题名

歷史唯物論中的結構與行動：資本主義起源論再探

并列篇名

Structure and Agency in Historical Materialism: A Re-examination of the Marxist Debates on the Origins of Capitalism

DOI

10.29816/TARQSS.200809.0004

作者

萬毓澤(Poe Yu-Ze Wan)

关键词

歷史唯物論 ； 結構與行動 ； 過渡論戰 ； 布蘭納論戰 ； 政治馬克思主義 ； 唯意志論 ； 柯恩 ； 卡林 ； historical materialism ； structure and agency ； transition debate ； Brenner debate ； political Marxism ； voluntarism ； G. A. Cohen ； Alan Carling

期刊名称

台灣社會研究季刊

卷期/出版年月

71期（2008 / 09 / 01）

页次

109 - 156

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

馬克思主義者向來對歷史唯物論持有不同見解，並且發展出幾種對資本主義起源的不同詮釋方式，至今仍然沒有定論。本文試圖在有限的字數內，以後者的相關討論為例，來勾勒一種比較靈活的歷史唯物論模型。本文首先追溯了第二國際以降馬克思主義歷史理論（尤其是G. A. Cohen）的發展（偏向結構決定論或某種版本的演化論），接著討論「政治馬克思主義」論者的作品（偏向唯意志論，強調資本主義純粹是階級鬥爭下的非意圖後果），最後本文引介了Alan Carling的作品，以他對資本主義的起源（封建分裂命題）與資本主義的勝利（競爭首要性命題）的分析為例，說明歷史唯物論有可能適當地將結構與行動因素整合進解釋架構之中，而不致偏廢任何一方。
英文摘要

Marxists have developed different interpretations of historical materialism, which in turn have informed the debates among Marxists over the origins of capitalism. This paper is an attempt to outline a more flexible version of historical materialism by taking stock of the related discussion on the origins of capitalism. I first trace the development of Marxist theory of history from the Second International to G. A. Cohen (which accepted a relatively more deterministic reading of Marxism and encouraged a certain variant of evolutionism), and then discuss works by ”political Marxists” on the agrarian capitalism in England (prone to voluntarism with their emphasis upon capitalism as an unintended consequence of class struggle). Finally, Alan Carling's works, which account for the rise and victory of capitalism on the basis of ”feudal fission thesis” and ”competitive primacy thesis”, are introduced to illustrate the possibility of incorporating both structure and agency into the explanatory framework of historical materialism.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會學
参考文献
  1. 萬毓澤(2006)。義大利自主主義運動與政治馬克思主義：對《帝國》的脈絡化解讀與批判。政治與社會哲學評論，18，93-149。
    連結：
  2. Amin, Samir(1985).Modes of Production: History and Unequal Development.Science and Society,49(1),194-207.
  3. Anderson, Perry(1976).Considerations on Western Marxism.London:New Left Books.
  4. Anderson, Perry(1980).Arguments Within English Marxism.London:Verso.
  5. Anderson, Perry、郭方、劉健譯(2001)。從古代到封建主義的過渡。上海:上海人民出版社。
  6. Archer, Margaret(1995).Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  7. Aston, Trevor Henry,C.H.E. Philpin (eds.)(1985).The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  8. Barker, Cohn(1996).Challenging the Bourgeois Paradigm.Monthly Review,48(7),41-48.
  9. Bensald, Daniel(2002).Marx for Our Times: Adventures and Misadventures of a Critique.London:Verso.
  10. Bertram, Christopher(1990).International Competition in Historical Materialism.New Left Review,183,116-128.
  11. Bhaskar, Roy(1998).The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences.London:Routledge.
  12. Bhaskar, Roy(1978).A Realist Theory of Science.Hassocks, Sussex:Harvester Press.
  13. Bisson, Thomas N.(1994).The `Feudal Revolution`.Past and Present,142,6-42.
  14. Blackledge, Paul(2004).Review of Socialist Darwin ism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought from Marx to Bernstein.Historical Materialism,12(1),213-232.
  15. Blackledge, Paul(2003).Political Marxism: Towards an Immanent Critique.Studies in Marxism,9,1-20.
  16. Blackledge, Paul,Graeme Kirkpatrick (eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Social Evolution.New York:Palgrave.
  17. Blackledge, Paul,Graeme Kirkpatrick(eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Social Evolution.New York:Palgrave.
  18. Blackledge, Paul,Jacques Bidet,Stathis Kouvelakis (eds.)(2008).Critical Companion to Contemporary Marxism.Leiden:Brill.
  19. Bois, Guy(1984).The Crisis of Feudalism: Economy and Society in Eastern Normandy c. 1300-1550.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  20. Bois, Guy(1992).The Transformation of the Year One Thousand: The Village of Lournand from Antiquity to Feudalism.Manchester:Manchester University Press.
  21. Bois, Guy,T. H. Aston,C. H. E. Philpin (eds.)(1985).The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  22. Brenner, Robert(1993).Merchants and Revolution.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  23. Brenner, Robert(1977).The Origins of Capitalist Development A Critique of Neo-Smithian Marxism.New Left Review,104,25-92.
  24. Brenner, Robert(1978).Dobb on the Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism.Cambridge Journal of Economics,2,121-140.
  25. Brenner, Robert,A. L. Brier (eds.)(1989).The First Modern Society.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  26. Brenner, Robert,Daniel Chirot (ed.)(1991).The Origins of Backwardness in Eastern Europe.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  27. Brenner, Robert,John Roemer (ed.)(1986).Analytical Marxism.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  28. Brenner, Robert,T. H. Aston,C. H. E. Philpin (eds.)(1985).The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-industrial Europe.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  29. Brenner, Robert,T. H. Aston,C. H. E. Philpin (eds.)(1985).The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-industrial Europe.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  30. Buican, Denis、史美珍譯(1999)。達爾文與達爾文主義。北京:商務印書館。
  31. Bunge, Mario(1997).Mechanism and Explanation.Philosophy of the Social Sciences,27,410-465.
  32. Bunge, Mario(1998).Social Science under Debate.Toronto:University of Toronto Press.
  33. Bunge, Mario(1999).The Sociology-Philosophy Connection.New Brunswick and London:Transaction.
  34. Callinicos, Alex(2004).The Revolutionary Ideas of Karl Marx.London:Bookmarks.
  35. Callinicos, Alex(2007).Making History: Agency, Structure, and Change in Social Theory.Amsterdam:Brill Academic Press.
  36. Callinicos, Alex(1995).Theories and Narratives: Reflections on the Philosophy of History.Durham:Duke University Press.
  37. Callinicos, Alex(2007).Social Theory: A Historical Introduction.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  38. Callinicos, Alex(1999).The Limits of `Political Marxism`.New Left Review,184,110-115.
  39. Callinicos, Alex(2003).Classical Historical Materialism in the Face of the 21st Century.paper presented at the conference of the Marxism Specialist Group, Political Studies Association
  40. Callinicos, Alex(1983).Marxism and Philosophy.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  41. Callinicos, Alex(1990).In Defence of Rational Choice: A Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood.New Left Review,184,97-109.
  42. Callinicos, Alex(1994).England`s Transition to Capitalism.New Left Review,207,124-133.
  43. Callinicos, Alex,Paul Blackledge,Graeme Kirkpatrick (eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Social Evolution.New York:Paigrave.
  44. Caning, Alan,Paul Nolan(2000).Historical Materialism, Natural Selection, and World History.Historical Materialism,6,215-264.
  45. Carling, Alan(2004).The Darwinian Weberian: W. G. Runciman and the Microfoundations of Historical Materialism.Historical Materialism,12(1),71-95.
  46. Carling, Alan(1991).Social Division.London:Verso.
  47. Carling, Alan(1993).Analytical Marxism and Historical Materialism: The Debate on Social Evolution.Science and Society,57(1),31-65.
  48. Carling, Alan,Paul Wetherly(ed.)(1992).Marx`s Theory of History: The Contemporary Debate.Aldershot:Avebury.
  49. Cohen, G. A.(2000).Karl Marx`s Theory of History: A Defence.Princeton, N.J.:Princeton University Press.
  50. Cohen, G. A.,Will Kymlicka(1988).Human Nature and Social Change in the Marxist Conception of History.The Journal of Philosophy,85(4),171-179.
  51. Comnimel, George(1987).Rethinking the French Revolution.London:Verso.
  52. Creaven, Sean(2007).Emergentist Marxism: Dialectical Philosophy and Social Theory.London:Routledge.
  53. Creaven, Sean(2000).Marxism and Realism: A Materialistic Application of Realism in the Social Sciences.London:Routledge.
  54. Asiatic, Tributary or Absolutist?
  55. Deutscher, Isaac(1984).Marxism, Wars, and Revolution: Essays from Four Decades.London:Verso.
  56. Duby, Georges(1976).Rural Economy and Country Life in the Medieval West.Columbia:University of South Carolina Press.
  57. Duby, Georges(1980).The Three Orders: Feudal Society Imagined.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  58. Duchesne, Ricardo(1993).Debating the Transition to Capitalism.Science and Society,57(1),80-86.
  59. Engels, Friedrich(1999)。反杜林論。北京:人民出版社。
  60. Engels, Friedrich(1995)。馬克思恩格斯選集。北京:人民出版社。
  61. Engels, Friedrich(1995)。恩格斯致彼·拉·拉甫羅夫。北京:人民出版社。
  62. Fine, Ben,Lawrence Harris(1979).Rereading Capital.New York:Columbia University Press.
  63. Foster, John Bellamy(2000).Marx`s & Ecology: Materialism and Nature.New York:Monthly Review Press.
  64. Gerstenberger, Heide(2007).Impersonal Power: History and Theory of the Bourgeois State.Leiden:Brill.
  65. Gilpin, Robert(1981).War and Change in World Politics.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  66. Gottlieb, Roger(1987).Historical Materialism, Historical Laws and Social Primacy: Further Discussion on the Transition Debate.Science and Society,51(2),188-199.
  67. Gottlieb, Roger(1984).Feudalism, and Historical Materialism: A Critique and a Synthesis.Science and Society,48(1),1-37.
  68. Gould, Stephen Jay、田洺譯(1996)。自達爾文以來：自然史沈思錄。北京:三聯書店。
  69. Harman, Chris(2006).Shedding New Light on the Dark Ages.International Socialism,109,187-191.
  70. Harman, Chris(1998).Marxism and History.London:Bookmarks.
  71. Harman, Chris(2004).The Rise of Capitalism.International Socialism,102,53-86.
  72. Harman, Chris(1998).Marxism and History.London:Bookmarks.
  73. Harman, Chris(1999).Footnotes and Fallacies: A Comment on Robert Brenner`s `The Economics of Global Turbulence`.Historical Materialism,4,95-104.
  74. Harman, Chris,Robert Brenner(2006).The Origins of Capitalism.International Socialism,111,127-165.
  75. Harré, Rom,Edward H. Madden(1975).Causal Powers.Oxford:Blackwell.
  76. Heller, Henry(1985).The Transition Debate in Historical Perspective.Science and Society,49(1),208-213.
  77. Hilton Rodney (ed.)(1976).The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism.London:NLB.
  78. Hoffman, John(1985).The Dialectic of Abstraction and Concentration in Historical Materialism.Science and Society,49(4),451-462.
  79. Katz, Claudio(1994).Debating the Dynamics of Feudalism: Challenges for Historical Materialism.Science and Society,58(2),195-204.
  80. Kautsky, Karl(1996).The Road to Power.New Jersey:Humanities Press.
  81. Kautsky, Karl(1988).The Materialist Conception of History.New Haven:Yale University Press.
  82. Kriedte, Peter(1983).Peasants, Landlords, and Merchant Capitalists: Europe and the World Economy, 1500-1800.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  83. Laibman, David(1987).Modes and Transitions: Replies to the Discussion and Further Comments.Science and Society,51(2),179-187.
  84. Laibman, David(1984).Modes of Production and Theories of Transition.Science and Society,48(3),257-294.
  85. Levine Andrew,Elliot Sober(1985).What`s Historical about Historical Materialism.Journal of Philosophy,6,304-326.
  86. Levine Andrew,Elliot Sober(2003).A Reply to Paul Nolan`s What`s Darwinian About Historical Materialism? A Critique of Levine and Sober.Historical Materialism,11(3),177-181.
  87. Levine Andrew,Erik Olin Wright,Elliot Sober(1992).Reconstructing Marxism.London:Verso.
  88. Lockwood, David,George K. Zollschan,Walter Hirsch (eds.)(1964).Explorations in Social Change.Boston:Houghton Muffin.
  89. Löwy Michael(1993).On Changing the World Essays in Political Philosophy, from Karl Marx to Walter Benjamin.London:Humanities Press.
  90. Lukiács Georg、杜章智譯(1992)。歷史與階級意識：關於馬克思主義辯證法的研究。北京:商務印書館。
  91. Maddison, Angus(1982).Phases of Capitalist Development.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
  92. Mandel, Ernest、孟捷譯(2002)。權力與貨幣：馬克思主義的官僚理論。北京:中央編譯出版社。
  93. Mann, Michael、劉北成、李少軍譯(2002)。社會權力的來源。上海:上海人民出版社。
  94. Marx, Karl(1995)。馬克思恩格斯選集。北京:人民出版社。
  95. Marx, Karl(1995)。馬克思恩格斯選集。北京:人民出版社。
  96. Marx, Karl(2001)。路易·波拿巴的霧月十八日。北京:人民出版社。
  97. Marx, Karl、Friedhch Engels(1995)。馬克思恩格斯選集。北京:人民出版社。
  98. Marx, Karl、Friedrich Engels、中共中央馬克思恩格斯列寧斯大林著作編譯局譯(1957)。馬克思恩格斯全集。北京:人民出版社。
  99. Marx, Karl、中共中央馬克思恩格斯列寧斯大林著作編譯局譯(2004)。資本論。北京:人民出版社。
  100. McLennan, Gregor(1986).Marxist Theory and Historical Research: Between the Hard and the Soft Options.Science and Society,50(1),157-165.
  101. McNally, David(1988).Political Economy and the Rise of Capitalism: A Reinterpretation.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  102. Mielants, Eric H.(2007).The Origins of Capitalism and the "Rise of the West".Philadelphia:Temple University Press.
  103. Milonakis, Dimitris(1997).The Dynamics of History: Structure and Agency in Historical Evolution.Science and Society,61(3),303-329.
  104. Milonakis, Dimitris(1993).Prelude to the Genesis of Capitalism: The Dynamics of the Feudal Mode of Production.Science and Society,57(4),390-419.
  105. Molyneux John(1995).Is Marxism Deterministic?.International Socialism,68,37-74.
  106. Mooers, Colin(1991).The Making of Bourgeois Europe: Absolutism, Revolution, and the Rise of Capitalism in England, France, and Germany.London:Verso.
  107. Mouzelis, Nicos(1991).Back to Sociological Theory: The Construction of Social Orders.London:Macmillan.
  108. Nolan, Paul(2002).What`s Darwinian about Historical Materialism? A Critique of Levine and Sober.Historical Materialism,10(2),143-169.
  109. Nolan, Paul(2003).Levine and Sober: A Rejoinder.Historical Materialism,11(3),183-200.
  110. Nolan, Paul,Paul Blackledge,Graeme Kirkpatrick (eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Social Evolution.New York:Palgrave.
  111. Okisbio, Nobuo(1961).Technical Changes and the Rate of Profit.Kobe University Economic Review,7,86-99.
  112. Perry, Matt(2002).Marxism and History.New York:Palgrave.
