「網友」作為消息來源：探討數位時代中電視新聞製作的實質秩序

Net-Users as News Source: The Production Order of TV News in Digital Era

10.30385/JRTS.201406_(36).0002

劉慧雯(Hui-Wen Liu)

內容分析 ； 消息來源 ； 匿名消息來源 ； 電視新聞 ； 網友 ； anonymous sources ； content analysis ； news source ； net-user news ； TV news

廣播與電視

36期（2014 / 06 / 01）

37 - 68

繁體中文

本研究考察電視新聞處理「網路消息來源」的策略，以瞭解「網友說」新聞的面貌。本研究採取內容研究法，分析商業台TVBS與公視新聞，並依據經驗資料提出可能的解釋。研究結果發現，TVBS播出的「網友說新聞」不論則數或時間，約是公視的十倍；且有近六成新聞完全使用匿名消息來源。不過，有部分匿名消息來源是因為網頁設計所造成，不見得是記者「偷懶」的結果；而網友言論的極端化，則可能是商業新聞台大量播出「網友說新聞」的主因。

This research aims at understanding how TV news channel strategically treat their news source of internet-users (i.e. netuser news) and its plausible reasons. By mainly applying content analysis, the author tries to compare the prime time news broadcasting of a commercial news channel 'TVBS' and the public channel 'PTS' in three months from March 1st to May 31st 2012. Major research findings include: firstly, TVBS broadcasts more net-user news than PTS on both time length and story numbers. Secondly, nearly 60 % of TVBS' net-user news are based on anonymous sources. However, checking the details of the targeted news leads us to an interesting finding-the webpage design is one of the main factors that makes large percentage net-user news sources as anonymous. This shows that anonymous source is not necessary equal to reporters' laziness as common argument indicates. Finally, net-users' radicalized speech are more attractive to TV news production.

1. 楊意菁(2011)。從「網友說」新聞探討公眾角色在新聞報導的變化。傳播研究與實踐，1(1)，43-53。
   連結：
2. 楊意菁(2008)。網路民意的公共意涵：公眾、公共領域與溝通審議。中華傳播學刊，14，115-167。
   連結：
3. 楊意菁(2013)。網路意見的新聞再現與公眾想像；「網友說」新聞的內容與論述分析。中華傳播學刊，24，119-164。
   連結：
4. 劉蕙苓(2013)。為公共？為方便？電視新聞使用網路影音之研究。中華傳播學刊，24，165-206。
   連結：
5. 羅玉潔、張錦華(2006)。人脈與新聞採集：從社會資本與組織衝突觀點檢視記者如何建立與消息來源之間的關係。中華傳播學刊，10，195-231。
   連結：
6. (1992).Communication Yearbook.Los Angeles, CA:Sage.
7. Richardson, J. H. (2003. Oct, 1). The search for Isabella. Retrieved from http://www.esquire.com/features/ESQ1003-OCT_ISABELLA
8. Scott, E. (2004). 'Bid media' meets 'blogger': Coverage on Trent Lott's remarks at Strom Thurmond's birthday party. Retrieved from Http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/perssol/Research_Publications/Case_Studies/1731_0.pdf
9. Carroll, B. (2004). Culture clash: Journalism and the communal ethos of the Blogosphere. Into the blogosphere. Retrieved from http://blog.lib.umn.edu/blogosphere/culture_clash_journalism_and_the_communal_ethos_of_the_blogosphere.html
10. Lasica, J. D. (2001). Blogging as a form of journalism. Online Journalism Review. http://www.ojr.org/ojr/1017958873.php
11. Gallo, J. (2004). Weblog journalism: Between infiltration and integration. Into the blogosphere, retrieved from http://blog.lib.umn.edu/blogosphere/weblog_journalism.html
12. 黃宗慧（2004 年9 月20 日）。〈觀念平台：網友說〉，《中國時報》，http://homepage.ntu.edu.tw/~soeko/articles/20040920.htm， 上網日期:2013 年3 月26 日
13. 陳順孝（2006 年8 月9 日）。〈打造公民媒體：web2.0 時代的新聞編寫〉。http://www.ashaw.org/2006/08/web20.html。上網日期：2014 年1 月9日
14. Blood, R. (2000, Sep, 7). Blog: A history and perspective. Rebecca's Pocket. Retrieved from http://www.rebeccablood.net/essays/weblog_history.html
15. (1991).A handbook of qualitative methodologies for mass communication research.London:Routledge.
16. Banaji, S.,Buckingham, D.(2010).Young people, the internet and civic participateon: An overview of key finding from the CivicWeb project.International Journal of Learning and Media,2(1),1-11.
17. Bauer, M. W.(Ed.),Gaskell, G.(Ed.)(2000).Qualitative researching with text, image and sound: A practical handbook.London, UK:Sage.
18. Bell, A.(1991).The language of news media.Oxford, UK:Blackwell.
19. Berelson, B.(1952).Content analysis in communication search.Glencoe, Ill:The Free Press.
20. Berkowitz, D.(1987).TV news source and news channels: A study in agenda-building.Journalism Quarterly,64(2),508-513.
21. Berkowitz, D.,Adams, D.(1990).Information subsidy and agenda-building in local television news.Journalism Quarterly,67(4),723-731.
22. Callister, T.A., Jr.(2000).Media literacy: On-ramp to the literacy of the 21st century or curl-de-sac on the information superhighway.Advances in Reading/Language Research,7,403-420.
23. Crawford, D.(2004).Editorial pointers.Communication of ACM-The blogosphere,47(12),5-8.
24. Dery, M.(1996).Escape velocity: Cyberculture at the end of the century.New York, NY:Grove Press.
25. Fishman, J.(1980).Manufacturing news.Austin, TX:University of Taxes Press.
26. Fogg, B. J.,Soohoo, C.,Danielson, D. R.,Marable, L.,Stanford, J.,Trauber, E. R.(2003).How do users evaluate the credibility of web sites? A study with over 2,500 participants.Porceedings of the 2003 Conference on Designing for User Experiences,San Francisco, CA.:
27. Gillmore, D.(2004).We the media: Grassroots journalism by the people, for the people.San Francisco, CA:O'Reilly.
28. Green, M. R.,Sachaman, D. B.,Sandman, P. M.,Salomone, K. L.(1989).Risk, drama and geopraphy in coverage of enironmental risk by network TV.Journalism Quarterly,66(22),267-276.
29. Hackett, R. A.(1985).A hierarchy of access: Aspects of sources bias in Canadian TV news.Journalism Quarterly,62(2),256-267.
30. Hagen, L. M.(1993).Opportune witnesses: An analysis of balance in the selection of sources and arguments in the leading newspaper' coverage of the census issue.European Journal of Communication,8,317-343.
31. Harrison, J.(2010).User-generated content and gatekeeping at the BBC hub.Journalism Studies,11(2),243-256.
32. Hauben, M.,Hauben, R.(1996).Netizens: On the history and impact of UseNet and the internet.New York, NY:Wiley-IEEE Computer Society Press.
33. Hermann, E. S.,Chomsky, N.(1988).Manufacturing consent: The political economy of the mass media.New York, NY:Patheon Books.
34. Hsieh, H.-F.,Shannon, S. H.(2005).Three approaches to qualitative content analysis.Qualitative Health Research,15(9),1277-1288.
35. Hurwitz, R(1999).Who needs politics? The ironies of democracy in cyberspace.Contemporary Sociology,28(6),655-661.
36. Keren, M.(2006).Blogosphere: The new political arena.Lanham, MD:Lexington Books.
37. Kracauer, S.(1952).The challenge of qualitative content analysis.The Public Opinion Quarterly,16(4),631-642.
38. Krippendorff, K.(1980).Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology.London, UK:Sage.
39. Lichter, S. R.,Rothman, S.,Lichter, L.S.(1986).The media elite.Bethesda, MD:Adler and Adler.
40. Lombard, M.,Snyder-Duch, J.,Bracken, C. C.(2002).Content analysis in mass communication research: An assessment and reporting of intercoder reliability.Human Communication Research,28,587-604.
41. Marlow, C.(2004).Audience, structure and authority in the weblog community.International Communication Association Conference,New Orleans, LA.:
42. McQuail, D.(1994).Mass communication theory: An introduction.London:Sage.
43. Metzger, M. J.(2007).Making sense of credibility in the web: Models for evaluating online information and recommendations for future research.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,58,2078-2097.
44. Metzger, M. J.,Flanagin, A. J.,Medder, R. B.(2010).Social and heuristic approaches to credibility evaluating online.Journal of Communication,60,413-439.
45. Nacos, B. L.(1990).The press, president and crises.New York, NY:Columbia University Press.
46. Noelle-Neumann, E.,Mathes, R.(1987).The events as events and the events as news: The significance of consonance for media effects research.European Journal of Communication,2,391-414.
47. North, R.(1963).Content analysis: A handbook with applications for the study of international crisis.Kirkland, WA:Northwest University Press.
48. Reese, S. D.,Routigliano, L.,Hyun, K.,Jeong, J.(2007).Mapping the blogosphere professional and citizen-based media in the global news arena.Journalism,8(3),235-261.
49. Singletary, M. W.(1993).Mass communication research: Contemporary methods and applications.Boston, MS:Addison-Wesley.
50. Stemples, G. H.,Clubertson, H. M.(1984).The prominence and dominance of news sources in newspaper medical coverage.Journalism Quarterly,61(3),671-676.
51. Stenvall, M.(2008).Unnamed sources as rhetorical constructs ion news report.Journalism Studies,61(3),671-676.
52. Talbott, S. L.(1995).The future does not compute: Transcending the machine in our midst.Sebastopol, CA:O'Reilly.
53. Thimas, M.(ed.)(2010).Deconstructing digital natives: Young people , technology and the new literacies.New York:Routledge.
54. Tinsley, H. E. A.(ed.),Brown, S. D.(ed.)(2000).Handbook of applied multivariate statistics and mathematical modeling.San Diego, CA:Academic.
55. Tinsley, H. E. A.,Weiss, D. J.(1975).Interrater reliability and agreement of subjective judgments.Journal of Counseling Psychology,22(4),358-376.
56. Toffler, A.,Toffler, H.(1995).Creating a new civilization: The politics of the third wave.Atlanta, GA:Turner.
57. Tuchman, G.(1978).Making news: A study in the construction of reality.New York, NY:Free Press.
58. Waelbers, K.(ed.),Briggle, A.(ed.),Brey, P.(ed.)(2008).Current issues in computing and philosophy.Amsterdam, HL:IOS Press.
59. Walters, L. M.,Walters, T. N.(1996).The four seasons: Patters of cyclical sussess in public relations placements.Southwestern Mass Communication Journal,10(1),86-97.
60. Webster, F.(1995).Theories of the information society.New York, NY:Routledge.
61. 王永志編(2004)。全球新聞神經大透視。台北:中央通訊社。
62. 王石番(1991)。傳播內容分析法：理論與實證。台北:幼獅出版社。
63. 王泰俐(2004)。電視新聞「感官主義」之初探研究。新聞學研究，81，1-41。
64. 吳齊殷、蔡博方、李文傑(2001)。網民研究：特徵與網路社會行為。第四屆資訊科技與社會轉型研討會，台北市南港:
65. 翁秀琪(1996)。消息來源策略研究—出探中時、聯合對婦運團體推動「民法親屬編」修法的報導。新聞學研究，52，121-148。
66. 郭良文編(1994)。台灣的環保公關。台北:巨流。
67. 陳一香(1988)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞系。
68. 楊秋蘋(1988)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞系。
69. 楊意菁(2002)。博士論文(博士論文)。政治大學新聞研究所。
70. 楊瑪利(2002)。弱智媒體，大家一起來誤國。天下雜誌，251，110-125。
71. 楊韶彧(1993)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞系。
72. 熊傳慧(1985)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞系。
73. 劉蕙苓(1989)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。政治大學新聞系。
74. 鄭瑞城(1991)。從消息來源途徑詮釋近用媒介權：台灣的經驗。新聞學研究，45，39-45。
75. 瞿海原(2001)。網路公共論壇與民意—有關停建核四討論的分析。第四屆資訊科技與社會轉型研討會，台北市南港:
76. 蘇蘅(1986)。媒介報導衝突事件之角色分析—以報紙報導核能四廠興建的爭議為例。新聞學研究，36，251-285。

1. 林宇玲(2020)。使用者自製內容對報紙報導選舉新聞的影響：以2016年台灣總統大選為例。資訊社會研究，39，29-69。
2. 劉昌德(2020)。小編新聞學：社群媒體與通訊軟體如何轉化新聞專業。新聞學研究，142，1-58。
3. 劉慧雯(2017)。建構「倫理閱聽人」：試論社群媒體使用者的理論意涵。新聞學研究，131，87-125。
4. (2020)。從新聞到粉絲團：社群小編重構公共話語現象的初探研究。傳播與社會學刊，54，161-192。