為民而戰的游擊隊政府？初探臺灣文官異議行為與動機

Fighting for the People with Guerrilla Government? A Preliminary Study of Public Administrators' Behavior and Motivation for Dissent in Taiwan

10.6166/TJPS.201806_(76).0005

黃建勳(Chien-hsun Huang)

官僚 ； 游擊隊政府 ； 異議 ； 行政倫理 ； Bureaucracy ； Guerrilla Government ； Dissent ； Ethics

政治科學論叢

76期（2018 / 06 / 01）

159 - 198

繁體中文

「游擊隊政府」（guerrilla government）是O'Leary（2006）形容在政府體系中一群對於上級有所不滿與反抗的異議官僚。目前「游擊隊政府」研究文獻主要以個案分析爲主，甚少進行量化研究。同時，公共行政理論認爲文官應該秉持公益而勇於表達不同意見，但是規範性理論仍需要經驗資料的支持。故本文利用2008年臺灣政府文官調査資料庫，選擇消極服從與對外透露資訊代表「游擊隊政府」具體行爲，並檢驗公益動機的影響關係。統計結果發現，當文官的工作目標以公益目的爲主時，有較高機會選擇消極服從，以回應上級指示不符公共利益；不過，公益動機與對外透露資訊間沒有統計上顯著性。本文目的不僅希望增進「游擊隊政府」的經驗性瞭解外，也提供循證性分析結果支持學界與實務界期待文官作爲人民受託者的規範性論述。

What drives public servants to become guerrillas? This study aims at examining the resistant behavior of dissenting bureaucrats as implied by O'Leary's ＂guerrilla government＂, and their motivation for pursuing public interests. This study uses survey data from the TGBS (Taiwan Government Bureaucrat Survey) in 2008 to focus on two types of resistant behavior: passive obedience and leaking information to stakeholders. The analyses show that there is a greater chance for public administrators to obey orders passively when their work goals are public interest-oriented, but that there is no significant relationship between leaking information and public interest-oriented goals/sector choices. These empirical results provide a quantitative contribution to the guerrilla government literature which has mostly relied on case studies, and give evidence-based support for the role of public orientation and trusteeship argued by normative theories in the public administration literature. Research limitations and suggestions for future research will also be identified.

