哈特向的地理學方法論研究：回顧與審視

Hartshorne's Research on the Geographical Methodology: Retrospect and Examination

10.6234/JGR.2008.49.03

池永歆(Yeong-Shin Chyr)

哈特向 ； 地理學的性質 ； 赫特納 ； 紹爾 ； 地理學的方法論 ； Hartshorne ； "The Nature of Geography" ； Hettner ； Sauer ； geographical methodology

地理研究

49期（2008 / 11 / 01）

41 - 60

繁體中文

哈特向的《地理學的性質》與其它方法論著作，在很大的程度上，係為反駁紹爾柏克萊學派的觀點而撰述。哈特向主要以赫特納的地理學觀點，作為其方法論的立論依據。由本研究可看出：他係以改編的方式，而再現赫特納的觀點；其首要目的在於想經由德國地理學知性傳統的採納，確立地理學的學科屬性，而鞏固地理學在美國學術中的地位。哈特向於《地理學的性質》所採取的論述方式，即以地理學者曾說過什麼，而歸納這些主張的表面意義，實忽視這作法本身，絕無法展現他所欲達成之地理學的性質或本質的闡明；亦即，本研究認為有關於此課題討論，須由地理學的存在論基礎的確認，方能闡釋地理學科的性質。

Richard Hartshorne's ”The Nature of Geography” and his other works of geographical methodology were mostly designed as a response to the tradition of Carl Sauer's Berkeley School. Hartshorne primarily took Hettner's system of geography as a model to establish his methodological framework. But as this article shows, Hartshorne adapted Hettner's viewpoint for his own end, and by this to lay the foundation for the discipline of geography among the sciences in America.In this article it also suggests that the understanding of geography's ontology is the key to illuminate the nature of geography, rather than what Hartshorne has done in his methodological research.

1. Brunn, S. D.,Entrikin, J. N.(eds.),S. D. Brunn(eds.)(1989).Reflection on Richard Hartshorne's The Nature of Geography.Washington:the Association of American Geographers.
2. Butzer, Karl W.,Entrikin, J. N.(eds.),S. D. Brunn(eds.)(1989).Reflection on Richard Hartshorne's The Nature of Geography.Washington:the Association of American Geographers.
3. Duncan, James S.(1980).The superorganic in American cultural geography.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,70(2),181-198.
4. Gregory, D.,R. J. Johnston(eds.)(2000).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Blackwell Publishers Ltd..
5. Gregory, D.,R. J. Johnston(eds.)(2000).The Dictionary of Human Geogrophy.Oxford:Blackwell Publishers Ltd..
6. Haggett, P.,R. J. Johnston(eds.)(1994).The Dictionary of Human Geography.Oxford:Blackwell Publishers Ltd..
7. Hartshorne, Richard(1958).The concept of geography no a science, from Kant and Humboldt to Hatter.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,48(2),97-108.
8. Hartshorne, Richard(1935).Recant developments in political geography I.American Political Science Review,29(5),785-804.
9. Hartshorne, Richard(1976).The Nature of Geography: A Critical Survey of Current Thought in the Light of the Pats.Pennsylvania:the Association Lancaster.
10. Hartshorne, Richard(1948).On the mores of methodological discussion in American geographer.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,38(2),113-125.
11. Hartshorne, Richard(1979).Notes toward a bibliobiography of the Nature of Geography.Annals of the Association of American Geographers, Special Issue: Seventy-Five Years of American Geography,69(1),63-76.
12. Harvey, F.,Wardenga, U.(1998).The Hettner-Hartshorne connection: reconsidering the process of reception and transformation of a geographic concept.Finisterra,33(65),131-140.
13. Harvey, F.,Wardenga, U.(2003).Richard Hartshorne's adaptation of Alfred Hettner's system of Geography.Journal of Historical Geography,32(2),422-440.
14. Johnston, R. J.,Sidaway, J. D.(2004).Geography and Geographers: Anglo-American Human Geography since 1945.London:Hodder Arnold.
15. Kant. I.,J. A. May(trans.)(1970).Kant's Concept of Geography and its Relation to recent Geographical Thought.Toronto:University of Toronto Press.
16. Lukermann, Fred,Entrikin, J. N.(eds.),S. D. Brunn(eds.)(1989).Reflection on Richard Hartshorne's The Nature of Geography.Washington:the Association of American Geographers.
17. Martin, Geoffrey J.(1994).In memoriam: Richard Hartshorne 1899-1992.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,84(3),480-492.
18. Martin, Geoffrey J.,Preston E. James(1993).All Possible World: A History of Geographical Ideas.New York:John Wiley & Sons, INC..
19. Sauer, Carl O.(1941).Foreword to Historical Geography.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,31(1),1-24.
20. Sauer, Carl O.,J. Leighly(ed.)(1967).Land and Life: A Selection from the Writings of Carl Ortwin Sauer.Berkeley and Los Angeles:University of California Press.
21. Schaefer, Fred K.(1953).Exceptionalism in geography: A Methodological Examination.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,43(3),226-249.
22. 哈特向、黎樵譯(1997)。地理學性質的透視。北京:商務印書館。
23. 海德格、陳嘉映合譯、王慶節合譯(2000)。存在與時間（修訂譯本）。北京:三聯書店。
24. 赫特納、王蘭生譯(1997)。地理學：它的歷史、性質和方法。北京:商務印書館。