题名

食品供應鏈中惡意汙染行為之防治:以美國、歐盟與國際組織的實踐為例

并列篇名

Preventing and Governing Deliberate Contamination in the Food Supply Chain -Case Studies of Practices in the US, the EU and International Organizations

DOI

10.7015/JEAS.201612_46(4).0004

作者

譚偉恩(Wei-En Tan)

关键词

食品安全 ; 食品供應鏈 ; 食品恐怖主義 ; 惡意的食品汙染行為 ; 威脅評估與關鍵管制點 ; Food Safety ; Food Supply Chain ; Food Terrorism ; Deliberate Food Contamination ; TACCP

期刊名称

歐美研究

卷期/出版年月

46卷4期(2016 / 12 / 01)

页次

563 - 602

内容语文

繁體中文

中文摘要

本文對「食品供應鏈」進行研究與分析,說明何以在供應鏈後端的惡意汙染行為較難預防,卻受害者範圍較小。反之,在供應鏈前端的汙染行為並不容易得逞,惟一旦成功則往往造成較為嚴重之損害後果。研究結果顯示,預防食品受到惡意汙染行為的治理重點應聚焦在對「威脅」的控管;操作上,威脅評估與關鍵管制點是值得考慮之治理途徑。鑑於現行全球食品貿易自由化的趨勢與結構不可逆,食安風險必然不會消失,在容許風險的概念下,建立預防威脅擴大和限縮損害結果的治理機制,將是防治惡意汙染食品行為較為務實之辦法。

英文摘要

This paper discusses current issues in the global food supply chain (FSC). More specifically, it focuses on why it is difficult to prevent deliberate, criminal contamination in downstream sections of the FSC, yet only limited harm is done to consumers. The paper also investigates why it is more feasible to hamper the food contamination in the upstream of FSC while the adverse effect could be serious given the effective criminal behavior. Observing the practices of food safety governance in the US, the EU and international organizations (the WHO in particular), the key point in preventing deliberate contamination should be the management of 'threats.' It is worth noting that threat assessment and critical control points (TACCP), as an approach to governing food safety, is certainly a considerable alternative. Thanks to the irreversible structures and trends associated with global food trade liberalization, current risks of food contamination from various sources will by no means fade away. Given this, efforts to establish an institution based on the concept of acceptable risk for preventing threats while managing the spillover effects of damages are a pragmatic means of defending against deliberate food-contamination.

主题分类 人文學 > 人文學綜合
社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 李河清、譚偉恩(2012)。衛生安全與國際食品貿易:以「人類安全」檢視世貿組織相關立法缺失。問題與研究,51(1),69-110。
    連結:
  2. 周桂田、張淳美(2006)。遲滯型高科技風險社會下之典範鬥爭:以換發身分證按捺指紋案為分析。政治與社會哲學評論,17,127-215。
    連結:
  3. 洪德欽(2008)。消費者權利在歐盟基改食品標示之規定與實踐。歐美研究,38(4),509-578。
    連結:
  4. Spink, J. (2014). GFSI direction on food fraud and vulnerability as sessment (VACCP). Retrieved from http://foodfraud.msu.edu/ 2014/05/08/gfsi-direction-on-food-fraud-and-vulnerability-assess ment-vaccp/
  5. Department of Homeland Security. (2007). The department of homeland security's role in food defense and critical infrastructure protection. Retrieved from https://www.oig.dhs.gov/assets/Mgmt/OIG_07-33_Feb07.pdf
  6. Fabi, R. (2003). FDA warns of "food terrorism." The Boston Globe.Retrieved from http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2003/10/11/fda_warns_of_food_terrorism/
  7. European Commission. (2007). The commission health emergency operations facility: For a coordinated management of public health emergency at EU level. Retrieved from http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_threats/com/preparedness/docs/HEOF_en.pdf
  8. European Commission. (2009). Background on the health security committee and the early warning and response system authorities.Retrieved from http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-09-363_en.htm?locale=en
  9. European Commission. (2014). Horsemeat: One year after: Actions announced and delivered. Retrieved from http://ec.europa.eu/food/sited/food/files/safety/docs/official-controls_food-fraud_five-point-action-plan_en.pdf
  10. European Commission. (2016). Health security committee activities.Retrieved from http://ec.europa.eu/health/preparedness_response/ risk_management/hsc/index_en.htm
  11. Keyes, S. (2014, June 10). A strange but true tale of voter fraud and bioterrorism. The Atlantic. Retrieved from http://www.theatlantic. com/politics/archive/2014/06/a-strange-but-true-tale-of-voterfraud- and-bioterrorism/372445/
  12. European Commission. (2015). RASFF-Food and feed safety alerts.Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/food/safety/rasff_en
  13. Stolberg, S. G., & Miller, J. (2002, September 9). Many worry that nation is still highly vulnerable to germ attack. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2002/09/09/us/ threats-responses-bioterrorism-many-worry-that-nation-still-highly -vulnerable.html?pagewanted=all
  14. Fresco, L., & Baudoin, W. (2002). Food and nutrition security towards human security. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/ag/agp/agpc/doc/reports/icv02e90spe.pdf
  15. Goetz, G. (2010, December 16). Who inspects what? A food safety scramble. Food Safety News. Retrieved from http://www.foodsafetynews.com/2010/12/who-inspects-what-a-food-safetyscramble/#.VjCm0lUrKM8
  16. de Haen, H. (2001). The impact of globalization and trade liberalization on food security. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/News/2001/stockholm/dehaenfull.htm
  17. Food and Drug Administration. (2012). FDA's China offices focus on product safety. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm284461.htm
  18. Butler, S., & Smithers, R. (2014, January 10). Horsemeat scandal results in slide in sales of red meat in Britain. The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/jan/10/horsemeat-scandal-sales-red-britain
  19. Government Accountability Office. (2007). High-risk series: An update.Retrieved from http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d07310.pdf
  20. "Maruha Nichiro unit recalls 6.3 million packages of frozen food."(2013, December 29). Japan Times. Retrieved from http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/12/29/national/maruha-nichiro-unitrecalls-6-3-million-packages-of-frozen-food/#.WD6lgGp96Uk
  21. European Commission-Directorate-General Justice, Freedom and Security. (2010). Secufood: Security of European food supply chain. Retrieved from http://secufood.unicampus.it/index.aspx
  22. Pollan, M. (2009, September 10). Big food vs. big insurance. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/10/opinion/10pollan.html
  23. World Health Assembly. (2002). Diet, physical activity and health. Retrieved from http://apps.who.int/gb/archive/pdf_files/WHA55/ ewha5523.pdf
  24. Alvarez, M. J.,Alvarez, A.,Maggio, M. C. D.,Oses, A.,Trombetta, M.,Setola, R.(2010).Protecting the food supply chain from terrorist attack.Critical infrastructure protection IV,Washington, DC:
  25. British Standards Iinstituion(2014).Guide to protecting and defending food and drink from deliberate attack.
  26. British Standards Institution(2008).Prerequisite programmes on food safety for food manufacturing (PAS 220: 2008).
  27. Casey, D.,Lawless, J.,Wall, P.(2010).A tale of two crises: The Belgian and Irish dioxin contamination incidents.British Food Journal,112(10),1077-1091.
  28. Chapman, J.(Ed.).(2005).,未出版
  29. Dalziel, G. R.(2009).Food defence incidents, 1950-2008: A chronology and analysis of incidents involving the malicious contamination of the food supply chain.
  30. Dardis, R.,Davenport, G.,Kurin, J.,Marr, J.(1983).Risk-benefit analysis and the determination of acceptable risk.Journal of Consumer Affairs,17(1),38-56.
  31. DeWaal, C. S.(2004).Rising imports, bioterrorism, and the food supply.Food and Drug Law Journal,59(3),433-439.
  32. Dreyer, M.(ed.),Renn, O.(ed.)(2009).Food safety governance-Integrating, science, precaution and public involvement.Heidelberg, Germany:Springer.
  33. Edelstein, S.(ed.),Gerald, B.(ed.),Bushell, T.(ed.),Gundersen, C.(ed.)(2009).Food and nutrition at risk in America-Food insecurity, biotechnology, food safety, and bioterrorism.Boston:Jones & Bartlett.
  34. Fewtrell, L.(ed.),Bartram, J.(ed.)(2001).Water quality: Guidelines, standards and health.London:IWA.
  35. Fidler, D.(2009).The swine flu outbreak and international law.ASIL Insights,13,5.
  36. Griffitch, G.(2000).Competition in the food marketing chain.Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,44(3),333-367.
  37. Hoffman, J.,Kennedy, S.(2007).International cooperation to defend the food supply chain: Nations are talking; next step-action.Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law,40,1172-1186.
  38. Kafetzopoulos, D. P.,Psomas, E. L.,Kafetzopoulos, P. D.(2013).Measuring the effectiveness of the HACCP food safety management system.Food Control,33(2),505-513.
  39. Leathers, R.(2014).Validation in relation to threat assessment critical control points (TACCP)..International Food Hygiene,24(1),13-14.
  40. Leathers, R.(2014).Protecting the food supply chain.Food & Drink Technology,14(1),48.
  41. Leibovitch, E. H.(2008).Food safety regulation in the European Union: Toward an unavoidable centralization of regulatory powers.Texas International Law Journal,43(3),429-450.
  42. Manning, L.,Baines, R. N.(2004).Globalisation: A study of the poultry-meat supply chain.British Food Journal,106(10/11),819-836.
  43. Manning, L.,Baines, R. N.,Chadd, S. A(2005).Deliberate contamination of the food supply chain.British Food Journal,107(4),225-245.
  44. Martinez, S.,Hand, M.,Da Pra, M.,Pollack, S.,Ralston, K.,Smith, T.(2010).United States Department of Agriculture: Economic Research ReportUnited States Department of Agriculture: Economic Research Report,未出版
  45. McDade, J.,Franz, D.(1998).Bioterrorism as a public health threat..Emerging Infectious Diseases,4(3),493-494.
  46. Merrill, R. A.,Francer, J. K.(2000).Organizing federal food safety regulation.Seton Hall Law Review,31(1),61-173.
  47. Monke, J.(2004).CRS Report for CongressCRS Report for Congress,未出版
  48. National Research Council.(1998).Ensuring safe food: From production to consumption.Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
  49. Nestle, M.(2010).Safe food: The politics of food safety.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
  50. Overbosch, P.(2013).Food safety management: Hazard- or risk-based?.Food Safety,Feb/Mar
  51. Paarlberg, R. L.(2010).Food politics: What everyone needs to know.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  52. Rayner, G.,Hawkes, C.,Lang, T.,Bello, W.(2006).Trade liberalization and the diet transition: A public health response[Special issue].Health Promotion International,21(1),67-74.
  53. Robinson, T.,Deluyker, H.(2012).EFSA's food and feed safety crisis preparedness and response.EFSA Journal,10(5),e1051.
  54. Sirbu, M.(2010).Green paper on bio-preparedness-General comments.Journal of Medicine and Life,3(4),430-432.
  55. Sözen, B. U.,Hecer, C.(2013).Is HACCP a difficult food safety system to implement?.Journal of Biodiversity and Environmental Sciences,7(19),33-38.
  56. Stearns, D.(2008).Intentional contamination: The legal risks and responsibilities.Journal of Environmental Health,70(6),58-59.
  57. van der Meulen, B.(ed.)(2011).Private food law-Governing food chains through contract law, self-regulation, private standards,audits and certification schemes.Wageningen, the Netherlands:Wageningen Academic Publishers.
  58. Wallace, C.,Powell, S.,Holyoak, L.(2005).Development of methods for standardised HACCP assessment.British Food Journal,107(10),723-742.
  59. Williams, R.(2015).Mercatus Working PaperMercatus Working Paper,未出版
  60. Wilson, B.(2008).Swindled: The dark history of food fraud, from poisoned candy to counterfeit coffee.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press..
  61. World Health Organization.(2008).Terrorist threats to food: Guidance for establishing and strengthening prevention and response systems.Geneva, Switzerland:WHO.
  62. World Health Organization.(2002).Terrorist threats to food: Guidance for establishing and strengthening prevention and response systems.Geneva, Switzerland:WHO.
  63. Yasar, S.,Boselli, E.(2015).Perception and awareness of the European Union food safety framework.Italian Journal of Food Science,27(1-9)
  64. Yoon, E.,Shanklin C.(2007).Food terrorism: Perceptional gaps between importance and performance of preventive measures.Journal of Foodservice Business Research,10(4),3-23.
  65. 林東茂(1996)。危險犯與經濟刑法。臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan Book。
  66. 林鈺雄(2014)。食安防線與食品犯罪:從正義、頂新黑油事件說起。台灣法學雜誌,259,1-7。
  67. 洪德欽編 (2011)。歐盟與美國生物科技政策。臺北=Taipei:中央研究院歐美研究所=IEAS。
  68. 程明修(2009)。行政法上之預防原則(Vorsorgeprinzip):食品安全風險管理手段之擴張。月旦法學雜誌,167,127-136。
  69. 黃榮堅(2003)。刑法問題與利益思考。臺北=Taipei:元照=Angle。
  70. 譚偉恩(2015)。論跨國食品詐欺及其治理。全球政治評論,51,123-146。