题名

工業污染區住民之正義觀：後勁與臺西個案分析

并列篇名

Residents' Conceptions of Justice in Industrial Pollution Sites: Case Studies of Houjin and Taishi

DOI

10.6166/TJPS.202109_(89).0002

作者

李翠萍(Tsuey-ping Lee)

关键词

褐地重建政策 ； 環境正義 ； 環境治理 ； 報應正義 ； 補償正義 ； Brownfield Redevelopment Policy ； Environmental Justice ； Environmental Governance ； Retributive Justice ； Compensatory

期刊名称

政治科學論叢

卷期/出版年月

89期（2021 / 09 / 01）

页次

39 - 87

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本文以高雄後勁與彰化大城臺西村爲研究對象，藉由問卷調查與深度訪談，探索工業污染區住民的正義觀偏好、形成正義觀的背景系絡、與實踐正義觀的困境。研究結果顯示，兩地受訪者正義觀的傾向相同，偏好污染清除與社區重建的補償正義，究其系絡因素，除了長住當地的居民在經歷自然環境的破壞後產生對好山好水的思念之外，後勁反五輕運動的意識形態與臺西村務農維生的經濟模式是形塑此正義觀的基礎。此外，若有其他正義觀可供選擇，兩地受訪者對程序正義的偏好皆會降低，顯見受訪者雖重視知的權利，但對參與相關決策有所遲疑。究其原因，除了面對龐大的污染企業所產生的參與無效感之外，後勁反五輕完成階段性任務與臺西村受訪者缺乏參與能力與自信是主要原因。這些因素阻礙了污染清除社區重建之補償正義觀的實踐，也容易促使補償個人損失之正義觀出現。
英文摘要

