题名

食物沙漠回顧與臺灣個案初探：臺北市生鮮食物可及性的空間分析

并列篇名

A Review on Food Deserts and a Case Study in Taiwan: Spatial Analysis of Fresh Food Accessibility in Taipei City

DOI

10.6234/JGR.201911_(71).0001

作者

郭乃文(Nae-Wen Kuo)；李崇恩(Chong-En Li)

关键词

食物沙漠 ； 生鮮食物 ； 可及性 ； 生鮮食物可及性指數（FFAI） ； 空間分析 ； food desert ； fresh food ； accessibility ； fresh food accessibility index (FFAI) ； spatial analysis

期刊名称

地理研究

卷期/出版年月

71期（2019 / 11 / 01）

页次

1 - 24

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

「食物沙漠」一詞是指居民無法購買或負擔不起生鮮食物的地區，往往會對弱勢族群帶來生理與心理上的負面影響，是社會排斥的一種方式，引起包括歐美、日本等已開發國家重視，然而臺灣這方面的論文卻不多，因此本文提出食物沙漠問題的回顧，並以臺北市為例進行食物沙漠初探。本研究分別繪製生鮮食物可及性地圖，以及依照人口年齡結構加權而成的生鮮食物可及性指數（FFAI）地圖，發現臺北市生鮮食物可及性低落的地區出現在陽明山區、南港山區、文山山區、洲美地區、社子島、關渡平原、都市內部零星地區等，其中後三個地方特別需要政府關注，因為那裡相較於山區來說人口更多，且導致士林區與北投區有約一成的人口居住在FFAI = 0（即1,000公尺以內都沒有生鮮食物商店）的環境中；另一方面，獨居老人高度聚居在食物綠洲所在的萬華區，他們卻普遍具有營養條件不良的特質，這應可歸因於其他因素，亟需後續研究深入探討。
英文摘要

