電視媒體與災難管理－災難新聞的倫理困境

Television News Coverage and Disaster Management-The Ethical Difficulties of Disaster Journalism

10.30385/JRTS.200912_(31).0002

林照真(Chao-Chen Lin)

收視率 ； 災難新聞 ； 災難管理 ； 電視 ； 新聞倫理 ； ratings ； disaster journalism ； disaster management ； Television ； news ethics

廣播與電視

31期（2009 / 12 / 01）

55 - 79

繁體中文

本研究關注電視災難新聞報導在收視率的驅動力之下的各種問題，同時亦關注災難新聞報導與災難管理的關聯性。本研究是採取「個案分析」與「深度訪談」的質化調查方法進行研究，並以2008年7月至9月發生的四個颱風，與同年九月間發生的三聚氰胺事件為研究對象，以進一步了解電視媒體如何報導災難新聞。本研究尤其關心災難新聞追逐收視率的現象，並探討在收視率機制下，記者在災難新聞的角色，及其衍生的新聞倫理問題。

The study explores ratings-driven television disaster journalism and other related issues on one side and discusses the relationship between disaster reporting and disaster management on the other. This study uses qualitative research methods such as ”case study” and ”in depth interview”, focuses on the four typhoon disasters occurring between July and September of 2008 and Melamine event happening on September of 2008. This study conducts related analysis affecting the disaster news production system of television in Taiwan. This paper concerns about the reality of ratings-driven disaster reporting and relevant discussions about the role of the journalist and ethics of journalism in disaster reporting.