This study explores the conceptions of justice held by community residents of industrial pollution sites, the contextual factors shaping their held conceptions of justice, and the challenges to the practice of justice. These are analyzed by conducting questionnaire surveys and in-depth face-to-face interviews in Houjin, Kaohsiung City and Taishi village, Changhua County. The results of the research show that respondents from both sites tended to choose public-interest oriented compensatory justice, including pollution clean-up and community revitalization, rather than private-interest oriented compensatory justice and retributive justice. The contextual factors behind these preferences are mainly the good memories held by residents about the natural environment before its deterioration, the ideology shaped by the long journey of the local environmental movement in Houjin, and the farming traditions in Taishi village. However, fatigue from the seemingly endless environmental movement and the losing of patience and trust in the government in the fight for justice have redirected the residents toward private-interest oriented compensatory justice. This study also finds that procedural justice was less preferred if other conceptions of justice became available. Obviously, the respondents hesitated to take participatory action, although they wanted to be well informed. The contextual factors behind this attitude are perceptions of the invalidity of participation, the accomplishment of settling the mission of the local environmental movement in Houjin, and the residents' lack of participatory capabilities and confidence.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. Lu, H. Y.(2009).Place and Environmental Movement in Houjin, Kaohsiung.Journal of Archaeology and Anthropology,70,47-77.
    連結：
  2. 王永慈, Yeong-tsyr,游進裕, Jin-Yu,林碧亮, Bi-Liang(2013)。淹水對沿海地層下陷區之貧窮家庭的社會影響—以臺灣西海岸漁村為例。臺灣社會工作學刊，11，81-114。
    連結：
  3. 李翠萍, Tsuey-ping(2018)。地社區修復式環境正義的興起、實作、與條件—美國南卡州斯巴坦堡社區重建政策之個案分析。公共行政學報，55，73-108。
    連結：
  4. 李翠萍, Tsuey-ping(2010)。地重建中的公民參與及政策間隙—以中石化舊台鹼安順廠戴奧辛污染為例。公共行政學報，34，123-151。
    連結：
  5. 李翠萍, Tsuey-ping(2011)。地重建中的社會資本與政府效能—日本熊本縣水俁市有機水銀污染個案分析。政治科學論叢，50，95-140。
    連結：
  6. 范玫芳, Mei-feng(2012)。從環境正義觀點探討曾文水庫越域引水工程計畫。台灣政治學刊，16(2)，117-173。
    連結：
  7. 莊國銘, Kuo-ming(2003)。亞里斯多德論鞏固政治共同體的兩大德性：正義與友誼。政治科學論叢，18，191-216。
    連結：
  8. 湯京平, Ching-ping,邱崇原, Chung-yuan(2007)。多元民主、政治吸納與政策回應：從台鹼污染案檢視台灣環保公益團體的政策角色。人文及社會科學集刊，19(1)，93-127。
    連結：
  9. 黃之棟, Chih-tung,黃瑞祺,Ruey-chyi(2009)。正義的繼受：我們與美國人講的到底是不是同樣的環境正義。國家發展研究，9(1)，85-144。
    連結：
  10. Ackerman, B. A.(1980).Social Justice and the Liberal State.New Haven:Yale University Press.
  11. Alstott, A.,Ackerman, B. A.(1999).The Stakeholder Society.New Haven:Yale University Press.
  12. Babbie, E.(2016).The Practice of Social Research.Boston:Cengage Learning.
  13. Barry, B.(1988).Equal Opportunity and Moral Arbitrariness.Equal Opportunity,London:
  14. Benford, R. D.,Snow, D. A.(2000).Framing Processes and Social Movements: An Overview and Assessment.Annual Review of Sociology,26,611-639.
  15. Berman, M.(2013).Rehabilitating Retributivism.Law and Philosophy,32(1),83-108.
  16. Blackstone, W.(1975).Reverse Discrimination and Compensatory Justice.Social Theory and Practice,3(3),253-288.
  17. Brooks, R.(1999).The Age of Apology.The Controversy over Apologies and Reparations for Human Injustic,New York:
  18. Canter, L. W.(1996).Environmental Impact Assessment.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  19. Clark, J. N.(2009).The Limits of Retributive Justice: Findings of an Empirical Study in Bosnia and Hercegovina.Journal of International Criminal Justice,7(3),463-487.
  20. Daly, K.(2002).Restorative Justice: The Real Story.Punishment and Society,4(1),55-79.
  21. D'Anjou, L.,Steijn, A.,Van Aarsen, D.(1995).Social Position, Ideology, and Distributive Justice.Social Justice Research,8(4),351-384.
  22. Dick, J.(1975).How to Justify a Distribution of Earnings ?.Philosophy and Public Affairs,4(3),248-272.
  23. Dixon, K. A.(2003).Reclaiming Brownfields : From Corporate Liability to Community Asset.National Assets : Democratizing Environmental Ownership of Nature,Washington:
  24. Du Rees, H.(2001).Can Criminal Law Protect the Environment ?.Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention,2(2),109-126.
  25. Dull, M.,Wernstedt, K.(2010).Land Recycling, Community Revitalization, and Distributive Politics: An Analysis of EPA Brownfields Program Support.Policy Studies Journal,38(1),119-141.
  26. Farber, D. A.(2005).The Story of Boomer : Pollution and the Common Law.Environmental Law Stories,New York:
  27. Feinberg, J.(1990).Harmless Wrongdoing.New York:Oxford University Press.
  28. Feinberg, J.(1970).Justice and Personal Desert.Doing and Deserving : Essays in the Theory of Responsibility,Princeton:
  29. Fraser, N.(1998).Social Justice in the Age of Identity Politics: Redistribution, Recognition, Participation.
  30. Fraser, N.,Honneth, A.(2003).Redistribution or Recognition? A Political Philosophical Exchange.London:Verso.
  31. Gallagher, D.(2009).Advocates for Environmental Justice: the Role of the Champion in Public Participation Implementation.Local Environment,14(10),905-916.
  32. Given, L. M.(ed.)(2008).The SAGE Encyclopedia of Qualitative Research Methods.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
  33. Gomes, M. E.(1992).The Rewards and Stresses of Social Change: A Qualitative Study of Peace Activists.Journal of Humanistic Psychology,32(4),138-146.
  34. Greenberg, M. R.(2003).Reversing Urban Decay: Brownfield Redevelopment and Environmental Health.Environmental Health Perspectives,111(2),A74-A75.
  35. Hall, M.(2013).Environmental Victims: Challenges for Criminology and Victimology in the 21st Century.Journal of Criminal Justice and Security,13(4),371-391.
  36. Harton, O. N.(2008).Indiana's Brownfields Initiatives: A Vehicle for Pursing Environmental Justice or Just Blowing Smoke.Indiana Law Review,41,215-244.
  37. Hasenfeld, Y.,Rafferty, J. A.(1989).The Determinants of Public Attitudes toward the Welfare State.Social Forces,67(4),1027-1048.
  38. Herman, J. L.(2005).Justice from the Victim's Perspective.Violence Against Women,11(5),571-602.
  39. Higgs, R.(2008).The Complex Course of Ideological Change.The American Journal of Economics and Sociology,67(4),547-566.
  40. Hird, J. A.(1993).Environmental Policy and Equity: The Case of Superfund.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,12(2),323-343.
  41. Hughes, J. 2000. “Tomoko Uemura, R.I.P.” in http://digitaljournalist.org/issue0007/hughes.htm. Latest update 21 March 2021.
  42. Ikeme, J.(2003).Equity, Environmental Justice and Sustainability: Incomplete Approaches in Climate Change Politics.Global Environmental Change,13(3),195-206.
  43. Kant, I. 1797. The Metaphysics of Morals. Trans Mary Gregor. New York: Cambridge University Press.
  44. Lamont, J(1997).Incentive Income, Deserved Income, and Economic Rents.Journal of Political Philosophy,5(1),26-46.
  45. Lee, S.,Mohai, P.(2012).Environmental Justice Implications of Brownfield Redevelopment in the United States.Society and Natural Resources,25(6),602-609.
  46. Lee, T. P.(2020).Pursuing Justice in a Community Experiencing Environmental Injustice: The Practice of Community Revitalization.Contemporary Justice Review,23(4),337-353.
  47. Masterson, S. S.,Tong, N.(2015).Justice Perception Formation in Social Settings.The Oxford Handbook of Justice in the Workplace,London:
  48. McCarty, L.(2009).Off the Mark ? Efficiency in Targeting the Most Marketable Sites rather than Equity in Public Assistance for Brownfield Redevelopment.Economic Development Quarterly,23(3),211-228.
  49. Milne, H.(1986).Desert, Effort and Equality.Journal of Applied Philosophy,3(2),235-243.
  50. Moore, M. S.(1997).Placing Blame : A Theory of Criminal Law.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  51. Murphy, J. G.(2007).Legal Moralism and Retribution Revisited.Criminal Law and Philosophy,1(1),5-20.
  52. Nussbaum, M. C.(2006).Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