The term ＂food desert＂ refers to areas where residents cannot buy or afford fresh food. It often brings negative physical and psychological impacts on disadvantaged residents. It is a way of social exclusion, which has been widely examined in developed countries including cases in Europe, North America and Japan. However, there are not many papers discussing this problem in Taiwan. Therefore, we proposed a review of the food desert issue, and take Taipei City as research area to analyze the urban food system in Taiwan. We drew a map of fresh food accessibility and a map of a fresh food accessibility index (FFAI) which were weighted according to the age structure of the population. It is found that the areas with low food accessibility in Taipei appear to be in Yangming Mountain, Nangang Mountain, Wenshan Mountain, Zhoumei Area, Shezi Island, Guandu Plain, and sporadic areas within the city, etc. The latter three places especially require government attention, because the population size is larger than the mountainous areas, and about 10% of the population in Shilin and Beitou District live with a situation of FFAI = 0 (that is, there is no fresh food store within 1,000 meters). On the other hand, elderly living alone concentrate in Wanhua District, which is considered to be a ＂food oasis＂ area, but they generally have poor nutritional conditions. This is due to other factors, and further research is urgently needed.
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
参考文献
  1. Algert, S.J.,Agrawal, A.,Lewis, D. S.(2006).Disparities in access to fresh produce in low-income neighborhoods in Los Angeles.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,30(5),365-370.
  2. Alwitt, L. F.,Donley, T. D.(1997).Retail stores in poor urban neighborhoods.The Journal of Consumer Affairs,31(1),139-164.
  3. An, R.,Sturm, R.(2012).School and residential neighborhood food environment and diet among California youth.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,42(2),129-135.
  4. Apparicio, P.,Abdelmajid, M.,Riva, M.,Shearmur, R.(2008).Comparing alternative approaches to measuring the geographical accessibility of urban health services.International Journal of Health Geographics,7,7.
  5. Apparicio, P.,Cloutier, M.,Shearmur, R.(2007).The case of Montreal's missing food deserts: Evaluation of accessibility to food supermarkets.International Journal of Health Geographics,6,4.
  6. Beaulac, J.,Kristjansson, E.,Cummins, S.(2009).A systematic review of food deserts: 1966-2007.Prev. Chronic Dis.,6,1-10.
  7. Beaumont, J.,Lang, T.,Leather, S.,Mucklow, C.(1995).,Watford:Institute of Grocery Distribution.
  8. Blanchard, T.,Lyson, T.(2002).Access to low cost groceries in nonmetropolitan counties: Large retailers and the creation of food deserts.Measuring Rural Diversity Conference Proceedings
  9. Block, D.,Kouba, J.(2006).A comparison of the availability and affordability of amarket basket in two communities in the Chicago Area.Public Health Nutrition,9(7),837-845.
  10. Block, J.P.,Scribner, R.A.,DeSalvo, K.B.(2004).Fast food, race/ethnicity, and income.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,27(3),211-217.
  11. The Inextricable Connection Between Food Insecurity and Diabetes
  12. Chen, Y.,Rennie, D.C.,Dosman, J.A.(2009).Changing prevalence of obesity in arural community between 1977 and 2003: a multiple cross-sectional study.Public Health,123(1),15-19.
  13. Chung, C.,Myers, S.L.(1999).Do the poor pay more for food? An analysis of grocery store availability and food price Disparities.The Journal of Consumer Affairs,33(2),276-296.
  14. Cooksey-Stowers, K.,Schwartz, M. B.,Brownell, K.D.(2017).Food Swamps Predict Obesity Rates Better Than Food Deserts in the United States.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,14(11),1366.
  15. Cotterill, R.W.,Franklin, A.W.(1995).,University of Connecticut, Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Charles J. Zwick Center for Food and Resource Policy.
  16. Coveney, J.,O’Dwyer, L.A.(2009).Effects of mobility and location on food access.Health and place,15(1),45-55.
  17. Cummins, S.,Flint, E.,Matthews, S.A.(2014).New Neighborhood Grocery Store Increased Awareness of Food Access But Did Not Alter Dietary Habits or Obesity.Health Affairs (Project Hope),33(2),283-291.
  18. Cummins, S.,Macintyre, S.(2002).The price and availability of food in Glasgow: a systematic study of an urban foodscape.Urban Studies,39(11),2115-2130.
  19. Cummins, S.,Macintyre, S.(1999).The location of food stores in urban areas: a case study in Glasgow.British Food Journal,101,545-553.
  20. Cummins, S.,Macintyre, S.(2002)."Food deserts"-evidence and assumption in health policy Making.British Medical Journal,325(7361),436-438.
  21. Curry, A.(2009).Bringing Healthy Fare to Big-City "Food Deserts".Diabetes Forecast,December
  22. Cushon, J.,Creighton, T.,Kershaw, T.,Marko, J.,Markham, T.(2013).Deprivation and food access and balance in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.Chronic Diseases and Injuries in Canada,33,146-159.
  23. Drewnowski, A.(2003).Fat and sugar: An economic analysis.Journal of Nutrition,133,838-840.
  24. Drewnowski, A.,Darmon, N.(2005).The economics of obesity: Dietary energy density and energy cost.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,82,265-273.