  113. Pirenne, Henri、樂文譯(2001)。中世紀歐洲經濟社會史。上海:上海人民出版社。
  114. Polanyi, Karl、許寶強、渠敬東編(2000)。反市場的資本主義。香港:牛津大學出版社。
  115. Postan, Michael Moissey(1975).The Medieval Economy and Society: An Economic History of Britain in the Middle Ages.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
  116. Prinz, Arthur M.(1969).Background and Ulterior Motive of Marx`s `Preface` of 1859.Journal of the History of Ideas,30(3),437-450.
  117. Rees, John(1998).The Algebra of Revolution: The Dialectic and the Classical Marxist Tradition.London:Routledge.
  118. Rigby, Stephen H.(2004).Historical Materialism: Social Structure and Social Change in the Middle Ages.Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies,34(3),473-522.
  119. Rudra, Ashok(1987).The Transition Debate: Lessons for Third World Marxists.Science and Society,51(2),170-178.
  120. Ruggie, John、Robert O. Keohane編、郭樹勇譯(2002)。新現實主義及其批判。北京:北京大學出版社。
  121. Runciman, Walter Garrison(1983).A Treatise on Social Theory.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  122. Runciman, Walter Garrison(1997).A Treatise on Social Theory.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  123. Runciman, Walter Garrison(1989).A Treatise on Social Theory.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  124. Sen, Amartya、劉楚俊譯(2001)。經濟發展與自由。台北:先覺。
  125. Smith, Adam、郭大力、王亞南譯(1972)。國民財富的性質和原因的研究。北京:商務印書館。
  126. Smith, Tony,Paul Blackledge,Graeme Kirkpatrick (eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Social Evolution.New York:Palgrave.
  127. Sober, Elliot(1993).The Nature of Selection Evolutionary Theory in Philosophical Focus.Chicago:Chicago University Press.
  128. Spruyt, Hendrik(1994).The Sovereign State and its Competitors An Analysis of Systems Change.Princeton, N J:Princeton University Press.
  129. Sweezy, Paul.(1986).Feudalism-to-Capitalism Revisited.Science and Society,50(1),81-84.
  130. Sweezy, Paul,Rodney Hilton (ed.)(1976).The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism.London:NLB.
  131. Teschke, Benno(1998).Geopolitical Relations in the European Middle Ages History and Theory.International Organization,52(2),325-358.
  132. Teschke, Benno(2003).The Myth of 1648: Class Geopolitics, and the Making of Modern International Relations.London:Verso.
  133. Timpanaro, Sebastiano(1975).On Materialism.London:New Left Books.
  134. Verhulst, Adriaan、徐家玲編譯、侯建新編(2002)。經濟－社會史：歷史研究的新方向。北京:商務印書館。
  135. Waltz, Kenneth、信強譯(2003)。國際政治理論。上海:上海人民出版社。
  136. Weikart, Richard(1998).Socialist Darwinism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought from Marx to Bernstein.San Francisco:International Scholars.
  137. Wickham, Chris(1985).The Uniqueness of the East.Journal of Peasant Studies,12(2-3),166-196.
  138. Wolf, Eric、賈士蘅譯(2003)。歐洲與沒有歷史的人。台北:麥田。
  139. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(1990).Explaining Everything or Nothing?.New Left Review,184,116-128.
  140. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(1999).The Origin of Capitalism.New York:Monthly Review Press.
  141. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(1985).Marxism and the Course of History.New Left Review,147,95-107.
  142. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(1981).The Separation of the Economic and the Political in Capitalism.New Left Review,127,66-95.
  143. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(1995).Democracy against Capitalism.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  144. Wood, Ellen Meiksins(2003).The Empire of Capital.London:Verso.
  145. Wood, Ellen Meiksins,Mark Rupert,Hazel Smith (eds.)(2002).Historical Materialism and Globalization.New York:Routledge.
  146. Wright, Erik Olin(1983).Giddens`s Critique of Marxism.New Left Review,138,11-35.
  147. 何順果(2003)。東歐「再版農奴制」莊園經濟的性質問題。歷史研究，4，111-123。
  148. 徐家玲侯建新編(2002)。經濟－社會史：歷史研究的新方向。北京:商務印書館。
  149. 《二十一世紀》網路版
  150. 黃宗智(1994)。長江三角洲小農家庭與鄉村發展，1350-1988。香港:牛津大學。
  151. 萬毓澤(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣大學社會學研究所。
  152. 萬毓澤(2007)。「當前的問題即歷史問題」：90年後回顧俄國十月革命。思想，7，19-53。
  153. 萬毓澤譯、Alex Callinicos(2007)。創造歷史：社會理論中的行動、結構與變遷。台北:群學。
  154. 劉景華、侯建新編(2002)。經濟－社會史：歷史研究的新方向。北京:商務印書館。
  155. 《二十一世紀》網路版
被引用次数
  1. 謝旭昇、葉光毅(2012)。存在於「政策研擬」與「歷史看法」之間的一些課題。東亞論壇，475，61-72。
  2. 張時健(2010)。美國影視產業的聚合性質—藉電視法案Finsyn與PTAR立廢的政治經濟脈絡理解之。新聞學研究，102，327-364。
  3. 張又升(2021)。空中相遇：阿圖塞的馬基維利閱讀與托洛茨基的雙重命題。政治與社會哲學評論，75，55-128。
print cancel