  53. Perkins, N.(2007).A Tale of Two Brownfield Sites: Making the Best of Times from the Worst of Times in Western Pennsylvania's Steel Valley.Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review,34(3),503-532.
  54. Pines, A. M.(1994).Burnout in Political Activism: An Existential Perspective.Journal of Health and Human Resources Administration,16(4),381-394.
  55. Preston, B.(2011).The Use of Restorative Justice for Environmental Crime.Criminal Law Journal,35(3),136-153.
  56. Quinton, M. A.(1954).On Punishment.Analysis,14(6),133-142.
  57. Rawls, J.(1999).A Theory of Justice.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
  58. Regehr, C.,Alaggia, R.(2006).Perspectives of Justice for Victims of Sexual Violence.Victims and Offenders,1(1),33-46.
  59. Rettig, H.(2006).The Lifelong Activist: How to Change the World without Losing Your Way.New York:Lantern.
  60. Robinson, R. V.,Bell, W.(1978).Equality, Success, and Social Justice in England and the United States.American Sociological Review,43(2),125-143.
  61. Rodgers, K.(2010).Anger is Why We're All Here ": Mobilizing and Managing Emotions in a Professional Activist Organization.Social Movement Studies,9(3),273-291.
  62. Rogge, M. E.,Davis, K.,Maddox, D.,Jackson, M.(2005).Leveraging Environmental, Social, and Economic Justice at Chattanooga Creek: A Case Study.Journal of Community Practice,13(3),33-53.
  63. Sadurski, W.(1985).Giving Desert Its Due: Social Justice and Legal Theory.Dordrecht:D. Reidel Publishing Company.
  64. Schaufeli, W.,Buunk, B.(2002).Burnout : An Overview of 25 Years of Research and Theorizing.The Handbook of Work and Health Psychology,Hoboken:
  65. Sen, A.(1999).Development as Freedom.New York:Alfred A. Knopf, Inc..
  66. Sen, A.(2009).The Idea of Justice.London:Allen Lane.
  67. Sharp, K. 2000. “‘Erin Brockovich’: The Real Story.” in http://www.salon.com/2000/04/14/sharp/.Latest update 27 March 2021.
  68. Shepelak, N. J.(1989).Ideological Stratification: American Beliefs about Economic Justice.Social Justice Research,3(3),217-231.
  69. Situ, Y.,Emmons, D.(2000).Environmental Crime: The Criminal Justice System's Role in Protecting the Environment.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
  70. Skinnider, E.(2013).Effect, Issues and Challenges for Victims of Crimes that have a Significant Impact on the Environment.Workshop on “Emerging forms of crime that have an impact on the environment: lessons learned”
  71. Snow, D. A.(2004).Framing Processes, Ideology, and Discursive Fields.The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements,Oxford:
  72. Solitare, L.,Lowrie, K.(2012).Increasing the Capacity of Community Development Corporations for Brownfield Redevelopment: An Inside-Out Approach.Local Environment,17(4),461-479.
  73. Starr, J. W.,Flack, B. L.,Foley, A. D.(2009).A New Intersection: Environmental Crimes and Victims ' Rights.Natural Resources & Environment,23(3),41-52.
  74. Stubbs, J.(2002).Domestic Violence and Women's Safety: Feminist Challenges to Restorative Justice.Restorative Justice and Family Violence,Cambridge:
  75. Swidler, A.(1986).Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies.American Sociological Review,51(2),273-286.
  76. United Nation Office for Drug Control and Crime Prevention(1999).Handbook on Justice for Victims.New York:Center for International Crime Prevention.
  77. US Environmental Protection Agency. 2021. "Learn from Environmental Justice." in https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/learn-about-environmental-justice. Latest update 21 March 2021.
  78. Vaccaro, A.,Mena, J. A.(2011).It's not Burnout, it's more: Queer College Activists of Color and Mental Health.Journal of Gay and Lesbian Health,15,339-367.
  79. Van Boven, T.(1995).United Nations Commission on Human Rights: Study Concerning the Right to Restitution, Compensation, and Rehabilitation for Victims of Gross Violations of Human Rights.Transitional Justice : How Emerging Democracies Reckon with Former Regimes, vol. 1, General Considerations,Herndon:
  80. Verry, J.,Heffernan, F.,Fisher, R.(2005).Restorative Justice Approaches in the Context of Environmental Prosecution.Safety, crime and justice: from data to policy, Australian Institute of Criminology Conference
  81. Walen, A.(2016).Retributive Justice.The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  82. Walker, G.(2010).Environmental Justice, Impact Assessment and the Politics of Knowledge: The Implications of Assessing the Social Distribution of Environmental Outcomes.Environmental Impact Assessment Review,30(5),312-318.
  83. Weakliem, D(1993).Class Consciousness and Political Change: Voting and Political Attitudes in the British Working Class, 1964 to 1970.American Sociological Review,58(3),382-397.
  84. White, R.(2008).Crimes against Nature: Environmental Criminology & Ecological Justice.Devon:Willan Publishing.
  85. Yin, R. K.(2009).Case Study Research: Design and Methods.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
  86. Young, I. M.(1990).Justice and the Politics of Difference.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
  87. Zehr, H.(2001).Transcending: Reflections of Crime Victims.Intercourse:Good Books.
  88. 土污基管會=Soil and Underground Water Pollution Remediation Fund Management Board(2021)。土污基管會，2021，〈污染場址列管查詢〉，場址查詢網頁，https://sgw.epa.gov.tw/ContaminatedSitesMap/Default.aspx，2021/03/27。Soil and Underground Water Pollution Remediation Fund Management Board. 2021. “Wuran changzhi lieguan chaxun” [Enquiry of Pollution Sites]. in https://sgw.epa.gov.tw/ContaminatedSitesMap/Default.aspx. Latest update 27 March 2021.。https://sgw.epa.gov.tw/ContaminatedSitesMap/Default.aspx
  89. 工傷害受害人協會,原臺灣美國無線公司員工關懷協會(2014).拒絕被遺忘的聲音：RCA 工殤口述史.臺北=Taipei:行人文化實驗室=Flâneur Culture Lab.
  90. 水俁病不知火患者會,拒絕水俣國賠等訴訟辯護團,拒絕水與編輯委員會(2015).拒絕水俣—以司法解決的道路.臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan.
  91. 地球公民基金會，2013，〈反五輕新里程後勁生態公園競圖比賽優勝揭曉〉，地球公民基金會網頁，https://www.cet-taiwan.org/node/1831 2021/03/27。 Citizen of the Earth, Taiwan. 2013. “Fanwuqing xinlicheng houjin shengtai gongyuan jingtu bisai yousheng jiexiao” [Milestone for Anti CPC Coporation Refinery Plant, Houjin Eco Park Design Competition Results]. in https://www. cet-taiwan.org/node/1831. Latest update 27 March 2021.
  92. 地球公民基金會,財團法人後勁社會福利基金會, Houjin Social Welfare Foundation(2015).堅持—後勁反五輕的未竟之路.臺南=Tainan:透南風文化創意有限公司= Southern Winds Studio Co., Ltd..
  93. 何明修, Ming-sho(2006).綠色民主：台灣環境運動的研究.臺北=Taipei:群學出版社=Socio Publishing.
  94. 余嘉榮，2016 ，〈「堅持」一漫長的陸上行舟後勁反五輕運動的未竟之路〉，20/07/02。Yu, Jia-rong. 2016. “‘Jianchi’— manchang de lushang xingzhou houjin fanwuqing yundong de weijing zhi lu” [Movement against Fifth Kaohsiung Refinery 1987-2015]. in http://www.civilmedia.tw/archives/43077. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  95. 吳慧君，2016，〈「路過縣府找縣長禁媒條例再送核備」會後報導〉，自從六輕來了網頁。Wu, Hui-jun. 2016. “Luguo xianfu zhao xianzhang, jinmei tiaoli zai song hebei huihou baodao” [Activity Report of Requiring County Chief to Resubmit Caol Restrictions].in http://fpccgoaway.blogspot.com/2016/12/blog-post.html. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  96. 呂欣怡, Hsin-yi(2016)。解析俗民環境論述。科技、醫療與社會，22，63-108。
  97. 房慧真, Hui chen,何榮幸, Rong-hsing,林雨佑, Yu-yo,蔣宜婷, I-ting(2019).煙囪之島：我們與石化共存的兩萬個日子.臺北=Taipei:春山=SpringHill Publishing.
  98. 洪敏隆，2017，〈從英文教師蛻變為台塑頭痛對手許立儀說從頭〉，蘋果新聞網網頁，https://tw.appledaily.convflife/20170713/H3GH30LLENZA4KYQE7DTSHGI4E/，2021/03/21。Hung, Min-long. 2017. “Cong yinwen jiaoshi tuibianwei taisu touting duishou Hsu LiYi shuo cong tou” [Becoming a Real Headache for Formosa Plastics Corporation from an English Teacher Hsu, LiYi Tells the Story from the Very Beginning]. in https://tw.appledaily.com/life/20170713/H3GH3OLLENZA4KYQE7DTSHGI4E/. Latest update 21 March 2021.
  99. 范玫芳, Mei-feng(2014)。風險管制與程序正義：風力發電機設置爭議。民主與治理，1(2)，59-81。
  100. 高雄後勁中油遷廠促進會，2016a，〈中油一再失信後勁人反抗到底！〉，高雄後勁中油遷廠促進會網頁，http://hjf2015.blogspot.tw/2016/01/blog-post.html，2020/07/02。Association of Urging Relocation of Houjin CPC Refinery Plant. 2016b. “Zhongyou sandu shuoming youcao qianyi zhuangkuang, rengwei tichu juti guihua” [CPC Coporation Talked About Oil Tank Relocation for the Third Time but Have Not Yet Provided Specific Plan]. in http://hjf2015.blogspot.tw/2016/01/blog-post_21.html. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  101. 高雄後勁中油遷廠促進會，2016b，〈中油三度說明油槽遷移狀況，仍未提出具體規劃〉，高雄後勁中油遷廠促進會網頁，http://hjf2015.blogspot.tw/2016/01/blog-post.html，2020/07/02。Association of Urging Relocation of Houjin CPC Refinery Plant. 2016a. “Zhongyou yizai shixin, houjin ren fankang daodi” [CPC Corporation Failed to Keep Promise, Houjin Residents Resisted to the End]. in http://hjf2015.blogspot.tw/2016/01/blog-post.html. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  102. 陳玉宰, Yu-chu,楊國禎, Guo-chen(2014).環保神明大進擊—後勁反五輕世紀終戰前夕.臺北=Taipei:前衛出版社=Avanguard Publishing House.
  103. 陳佳珣，2013，〈被遺忘的臺西村〉，我們的島網頁，https://ourisland.pts.org. tw/content/1014，2021/03/21。Chen, Jia-hsun. 2013. “Bei yiwang de taixi cun” [The Forgotten Taishi Village]. in https://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/1014. Latest update 21 March, 2021.
  104. 陳冠備，2016，〈 反六輕空污彰化縣臺西村民用行動表演 〉，《 自由時報 》 網頁，http://news.ltn.com.tw/news/local/paper/962737，2020/07/02。 Chen, Guan-bei. 2016. “Fan liuqing kongwu changhuaxian taixi cunmin yong xingdong biaoyan” [Residents of Taixi Villiage, Changhua County Presented an Action Drama for Anti-No. 6 Naphtha Cracking Complex of Formosa Plastic Corporation]. in http://news.ltn.com.tw/news/local/paper/962737. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  105. 陳朝福，2015，〈中油高雄後勁關廠了結反五輕環保糾葛〉，《中央通訊社》網頁，http://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201510290275-1.aspx，2020/07/02。Chen, Chao-fu. 2015. “Zhongyou Gaoxiong houjin guanchang, liaojie fanwuqing huanbao jiuge” [CPC Coporation Kaohsiung Plant Closed Ending Environmental Protection Movement Against Fifth Kaohsiung Refinery]. in http://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201510290275-1.aspx. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  106. 彭杏珠，2016，〈村民卑微祈求：拜託，癌症別找上我！〉，遠見 35 網頁 ，https://www.gvm.com.tw/article/21377，2021/03/21。Peng, Hsing-chu. 2016. “Cunmin beiwei qiqiu: baituo, aizheng bie zhaoshang wo!” [Villagers’ Humble Request: Please Don’t let Me Get Cancer]. in https://www.gvm.com.tw/article/21377. Latest update 21 March 2021.
  107. 華視新聞雜誌，2020 ，〈後勁悲歌不可承受之「輕」：全台最大污染場址〉，《華視》網頁，https://news.cts.com.tw/cts/society/202004/202004201997765.html，2020/03/27。CTS News Magazine. 2020. “Houjin beige buke chengshou zhi ‘qing’: quantai zuida wuran changzhi” [The Sad Song of Houjin and The Unbearable of Lightness: The Biggest Pollution Site in Taiwan.] in https://news.cts.com.tw/cts/society/202004/202004201997765.html. Latest update 27 March, 2021.
  108. 黃之棟, Chih-tung,黃瑞祺,Ruey-chyi(2009)。正義的本土化—台灣對歐美環境正義理論的繼受及其所面臨之困難。應用倫理評論，46，17-50。
  109. 黃旭磊，2015，〈 中油高雄廠地下水驗出高濃度殘油 〉，《 自由時報 》 網頁，https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/1495657，2020/03/27。Huang, Hsu-lei. 2015. “Zhongyou gaohsiung dixiashui yanchu gaonongdu canyou” [Underground Water of CPC Corporation Kaohsiung Plant was Tested high concentration of residual oil]. in https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/1495657. Latest update 27 March 2021.
  110. 葉浩, Hao(2003)。環境治理與回溯正義—以南台灣「安順廠」個案為例。哈爾濱工業大學學報，15(6)，134-140。
  111. 賴品瑀，2015 ，〈南風灌毒彰化大城居民重金屬含量高過麥寮〉， 《 環境資訊中心電子報》網頁，http://e-info.org.tw/node/106578，2020/07/02。Lai, Pin-yu. 2015. “Nanfeng guandu changhua dacheng jumin zhongjinshu hanliang gaoguo mailiao” [The South Wind Brought Toxic Elements, Residents’ blood levels of Heavy Metals in Dacheng Changhua Higher than Residents’ in Miliao]. in http://e-info.org.tw/node/106578. Latest update 2 July 2020.
  112. 環境資訊中心，2015 ，〈中油收回後勁 15 億回饋基金會叫苦〉，環境資訊中心網頁，https://e-info.org.tw/node/110708，2020/07/02。Environmental Information Center. 2015. “Zhongyou huishou houjin 15yi huikui jijinhui jiaoku” [CPC Corporation withdraw 15 billion good-neighbour fund, the foundation complains about it]. in https://e-info.org.tw/node/110708. Latest update 2 July 2020.
被引用次数
  1. (2023)。環境法案如何進入政策議程？如何獲得立法通過？《溫室氣體減量及管理法》的個案分析（2006～2015）。政治學報，76，111-144。
print cancel