  25. Drewnowski, A.,Specter, S.E.(2004).Poverty and obesity: the role of energy density and energy costs.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,79(1),6-16.
  26. Ford, P. B.,Dzewaltowski, D.A.(2008).Disparities in obesity prevalence due to variation in the retail food environment: three testable hypotheses.Nutrition Reviews,66(4),216-228.
  27. Freedman, D.A.(2009).Local food environments: they’re all stocked differently.American Journal of Community Psychology,44(3-4),382-393.
  28. Freedman, D.A.,Bell, B.A.(2009).Access to healthful foods among an urban food insecure population: perceptions versus reality.Journal of Urban Health,86(6),825-838.
  29. Friedrich, M.J.(2000).Poor children subject to "environmental injustice".Medical News and Perspectives,283(23),3057-3058.
  30. Furey, S.,Strugnell, C.,McIlveen, H.(2001).An investigation of the potential existence of "Food Deserts" in rural and urban areas of Northern Ireland.Agriculture and Human Values,18,447-457.
  31. Garasky, S.,Morton, L. W.,Greder, K.(2004).The food environment and food in security: perception sofrural, suburban, and urban food pantry clients in Iowa.Family Economics and Nutrition Review,16(2),41-48.
  32. Giang, T.,Karpyn, A.,Laurison, H.B.,Hillier, A.,Perry, R.D.(2008).Closing the grocerygap in underserved communities: the creation of the Pennsylvania fresh food financing initiative.Journal of Public Health Management and Practice,14(3),272-279.
  33. Glanz, K.,Sallis, J.F.,Saelens, B.E.,Frank, L.D.(2007).Nutrition environment measures survey in stores (NEMS-S).American Journal of Preventive Medicine,32(4),282-289.
  34. Gould, A.,Apparicio, P.,Cloutier, M.(2012).Classifying neighbourhoods by level of access to stores selling fresh fruit and vegetables and groceries: Identifying problematic areas in the city of Gatineau, Quebec.Canadian Journal of Public Health,103,433-437.
  35. Helbich, M.,Schadenberg, B.,Hagenauer, J.,Poelman, M.(2017).Food deserts? Healthy food access in Amsterdam.Applied Geography,83,1-12.
  36. Hendrickson, D.,Smith, C.,Eikenberry, N.(2006).Fruit and vegetable access in fourlow-income food deserts communities in Minnesota.Agriculture and Human Values,23,371-383.
  37. Inagami, S.,Cohen, D.A.,Finch, B.K.,Asch, S.M.(2006).You are where you shop: grocery store locations, weight, and neighborhoods.American journal of preventive medicine,31(1),10-17.
  38. Ismailov, R.M.,Leatherdale, S.T.(2010).Rural-urban differences in overweight and obesity among a large sample of adolescents in Ontario.International Journal of Pediatric Obesity,5,351-360.
  39. Jehoel-Gijsbers, G.,Vrooman, C.(2007).Explaining social exclusion: A theoretical model tested in the Netherlands.The Hague:The Netherlands Institute for Social Research/scp.
  40. Kaufman, P. R.,MacDonald, J. M.,Lutz, S. M.,Smallwood, D. M.(1997).Do the poor pay more for food? Item selection and price differences affect low-income household food costs. Food and Rural Economics Division. Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture.Agricultural Economic Report,759,1795-1799.
  41. Kaufman, P.R.(1999).Rural poor have less access to supermarkets, large grocery stores.Rural Development Perspectives,13(3),19-25.
  42. Kirkup, M.,Kervenoael, R.,Hallsworth, A.,Clarke, I.,Jackson, P.,Aguila, R.(2004).Inequalities in retail choice: exploring consumer experiences in suburban neighbourhoods.International Journal of Retailing and Distribution Management,32(11),511-522.
  43. Lake, A.,Townshend, T.(2006).Obesogenic environments: exploring the built and food environments.Journal of the Royal Society of Health,126(6),262-267.
  44. Larson, N. I.,Story, M. T.,Nelson, M. C.(2009).Neighborhood environments: Disparities in access to healthy foods in the US.American journal of preventive medicine,36(1),74-81.
  45. Larson, N.,Story, M.(2009).A review of environmental influences on food choices.Annals of Behavioral Medicine,38(suppl_1),s56-s73.
  46. Lewis, L.B.,Sloane, D.C.,Nascimento, L.M.,Diamant, A.L.,Guinyard, J.J.,Yancey, A. K.(2005).African Americans’ access to healthy food options in South Los Angeles restaurants.Research and Practice,95(4),668-673.
  47. Liese, A.D.,Hibbert, J.D.,Ma, X.-G.,Bell, B.A.,Battersby, S.E.(2014).Where are the food deserts? An evaluation of policy-relevant measures of community food access in South Carolina.Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition,9(1),16-32.
  48. Lopez, R.P.(2007).Neighborhood risk factors for obesity.Obesity (Silver Spring),15(8),2111-2119.
  49. Mari Gallagher Research and Consulting Group (July 18, 2006). Examining the Impact of Food Desert s on Public Health in Chicago. Chicago, IL: Available at: http://www.marigallagher.com/projects/
  50. Moore, L.V.,Diez Roux, A.V.(2006).Associations of neighborhood characteristics with the location and type of food stores.American Journal of Public Health,96(2),325-331.
  51. Morland, K.,Wing, S.,Diez Roux, A.V.(2002).The Contextual effect of the local food environment on residents’ diets: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study.American Journal of Public Health,92(11),1761-1767.
  52. Morland, K.,Wing, S.,Diez Roux, A,Poole, C.(2002).Neighborhood characteristics associated with the location of food stores and food service places.American Journal of Preventive Medicine,22(1),23-29.
