馬克思（及恩格斯）的烏托邦社會主義批判：作爲一種政治哲學方法

Marx's (and Engel's) Critiques of Utopian Socialism: As a Method of Political Philosophy

10.6166/TJPS.202209_(93).0001

鄭楷立(Kai-li Cheng)

卡爾馬克思 ； 烏托邦社會主義 ； 政治哲學方法論 ； 政治道德主義 ； 實踐依賴的原則 ； Utopian Socialism ； Methodology of Political Philosophy ； Karl Marx ； Political Moralism ； Practice-dependent Principles

政治科學論叢

93期（2022 / 09 / 01）

1 - 43

繁體中文;英文

本文由馬克思（Karl Marx, 1818-1883）及恩格斯（Friedrich Engels, 1820-1895）對「烏托邦社會主義」（utopian socialism）的批判來形塑一個「馬克思式」（Marxian）的政治哲學方法論，亦即，馬克思或是馬克思主義者們所應該偏好的形塑規範性政治哲學的方式。本文分爲兩個部分，第一個部分說明並釐清馬克思（及恩格斯）對烏托邦社會主義的批判是什麼，第二部分將他們的烏托邦社會主義批判作爲一個重要指標來定位馬克思式政治哲學的立場，並且在當代政治哲學方法論中的四個主要概念區分裡，說明為什麼這個批判可以被理解為偏好某種規範性政治哲學的方法。據此，當我們將馬恩的烏托邦社會主義批判置於當代政治哲學方法論的四組概念之中時，我們可以概要地得出馬克思式政治哲學的立場。

This paper adopts Karl Marx (1818-1883) and Friedrich Engels's (1820-1895) critiques of utopian socialism to formulate a Marxian normative political philosophy; that is, the way that Marx or Marxists should have preferred to engage normative political philosophy. This paper, therefore, is divided into two major parts: the first part explains and clarifies what Marx and Engels's critiques of utopian socialism are, and the second part takes their critiques of utopian socialism as a critical reference point to define Marxian political philosophy. After introducing the four main conceptual distinctions in the analytical tradition of the methodology of contemporary political philosophy, I explain why their critiques can be understood as having preferences for certain positions toward the methodology of normative political philosophy. Accordingly, when we locate the Marxian critique of utopian socialism within the four conceptual distinctions, we are able to outline the methodology of Marxian political philosophy.

1. Alexander, Peter(ed.),Gill, Roger(ed.)(1984).Utopias.London:Duckworth.
2. Avineri, S.(1973).Marx’s Vision of Future Society and the Problem of Utopianism.Dissent,20(3),323-331.
3. Carver, Terrel(ed.)(1991).The Cambridge Companion to Marx.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
4. Chiappero-Martinetti(ed.),Osmani, S.(ed.),Qizilbash, M.(ed.)(2020).Cambridge Handbook of the Capability Approach.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
5. Claeys, G.(2018).Marx and Marxism.London:Pelican.
6. Claeys, Gregory(ed.)(2010).The Cambridge Companion to Utopian Literature.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
7. Cohen, G. A.(2001).If You’re an Egalitarian, How Come You’re so Rich?.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
8. Cohen, G. A.(2008).Rescuing Justice and Equality.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
9. Cohen, G. A.(1995).Self-ownership, Freedom, and Equality.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
10. Cohen, G. A.(2011).On the Currency of Egalitarian Justice, and Other Essays in Political Philosophy.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
11. Collier, A.(2004).Marx.Oxford:Oneworld Publications.
12. Cunliffe, J.,Reeve, A.(1996).Exploitation: The Original Saint Simonian Account.Capital & Class,20(2),61-80.
13. Estlund, D.(2011).Human Nature and The Limits (If Any) of Political Philosophy.Philosophy & Public Affairs,39(3),207-237.
14. Estlund, David(ed.)(2012).The Oxford Handbook of Political Philosophy.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
15. Fareld, Victoria(ed.),Kuch, Hannes(ed.)(2019).From Marx to Hegel and Back.London:Bloomsbury.
16. Farrelly, C.(2007).Justice in Ideal Theory: A Refutation.Political Studies,55(4),844-864.
17. Fourier, Carina(ed.),Schuppert, Fabian(ed.),Wallimann-Helmer, Ivo(ed.)(2015).Social Equality: On What it Means to be Equals.New York:Oxford University Press.
18. Galston, W.(2010).Realism in Political Theory.European Journal of Political Theory,9(4),385-411.
19. Geoghegan, V.(1987).Utopianism and Marxism.London:Methuen & Co..
20. Geuss, R.(2008).Philosophy and Real Politics.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
21. Hawthorn, Geoffrey(ed.)(2005).In the Beginning Was the Deed.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
22. Hudis, P.(2013).Marx’s Concept of the Alternatives to Capitalism.Leiden:Brill.
23. Kumar, K.(1991).Utopianism.Buckingham:Open University Press.
24. Lawrence & Wishart. 2022. “Marx and Engels Collected Works.” in https://lwbooks.co.uk/marx-engels-collected-works/read-and-search-online. Latest update 31 October 2021.
25. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1989).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
26. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1990).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
27. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1975).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
28. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1982).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
29. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1998).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
30. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1976).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
31. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1991).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
32. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1988).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
33. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1992).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
34. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1975).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
35. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1976).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
36. Lawrence & Wishart(ed.)(1986).Marx and Engels Collected Works.London:Lawrence & Wishart.
37. Leopold, D.(2015).Marx, Engels and Other Socialisms.The Cambridge Companion to the Communist Manifesto,Cambridge:
38. Leopold, D.(2016).On Marxian Utopophobia.Journal of the History of Philosophy,54(1),111-134.
39. Leopold, D.(2012).‘Socialist Turnips’: The Young Friedrich Engels and the Feasibility of Communism.Political Theory,40(3),347-378.
40. Leopold, D.(2005).The Structure of Marx and Engels’ Considered Account of Utopian Socialism.History of Political Thought,26(3),443-466.
41. Leopold, D.(2007).Socialism and (the Rejection of) Utopia.Journal of Political Ideologies,12(3),219-237.
42. Levitas, R.(2011).The Concept of Utopia.Oxford:Peter Lang Ltd.
43. Lovell, D. W.(1992).Socialism, Utopianism and the ‘Utopian Socialists’.History of European Ideas,14(2),185-201.
44. Mander, William(ed.)(2014).Oxford Handbook of Nineteen-Century British Philosophy.Oxford:University of Oxford.
45. Marx, K.(2017).Later Political Writings.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
46. Marx, K.(2019).The Political Writings.London:Verso.
47. Marx、 K.,Engels, F.,孫善豪（譯）, Shan-hao(Trans.)(2016).德意志意識型態Ｉ.費爾巴哈原始手稿.臺北=Taipei:聯經出版社=Lianjing publishing.
48. Mills, C. W.(2005).‘Ideal Theory’ as Ideology.Hypatia,20(3),165-183.
49. O’Neill, O.(2009).Applied Ethics: Naturalism, Normativity and Public Policy.Journal of Applied Philosophy,26(3),219-230.
50. Ollman, B.(1977).Marx’s Vision of Communism: A Reconstruction.Critique: Journal of Socialist Theory,8(1),4-41.
51. Paden, R.(2002).Marx’s Critique of the Utopian Socialists.Utopian Studies,13(2),67-91.
52. Pojman, L. P.,Fieser, J.(2012).Ethics: Discovering Right and Wrong.Boston:Wadsworth.
53. Porter, Theodore M.(ed.),Ross, Dorothy(ed.)(2008).The Cambridge History of Science.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
54. Rawls, J.(1999).A Theory of Justice: Revisited Edition.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
55. Rawls, J.(1999).The Law of Peoples.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
56. Rawls, J.(2001).Justice as Fairness: A Restatement.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
57. Sangiovanni, A.(2007).Global Justice, Reciprocity, and the State.Philosophy & Public Affairs,35(1),3-39.
58. Sangiovanni, A.(2008).Justice and the Priority of Politics to Morality.Journal of Political Philosophy,16(2),137-164.
59. Sargent, L. T.(1994).The Three Faces of Utopianism Revisited.Utopian Studies,5(1),1-37.
60. Schrift, Alan D.(ed.)(2010).The History of Continent Philosophy.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
61. Sen, A.(2009).The Idea of Justice.London:Penguin.
62. Simmons, J. A.(2010).Ideal and Nonideal Theory.Philosophy & Public Affairs,38(1),5-36.
63. Sleat, Matt(ed.)(2018).Politics Recovered: Realist Thought in Theory and Practice.New York:Columbia University Press.
64. Smith, P. B.(2009).Reflections on Aspects of Marxist Anti-Utopianism.Critique,37(1),99-120.
65. Stemplowska, Z.(2008).What’s Ideal About Ideal Theory?.Social Theory and Practice,34(3),319-340.
66. Stemplowska, Z.(2017).Nonideal Theory.A Companion to Applied Philosophy,Chichester:
67. Swift, A.(2008).The Value of Philosophy in Nonideal Circumstances.Social Theory and Practice,34(3),363-387.
68. Valentini, L.(2012).Ideal vs. Non-ideal Theory: A Conceptual Map.Philosophy Compass,7(9),654-664.
69. Webb, D.(2000).Marx, Marxism and Utopia.England:Ashgate Publishing Company.
70. Yassour, A.(1983).Communism and Utopia: Marx, Engels and Fourier.Studies in Soviet Thought,26(3),217-227.
71. 孫善豪, Shan-hao(2009)。批判與辯證：馬克思主義政治哲學論文集，臺北=Taipei:
72. 萬毓澤，2021，〈馬克思主義（上）：古典及其基礎〉，《華文哲學百科》網頁，http://mephilosophy.ccu.edu.tw/entry.php?entry_name=馬克思主義（上）：古典及其基礎，2022/5/4。Wan, Yu-ze. 2021. “Makesizhuyi shang: gudian jiqi jichu” [Marxism (Volume 1 of 3): Classical Foundations]. in http://mephilosophy.ccu.edu.tw/entry.php?entry_name=馬克思主義（上）：古典及其基礎。Latest update 14 November 2021.
73. 萬毓澤, Yu-ze(2018).資本論完全使用手冊：版本、系譜、爭議與當代價值.臺北=Taipei:聯經出版社=Lianjing publishing.
74. 蕭高彥, Gao-yan(2020).探索政治現代性：從馬基維利到嚴復.臺北=Taipei:聯經出版社=Lianjing publishing.