New York:The Free Press.
28. Hill, Martha S.,Duncan, Greg J.(1987).Parental Family Income and the Socioeconomic Attainment of Children.Social Science Research,16(1),39-73.
29. Huang, Fung-Mey(2000).The Impact of Childhood Events on Educational Achievement: A Sibling Study.Taiwan Economic Review,28(4),425-450.
30. Jenkins, Stephen,Schluter, Christian(2002).IZA Discussion PaperIZA Discussion Paper,未出版
31. Martins, S. Pedro,Pereira, Pedro T.(2004).Does Education Reduce Wage Inequality? Quantile Regression Evidence From 16 Countries.Labour Economics,11(3),355-371.
32. Plomin, Robert,Corley, Robin P.,DeFries, John C.,Fulker, David W.(1990).Individual Differences in Television Viewing in Early Childhood: Nature as well as Nurture.Psychologicod Science,1(6),371-377.
33. Plug, Erick(2004).Estimating the Effect of Mother's Schooling on Children's Schooling using a Sample of Adoptees.American Economic Review,94(1),358-368.
34. Plug, Erick,Vijverberg, Wim(2003).Schooling, Family Background, and Adoption: Is it Nature or Is Nurture.Journal of Political Economy,111(3),611-641.
35. Plug, Erick,Vijverberg, Wim(2005).Does Family Income Matter for Schooling Outcomes? Using Adoption as a Natural Experiment.Economic Journal,115(506),879-906.
36. Roksa, Josipa,Potter, Danniel(2011).Parenting and Academic Achievement: Intergenerational Transmission of Educational Advantage.Sociology of Education,84(4),299-321.
37. Tallman, W. Ellis,Wang, Ping(1994).Human Capital and Endogenous Growth: Evidence from Taiwan.Journal of Monetary Economics,34(1),101-124.
38. Tam, Towy,Yang, Meng-Li,Chang, Ly-Yun,Kuan, Ping-Yin(2004).Family in the Making of Educational Inequality: A Comparative Analysis of Taiwan and the U.S..Conference of Special Issues on Education Stratification and Family,Taipei:
39. 楊孟麗, Meng-Li,譚康榮, Tony,黃敏雄, Min-Hsiung(2003)。楊孟麗, 譚康榮, 與黃敏雄 (2003), “心理計量報告: TEPS2001 分析能力測驗,” 中央研究院調查研究專題中心, URL: http//:srda.sinica.edu.tw。 (Yang, Meng-Li, Tony Tam, and Min-Hsiung Huang (2003), “Psychometric Report: TEPS2001 Analytical Ability Test,” Center of Survey Research Data Archive, Acadmia Sinica. URL: http//:srda.sinica.edu.tw)楊孟麗, 譚康榮, 與黃敏雄 (2003), “心理計量報告: TEPS2001 分析能力測驗,” 中央研究院調查研究專題中心, URL: http//:srda.sinica.edu.tw。 (Yang, Meng-Li, Tony Tam, and Min-Hsiung Huang (2003), “Psychometric Report: TEPS2001 Analytical Ability Test,” Center of Survey Research Data Archive, Acadmia Sinica. URL: http//:srda.sinica.edu.tw),中央研究院調查研究專題中心=Center of Survey Research Data Archive, Acadmia Sinica。