  53. Morland, L.,Filomena, S.(2007).Disparities in the availability of fruits and vegetables between racially segregated urban neighbourhoods.Public Health Nutrition,10,1481-1489.
  54. Morris, P.M.,Bellinger, M.,Haas, E.(1990).,Washington, DC.:Public Voice for Food and Health Policy.
  55. Morris, P.M.,Neuhauser, L.,Campbell, C.(1992).Food security in rural America: A study of the availability and costs of food.Journal of Nutrition Education,24(1),52-58.
  56. Morton, L.W.,Blanchard, T.C.(2007).Starved for access: life in rural America’s food deserts.Rural Realities,1(4),1-10.
  57. Oliver, L.,Schuurman, N.,Hall, A.(2007).Comparing circular and network buffers to examine the influence of land use on walking for leisure and errands.International Journal of Health Geographic,6,41.
  58. Páez, A.,Scott, D. M.,Catherine, M.(2012).Measuring accessibility: positive and normative implementations of various accessibility indicators.Journal of Transport Geography,25,141-153.
  59. Pearson, T.,Russell, J.,Campbell, M.J.,Barker, M.E.(2005).Do ‘food deserts’ influence fruit and vegetable consumption? -a cross-sectional study.Appetite,45,195-197.
  60. Phillips, A. L.(2011).Making Better Maps of Food Deserts.American Scientist,99(3),209.
  61. Powell, L.M.,Slater, S.,Mirtcheva, D.,Bao, Y.,Chaloupka, F.J.(2007).Food store availability and neighborhood characteristics in the United States.Preventive Medicine,44,189-195.
  62. Raja, S.,Ma, C.,Yadav, P.(2008).Beyond food deserts: measuring and mapping racial disparities in neighborhood food environments.Journal of Planning Education and Research,27,469-482.
  63. Richards, R.,Smith, C.(2007).Environmental, parental, and personal influences on food choice, access, and overweight status among homeless children.Social Science and Medicine,65(8),1572-1583.
  64. Rose, D.,Richards, R.(2004).Food store access and household fruit and vegetable use among participants in the US food stamp program.Public Health Nutrition,7(8),1081-1088.
  65. Sadler, R.C.,Gilliland, J.A.,Arku, G.(2013).A Food Retail-Based Intervention on Food Security and Consumption.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,10(8),3325-3346.
  66. Saito, Y.,Koshigaya, K.,Narita, Y.,Yoshida, K.,Kimura, T.(1986).A study of spastic gait on stroke patient - Comparative study of walking analysis of prae and post operation.The Hokkaido Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology,30,115-120.
  67. Schafft, K.A.,Jensen, E.B.,Hinrichs, C.C.(2009).Food deserts and overweight schoolchildren: evidence from Pennsylvania.Rural Sociology,74(2),153-177.
  68. Shaw, H. J.(2006).Food deserts: towards the development of a classification.Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography,88(2),231-247.
  69. Shaw, H. J.(2003).University of Leeds.
  70. Sims, R. R.,Felton, E. L.(2006).Designing and delivering business ethics teaching and learning.Journal of Business Ethics,63(3),297-312.
  71. Smith, C.,Morton, L.W.(2009).Rural food deserts: low-income perspectives on food access in Minnesota and Iowa.Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior,41(3),176-187.
  72. Sobal, J.,Troiano, R. P.,Frongillo Jr., E.A.(1996).Rural‐Urban Differences in Obesity.Rural Sociology,61(2),289-305.
  73. Swinburn, B.,Caterson, I.,Seidell, J.,James, W.(2004).Diet, nutrition and the preventionof excess weight gain and obesity.Public Health Nutrition,7(1A),123-146.
  74. Trivedi, M.(2011).Regional and Categorical Patterns in Consumer Behavior: Revealing Trends.Journal of Retailing,87(1),18-30.
  75. Veenema, T.G.(2001).Children’s exposure to community violence.Journal of Nursing Scholarship,33(2),167-173.
  76. Ver Ploeg, M.(Ed.)(2009).,Diane Publishing.
  77. Walker, R. E.,Keane, C. R.,Burke, J.G.(2010).Disparities and access to healthy food in the United States: A review of food deserts literature.Health Place,16(5),876-884.
  78. Wrigley, N.,Warm, D.,Margetts, B.(2003).Deprivation, diet, and food-retail access: findings from the Leeds 'food deserts' study.Environment Plant A,35(1),151-188.
  79. Yuran, C.,Tsutomu, S.(2013).Food deserts, activity patterns, and social exclusion: The case of Tokyo, Japan.Applied geography,43,87-98.
  80. Zenk, S.N.,Schulz, A.J.,Israel, B.A.,James, S.A.,Bao, S.,Wilson, M.L.(2005).Neighborhood racial composition, neighborhood poverty, and the spatial accessibility of supermarkets in Metropolitan Detroit.American Journal of Public Health,95(4),660-667.
  81. 岩間信之(2017)。都市のフードデザート問題。東京都=Tokyo Metropolis:農林統計協会=Agriculture and Forestry Statistics Association。
  82. 郭景珣, G.H.(2013)。臺北市=Taipei City，國立臺灣師範大學地理學系=Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University。
  83. 農林水産政策研究所（2015）。食料品アクセスマップ。取自 http://www.maff.go.jp/primaff/seika/fsc/faccess/a_map.html。【Policy Research Institute, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (2015). Food desert access map. Retrieved from http://www.maff.go.jp/primaff/seika/fsc/faccess/a_map.html】
  84. 蔡宗達, Z.D.,廖麗娜, L.N.,李佳霙, J.Y.,李采娟, C.J.,王英偉, Y.W.,黃惠煐, H.Y.,林正介, Z.J.(2017)。臺灣高齡者人口學及食物可獲性影響因素與飲食行為的相關。臺灣老年醫學暨老年學雜誌，12(4)，257-273。
被引用次数
  1. 彭以安,吳幸玲(2022)。臺中市弱勢人口公共運輸服務缺口分析。運輸學刊，34(2)，153-182。
  2. (2024)。從移動性到可及性：偏鄉需求反應式服務場所的概念建構。都市與計劃，51(2)，162-187。
print cancel