1. 林照真(2009)。收視率新聞學－台灣電視新聞商品化。台北:聯經出版社。
   連結：
2. Anderson, A.(1997).Media, culture, and the environment.New Brunswick, NJ:Rutgers University Press.
3. Ang, I.(1991).Desperately seeking the audience.NY:Routledge.
4. Burkhart, F. N.(1991).Media, emergency warnings, and citizen response.Colorado:Western Press.
5. Cantrill, J. G.,Oravec, C. L., . In J. 0. Cantrill(Eds.),C. L. Oravec(Eds.)(1996).The symbolic earth: Discourse and our creation of the environment.Lexington:University of Kentucky Press.
6. Coppola, D. P.(2007).Introduction to international disaster management.Amsterdam:Elsevier.
7. Cox, R.(2006).Environmental communication and the public sphere.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
8. Deluca, K. M.(1999).Image politics: The new rhetoric of environmental activism.NY:Guilford Press.
9. Ettema, J. S.(Eds.),Whitney, D. C.(Eds.)(1994).Audiencemaking: How the media create the audience.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
10. Friedman, S. M.,S. Senecah(Ed.)(2004).And the beat goes on: The third decade of environmental journalism.The environmental communication yearbook.
11. Fry, K.(2003).Constructing the heartland: Television news and natural disaster.Cresskill & NJ:Hampton Press.
12. Granatt, M.,Shirley Harrison(Ed.)(1999).Disasters and the media: Managing crisis communications.London:Macmillan Business.
13. Harrison, S.(Ed.)(1999).Disasters and the media: Managing crisis communications.London:Macmillan Business.
14. Holland, P.(1997).The television handbook.London:Routledge.
15. Jefferson, J.,Shirley Harrison(Ed.)(1999).Disasters and the media: Managing crisis communications.London:Macmillan Business.
16. Killian, L. M.,R. A. Stallings(Ed.)(2002).Methods of disaster research.CA:International Research Committee on Disasters.
17. Meehan, E. R.(2005).Why TV is not our fault: Television programming, viewers, and who's really in control.London:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. Inc..
18. Meyrowitz, J.(1985).No sense of place: The impact of electronic media on social behavior.NY:Oxford University Press.
19. Mileti, D. S.(1999).Disasters by design: A reassessment of natural hazards in the United States.Washington:Joseph Henry Press.
20. Moeller, S. D.(1999).Compassion fatigue.NY:Routledge.
21. National Academy of Public Administration (NAPA)(1993).Coping with catastrophe: Building an emergency management system to meet people's needs in national and manmade disaster.Washington, D. C.:
22. Parker, D.,Handmer, J.(1992).Hazard management and emergency planning: Perspectives on Britain.London:James & James.
23. Patterson, P.,L. M. Walters(Eds.),L.Wilkins(Eds.),T. walters(Eds.)(1989).Reporting Chernobyl: Cutting the government fog to cover the nuclear cloud, Bad tidings: Communication and catastrophe.Hillsdale:Lawrence.
24. Perry, R. W.(1985).Comprehensive emergency management: Evacuating threatened populations.London:Greenwich, Connecticut.
25. Postman, N.(2003).Amusing ourselves to death.NY:Viking.
26. Roshico, B.(1975).Newsmaking.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
27. Rotberg, R. I.(1996).From massacres to genocide: The media, public policy, and humanitarian crises.Washington:Brookings Institution.
28. Sanders, K.(2003).Ethics & journalism.London:Sage.
29. Scanlon, J.,Havidan Rodriguez(Eds.),enrico L. Quarantelli(Eds.),Russell R. Dynes(Eds.)(2006).Handbook of disaster research.NY:Springer.
30. Shabecoff, P.(2000).Earth rising: American environmentalism in the 21st century.Washington, DC:Island Press.
31. Shearer, A.(1991).Survivors and the media.London:John Libbey.
32. Sigal, L. V.(1973).Reporters and officials.Lexington, MA:Lexington Books.
33. Singer, E.,Endreny, P. M.(1993).Reporting on risk: How the mass media portray accidents, diseases, disaster, and other hazards.NY:Russell Sage Foundation.
34. Smith, C.(1992).Media and apocalypse: News coverage of the Yellowstone forest fires. Exxon Valdez oil spill, and Loma Prieta earthquake.Westport:Greenwood Press.
35. Smythe, D. W.(1977).Communications: Blindspot of western Marxism.Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory,1(3),1-27.
36. Smythe, D. W.(1978).Rejoinder to Graham Murdock.Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory,2(2),120-129.
37. Sylves, R. T.(Eds.),Waugh, W. L.(Eds.)(1996).Disaster management in the U S. and Canada: The politics, policymaking, administration and analysis of emergency management.Springfield:Charles C Thomas.
38. Tierney, K.,Bevc, C.,Kuligowski, E.(2006).Metaphors matter: Disaster myths, media frames, and their consequences in Hurricane Katrina.The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,604,57-81.
39. Whitbread, P.,Shirley Harrison(Ed.)(1999).Disasters and the media: Managing crisis communication.London:Macmillan.
40. Willcins, L.,L. M. Walters(Eds.),L. Wilkins(Eds.),T. waiters(Eds.)(1989).Bad tidings: Communication and catastrophe.Hilisdale:Lawrence.
41. Zettle, H.(2005).Sight, sound, motion: Applied media aesthetics.Belmont, CA:Thomson Wadsworth.
42. Zettle, H.(1998).Contextual media aesthetics as the basis for media literacy.Journal of Communication,48,81-95.
43. Zettle, H.,R. P. Adler(Ed.)(1981).Understanding television: Essays on television as a social and cultural force.NY:Praeger.
44. 艾謹(1999)。地震新聞宜逐步降溫。新聞鏡，570，43。
45. 杜玟玲(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。世新大學傳播研究所。
46. 林元輝(2000)。日本阪神地震的傳播檢討。新聞學研究，62，183-186。
47. 孫曼蘋(2000)。921地震政府體系資訊傳佈之初探。新聞學研究，62，165-170。
48. 陳世敏(2000)。小兵立大功。新聞學研究，62，175-182。
49. 陳鳳如(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立師範大學大眾傳播研究所。
50. 臧國仁、鍾蔚文(2000)。災難事件與媒體報導：相關研究簡述。新聞學研究，62，143-151。
51. 趙庭輝(1991)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。輔仁大學大眾傳播研究所。
52. 蔡筱穎譯(2000)。布赫迪厄論電視。台北:麥田出版社。
53. 蘇衡(2000)。集集大地震中媒體危機處理的總體檢。新聞學研究，62，153-163。

1. 林照真(2013)。台灣電視新聞之災難報導：以「莫拉克」風災為例。新聞學研究，115，141-185。
2. 劉昌德、張春炎(2017)。探索風險社會下的反身性知識技能：以日本311災難報導經驗和專業反思為例。科技、醫療與社會，25，63-118。
3. 葉欣誠、楊樺、張春炎(2015)。自然災難與媒體建構：以TVBS 新聞為例，重探八八風災新聞論述。環境教育研究，11(1)，1-30。
4. 鄭宇君、陳百齡(2012)。溝通不確定性：探索社交媒體在災難事件中的角色。中華傳播學刊，21，119-153。
5. (2016)。「救急」的媒介溝通效果：以災難新聞為例。傳播與社會學刊，38，37-82。
6. (2021)。台灣商業電視媒體的災難新聞產製與反思：新聞工作、常規與災難的不確定性。傳播與社會學刊，55，93-126。