题名

邁向循證基礎的公共政策宣導：一個以臺灣酒駕防制廣告類型有效性為核心的準實驗研究

并列篇名

Toward an Evidence-based Public Policy Campaign: A Quasi-experimental Analysis of the Effectiveness of Types of Advertisements on the Drunk Driving Prevention Campaign in Taiwan

DOI

10.6166/TJPS.202006_(84).0003

作者

許弘毅(Hung-yi Hsu)；劉俐良(Li-liang Liu)；陳敦源(Don-yun Chen)

关键词

酒駕防制 ； 政策宣導 ； 準實驗設計 ； 循證基礎的公共政策 ； 動機保護理論 ； Drunk Driving Prevention ； Policy Campaign ； Quasi-Experimental Design ； Evidence-based Public Policy ； Protection Motivation Theory

期刊名称

政治科學論叢

卷期/出版年月

84期（2020 / 06 / 01）

页次

71 - 111

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

「何種政策宣導內容比較有效？」一直是政策管理者關切的核心議題。奠基於循證的公共政策精神，本研究以酒駕防制宣導來回答這問題意識。參考保護動機理論（Protection Motivation Theory，PMT）將酒駕防制廣告分成威脅（threat）取向、因應（coping）取向以及結合威脅與因應取向的三種影片類型，以準實驗設計對臺北市區監理所及臺北區監理所之酒駕道安違規講習班學員，三組實驗組分別播放三種不同類型的酒駕防制宣導影片，控制組則未播放宣導影片，透過前後測問卷調査（有效樣本爲625份），以確定不同類型宣導影片對避免酒駕行爲意圖的影響。研究結果顯示，四組受試者的避免酒駕行爲意圖並無顯著差異。然而，結合威脅與因應取向的宣導影片對不同程度的酒精依賴者有不同效果。相較於未觀看任何宣導影片的控制組，高酒精依賴者觀看完威脅與因應取向的宣導影片後，其避免酒駕的行爲意圖高於低酒精依賴者，顯示符合PMT設計的宣導影片內容，更有可能對高酒精成癮者發揮正面宣導作用。本研究建議未來政府設計宣導內容應引入更多的循證基礎，以精準掌握宣導的效果。
英文摘要

＂What kinds of policy campaign content should be the most effective?＂ This question has been a core issue among policymakers. Following the spirit of evidence-based policy, this study has used the case of the drunk driving prevention campaign in Taiwan to answer this essential question. Based on protection motivation theory (PMT), this study has categorized drunk driving prevention advertisements into three types: threat orientation, coping orientation, and threat-coping orientation. Participants (n=625) were drunk drivers sampled from traffic education programs which were provided by the Taipei City Motor Vehicles Office and the New Taipei City Motor Vehicles Office. The quasi-experiment took place in the two aforementioned offices, where the three types of advertisements were shown respectively to three experiment groups while no ads were displayed to the control group. By using the pre-test and post-test questionnaires, this study measured the behavioral intention of avoiding drunk driving as the treatment effect. The result showed that the behavioral intention of avoiding drunk driving was not significantly different among the four groups. However, the threat-coping orientated advertisement had divergent effects on lighter drinkers and heavier drinkers. Compared to the control group where no ad was viewed, in the experiment group where the threat-coping orientated ad was viewed, heavier drinkers had a higher behavioral intention of avoiding drunk driving than lighter drinkers did, which implied that the drunk driving prevention advertisement based on PMT was more likely to exert a positive campaign effect on heavier drinkers. In the light of the research findings, this study suggests that more evidence-based designs should be incorporated into government campaign advertisements to leverage the policy campaign more precisely.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 吳文貴, Wen-kuei,羅浣云, Wan-gun(2011)。簡訊廣告標題與廣告訴求之廣告效果研究。行銷評論，8(2)，267-283。
    連結：
  2. 張新立, Hsin-li,葉純志, Churr-chih(2003)。酒後駕車防治措施成效之監控與評估一以台北市為例。運輸計劃季刊，32(1)，131-150。
    連結：
  3. 葉寶文, Po-wen,傅祖壇, Tsu-tan(2006)。酒後駕車行為決策之研究。運輸計劃季刊，35(3)，337-364。
    連結：
  4. 蕭至惠, Chih-hui,蔡進發, Chin-fa,陳玟君, Wen-churr(2012)。廣告訴求與產品屬性的差異真能左右消費者對廣告效果的知覺？。行銷評論，9(1)，61-90。
    連結：
  5. 賴怡樺, Yi-hua,林水波, Shoei-po,陳敦源, Don-gun(2018)。行為主義導向的公共政策研究:以政策工具「推力」為核心的初探。行政暨政策學報，67，1-37。
    連結：
  6. Atkin, C. K.(1988).Mass Communication Effects on Drinking and Driving.Surgeon General’s Workshop on Drunk Driving: Background Papers, ed. U. S. Department of Health and Human Services,Rockville, MD:
  7. Bemelmans-Videc, Marie-Louise(ed.),Rist, Ray C.(ed.),Vedung, Evert Oskar(ed.)(2011).Carrots, Sticks, and Sermons: Policy Instruments and Their Evaluation.New Brunswick:Transaction Publishers.
  8. Bettinghaus, E. P.(1986).Health Promotion and the Knowledge-Attitude-Behavior Continuum.Preventive Medicine,15(5),475-491.
  9. Brehm, J. W.(1966).A Theory of Psychological Reactance.New York:Academic Press.
  10. Brennan, L.,Binney, W.(2010).Fear, Guilt, and Shame Appeals in Social Marketing.Journal of Business Research,63(2),140-146.
  11. Brown, K. G.,Stautz, K.,Hollands, G. J.,Winpenny, E. M.,Marteau, T. M.(2016).The Cognitive and Behavioural Impact of Alcohol Promoting and Alcohol Warning Advertisements: An Experimental Study.Alcohol and Alcoholism,51(3),354-362.
  12. Bryant, Jennings(ed.),Zillmann, Dolf(ed.)(2002).Media Effects: Advances in Theory and Research.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  13. Cacioppo, John T.(ed.),Petty, Richard E.(ed.)(1983).Social Psychophysiology: A Sourcebook.New York:Guilford Press.
  14. Cismaru, M.,Chao, P.,Lavack, A. M.,Markewich, E.(2009).Social Marketing Campaigns Aimed at Preventing Drunk Driving.International Marketing Review,26(3),292-311.
  15. Cohen, P.,West, S. G.,Aiken, L. S.(2014).Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  16. DeFleur, M. L.,Ball-Rokeach, S.(1982).Theories of Mass Communication.New York:Longman.
  17. Dejong, W.,Atkin, C. K.(1995).A Review of National Television PSA Campaigns for Preventing Alcohol-Impaired Driving, 1987-1992.Journal of Public Health Policy,16(1),59-80.
  18. Donovan, R. J.,Henley, N.,Jalleh, G.,Slater, C.(1995).Road Safety Advertising: An Empirical Study and Literature Review.Canberra:Federal Office of Road Safety.
  19. Donovan, R. J.,Jalleh, G.,Henley, N.(1999).Executing Effective Road Safety Advertising: Are Big Production Budgets Necessary?.Accident Analysis & Prevention,31(3),243-252.
  20. Dunning, T.(2012).Natural Experiments in the Social Sciences: A Design-Based Approach.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  21. Elder, R. W.,Shults, R. A.,Sleet, D. A.,Nichols, J. L.,Thompson, R. S.,Rajab, W.,Task Force on Community Preventive Service(2004).Effectiveness of Mass Media Campaigns for Reducing Drinking and Driving and Alcohol-Involved Crashes: A Systematic Review.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,27(1),57-65.
  22. Elliott, B.(2011).Beyond Reviews of Road Safety Mass Media Campaigns: Looking Elsewhere for New Insights.Journal of the Australasian College of Road Safety,22(4),11-17.
  23. Elliott, B.(1993).Road Safety Mass Media Campaigns: A Meta Analysis.Canberra:Federal Office of Road Safety.
  24. Elvik, R.,Vaa, T.,Hoye, A.,Sorensen, M.(2009).The Handbook of Road Safety Measures.UK:Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
  25. Field, M.,Cox, W. M.(2008).Attentional Bias in Addictive Behaviors: A Review of Its Development, Causes, and Consequences.Drug and Alcohol Dependence,97(1-2),1-20.
  26. Fishbein, M.,Ajzen, I.(1977).Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
  27. Floyd, D. L.,Prentice-Dunn, S.,Rogers, R. W.(2000).A Meta-Analysis of Research on Protection Motivation Theory.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,30(2),407-429.
  28. Gelman, A.,Hill, J.(2006).Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/ Hierarchical Models.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  29. Giesbrecht, N.,Greenfield, T. K.(1999).Public Opinions on Alcohol Policy Issues: A Comparison of American and Canadian Surveys.Addiction,94(4),521-531.
  30. Guttman, N.(2015).Persuasive Appeals in Road Safety Communication Campaigns: Theoretical Frameworks and Practical Implications from the Analysis of a Decade of Road Safety Campaign Materials.Accident Analysis and Prevention,84,153-164.
  31. Hannigan, J. H.,Spear, L. P.,Spear, N. E.,Goodlett, C. R.(1999).Alcohol and Alcoholism: Effects on Brain and Development.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  32. Haskins, J. B.(1985).The Role of Mass Media in Alcohol and Highway Safety Campaigns.Journal of Studies on Alcohol Supplement,10,184-191.
  33. Hastings, G.,Stead, M.,Webb, J.(2004).Fear Appeals in Social Marketing: Strategic and Ethical Reasons for Concern.Psychology and Marketing,21(11),961-986.
  34. Hoekstra, T.,Wegman, F.(2011).Improving the Effectiveness of Road Safety Campaigns: Current and New Practices.IATSS Research,34(2),80-86.
  35. Huckle, T.,You, R. Q.,Casswell, S.(2010).Socio-Economic Status Predicts Drinking Patterns but Not Alcohol-Related Consequences Independently.Addiction,105(7),1192-1202.
  36. Hutchinson, T. P.,Wundersitz, L. N.(2011).Road Safety Mass Media Campaigns: Why Are Results Inconclusive, and What Can Be Done?.International Journal of Injury Control and Safety Promotion,18(3),235-241.
  37. Kees, J.,Fitzgerald, P.,Dorsey, J. D.,Hill, R. P.(2020).Evidence-Based Cannabis Policy: A Framework to Guide Marketing and Public Policy Research.Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,39(1),76-92.
  38. King, K. W.,Reid, L. N.(1990).Fear Arousing Anti-Drinking and Driving Psas: Do Physical Injury Threats Influence Young Adults?.Current Issues and Research in Advertising,12(1-2),155-175.
  39. Mann, R. E.,Leigh, G.,Vingilis, E. R.,Genova, K. De(1983).A Critical Review on the Effectiveness of Drinking-Driving Rehabilitation Programmes.Accident Analysis & Prevention,15(6),441-461.
  40. Milne, S.,Sheeran, P.,Orbell, S.(2000).Prediction and Intervention in Health Related Behavior: A Meta-Analytic Review of Protection Motivation Theory.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,30(1),106-143.
  41. Moore, J. N.,Raymond, M. A.,Mittelstaedt, J. D.,Tanner, J. F.(2002).Age and Consumer Socialization Agent Influences on Adolescents’ Sexual Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behavior: Implications for Social Marketing Initiatives and Public Policy.Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,21(1),37-52.
  42. Mowen, J. C.,Harris, E. G.,Bone, S. A.(2004).Personality Traits and Fear Response to Print Advertisements: Theory and an Empirical Study.Psychology and Marketing,21(11),927-943.
  43. Murry, J. P.,Stam, A.,Lastovicka, J. L.(1993).Evaluating an Anti-Drinking and Driving Advertising Campaign with a Sample Survey and Time Series Intervention Analysis.Journal of the American Statistical Association,88(421),50-56.
  44. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. 2017. “Impaired Driving Segmentation.” in https://www.trafficsafetymarketing.gov/marketing-tools/ research. Latest update 9 March 2020.
  45. National Police Agency. 2019. "Jiuhou jiache qudijian shu" [Statistics on Drinking Driving Crackdown]. in https://ba.npa.gov.tw/npa/stmain.jsp?sys=100. Lastest update 9 November 2019.
  46. Niederdeppe, J.,Avery, R. J.,Miller, E. E. N.(2018).Theoretical Foundations of Appeals Used in Alcohol-Abuse and Drunk-Driving Public Service Announcements in the United States, 1995-2010.American Journal of Health Promotion,32(4),887-896.
  47. Niederdeppe, J.,Avery, R.,Miller, E. N.(2017).Alcohol-Control Public Service Announcements (Psas) and Drunk-Driving Fatal Accidents in the United States, 1996-2010.Preventive Medicine,99,320-325.
  48. O’Hare, M.(1989).A Typology of Governmental Action.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,8(4),670-672.
  49. Peattie, K.,Peattie, S.,Clarke, P.(2001).Skin Cancer Prevention: Reevaluating the Public Policy Implications.Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,20(2),268-279.
  50. Phillips, R. O.,Ulleberg, P.,Vaa, T.(2011).Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Road Safety Campaigns on Accidents.Accident Analysis & Prevention,43(3),1204-1218.
  51. Porumbescu, G. A.,Lindeman, M. I. H.,Ceka, E.,Cucciniello, M.(2017).Can Transparency Foster More Understanding and Compliant Citizens?.Public Administration Review,77(6),840-850.
  52. Randolph, W.,Viswanath, K.(2004).Lessons Learned from Public Health Mass Media Campaigns: Marketing Health in a Crowded Media World.Annual Review of Public Health,25(1),419-437.
  53. Rautaray, Siddharth Swarup(ed.),Eichler, Gerald(ed.),Erfurth, Christian(ed.),Fahrnberger, Günter(ed.)(2020).Non-Fear-Based Road Safety Campaign as a Community Service: Contexts from Social Media.Innovations for Community Services,Cham:
  54. Rice, Ronald E.(ed.),Paisley, William J.(ed.)(1981).Public Communication Campaigns.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage Publications.
  55. Ringold, D. J.(2002).Boomerang Effects in Response to Public Health Interventions: Some Unintended Consequences in the Alcoholic Beverage Market.Journal of Consumer Policy,25(1),27-63.
  56. Rossiter, J. R.,Thornton, J.(2004).Fear-Pattern Analysis Supports the Fear-Drive Model for Antispeeding Road-Safety TV Ads.Psychology & Marketing,21(11),945-960.
  57. Schneider, A.,Ingram, H.(1990).Behavioral Assumptions of Policy Tools.The Journal of Politics,52(2),510-529.
  58. Sen, A.(2005).Do Stricter Penalties or Media Publicity Reduce Alcohol Consumption by Drivers?.Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques,31(4),359-379.
  59. Shadish, W. R.,Cook, T. D.,Campbell, D. T.(2002).Experimental and Quasi Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin.
  60. Siegfried, N.,Parry, C.(2019).Do Alcohol Control Policies Work? An Umbrella Review and Quality Assessment of Systematic Reviews of Alcohol Control Interventions (2006-2017).PloS one,14(4),e0214865.
  61. Simpson, J. K.(2017).Appeal to Fear in Health Care: Appropriate or Inappropriate?.Chiropractic & Manual Therapies,25,27.
  62. Tay, R.(2005).Mass Media Campaigns Reduce the Incidence of Drinking and Driving.Evidence-Based Healthcare and Public Health,9(1),26-29.
  63. Tay, R.,Watson, B.(2002).Changing Drivers’ Intentions and Behaviours Using Fear-Based Driver Fatigue Advertisements.Health Marketing Quarterly,19(4),55-68.
  64. Teng, L.,Zhao, G.,Li, F.,Liu, L.,Shen, L.(2019).Increasing the Persuasiveness of Anti-Drunk Driving Appeals: The Effect of Negative and Positive Message Framing.Journal of Business Research,103,240-249.
  65. Thaler, R. H.,Sunstein, C. R.(2008).Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness.New Haven:Yale University Press.
  66. Vingilis, E.,Coultes, B.(1990).Mass Communications and Drinking-Driving: Theories, Practices and Results.Alcohol, Drugs and Driving,6(2),61-81.
  67. Weaver, R. K.(2014).Compliance Regimes and Barriers to Behavioral Change.Governance,27(2),243-265.
  68. Weenig, M. W. H.,Midden, C. J. H.(1997).Mass-Media Information Campaigns and Knowledge-Gap Effects.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,27(11),945-958.
  69. Wilde, G. J.(1993).Effects of Mass Media Communications on Health and Safety Habits: An Overview of Issues and Evidence.Addiction,88(7),983-996.
  70. Witte, K.,Allen, M.(2000).A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns.Health Education & Behavior,27(5),591-615.
  71. Worden, J. K.,Waller, J. A.,Riley, T. J.(1975).The Vermont Public Education Campaign in Alcohol and Highway Safety: A Final Review and Evaluation.Montpelier, VT:Department of Mental Health.
  72. World Health Organization. 2007. “Drinking and Driving: An International Good Practice Manual.” in https://www.grsproadsafety.org/wp-content/uploads/ DrinkingDriving_English.pdf. Latest update 9 November 2019.
  73. World Health Organization. 2001. “Audit: The Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test: Guidelines for Use in Primary Health Care.” in https://apps.who.int/ iris/bitstream/handle/10665/67205/WHO_MSD_MSB_01.6a.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y. Latest update 9 November 2019. 1&isAllowed
  74. Yadav, R. P.,Kobayashi, M.(2015).A Systematic Review: Effectiveness of Mass Media Campaigns for Reducing Alcohol-Impaired Driving and Alcohol-Related Crashes.BMC Public Health,15(1),857.
  75. Young, B.,Lewis, S.,Katikireddi, S. V.,Bauld, L.,Stead, M.,Angus, K.,Langley, T.(2018).Effectiveness of Mass Media Campaigns to Reduce Alcohol Consumption and Harm: A Systematic Review.Alcohol and Alcoholism,53(3),302-316.
  76. Yuen, K. F.,Li, K. X.,Ma, F.,Wang, X.(2020).The Effect of Emotional Appeal on Seafarers’ Safety Behaviour: An Extended Health Belief Model.Journal of Transport & Health,16,100810..
  77. 王玉玲, Yul-ing(2011)。桃園=Taoyuan, Taiwan，中央警察大學交通管理研究所=Department of Traffic Science, Central Police University。
  78. 王家麟, Chia-lin(2003)。臺中=Taichung, Taiwan，逢甲大學交通工程與管理學系=Department of Transportation and Logistics, Feng Chia University。
  79. 交通部運輸研究所，2018，〈 106年度交通安全統計報表〉，運輸安全網站資料系統，http://talas-pub.lot.goo.tw/TSFdownload.aspx,2019/11/09. Institute of Transportation, Ministry of Transportation and Communications of R.O.C. 2018. “2017 niandu jiaotong anqua tongji baobiao” [2017 Traffic Safety Satistics]. in http://talas-pub.iot.gov.tw/TSFdownload.aspx. Lastest update 9 November 2019.
  80. 游俊哲,Churr-che(2003)。新竹=Hsinchu, Taiwan，國立交通大學運輸科技與管理學系=Department of Transportation and Logistics Management,National ChiaoTung University。
  81. 趙家皓, Chia-hao(2000)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，輔仁大學經濟學研究所=Department of Economics, Fu Jen Catholic University。
  82. 蔡中志, Zhong-zhi,洪嘉臨, Jia-lin,宋宗哲, Zong-zhe(2011)。高速公路AI類酒後駕車肇事與執法強度及社會經濟關聯性之研究。100年道路交通安全與執法研討會論文集，桃園=Taoyung:
  83. 蔡秉諺, Bing-gan(2013)。新竹=Hsinchu, Taiwan.，中華大學運輸科技與物流管理學系=Department of Transportation Technology and Logistics Management, Chung Hua University。
  84. 賴建都, Chien-to(2008)。政府宣導廣告之文案測試研究:以國民健康局2004-2006年「鼓勵生育」宣導廣告為例。廣告學研究，29，1-28。
  85. 警政署，2019，〈酒後駕車取締件數〉，警政統計查詢網，https://ba.npa.goo.tw/npa/stmain.jsp?sys=100， 2019/11/09.
被引用次数
  1. 呂嘉穎(2022)。分析公共政策網路參與平臺之效益－以有關臺中市之提議議案為例。弘光學報，89，83-95。
  2. (2024)。不尊重專業vs.不懂政治：循證政策的政治觀點。公共行政學報，66，139-148。
  3. (2024)。個人資料授權在知情同意機制的優化研究。行政暨政策學報，78，67-93。
print cancel