1. 余致力(2016)。民主與行政：政黨輪替對文官體系的衝擊與影響。文官制度季刊，8(3)，1-20。
   連結：
2. 施能傑(2004)。公共服務倫理的理論架構與規範作法。政治科學論叢，20，103-140。
   連結：
3. 胡至沛、于繼安(2010)。建立我國弊端揭發人制度可行性之研究：利害關係人的觀點。中華行政學報，7，31-60。
   連結：
4. 陳成宏(2012)。策略性順服：一所私立大學之游擊隊治理的個案研究。臺北市立教育大學學報，43(2)，1-26。
   連結：
5. 陳敦源(2006)。內戰：行政政治中的異議管理。公共行政學報，19，175-183。
   連結：
6. 黃宏森(2005)。弊端揭發者（Whistle-blowers）面臨的難題與抉擇之研究。公共行政學報，14，39-78。
   連結：
7. Aberbach, J. D.,Rockman, B. A.(1994).Civil Servants and Policymakers: Neutral or Responsive Competence?.Governance,7,461-469.
8. Adams, G. B.,Balfour, D. L.(2004).Unmasking Administrative Evil.Thousand, Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
9. Andrews, R.,Ashworth, R.,Meier, K. J.(2014).Representative Bureaucracy and Fire Service Performance.International Public Management Journal,17(1),1-24.
10. Appleby, P. H. 1949. Policy and Administration. Birmingham: University of Alabama Press.
11. Barry, M. S.(ed.),Cummings, L. L.(ed.)(1986).Research in Organizational Behavior.Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
12. Benveniste, G.(1973).The Politics of Expertise.Berkeley, CA:Glendessary Press.
13. Borins, S.(2000).Loose Cannons and Rule Breakers, or Enterprising leaders? Some Evidence About Innovative Public Managers.Public Administration Review,60(6),498-507.
14. Bozeman, B.(2007).Public Values and Public Interest: Counterbalancing Economic Individualism.Washington, D.C.:Georgetown University Press.
15. Brehm, J.,Gates, S.(1999).Working, Shirking, and Sabotage: Bureaucratic Response to a Democratic Public.Ann Arbor, MA:The University of Michigan Press.
16. Brewer, G. A.,Selden, S. C.(1998).Whistle Blowers in the Federal Civil Service: New Evidence of the Public Service Ethic.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,8,413-440.
17. Bright, L.(2005).Public Employees with High Levels of Public Service Motivation: Who are They, Where are They, and What do They Want?.Review of Public Personnel Administration,25(2),138-154.
18. Burke, J. P.(1986).Bureaucratic Responsibility.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press.
19. Caillier, J. G.(2016).Whistle-Blowing: Individual and Organizational Determinants of the Decision to Report Wrongdoing in the Federal Government.American Review of Public Administration,46(1),113-136.
20. Chen, C. P.,Lai, C. T.(2014).To Blow or Not to Blow the Whistle: the Effects of Potential Harm, Social Pressure, and Organizational Commitment on Whistleblowing Intention and Behaviour.Business Ethics: A European Review,23(3),327-342.
21. Chen, Chung-an,Berman, E. M.,Wang, Chun-yuan(2017).Middle Managers' Upward Roles in the Public Sector.Administration & Society,49(5),700-729.
22. Cho, Y. J.,Ringguist, E. J.(2010).Managerial Trustworthiness and Organizational Outcomes.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,21,53-86.
23. Cho, Y. J.,Song, H. J.(2015).Determinants of Whistleblowing within Government Agencies.Public Personnel Management,44(4),450-472.
24. Clarke, J.,Newman, J.(1997).The Managerial State.London:Sage.
25. Cooper, T. L.(1998).The Responsible Administrator: An Approach to Ethics for the Administrative Role.San Francisco, CA:Publishers.
26. Couto, R.(1991).Heroic Bureaucracies.Administration & Society,23(1),123-147.
27. Deci, E. L.,Connell, J. P.,Ryan, R. M.(1989).Self-determination in a Work Organization.Journal of Applied Psychology,74(4),580-590.
28. Denhart, R. B.,Denhardt, J. V.,Aristigueta, M. P.(2000).Managing Human Behavior in Public and Nonprofit Organizations.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
29. Dobel, P. J.(1999).Public Integrity.Baltimore, MD:Johns Hopkins University Press.
30. Downs, A.(1967).Inside Bureaucracy.Boston:Little, Brown.
31. Dozier, J. B.,Miceli, M. P.(1985).Potential Predictors of Whistle-Blowing: A Prosocial Behavior Perspective.The Academy of Management Review,10,823-836.
32. Dunleavy, P.(1991).Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice: Economic Approaches in Political Science.Brighton:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
33. Flathman, R. E.(1966).The Public Interest: An Essay Concerning the Normative Discourse of Politics.New York:Wiley.
34. Frederickson, H. G.(1997).The Spirit of Public Administration.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass Publishers.
35. Friedrich, C. J. 1940. “The Nature of Administrative Responsibility.” In Public Administration and Policy, ed. Peter Woll. New York: Harper Torch Books, 221-246.
36. Golden, M. M.(2000).What Motivates Bureaucrats? Politics and Administration During the Reagan Years.New York:Columbia University Press.
37. Goodsell, C.(1994).The Case for Bureaucracy: A Public Administration Polemics.Chatham, NJ:Chatham House Publishers.
38. Hirschman, A. O.(1970).Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Response to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
39. Huber, G. A.(2007).The Craft of Bureaucratic Neutrality: Interests and Influence in Governmental Regulation of Occupational Safety.New York:Cambridge University Press.
40. James, L. P.(ed.),Hondeghem, A.(ed.)(2008).Motivation in Public Management: The Call of Public Service.New York:Oxford University Press.
41. Jos, P. H.,Tompkins, M. E.,Hays, S. W.(1989).In Praise of Difficult People: A Portrait of the Committed Whistleblower.Public Administration Review,49,552-561.
42. Kassing, J. W.(2011).Dissent in Organizations.Malden: MA:Polity.
43. Kassing, J. W.(1997).Articulating, Antagonizing, and Displacing: A Model of Employee Dissent.Communication Studies,48,311-332.
44. Kassing, J. W.(2001).From the Looks of Things: Assessing Perceptions of Organizational Dissenters.Management Communication Quarterly,14(3),442-470.
45. Kassing, J. W.(2000).Investigating the Relationship between Superior-Subordinate Relationship Quality and Employee Dissent.Communications Research Reports,17(1),58-70.
46. Kaufman, H.(1960).The Forest Ranger: A Study in Administrative Behavior.Baltimore, MD:Johns Hopkins Univeristy Press.
47. Kaufman, H.(1956).Emerging Conflicts in the Doctrines of Public Administration.American Political Science Review,50(4),1057-1073.
48. Lavena, C. F.(2016).Whistle-blowing: Individual and Organizational Determinants of the Decision to Report Wrongdoing in the Federal Government.American Review of Public Administration,46(1),113-136.
49. Le Grand, J.(2003).Motivation, Agency, and Public Policy: Of Knights and Knaves, Pawns and Queens.New York:Oxford University Press.
50. Levine, C.,Peters, B. G.,Thompson, F. J.(1990).Public Administration: Challenge, Choices, Consequences.Glenview:Scott Foresman & Company.
51. Lipsky, M.(1980).Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service.New York:Russell Sage.
52. Long, N. E. 1949. “Power and Administration.” Public Administration Review 9(4): 257-264
53. Long, N. E.(1993).The Ethics and Efficacy of Resignation in Public Administration.Administration & Society,25(1),3-11.
54. Lowi, T. J.(1969).The End of Liberalism.New York:Norton.
55. Maranto, R.,Hult, K. M.(2004).Right Trun? Political Ideology in the Higher Civil Service, 1987-1994.American Review of Public Administration,34(2),199-222.
56. March, J. G.,Olsen, J. P.(1995).Democratic Governance.New York, NY:The Free Press.
57. March, J. G.,Olsen, J. P.(1989).Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics.New York:Free Press.
58. Marini, F.(ed.)(1971).Toward a New Public Administration: The Minnowbrook Perspective.New York:Chandler.
59. Martinez, J. M.,Richardson, W. D.(2008).Administrative Ethics in the Twenty-First Century.New York:Peter Lang Publishing.
60. McCubbins, M. D.,Noll, R. G.,Weingast, B. R.(1987).Administrative Procedures as Instruments of Political Control.Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization,3,243-277.
61. Meier, K. J.(1997).Bureaucracy and Democracy: The Case for More Bureaucracy and Less Democracy.Public Administration Review,57,193-199.
62. Meier, K. J.,O'Toole, L. J.(2006).Bureaucracy in a Democratic State: A Governance Perspective.Baltimore, MD:Johns Hopkins University Press.
63. Miceli, M. P.,Near, J. P.(1992).Blowing the Whistle: The Organizational and Legal Implications for Companies and Employees.New York:Lexington Books.
64. Miceli, M. P.,Near, J. P.,Dworkin, T. M.(2008).Whistle-blowing in Organizations.New York, NY:Routledge.
65. Miceli, M. P.,Near, J. P.,Schwenk, C. R.(1991).Who Blows the Whistle and Why?.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,45,113-130.
66. Miller, G.(2000).Above Politics: Credible Commitment and Efficiency in the Design of Public Agencies.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(2),289-327.
67. Montjoy, R. S.,Watson, D. J.(1995).A Case for Reinterpreted Dichotomy of Politics and Administration as a Professional Standard in Council-Manager Government.Public Administration Review,55,231-239.
68. Mosher, F. C.(1982).Democracy and the Public Service.Oxford University Press, Incorporated.
69. Niskanen, W.(1971).Bureaucracy and Representative Government.New York:Aldine-Atherton.
70. O'Leary, R.(2006).The Ethics of Dissent: Managing Guerrilla Government.Washington, D.C.:CQ Press.
71. O'Leary, R.(2010).Guerrilla Employees: Should Managers Nurture, Tolerate, or Terminate Them?.Public Administration Review,70(1),8-19.
72. Osborne, S. P.,Brown, K.(2005).Managing Change and Innovation in Public Service Organizations.New York:Routledge.
73. O'Toole, L. J.,Meier, K. J.(2011).Public Management: Organizations, Governance, and Performance.New York:Cambridge University Press.
74. O'Toole, L. J.,Meier, K. J.(2007).Public Management and the Administrative Conservator: Empirical Support for Larry Terry's Prescriptions.Administrative Theory & Praxis,29(1),148-156.
75. Pandey, S. K.,Wright, B. E.,Moynihan, D. P.(2008).Public Service Motivation and Interpersonal Citizenship Behavior in Public Organizations: Testing a Preliminary Model.International Public Management Journal,11(1),89-108.
76. Payne, H. J.(2014).Examining the Relationship Between Trust in Superior-Employee Relationships and Workplace Dissent Expression.Communications Research Reports,31(2),131-140.
77. Rainey, H. G.(2009).Understanding and Managing Public Organizations.San Francisco, CA:John Wiley & Sons.
78. Riccucci, N. M.(1995).Unsung Heroes: Federal Execucrats Making a Difference.Washington, DC:Georgetown University Press.
79. Rohr, J. A.(1986).To Run a Constitution: The Legitimacy of the Administrative State.Lawrence, KA:University Press of Kansas.
80. Rothwell, G. R.,Baldwin, J. N.(2007).Whistle-blowing and the Code of Silence in Police Agencies: Policy and Structural Predictors.Crime & Delinquency,53,605-632.
81. Rourke, F. E.(1984).Bureaucracy, Politics, and Public Policy.Boston:Little, Brown and Company.
82. Rourke, F. E.(1992).Responsiveness and Neutral Competence in American Bureaucracy.Public Administration Review,52,539-546..
83. Rusbult, C. E.,Zembrodt, I. M.,Gunn, L. K.(1982).Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect: Responses to Dissatisfaction in Romantic Involvements.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,43,1230-1242.
84. Sabatier, P. A.,Loomis, J.,McCarthy, C.(1995).Hierarchical Controls, Professional Norms, Local Constituencies, and Budget Maximization: An Analysis of US Forest Service Planning Decisions.American Journal of Political Science,39(1),204-242.
85. Selznick, P. 1949. TVA and the Great Roots. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
86. Steg, L.,Bolderdijk, J. W.,Keizer, K.,Perlaviciute, G.(2014).An Integrated Framework for Encouraging Pro-Environmental Behaviour: The Role of Values, Situational Factors and Goals.Journal of Environmental Psychology,38,104-115.
87. Stern, P. C.(2000).New Environmental Theories: Toward a Coherent Theory of Environmentally Significant Behavior.Journal of Social Issues,56(3),523-530.
88. Svara, J. H.(2007).The Ethics Primer for Public Administrators in Government and Nonprofit Organizations.Sudbury, MA:Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
89. Trevino, L. K.,Weaver, G. R.(2001).Organizational Justice and Ethics program Follow-through: Influences on employees' Harmful and Helpful Behavior.Business Ethics Quarterly,11,651-671.
90. Van Wart, M.(2007).Do Public Administrators Tend to Be Morally Superior?.Public Management Review,67(1),168-171.
91. Vandenabeele, W.(2007).Toward a Public Administration Theory of Public Service Motivation: An Institutional Approach.Public Management Review,9(4),545-556.
92. Wamsley, G. L.,Bacher, R. N.,Goodsell, C. T.,Kronenberg, P. S.,Rohr, J. A.,Stivers, C. M.,White, O. F.,Wolf, J. F.(1990).Refounding Public Administration.Newbury Park, CA:Sage Publications.
93. Whitford, A. B.,Lee, Soo-Young(2014).Exit, Voice, and Loyalty with Multiple Exit Options: Evidence from the US Federal Workforce.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,25(2),373-398.
94. Wilson, J. Q.(1974).Political Organizations.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
95. Wood, B. D.,Waterman, R. W.(1994).Bureaucratic Dynamics: The Role of Bureaucracy in a Democracy.Bouldrer, CO:Westview Press.
96. 余致力(2000)。論公共行政在民主治理過程中的正當角色：黑堡宣言的內涵、定位與啟示。公共行政學報，4，1-30。
97. 洪美仁(2009)。官僚反抗行為之研究：多元倫理的困境及組織管理的挑戰。臺灣民主季刊，6(4)，265-271。
98. 陳玉惠(2010)。桃園=Taoyuan, Taiwan，元智大學資訊管理學系=Department of Information Management, Yuanze University。
99. 游士賢(2010)。桃園=Taoyuan, Taiwan，元智大學資訊管理學系=Department of Information Management, Yuanze University。
100. 黃東益(2013)。從價値差異到夥伴關係：政務官事務官的互動管理。臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan。
101. 黃紀、王德育(2012)。質變數與受限依變數的迴歸分析。臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan。
102. 趙達瑜(1999)。我國公務人員保障法與美國弊端揭發人保護法之比較研究。暨大學報，3(1)，297-320。
103. 趙達瑜(1997)。美國弊端揭發人保護法析介。人事行政，122，41-49。
104. 蔡秀涓(2009)。台灣文官的公共服務價值觀與新公共服務精神的比較：經驗調查初探。文官制度季刊，1(4)，111-135。
105. 蔡秀涓、王千文(2008)。研究架構、議題選取與問卷設計：民主治理系絡之台灣政府文官調查。2008年台灣政治學會年會研討會，南投=Nantou:
106. 蔡明瀚(2016)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwa，政治大學公共行政學系=Department of Public Administration, National Chengchi University。
107. 賴志宗(2015)。桃園=Taoyuan, Taiwan，元智大學資訊管理學系=Department of Information Management, Yuanze University。

1. 陳敦源,林俐君,呂季蓉(2018)。民主治理下的政務官與事務官互動關係：以「是的，部長！」影集分析為例。文官制度季刊，10(4)，85-118。
2. (2024)。地方政府政務職位與專業行政之整合。中國地方自治，77(1)，24-53。