再探銀行產業的市場競爭度－東亞八國的實證分析

Re-visit the Market Competition of the Banking Industries in Eight East Asian Countries

10.6656/MR.2015.34.4.CHI.59

黃台心(Tai-Hsin Huang)；江典霖(Dien-Lin Chiang)；張雅凱(Ya-Kai Chang)

銀行競爭度 ； PR非結構檢定法 ； 切齊隨機邊界模型 ； Degrees of Competition ； PR Non-structural Test ； Censored Stochastic Frontier Model

管理評論

34卷4期（2015 / 10 / 01）

59 - 76

繁體中文

本文使用非結構法之PR檢定法，探討東亞八國銀行業於1994年到2008年的亞洲金融風暴前後市場競爭程度。與過去相關文獻主要差異，在於應用切齊隨機邊界模型，檢定各樣本國家銀行產業是否處於長期均衡狀態。此模型的優點為不必依照傳統方式，將所有樣本的應變數－資產報酬率－加1調整成正值，以利再取自然對數後進行迴歸分析，可避免扭曲樣本蘊含之訊息並獲得具備一致性的係數估計式。實證結果發現各樣本國銀行業在亞洲金融風暴前後，皆為獨占性競爭或完全競爭，業者間競爭程度頗高。運用切齊隨機邊界模型，發現六個國家的銀行業達到長期均衡狀態；唯若使用傳統方法，卻出現六個國家銀行業未達到長期均衡狀態，顯示傳統方法容易導致迴歸係數估計式缺乏一致性。

This paper investigates the degree of market competition in the banking industries of eight East Asian countries over the period of 1994-2008, using the ‘H-statistic’ proposed by Panzar and Rosse (1987). Differing from previous works, this paper applies the newly developed model, i.e., the censored stochastic frontier (CSF) model, to test whether these markets under consideration have achieved the long-run equilibrium. The model is superior to the conventional one that requires researchers adding unity to dependent variable ROA for all observations to force the transformed dependent variable having a positive value and being able to take the natural logarithm. Evidence is found that all of the banking industries in our sample are characterized as either monopolistic, or perfect, competition, intead of monoply, or oligopoly. The CSF model confirms that six out of the eight banking markets are already in the long-run equilibrium, which validates the use of Panzar-Rosse model. Conversely, the employment of the conventional approach leads to a rejection of the long-run equilibrium in six out of the eight markets.

1. Bureau Van Dijk (2009), “Bankscope Database,” (accessed January 31, 2009), [available at https://bankscope.bvdinfo.com/version-2015831/home.serv?product.https://bankscope.bvdinfo.com/version-2015831/home.serv?product=scope2006
2. 台灣經濟新報社 (2009)，「台灣經濟新報資料庫」，(取得日期：2009年1月31日)，[available at http://www.tej.com.tw/twsite/Default.aspx]。http://www.tej.com.tw/twsite/Default.aspx
3. Al-Muharrami, Saeed,Matthews, Kent,Khabari, Yusuf(2006).Market Structure and Competitive Conditions in the Arab GCC Banking System.Journal of Banking and Finance,30(12),3487-3501.
4. Amemiya, Takeshi(1985).Advanced Econometrics.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
5. Baumol, William J.,Panzar, John C.,Willig, Robert D.(1982).Contestable Markets: An Uprising in the Theory of Industry Structure.American Economic Review,72(1),1-15.
6. Berger, Allen N.(1995).The Profit-structure Relationship in Banking - Tests of Market-Power and Efficient-Structure Hypotheses.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,27(2),404-415.
7. Berger, Allen N.,Demsetz, Rebecca S.,Strahan, Philip E.(1999).The Consolidation of the Financial Services Industry: Causes, Consequences, and Implications for the Future.Journal of Banking and Finance,23(2),135-194.
8. Berger, Allen N.,Klapper, Leora F.,Turk-Ariss, Rima(2009).Bank Competition and Financial Stability.Journal of Financial Services Research,35(2),99-118.
9. Bikker, Jacob A.,Haaf, Katharina(2002).Competition, Concentration and Their Relationship: An Empirical Analysis of the Banking Industry.Journal of Banking and Finance,26(11),2191-2214.
10. Bresnahan, Timothy F.(1982).The Oligopoly Solution Identified.Economics Letters,10(1),19-27.
11. Carbó, Santiago,Humphrey, David,Maudos, Joaquín,Molyneux, Philip(2009).Crosscountry comparisons of competition and pricing power in European banking.Journal of International Money and Finance,28(1),115-134.
12. Casu, Barbara,Girardone, Claudia(2006).Bank Competition, Concentration and Efficiency in the Single European Market.The Manchester School,74(4),441-468.
13. Claessens, Stijn,Laeven, Luc(2004).What Drives Bank Competition? Some International Evidence.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,36(3),563-584.
14. De Bandt, Olivier,Davis, Eric Philip(2000).Competition, Contestability and Market Structure in European Banking Sectors on the Eve of EMU.Journal of Banking and Finance,24(6),1045-1066.
15. Demsetz, Harold(1973).Industry Structure, Market Rivalry, and Public Policy.Journal of Law and Economics,16(1),1-10.
16. Fernández de Guevara, Juan,Maudos, Joaquin,Pérez, Francisco(2007).Integration and Competition in the European Financial Markets.Journal of International Money and Finance,26(1),26-45.
17. Fernández de Guevara, Juan,Maudos, Joaquin,Pérez, Francisco(2005).Market Power in European Banking Sectors.Journal of Financial Services Research,27(2),109-137.
18. Gelos, Gaston,Roldós, Jorge E.(2004).Consolidation and Market Structure in Emerging Market Banking Systems.Emerging Markets Review,5(1),39-59.
19. Gilbert, Alton R.(1984).Bank Market Structure and Competition: A Survey.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,16(4),617-645.
20. Hannan, Timothy H.(1991).Foundations of the Structure-Conduct-Performance Paradigm in Banking.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,23(1),68-84.
21. Hempell, Hannah S.(2002).,Economic Research Centre, The Deutsche Bundesbank.
22. Hondroyiannis, George,Lolos, Sarantis,Papapetrou, Evangelia(1999).Assessing Competitive Conditions in the Greek Banking System.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,9(4),377-391.
23. Iwata, Gyoichi(1974).Measurement of Conjectural Variations in Oligopoly.Econometrica,42(5),947-966.
24. Jackson III, William E.(1997).Market Structure and the Speed of Adjustment: Evidence of Non-Monotonicity.Review of Industrial Organization,12(1),37-57.
25. Johnston, Jack,DiNardo, John(1997).Econometric Methods.Singapore:McGraw-Hill Book Company.
26. Matthews, Kent,Murinde, Victor,Zhao, Tianshu(2007).Competitive Conditions among the Major British Banks.Journal of Banking and Finance,31(7),2025-2042.
27. Molyneux, Phil,Lloyd-Williams, D. Michael,Thornton, John(1994).Competitive Conditions in European Banking.Journal of Banking and Finance,18(3),445-459.
28. Molyneux, Phil,Thornton, John,Lloyd-Williams, D. Michael(1996).Competition and Market Contestability in Japanese Commercial Banking.Journal of Economics and Business,48(1),33-45.
29. Nathan, Alli,Neave, Edwin H.(1989).Competition and Contestability in Canada's Financial System: Empirical Results.Canadian Journal of Economics,3(3),577-594.
30. Panzar, John C.,Rosse, James N.(1987).Testing for 'Monopoly' Equilibrium.Journal of Industrial Economics,35(4),443-456.
31. Schaeck, Klaus,Cihak, Martin,Wolfe, Simon(2009).Are Competitive Banking Systems More Stable?.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,41(4),711-734.
32. Shaffer, Sherrill(1982).A Non-Structural test for Competition in Financial Markets, In: Bank Structure and Competition.Conference Proceedings, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
33. Shaffer, Sherrill(2004).Patterns of Competition in Banking.Journal of Economics and Business,56(4),287-313.
34. Tsay, Wen-Jen,Huang, Cliff J.,Fu, Tsu-Tan,Ho, I-Lin(2013).A Simple Closed-Form Approximation for the Cumulative Distribution Function of the Composite Error of Stochastic Frontier Models.Journal of Productivity Analysis,39(3),259-269.
35. Turk-Ariss, Rima(2009).Competitive Behavior in Middle East and North Africa Banking Systems.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,49(2),693-710.
36. Turk-Ariss, Rima(2010).On the Implications of Market Power in Banking: Evidence from Developing Countries.Journal of Banking and Finance,34(4),765-775.
37. Vesala, Jukka(1995).,Bank of Finland Studies.
38. Yeyati, Eduardo Levy,Micco, Alejandro(2007).Concentration and Foreign Penetration in Latin American Banking Sectors: Impact on Competition and Risk.Journal of Banking and Finance,31(6),1633-1647.
39. Yuan, Yuan(2006).The State of Competition of the Chinese Banking Industry.Journal of Asian Economics,17(3),519-534.
40. 沈中華、呂美慧(2007)。本國銀行業逐年的競爭程度及其變化之分析。證券市場發展季刊，2(19)，119-152。

1. 黃台心,陳禹伶,邱義晃(2020)。運用隨機共同成本邊界函數聯合估計中國銀行業之成本效率及市場競爭度。經濟論文，48(3)，373-412。
2. 黃台心,林宜君(2023)。隨機共同邊界與要素內生性架構下探討我國會計師事務所之經濟效率。臺灣經濟預測與政策，53(2)，105-155。
3. (2024).Applying the Non-Standard Profit Function to Studying the Synergy of Taiwan's Commercial Banks.財務金融學刊,32(1),1-47.