题名

《清華(伍).命訓》校詁與詮釋-以「大命小命互動互成」、十二字訣、「權不法、中不忠」為觀測標的

并列篇名

Research" Study on the Exegesis and Interpretation of 'Ming Xun' Colleted from Qing Hua Chu Bamboo Slips Vol.5-from The Perspective of "Da Ming and Xiao Ming Work as a System Structure", Twelve Secrets", and "Quan Bu Fa, Zhong Bu Zhong"

DOI

10.6239/BOC.202212_(72).01

作者

黃麗娟(HUANG, LI-JUAN)

关键词

清華簡(伍) ; 命訓 ; 逸周書 ; 大命 ; 小命 ; 權不法 ; 中不忠 ; Qing Hua Chu Bamboo Slips Vol.5 ; Ming Xun ; Yi Chou Shu ; Da Ming ; Xiao Ming ; Quan Bu Fa ; Zhong Bu Zhong

期刊名称

國文學報

卷期/出版年月

72期(2022 / 12 / 01)

页次

1 - 34

内容语文

繁體中文;英文

中文摘要

〈命訓〉是《清華簡(伍)》中《尚書》類篇章三篇之一,簡文內容與傳世《逸周書.命訓》大致相合,整理者謂「當係〈命訓〉篇的戰國寫本」。〈命訓〉首段揭示「大命有常,小命日成」之旨,提供窺豹「天命論」在東周之季發展的重要參考基礎。本文以「大命小命互作互成」、「權不法、中不忠」為觀測標的,首先分析〈命訓〉首段大命小命之間互動互成的運作體系出發,討論「天-王-民」之間的權力位階關係。其次討論明王如何運用「惠、均、哀、樂、禮、藝、政、事、賞、罰、中、權」十二字訣掌理天下人事,論文將由上述十二字訣「正-反-反」第二次反面申訓的行文方式切入討論,將訓詁的重點由字、而詞、而語、而句、而章敷衍開來。分析「臨中」、「行權」的御下方法,辨析「權不法,中不忠」其中原則與工具的內在聯繫。最後再將〈命訓〉的權變概念與先秦儒家孔、孟的權變哲學相互比較,解析諸家側重範圍的不同。

英文摘要

'Ming Xun' is one of three Shang-Shu Related Chapters collected from Qing Hua Chu Bamboo slips Vol.5. The article content is highly similar to handed-down documentary "Yi Zhou Shu" edition. The article interpreter considered slips edition to be the earlier warring states period transcript of handed-down edition. The paragraph reveals the main subject of whole article:There are established rules and standards in Da Ming (大命), While Xiao Ming (小命) can be achieved through daily practice. The contention could be regarded as a perspective to observe the development of fatalism at late period of eastern zhou dynasty. There are three observation targets in this article: the way Da Ming (大命) and Xiao Ming (小命) work as a system structure, the key to belence the political domination with twelve secrets (Hui 惠、Jun 均、Ai 哀、Le 樂、Li 禮、Yi 藝、Zhen 政、Shi 事、Shang 賞、Fa 罰、Zhong 中、Quan權), and the contingency approach on political management. The study would focus on four points of view: First, how Da Ming (大命) and Xiao Ming (小命) can work togother and accomplish the emperor's mission to awake people's consciousness. Second, how too much of a good thing make domination collapse. Third, use Quan (權) to replace Fa (法), use Zhong (中) to replace Zhong (忠). And the other five groups of similar replace collocation. Four, compare the philosophy of contingency approach in 'Ming Xun' with other Pre-Qin period philosophers.

主题分类 人文學 > 中國文學
参考文献
  1. 簡帛論壇 FORUM OF BAMBOO SILK MANUSCRIPTS CENTER OF WU HAN UNIVERSITY:〈清華五《命訓》初讀〉“Qing Hua Vol.5‘Ming Xun’Chu Du”網址:http://www.bsm.org.cn/forum/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3250(最後瀏覽日期:2022.12.10)。
  2. (周)左丘明(傳), QIU-MING,(晉)杜預(注), YU,(唐)孔穎達(疏), YING-DA,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 6 春秋左傳正義.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  3. (周)左丘明, QIU-MING,(吳)韋昭(注), ZHAO(2015).國語.上海=Shanghai:上海古籍出版社=Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House.
  4. (周)左丘明, QIU-MING,楊伯駿(編), BUO-JUN(1981).春秋左傳注.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  5. (周)呂不韋, BU-WEI,許維遹(集釋), WEI-YU,梁運華(整理), YUN-HUA(2009).呂氏春秋集釋.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  6. (周)孟軻, KE,(清)焦循, XUN,沈文倬(點校), WEN-ZHOU(1987).孟子正義.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  7. (周)韓非, FEI,(清)王先慎(集解), XIAN-SHEN,鍾哲(點校), ZHE(1998).韓非子集解.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  8. (漢)公羊壽(傳), SHOU,(漢)何休(解詁), XIU,(唐)徐彥(疏), YAN,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 7 春秋公羊傳注疏.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  9. (漢)孔安國(傳), AN-GUO,(唐)孔穎達(疏), YING-DA,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 1 尚書正義.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  10. (漢)司馬遷, QIAN,(劉宋)裴駰(集解), YIN,(唐)司馬貞(索隱), ZHEN,(唐)張守節(正義), SHOU-JIE(1986).史記.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  11. (漢)許慎, SHEN,(清)段玉裁(注), YU-CAI(1991).說文解字注.臺北=Taipei:黎明文化=Li Ming Cultural Enterprise Co., Ltd..
  12. (漢)鄭玄(傳), XUAN,(唐)孔穎達(疏), YING-DA,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 5 禮記注疏.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  13. (漢)鄭玄(傳), XUAN,(唐)賈公彥(疏), GONG-YAN,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 4 儀禮注疏.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  14. (魏)何晏(注), YAN,(宋)邢昺(疏), BING,(清)阮元(校勘), YUAN(1989).十三經注疏 8論語正義.臺北=Taipei:藝文印書館=Yee Wen Publishing Company.
  15. 宋志英(編), ZHI-YING,晁岳佩(編), YUE-PEI(2015).逸周書研究文獻輯刊.北京=Beijing:國家圖書館出版社=National Library of China Publishing House.
  16. 宋志英(編), ZHI-YING,晁岳佩(編), YUE-PEI(2015).逸周書研究文獻輯刊.北京=Beijing:國家圖書館出版社=National Library of China Publishing House.
  17. 宋志英(編), ZHI-YING,晁岳佩(編), YUE-PEI(2015).逸周書研究文獻輯刊.北京=Beijing:國家圖書館出版社=National Library of China Publishing House.
  18. 夏含夷, EDWARD L.(2016)。清華五《命訓》簡、傳本異文考。古文字研究,北京=Beijing:
  19. 高佑仁, YOU-REN(2018).清華(伍)書類文獻研究.臺北=Taipei:萬卷樓圖書公司=Wan Juan Lou Books Company.
  20. 張純一, CHUN-YI,梁運華(點校), YUN-HUA(2017).晏子春秋校注.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  21. 清華大學出土文獻研究與保護中心(編),李學勤(編), XUE-QIN(2015).清華大學藏戰國竹簡(伍).上海=Shanghai:中西書局=Zhong Xi Book Company.
  22. 程樹德(集釋), SHU-DE,程俊英(點校), JUN-YING,蔣見元(點校), JIAN-YUAN(1962).論語集釋.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhonghua Book Company.
  23. 馮勝君, SHENG-JUN(2018)。清華簡《命訓》釋讀掇瑣(四則)。出土文獻研究,上海=Shanghai:
  24. 黃懷信, HUAI-XIN(2006).逸周書校補注釋.西安=Xian:三秦出版社=San Qin Chu Ban She.
  25. 黃懷信, HUAI-XIN,張懋鎔, MAO-RONG,田旭東, XU-DONG,李學勤(審定), XUE-QIN(1995).逸周書彙校集注.上海=Shanghai:上海古籍出版社=Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House.
  26. 趙平安, PING-AN(2015)。釋清華簡《命訓》中的耕字。深圳大學學報(人文社會科學版),2015(3),34-37。
  27. 劉國忠, GUO-ZHONG(2016)。清華簡《命訓》中的命論補正。中國史研究,2016(1),25-28。
  28. 蔡一峰, YI-FENG(2016)。讀清華簡《命訓》札記三則。簡帛,上海=Shanghai:
  29. 黎翔鳳, XIANG-FENG,梁運華(整理), YUN-HUA(2004).管子校注.北京=Beijing:中華書局=Zhong Hua Book Company.
  30. 鐘舒婷, SHU-TING(2018)。清華簡《命訓》與今本《命訓》異文對比整理。學行堂語言文字論叢,北京=Beijing: