虛擬社群涉入對於股票投資行為之影響

The Impacts of e-Stock-Investors' Involvement in Virtual Community on Their Investment Behaviors

10.6656/MR.2014.33.3.CHI.53

郭敏華(Min-Hua Kuo)；黃柏凱(Po-Kai Huang)；許碧芳(Pi-Fang Hsu)

虛擬社群 ； 持股分散程度 ； 進出頻次 ； 停損 ； virtual community ； portfolio diversification ； trading turnover ； stop-loss

管理評論

33卷3期（2014 / 07 / 01）

53 - 70+121-125

繁體中文

本研究探討虛擬社群涉入對於股票投資行為之影響，係國內外首篇針對此議題所進行的大規模調查研究。實證結果發現，臺灣e股民的投資行為，不論是靜態的持股分散程度或是動態的投資進出頻次，均受到投資者虛擬社群的涉入程度所影響，更明確地說，個別投資人對於虛擬社群的參與深度（涉入時間）與其持股分散程度和交易頻次，都呈現顯著的正向關係。此外，本研究也發現，投資人對於虛擬社群的參與廣度（參與的社群網站數）較高者，較能積極設立停損且切實執行。此現象意味著，虛擬世界中的人際網絡並不「虛擬」，對於投資人的決策與行為已具有十分顯著的影響。本研究的成果發現，對於財務學中的投資行為與社會心理學的人際關係等議題之探討，都具有開創性的重要價值。

This study explores the impacts of e-stock-investors' involvement in virtual community on their investment behaviors. It is the first paper, as far as we know, discussing this issue systematically by a large-scale survey. The empirical results show that individual e-investors' involvement in virtual communities significantly affects their portfolio diversification and trading turnover. Specifically, when a Taiwanese e-investor spends more time in virtual community, he/she holds a more diversified portfolio and trades more frequently. In addition, when he/she attends more social websites, he/she is more inclined to do the loss-stops. It implies that the virtual community is not ＂virtual＂ and brings about significant influences on investment behaviors. The findings of this paper are insightful for the re-searches on the social networks analysis in Sociology, the interpersonal relationships in Social Psychology, as well as the investment behaviors in Finance.

1. 郭敏華(2011)。人際網絡對家計單位金融服務支出之影響：台灣家戶跨年度分量迴歸分析。管理評論，30(1)，95-113。
   連結：
2. Antweiler, Werner,Frank, Murray Z.(2004).Is All That Talk Just Noise? The Information Content of Internet Stock Message Boards.Journal of Finance,59(3),1259-1294.
3. Barber, Brad M.,Odean, Terrance(2002).Online Investors: Do the Slow Die First?.Review of Financial Studies,15(2),455-488.
4. Blume, Marshall E.,Crockett, Jean,Friend, Irwin(1974).Stock Ownership in the United States: Characteristics and Trends.Survey of Current Business,54(11),16-40.
5. Blume, Marshall E.,Friend, Irwin(1975).The Asset Structure of Individual Portfolios and Some Implications for Utility Functions.Journal of Finance,30(2),585-603.
6. Campbell, John Y.,Lettau, Martin,Malkiel, Burton G.,Xu, Yexiao(2001).Have Individual Stocks Become More Volatile? An Empirical Exploration of Idiosyncratic Risk.Journal of Finance,56(1),1-43.
7. Choi, James J.,Laibson, David,Metrick, Andrew(2002).How Does the Internet Affect Trading? Evidence from Investor Behavior in 401(k) Plans.Journal of Financial Economics,64(3),397-421.
8. Clarkson, Peter M.,Joyce, Daniel,Tutticci, Irene(2006).Market Reaction to Takeover Rumour in Internet Discussion Sites.Accounting and Finance,46(1),31-52.
9. Das, Sanjiv R.,Chen, Mike Y.(2007).Yahoo! for Amazon: Sentiment Extraction from Small Talk on the Web.Management Science,53(9),1375-1388.
10. Das, Sanjiv R.,Martinez-Jerez, Asis,Tufano, Peter(2005).einformation: A Clinical Study of Investor Discussion and Sentiment.Financial Management,34(3),103-137.
11. Ellison, Glenn,Fudenberg, Drew(1993).Rules of Thumb for Social Learning.Journal of Political Economy,101(4),612-643.
12. Elton, Edwin J.,Gruber, Martin J.(1977).Risk Reduction and Portfolio Size: An Analytical Solution.Journal of Business,50(4),415-437.
13. Emirbayer, Mustafa,Goodwin, Jeff(1994).Network Analysis, Culture, and the Problem of Agency.American Journal of Sociology,99(6),1411-1454.
14. Forsyth, Donelson R.(1990).Group Dynamics.California:Pacific Grove.
15. Goetzmann, William N.,Kumar, Alok(2008).Equity Portfolio Diversification.Review of Finance,12(3),433-463.
16. Granovetter, Mark(1985).Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness.American Journal of Sociology,91(3),481-510.
17. Hochberg, Yael V.,Ljungqvist, Alexander,Lu, Yang(2007).Whom You Know Matters: Venture Capital Networks and Investment Performance.Journal of Finance,62(1),251-301.
18. Hong, Harrison,Kubik, Jeffrey D.,Stein, Jeremy C.(2005).The Neighbor's Portfolio: Word-of-Mouth Effects in the Holdings and Trades of Money Managers.Journal of Finance,60(6),2801-2824.
19. Hong, Harrison,Kubik, Jeffrey D.,Stein, Jeremy C.(2004).Social Interaction and Stock-Market Participation.Journal of Finance,59(1),137-163.
20. Jones, Anne Leah(2006).Have Internet Message Boards Changed Market Behavior?.Info,8(5),67-76.
21. Knoke, David,Kuklinski, James H.(1982).Network Analysis.Thousand Oaks:Sage Publications.
22. Kuo, Min-Hua(2009).Does Internet Usage Activate or Inactivate Global Stock Markets? Exploration by Spatial Econometrics Models.Problems and Perspectives in Management,7(4),4-14.
23. Kuo, Min-Hua,Huang, Po-Kai,Jane, Wen-Jhan(2013).The Impact of the Financial Tsunami on Stock Investment Behavior: The Case of Individual Investors in Taiwan.Investment Management and Financial Innovations,10(1),206-215.
24. Lease, Ronald C.,Lewellen, Wilbur G.,Schlarbaum, Gary G.(1976).Market Segmentation: Evidence on the Individual Investor.Financial Analysts Journal,32(5),53-60.
25. Mayshar, Joram(1979).Transaction Costs in a Model of Capital Market Equilibrium.Journal of Political Economy,87(4),673-700.
26. Mizrach, Bruce,Weerts, Susan(2009).Experts Online: An Analysis of Trading Activity in a Public Internet Chat Room.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,70(1-2),266-281.
27. Sabherwal, Sanjiv,Sarkar, Salil K.,Zhang, Ying(2011).Do Internet Stock Message Boards Influence Trading? Evidence from Heavily Discussed Stocks with No Fundamental News.Journal of Business Finance & Accounting,38(9-10),1209-1237.
28. Sabherwal, Sanjiv,Sarkar, Salil K.,Zhang, Ying(2008).Online Talk: Does It Matter?.Managerial Finance,34(6),423-436.
29. Statman, Meir(1987).How Many Stocks Make a Diversified Portfolio?.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,22(3),353-363.
30. Statman, Meir(2004).The Diversification Puzzle.Financial Analysts Journal,60(4),44-53.
31. Tumarkin, Robert(2002).Internet Message Board Activity and Market Efficiency: A Case Study of the Internet Service Sector using RagingBull.Com.Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments,11(4),313-335.
32. Tumarkin, Robert,Whitelaw, Robert F.(2001).News or Noise? Internet Postings and Stock Prices.Financial Analysts Journal,57(3),41-51.
33. 郭敏華(2010)。台灣股民之網路社會行為暨網路資訊行為。當代商管研究，2(2)，21-34。
34. 郭敏華(2004)。從送禮行為看台灣股票族之人際網絡。貨幣觀測與信用評等，50，33-42。
35. 郭敏華、郭迺鋒(2006)。台灣股票投資散戶持股多角化之應然與實然。世新大學五十週年校慶學術論文集，臺北:
36. 郭敏華、郭迺鋒、蕭欣宜(2003)。人際網絡對家計單位金融投資的影響：民國86年到90年家計收支調查之實證分析。第四屆全國實證經濟學研討會，花蓮:
37. 郭敏華、陳靜宜(2006)。資訊網絡使投資人進出頻繁。2006年國際學術研討會（管理組），臺北: