西方友誼研究及其在地用處初探

Occidental Friendship Studies and Its Possible Use in the Chinese Context

朱偉誠(Wei-Cheng Chu)

大歷史 ； 現代性 ； 友誼政治 ； 平等主義 ； 同性戀 ； macro-history ； modernity ； politics of friendship ； egalitarianism ； homosexuality

台灣社會研究季刊

99期（2015 / 06 / 01）

1 - 77

繁體中文

本論文從友誼在古今論述中之地位差異出發，先綜覽西方當代有大幅進展之友誼研究成果，尤其集中於兩位有特殊貢獻之學者，即布睿與希佛的主要研究發明，並將之對比參照以勾勒西方友誼之大歷史，同時也對現代性與現代的友誼狀況有所說明。論文的第二部分則關注歷來友誼論述與實踐最引人興味之處，即友誼之平等主義意含及其在傳統上所具有的政治挑戰效果，乃至後來被吸納為現代國族主義民主之主流意識形態，也即德希德《友愛政治》一書加以解構之由。第三部分將焦點轉回我們所處身之中文語境，探討中國家族宗法社會對於友誼歷來的懷疑看法以及晚期（晚明）進步知識份子的顛覆挪用（包括西方友論透過利瑪竇之引進），後來卻在現代西化的外來語境中直接越過。最後一部分由當代友誼與同性戀之糾結出發，透過福寇「友誼做為一種生活方式」的提法，試探性地提出在當代狀況中友誼仍可能具有之進步潛能。

This essay starts with a general survey of contemporary occidental friendship studies in its present condition by focusing in particular on two scholars with major contributions to the field, namely Alan Bray and Allan Silver, whose works are then juxtaposed in a ＂debate＂ for the purpose of mapping out the macro-history of occidental friendship as well as throwing a new light on modernity from this perspective. The second part foregrounds one of the most intriguing aspects of friendship either as practice or discourse, i.e. the egalitarian politics of friendship that has posed as a challenge to the established order before it is adopted as the dominant ideology of modern nationalist democracy (which is why Jacques Derrida deconstructs it in his Politics of Friendship). The third part turns to explore the ＂suspicious＂ status of friendship in the traditional, family-centered Chinese context, friendship's subversive use in this regard in the late imperial times (late Ming), and its oblivion in the modern process of modernization. The fourth as well as the last part concludes the essay with a tentative exposition of the continuing progressive potential of friendship ＂as a way of life,＂ based on its modern conflation with homosexuality.

1. Patapan, H.、黃俊龍譯、汪宏倫校訂(2003)。朋友與公民：轉變中的現代共同體基礎。政治與社會哲學評論，6，1-26。
   連結：
2. Tsai、 Hsiu-chih(2008).The stranger's friendship on the battlefield: The performance of xenia in the Iliad.臺大文史哲學報,69,185-221.
   連結：
3. 朱偉誠(2001)。詭異的鏡像：透過馬婁的《愛德華二世》來看中國古典男色的「君臣篇」。英美文學評論，5，123-70。
   連結：
4. 林淑芬(2015)。創作論：洪希耶的歷史與政治書寫。中外文學，43(4)，17-58。
   連結：
5. 黃文樹(2006)。李贄與利瑪竇的交誼及其「友論」之比較。玄奘佛學研究，5，127-52。
   連結：
6. 廖珮芸(2010)。從《教坊記》之「香火兄弟」則探討唐代特殊的婚姻關係與性別意義。東海中文學報，22，27-52。
   連結：
7. 何永佶。1932。〈提倡第六倫道德〉。《民聲週報：自第四期至第三十二期》，民國史料叢書．中國青年黨史料叢刊3。陳正茂編，《民聲週報》18（2 月23 日）：9-12。台北：國史館。
8. 《拉媽報》。2007 年3 月31 日。〈拉弗與舞邦〉。《蕃薯藤．天空部落》網址：http://blog.yam.com/la_ma_news/article/9153875（上網日期：2014 年1 月15 日）
9. Derrida, J. 1997. Politics and friendship: A discussion with Jacques Derrida. By Geoffrey Bennington. Hydra. Peter Krapp. Web. 15 Janurary 2014
10. Dugas, L. 1914[1894]. L'Amitié antique. 2nd ed. Paris: Librairie Félix Alcan
11. 邊緣同志南區原住民小組。2007。〈封面故事的延伸討論〉。《拉媽報》3 月31 日。網址：http://blog.yam.com/la_ma_news/article/9153706（上網日期：2014年1月15日）
12. Mills, L. J. 1937. One soul in bodies twain: Friendship in Tudor literature and Stuart drama. Bloomington: Principia Press
13. Carpenter, E. 1920. Ioläus: An anthology of friendship. London: George Allen and Unwin
14. Gee, S. 2001. Alan Bray: Unearthing the history of gay Britain. Guardian 18 December. Web. 15 January 2014
15. (1997)。元明史料筆記叢刊。北京:中華書局。
16. 「朋友」項目組編(2009)。『朋友』十年選萃。青島:
17. 「朋友」項目組編(2009)。『朋友』十年選萃。青島:
18. 「朋友」項目組編(2009)。『朋友』十年選萃。青島:
19. 「朋友」項目組編(2009)。『朋友』十年選萃。青島:
20. Agamben, G.,Kishik, David(Trans.),Pedatella, Stefan(Trans.)(2009).What is an apparatus? And other essays.Stanford:Stanford UP..
21. Aggleton, Peter(Ed.),Hart, Graham(Ed.),Davies, Peter(Ed.)(1999).Families and communities responding to AIDS.London:UCL Press.
22. Alexander, Jeffrey C.(Ed.)(1988).Durkheimian sociology: Cultural studies.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
23. Allan, G.(1979).A sociology of friendship and kinship.London:George Allen and Unwin.
24. Allan, G.(1989).Friendship: Developing a sociological perspective.Hemel Hempstead, Eng.:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
25. Allen, D. S.(2004).Talking to strangers: Anxieties of citizenship since Brown v. Board of Education.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
26. Arendt, H.(1998).The human condition.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
27. Ariès, Philippe(dir.),Duby, Georges(dir.)(1985).Histoire de la vie privée.Paris:Seuil.
28. Ariès, Philippe(dir.),Duby, Georges(dir.)(1985).Histoire de la vie privée.Paris:Seuil.
29. Ariès, Philippe(dir.),Duby, Georges(dir.)(1985).Histoire de la vie privée.Paris:Seuil.
30. Ariès, Philippe(dir.),Duby, Georges(dir.)(1985).Histoire de la vie privée.Paris:Seuil.
31. Ariès, Philippe(dir.),Duby, Georges(dir.)(1985).Histoire de la vie privée.Paris:Seuil.
32. Aurelius, Marcus,Fronto, Marcus Cornelius,Richlin, Amy(Ed. Trans.)(2006).2006. Marcus Aurelius in love.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
33. Badhwar, Neera K.(2008).Friendship and commercial society.Politics, Philosophy and Economics,7(3),301-26.
34. Badhwar, Neera Kapur(Ed.)(1993).Friendship: A philosophical reader.Ithaca, NY:Cornell UP.
35. Bauman, Z.(1991).Modernity and ambivalence.Cambridge:Polity.
36. Bech, H.,Mesquit, Teresa(Trans.),Davies, Tim(Trans.)(1997).When men meet: Homosexuality and modernity.Cambridge:Polity.
37. Bell, R. R.(1981).Worlds of friendship.Beverly Hills:Sage.
38. Bell, Sandra(Ed.),Coleman, Simon(Ed.)(1999).The anthropology of friendship.Oxford:Berg.
39. Bellah, R. N.(2007).Habits of the heart: Individualism and commitment in American life.Berkeley:U of California P..
40. Bergeron, D. M.(1999).King James and letters of homoerotic desire.Iowa City:U of Iowa P..
41. Blosser, P.(Ed.),Bradley, Marschell Carl(Ed.)(1997).Friendship: Philosophic reflections on a perennial concern.Lanham:UP of America.
42. Blundell, M. W.(1989).Helping friends and harming enemies: A study in Sophocles and Greek ethics.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
43. Boswell, J.(1981).Christianity, social tolerance, and homosexuality: Gay people in western Europe form the beginning of the Christian era to the fourteeth century.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
44. Boswell, J.(1994).Same-sex unions in pre-modern Europe.New York:Vintage.
45. Brain, R.(1976).Friends and lovers.New York:Basic Books.
46. Bray, A.(2003).The friend.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
47. Bray, A.(1988).Homosexuality in Renaissance England.London:GMP..
48. Brod, Harry(Ed.)(1987).The making of masculinities: The new men's studies.Boston:Allen and Unwin.
49. Brown, E. A. R.(1997).Introduction (to: Ritual Brotherhood in Ancient and Medieval Europe: A Symposium).Traditio,52,261-83.
50. Brunkhorst, H.,Flynn, Jeffrey(Trans.)(2005).Solidarity: From civic friendship to a global legal community.Cambridge, MA:MIT P..
51. Bryant, T. L.(1990).Sons and lovers: Adoption in Japan.American Journal of Comparative Law,38,299-336.
52. Butler, J.(2000).Antigone's claim: Kinship between life and death.New York:Columbia UP.
53. Caine, Barbara(Ed.)(2009).Friendship: A history.London:Equinox.
54. Carroll, L.(2009).University of Pittsburg.
55. Chauncey, G.(2005).Why marriage? The history shaping today's debate over gay equality.New York:Basic Books.
56. Chiba、 S.(1995).Hannah Arendt on love and the political: Love, friendship, and citizenship.Review of Politics,57(3),505-35.
57. Clunas, C.(2004).Elegant debts: The social art of Wen Zengming, 1470-1559.London:Reaktion.
58. Cobb, M.(2012).Single: Arguments for the uncoupled.New York:NYU P..
59. Cole, S.(2003).Modernism, male friendship, and the First World War.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
60. Connor, W. R.(1992).The new politicians of fifth-century Athens.Indianapolis:Hackett..
61. Cooper, J. M.(1999).Reason and emotion: Essays on ancient moral psychology and ethical theory.Princeton:Princeton UP..
62. Cosslett, T.(1988).Woman to woman: Female friendship in Victorian fiction.Brighton, Eng:Harvester.
63. D'Elia, Pasquale M.(1956).Further Notes on Matteo Ricci's De Amicitia.Monumenta Serica,25(1),356-77.
64. DeMott, B.(1998).The trouble with friendship: Why Americans can't think straight about race.New Haven:Yale UP..
65. Deneen, P. J.(2001).Friendship and politics: Ancient and American.Friends and citizens: Essays in honor of Wilson Carey McWilliams,Lanham:
66. Derlega, V. J.(Ed.),Winstead, Barbara A.(Ed.)(1986).Friendship and social interaction.New York:Springer-Verlag..
67. Derrida, J.,Brault, Pascale-Anne(Trans.),Naas, Michael(Trans.)(1999).Adieu: To Emmanuel Levinas.Stanford:Stanford UP.
68. Derrida, J.,Collins, George(Trans.)(1997).Politics of friendship.London:Verso.
69. Descharmes(Ed.),Heuser(Ed.),Krüger(Ed.),Loy(Ed.)(2011).Varieties of friendship: Interdisciplinary perspectives on social relationships.
70. Devere, H.(2000).Reviving Greco-Roman friendship: A bibliographical review.Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy,2(4),149-87.
71. Devere, H.,Smith, Graham M.(2010).Friendship and politics.Political Studies Review,8,341-56.
72. Donalson, M.(2005).Masculinity in the interracial buddy film.Jefferson:McFarland.
73. Dyzenhaus, D.(1997).Legality and legitimacy: Carl Schmitt, Hans Kelsen and Hermann Heller in Weimar.Oxford:Oxford UP..
74. Eisenstadt, S. N.(1956).Ritualized personal relations: Blood brotherhood, best friends, compadre, etc.-Some comparative hypotheses and suggestions.Man,56,90-95.
75. Eisenstadt, S. N.,Roniger, L.(1984).Patrons, clients and friends: Interpersonal relations and the structure of trust in society.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
76. Elkana, Yehuda(Ed.)(2002).Unraveling ties: From social cohesion to new practices of connectednesss.Frankfurt:Campus Verlag.
77. Eskridge, W. N., Jr.(2008).Dishonorable passions: Sodomy laws in America, 1861-2003.New York:Viking.
78. Evrigenis, I. D.(2008).Fear of enemies and collective action.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
79. Faderman, L.(2001).Surpassing the love of men: Romantic friendship and love between women from the Renaissance to the present.New York:Perennial.
80. Ferguson, G.(2008).Queer (re)readings in the French Renaissance: Homosexuality, gender, culture.England:Ashgate.
81. Forster, E. M.(2006).The longest journey.London:Penguin Classics.
82. Forster, E. M.(1972).Two cheers for democracy.London:Edward Arnold.
83. Foucault, M.,Rabinow, Paul(Ed.),Hurley, Robert(Trans.)(2000).Essential works of Foucault 1954-1984.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
84. Friedman, M.(1993).What are friends for? Feminist perspectives on personal relationships and moral theory.Ithaca:Cornell UP..
85. Giddens, A.(1992).The transformation of intimacy: Sexuality, love and eroticism in modern societies.Cambridge:Polity Press.
86. Giddens, A.(1991).Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age.Stanford:Stanford UP..
87. Godbeer, R.(2009).The overflowing of friendship: Love between men and the creation of the American republic.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins UP..
88. Gold, T. B.(1985).After comradeship: Personal relations in China since the cultural revolution.China Quarterly,104,657-75.
89. Goldberg, J.(1994).Queering the Renaissance.Durham, NC:Duke UP.
90. Goldberg, J.(1994).Queering the Renaissance.Durham, NC:Duke UP..
91. Goldhill, S.(1986).Reading Greek tragedy.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
92. Halperin, D. M.(1990).One hundred years of homosexuality: And other essays on Greek love.New York:Routledge.
93. Harvey, Karen(ed.)(2005).The kiss in history.Manchester:Manchester UP..
94. Herman, G.(1987).Ritualised friendship and the Greek city.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
95. Hill, L.,McCarthy, Peter(2000).Hume, Smith and Ferguson: Friendship in commerical society.Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy,2(4),33-49.
96. Hill, L.,McCarthy, Peter(2004).On friendship and necessitudo in Adam Smith.History of the Human Sciences,17(4),1-16.
97. Honneth, A.,Ganahl, Joseph(Trans.)(2014).Freedom's right: The social foundations of democratic life.New York:Columbia UP..
98. Huang, M. W.(2007).Male friendship and jiangxue (philosophical debates) in sixteenth-century China.Nan Nü,9,146-78.
99. Huang, M. W.(2007).Male friendship in Ming China: An introduction.Nan Nü,9,2-33.
100. Huang, M. W.(Ed.)(2007).Male friendship in Ming China.Leiden:Brill.
101. Hudson, Wayne(Ed.),Slaughter, Steve(Ed.)(2007).Globalisation and citizenship: The transnational challenge.Abingdon:Routledge.
102. Hunt, L.(1992).The family romance of the French Revolution.London:Routledge.
103. Hutson, L.(1994).The Usurer's daughter: Male friendship and fictions of women in sixteenthcentury England.London:Routledge.
104. Hutter, H.(1978).Politics as friendship.Waterloo, Canada:Wilfrid Laurier UP..
105. Hyatte, R.(1994).The arts of friendship: The idealization of friendship in medieval and early Renaissance literature.Leiden:Brill.
106. Jacobsen, Michael Hviid(Ed.),Poder, Poul(Ed.)(2008).The Sociology of Zygmunt Bauman: Challenges and critique.Aldershot:Ashgate.
107. Jaeger, C. S.(1999).Ennobling love: In search of a lost sensibility.Philadelphia:U of Pennsylvania P..
108. Jamieson, L.(1998).Intimacy: Personal relationship in modern societies.Cambridge:Polity.
109. Jamieson, L.、蔡明璋譯(2002)。親密關係：現代社會的私人關係。台北:群學。
110. Johnson, E. J.(2003).Once there were two true Friends, or idealized male friendship in French narrative from the middle ages through the Enlightenment.Birmingham, AL:Summa.
111. Jordan, D. K.(1985).Sworn brothers: A study in Chinese ritual kinship (with an appendix on sworn brotherhood and folk law).中國家族及其儀式行為,台北=Taipei:
112. Jordan, M. D.(Ed.),Sweeney, Meghan T.(Ed.),Mellott, David M.(Ed.)(2006).Authorizing marriage: Canon, tradition, and critique in the blessing of same-sex union.Princeton:Princeton UP..
113. Kaplan, D.(2006).The men we loved: Male friendship and nationalism in Israeli culture.New York:Berghahn Books.
114. Kaplan, D.(2007).What can the concept of friendship contribute to the study of national identity.Nations and Nationalism,13(2),225-44.
115. Kaplan, M. A.(2010).Friendship fictions: The rhetoric of citizenship in the liberal imaginary.Tuscaloosa:U of Alabama P..
116. Kent, F. W.(Ed.),Simons, Patricia(Ed.),Eade, J. C.(Ed.)(1987).Patronage, art, and society in Renaissance Italy.Canberra:Humanities Research Centre.
117. King, Preston(Ed.),Devere, Heather(Ed.)(2000).The challenge to friendship in modernity.Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy,2(4)
118. Klinenberg, E.(2002).Heat wave: A social autopsy of disaster in Chicago.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
119. Konstan, D.(1997).Friendship in the classical world.New York:Cambridge UP..
120. Konstan, D.(1994).Friendship and the state.Hyperboreus,1(2),1-16.
121. Kutcher, N.(2000).The fifth relationship: Dangerous friendships in the Confucian context.American Historical Review,106,1615-29.
122. Leaman, Oliver(Ed.)(1996).Friendship East and West: Philosophical perspectives.Richmond, Eng.:Curzon.
123. Leib, E. J.(2011).Friend v. Friend: The transformation of friendship-and what the law has to do with it.New York:Oxford UP..
124. Lewis, C. S.(1990).Four loves.Orlando:Harvest.
125. Leyton, E.(Ed.)(1974).The compact: Selected dimensions of friendship,Newfoundland:
126. Lochman, Daniel T.(Ed.),López, Maritere(Ed.),Hutson, Lorna(Ed.)(2010).Discourses and representations of friendship in early modern Europe, 1500-1700.Farnham, Eng.:Ashgate.
127. Louie, K.(2002).Theorising Chinese masculinity: Society and gender in China.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
128. Love, H.(2007).Feeling backward: Loss and the politics of queer history.Cambridge, MA:Harvard UP.
129. Lucian,Harmon, A. M.(1996).Lucian.Cambridge:Harvard UP..
130. Luftig, V.(1993).Seeing together: Friendship between the sexes in English writing, from mill to woolf.Stanford:Stanford UP..
131. Lynch, J. H.(1986).Godparents and kinship in early medieval Europe.Princeton:Princeton UP..
132. Lynch, J. H.(1998).Christianizing kinship: Ritual sponsorship in Anglo-Saxon England.Ithaca:Cornell UP..
133. MacPhail, E.(1989).Friendship as a political ideal in Montaigne's Essais.Montaigne Studies,1,177-87.
134. Marcus, S.(2007).Between women: Friendship, desire, and marriage in Victorian England.Princeton:Princeton UP..
135. Martel, J. R.(2001).Love is a sweet chain: Desire, autonomy, and friendship in liberal political theory.New York:Routledge.
136. Martin, B. J.(2011).Napoleonic friendship: Military fraternity, intimacy, and sexuality in nineteenth-century France.Hanover:UP of New England.
137. McDermott, J.(1992).Friendship and its friends in the late Ming.近世家族與政治比較歷史論文集,台北:
138. McGuire, B. P.(1988).Friendship and community: The monastic experience 350-1250.MN:Cistercian Publications.
139. McLean, P. D.(2007).The art of the network: Strategic interaction and patronage in Renaissance Florence.NC:Duke UP..
140. Meilaender, G.(1981).Friendshp: A study in theological ethics.Notre Dame:U of Notre Dame P.
141. Miller, S.(1983).Men and friendship.Boston:Houghton Mifflin.
142. Moazzam-Doulat, M.(2008).Future impossible: Carl Schmitt, Jacques Derrida, and the problem of political messianism.Philosophy Today,52(1),73-81.
143. Mongoven, A.(2009).Just love: Transforming civic virtue.Bloomington:Indiana UP.
144. Monteith, S.(2000).Advancing sisterhood? Interracial friendships in contemporary southern fiction.GA:U of Georgia P..
145. Mosse, G.(1985).Nationalism and sexuality: Middle-class morality and sexual norms in modern Europe.Madison:U of Wisconsin P..
146. Müller, Jan-Werner(2003).A dangerous mind: Carl Schmitt in post-war European thought.New Haven:Yale UP.
147. Murphy, P.(1988).Introduction.South Atlantic Quarterly,97(1),1-4.
148. Najemy, J. M.(1993).Between friends: Discourses of power and desire in the Machiavelli-Vettori letters of 1513-1515.Princeton:Princeton UP..
149. Nardi, P. M.(1999).Gay men's friendships: Invincible communities.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
150. Nelson, B.(1969).The idea of usury: From tribal brotherhood to universal otherhood.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
151. Newfield, C.(1996).The Emerson effect: Individualism and submission in America.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
152. NHK特別採訪小組、鄭舜瓏譯(2014)。無緣社會：「無緣死」三萬二千人的衝擊。台北:新雨。
153. Nora, Pierre(Ed.),Kritzman, Lawrence D.(Ed.),Goldhammer, Arthur(Trans.)(1998).Realms of memory: The construction of the French past. Vol. 3: Symbols.New York:Columbia UP.
154. Nygren, A.,Watson, Philip S.(Trans.)(1953).Agape and Eros.Philadelphia:Westminster Press.
155. O'Conner, P.(1992).Friendship between women: A critical review.Hemel Hempstead:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
156. O'Donnell, Katherine(Ed.),O'Rourke, Michael(Ed.)(2003).Love, sex, intimacy, and friendship between men, 1550-1800.Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan.
157. Oulton, Carolyn W.(2007).Romantic friendship in Victorian literature.Aldershot:Ashgate.
158. Ownby, D.(1996).Brotherhoods and secret societies in early and mid-Qing China: The formation of a tradition.Stanford:Stanford UP..
159. Pahl, R.(2000).On friendship.Cambridge:Polity.
160. Pakaluk, M.(1991).Other selves: Philosophers on friendship.Indianapolis:Hackett.
161. Petkov, K.(2003).The kiss of peace: Ritual, self, and society in the high and late medieval West.Leiden:Brill.
162. Price, A. W.(1989).Love and friendship in Plato and Aristotle.Oxford:Clarendon.
163. Raymond, J.(1991).A passion for friends: Towards a philosophy of female affection.London:Women's Press.
164. Reinhold, S.(1994).Through the parliamentary looking glass: 'Real' and 'pretend' families in contemporary British politics.Feminist Review,48(1),61-79.
165. Ricci, M.,Billings, Timothy(Trans.)(2009).On friendship: One hundred maxims for a Chinese prince.New York:Columbia UP.
166. Roach, T.(2012).Friendship as a way of life: Foucault, AIDS, and the politics of shared estrangement.Albany:SUNY P.
167. Rosenberg, Samuel N.(Trans.),Danon, Samuel(Trans.)(1996).Ami and Amile: A medieval tale of friendship.Ann Arbor:U of Michigan P..
168. Rubin, L. B.(1985).Just friends: The role of friendship in our lives.New York:Harper and Row.
169. Schachter, M. D.(2008).Voluntary servitude and the erotics of friendship: From classical antiquity to early modern France.Aldershot, Eng.:Ashgate.
170. Schaefer, D. L.(Ed.)(1998).Freedom over servitude: Montaigne, La Boétie, and on voluntary servitude.CT:Greenwood.
171. Schwarzenbach, S. A.(2009).On civic friendship: Including women in the state.New York:Columbia UP..
172. Schweitzer, I.(2006).Perfecting friendship: Politics and affiliation in early American literature.Chapel Hill:U of North Carolina P..
173. Sedgwick, E. K.(1985).Between men: English literature and male homosocial desire.New York:Columbia UP.
174. Sharp, R. A.(1986).Friendship and literature: Spirit and form.Durham:Duke UP..
175. Shlapentokh, V.(1989).Public and private life of the Soviet people: Changing values in post-Stalin Russia.New York:Oxford UP..
176. Shlapentokh, V.(1984).Love, marriage, and friendship in the Soviet Union.New York:Praeger.
177. Sills, David L.(Ed.)(1972).International encyclopedia of the social sciences.London:Collier-Macmillan.
178. Silver, A.(1989).Friendship and trust as moral ideals: An historical approach.Archives européennes de sociologie,30,274-97.
179. Silver, A.(1990).Friendship in commercial society: Eighteenth-century social theory and modern sociology.American Journal of Sociology,95,74-1504.
180. Simmel, G.,Blasi, Anthony J.(Trans. Ed.),Jacobs, Anton K.(Trans. Ed.),Kanjirathinkal, Mathew(Trans. Ed.)(2009).Sociology: Inquiries into the construction of social forms.Leiden:Brill.
181. Spencer, L.,Pahl, Ray(2006).Rethinking friendship: Hidden solidarities today.Princeton:Princeton UP..
182. Spivak, G. C.(2000).Schmitt and poststructuralism: A response.Cardozo Law Review,21,1723-37.
183. Stern-Gillet, S.(1995).Aristotle's philosophy of friendship.Albany:SUNY Press.
184. Stewart, A.(1997).Close readers: humanism and sodomy in Early Modern England.Princeton:Princeton UP.
185. Tadmor, N.(2001).Family and friends in eighteenth-century England: Household, kinship, and patronage.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
186. Terpstra, Nicholas(Ed.)(2000).The politics of ritual kinship: Confraternities and social order in early modern Italy.Cambridge:Cambridge UP..
187. Thomson, A. J. P.(2005).Deconstruction and democracy: Derrida's politics of friendship.London:Continuum.
188. Tobin, R.(2002).The love that is called friendship and the rise of sexual identity.Literary paternity, literary friendship: Essays in honor of stanley corngold,Chapel Hill:
189. Todd, J.(1980).Women's friendship in literature.New York:Columbia UP.
190. Velásquez, Eduardo A.(Ed.)(2003).Love and friendship: Rethinking politics and affection in modern times.Lanham:Lexington.
191. Vernon, M.(2005).The philosophy of friendship.Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan.
192. Vicinus, M.(2004).Intimate friends: Women who loved women, 1778-1928.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
193. Vogel, E. F.(1965).From friendship to comradeship: The change in personal relations in Communist China.China Quarterly,21,46-60.
194. Way, N.(2011).Deep secrets: Boys' friendships and the crisis of connection.Cambridge, MA:Harvard UP.
195. Weeks, J.(2000).Making sexual history.Cambridge:Polity.
196. Weeks, Jeffrey,Heaphy, Brian,Donovan, Catherine(2001).Same sex intimacies: Families of choice and other life experiments.London:Routledge.
197. Weinstock, J. S.(Ed.),Rothblum, Esther D.(Ed.)(1996).Lesbian friendships: For ourselves and each other.New York:New York UP..
198. Weintraub, Jeff(Ed.),Kumar, Krishan(Ed.)(1997).Public and private in thought and practice: Perspectives on a grand dichotomy.Chicago:U of Chicago P.
199. Weston, K.(1997).Families we choose: Lesbians, gays, kinship.New York:Columbia UP.
200. White, C.(2002).Christian friendship in the fourth century.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
201. Wilcox, A.(2012).The gift of correspondence in classical Rome: Friendship in Cicero's Ad Familiares and Seneca's Moral Epistles.Madison:U of Wisconsin P..
202. Wohl, V.(2002).Love among the ruins: The erotics of democracy in classical Athens.Princeton:Princeton UP..
203. Wolff, K. H.(Trans. Ed.)(1950).The sociology of Georg Simmel.Glencoe:Free Press.
204. Yan, Y.(2003).Private life under socialism: Love, intimacy, and family change in a Chinese village, 1949-1999.Stanford:Stanford UP.
205. Yang, Mayfair Mei-hui(1994).Gifts, favors, and banquets: The art of social relationships in China.Ithaca:Cornell UP..
206. Žižek, Slovaj(2005).The neighbor: Three inquiries in political theology.Chicago:U of Chicago P.
207. 山崎正和、周保雄譯(2008)。社交的人。上海:上海譯文出版社。
208. 方健(2013)。北宋士人交游錄。上海:上海書店出版社。
209. 方豪(1969)。方豪六十自定稿。台北:方豪。
210. 王大為、劉平譯(2009)。兄弟結拜與秘密會黨：一種傳統的形成。北京:商務印書館。
211. 王長金(2006)。傳統家訓思想通論。長春:吉林人民出版社。
212. 王昱峰(2001)。李國鼎先生的未竟志業：談「第六倫運動」。歷史月刊，162，67-73。
213. 王振忠(2000)。契兄、契弟、契友、契父、契子：《孫八救人得福》的歷史民俗背景解讀。漢學研究，18(1)，163-85。
214. 王振寰編(2002)。台灣社會。台北:巨流。
215. 尼采、魏育青譯、李晶浩譯、高天忻譯(2008)。人性的，太人性的：一本獻給自由精神的書。上海:華東師範大學出版社。
216. 尼采、魏育青譯、李晶浩譯、高天忻譯(2008)。人性的，太人性的：一本獻給自由精神的書。上海:華東師範大學出版社。
217. 布倫戴爾，M. W.、包利民譯(2009)。扶友損敵：索福克勒斯與古希臘倫理。北京:三聯書店。
218. 皮耶．諾哈編、戴麗娟譯(2012)。記憶所繫之處。台北:行人。
219. 朱剛(2012)。開端與未來：從現象學到解構。北京:商務印書館。
220. 江沛(2001)。戰國策派司潮研究。天津:天津人民出版社。
221. 池田溫(1997)。關於唐宋時代的結為兄弟憑。唐代的歷史與社會：中國唐史學會第六屆年會暨國際唐史學會研討會論文選集，武漢:
222. 竹中信子、蔡龍保譯(2007)。日本女人在台灣：日治台灣生活史。台北:時報。
223. 竹中信子、蔡龍保譯(2007)。日本女人在台灣：日治台灣生活史。台北:時報。
224. 竹中信子、蔡龍保譯(2007)。日本女人在台灣：日治台灣生活史。台北:時報。
225. 竹中信子、蔡龍保譯(2007)。日本女人在台灣：日治台灣生活史。台北:時報。
226. 米勒，楊．維爾納、張龔譯、鄧曉菁譯(2006)。危險的心靈：戰後歐洲思潮中的卡爾．施米特。北京:新星出版社。
227. 艾爾雷德、黎子鵬譯(2011)。屬靈友情禮讚。香港:基督教文藝出版社。
228. 西美爾，蓋奧爾格、林榮遠譯(2002)。社會學：關於社會化形式的研究。北京:華夏出版社。
229. 亨特，林、鄭明萱譯、陳瑛譯(2002)。法國大革命時期的家庭羅曼史。台北:麥田。
230. 何心隱、容肇祖整理(1986)。何心隱集。台北:弘文館。
231. 余英時(1980)。中國知識階層史論：古代篇。台北:聯經。
232. 余英時(1982)。史學與傳統。台北:時報。
233. 克里納柏格，埃里克、徐家良譯、孫龍譯、王彥瑋譯(2014)。熱浪：芝加哥災難的社會剖析。北京:商務印書館。
234. 利瑪竇、朱維錚編(2001)。利瑪竇中文著譯集。香港:香港城市大學出版社。
235. 吳承仕(1984)。吳承仕文錄。北京:北京師範大學出版社。
236. 呂妙芬(2003)。陽明學士人社群：歷史、思想與實踐。台北:中央研究院近代史研究所。
237. 李國鼎(1987)。工作與信仰：台灣經濟社會發展的見證。台北:經濟與生活。
238. 李奭學(2012)。譯述明末耶穌會翻譯文學論。香港:中文大學出版社。
239. 李奭學(2010)。中國晚明與歐洲文學：明末耶穌會古典型證道故事考詮。北京:三聯書店。
240. 沈定平(2007)。明清之際中西文化交流史：明代─調適與會通。北京:商務印書館。
241. 沈定平(2012)。明清之際中西文化交流史：明季—趨同與辨異。北京:商務印書館。
242. 貝拉，羅伯特N.、周穗明譯、翁寒松譯、翟宏彪譯(2011)。心靈的習性：美國人生活中的個人主義和公共責任。北京:中國社會科學出版社。
243. 周作人譯(2003)。路吉阿諾斯對話集。北京:中國對外翻譯出版公司。
244. 拉博埃西、曹帥譯、劉訓練校(2012)。反暴君論。南京:譯林出版社。
245. 林安梧(1996)。儒學與中國傳統社會之哲學省察：以「血緣性縱貫軸」為核心的理解與詮釋。台北:幼獅。
246. 林端(2002)。儒家倫理與法律文化：社會學觀點的探索。北京:中國政法大學出版社。
247. 林聰舜(2013)。漢代儒學別裁：帝國意識形態的形成與發展。台北:國立台灣大學出版中心。
248. 杰弗里．亞歷山大編、戴聰騰譯(2001)。迪爾凱姆社會學。瀋陽:遼寧教育出版社。
249. 金觀濤、劉青峰(2009)。觀念史研究：中國現代重要政治術語的形成。北京:法律出版社。
250. 阿倫特，漢娜、王寅麗譯(2006)。人的境況。上海:上海人民出版社。
251. 威克斯，杰弗瑞、宋文偉譯、侯萍譯(2002)。20世紀的性理論和性觀念。南京:江蘇人民出版社。
252. 施皮茨萊編、阿貝拉爾、李承言譯(1996)。親吻神學：中世紀修道院情書選。香港:漢語基督教文化研究所。
253. 施米特，卡爾、劉宗坤譯(2004)。政治的概念。上海:上海人民出版社。
254. 施特勞斯、科耶夫、古熱維奇編、羅茲編、何地譯、觀溟校(2006)。論僭政：色諾芬『希耶羅』義疏。北京:華夏出版社。
255. 柯律格、邱士華譯、劉宇珍譯、胡雋譯(2009)。雅債：文徵明的社交性藝術。台北:石頭出版。
256. 柯慶明(2008)。白先勇外集3：白先勇研究精選。北京:天下文化。
257. 查昌國(2006)。先秦「孝」、「友」觀念研究：兼漢宋儒學探索。合肥:安徽大學出版社。
258. 洪瓊芳(2010)。博士論文(博士論文)。中壢，國立中央大學中國文學研究所。
259. 胡發貴(2008)。儒家朋友倫理研究。北京:光明日報出版社。
260. 迪維爾，希瑟、李自修譯(2005)。復興希臘：羅馬式友誼—文獻評述。生產，2005(2)，173-214。
261. 夏可君編校、杜小真譯(2006)。解構與思想的未來。長春:吉林人民出版社。
262. 孫尚揚、鍾鳴旦(2004)。1840年前的中國基督教。北京:學苑出版社。
263. 徐昌治編(2005)。藏外佛經。合肥:黃山書社。
264. 徐賁(2011)。文化批評往何處去：八十年代末後的中國文化討論。北京:吉林出版。
265. 國家清史編纂委員會(2011)。清代詩文集彙編。上海:上海古籍出版社。
266. 曹晉(2008)。媒介與社會性別研究：理論與實例。上海:上海三聯書店。
267. 梁漱溟(2013)。中國文化要義。台北:台灣商務印書館。
268. 許烺光、于嘉雲譯(2000)。家元：日本的真髓。台北:南天。
269. 郭文沁(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台南，成功大學中國文學系。
270. 郭為藩(1985)。「公共道德」概念試析。國立臺灣師範大學教育研究所集刊，27，141-51。
271. 陳立、吳則虞點校(1994)。白虎通疏證。北京:中華書局。
272. 陳立、吳則虞點校(1994)。白虎通疏證。北京:中華書局。
273. 陳其南(1998)。傳統制度與社會意識的結構：歷史與人類學的探索。台北:允晨。
274. 陳鄭雙譯疏、柏拉圖(2014)。『呂西斯』譯疏。北京:華夏出版社。
275. 勞悅強, Yuet Keung(2006).My second self: Matteo Ricci's friendship in China.華裔學志,25,221-41.
276. 嵇文甫(1990)。左派王學。上海:上海書店。
277. 曾棗莊編、劉琳編(2006)。全宋文。上海:上海辭書出版社。
278. 陽嘉同輯譯(1997)。同信戀。台北:開心陽光。
279. 馮天瑜、謝貴安(2003)。解構專制：明末清初「新民本」思想研究。武漢:湖北人民出版社。
280. 黃衛總(2012)。晚明朋友楷模的重寫：馮夢龍《三言》中的友倫故事。人文中國學報，18，225-38。
281. 塞吉維克，伊芙．科索夫斯基、郭劼譯(2011)。男人之間：英國文學與男性同性社會性欲望。上海:上海三聯書店。
282. 楊念群(2010)。何處是「江南」？清朝正統觀的確立與士林精神世界的變異。北京:三聯書店。
283. 楊美惠、趙旭東譯、孫珉譯、張耀宏譯校(2009)。禮物、關係學與國家：中國人際關係與主體性建構。南京:江蘇人民出版社。
284. 虞格仁、翻譯小組譯(2012)。基督教愛觀研究。台北:台北市基督教中華文字差傳協會。
285. 雷金慶、劉婷譯(2012)。男性特質論：中國的社會與性別。南京:江蘇人民出版社。
286. 鄔正杰(2012)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。北京，清華大學。
287. 福斯特，E. M.、李向東譯(1998)。現代的挑戰。北京:作家出版社。
288. 福斯特，E. M.、蘇福忠譯(2009)。最漫長的旅程。北京:人民文學出版社。
289. 趙令揚(1994)。明宣宗《五倫書》中對明太祖之評價。明史研究，1994(4)，131-36。
290. 劉小楓編、陳少明編(2005)。古典傳統與自由教育。北京:華夏出版社。
291. 德里達，雅克、杰弗里．本明頓、戴阿寶譯(2005)。政治與友誼：與雅克．德里達的座談。生產，2005(2)，50-69。
292. 德里達，雅克、胡繼華譯、夏可君編(2006)。『友愛的政治學』及其他。長春:吉林人民出版社。
293. 潘光旦(2010)。儒家的社會思想。北京:北京大學出版社。
294. 蔣勳(2012)。萍水相逢：蔣勳的第一本散文集。台北:爾雅。
295. 鄧偉志(1994)。近代中國家庭的變革。上海:上海人民出版社。
296. 蕭伶玲(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。新竹，國立清華大學社會學研究所。
297. 閻雲翔、龔小夏譯(2006)。私人生活的變革：一個中國村莊裡的愛情、家庭與親密關係1949-1999。上海:上海書店出版社。
298. 霍耐特，阿克塞爾、王旭譯(2013)。自由的權利。北京:社會科學文獻出版社。
299. 鮑曼，齊格蒙特、邵迎生譯(2003)。現代性與矛盾性。北京:商務印書館。
300. 戴岑豪斯，大衛、劉毅譯(2013)。合法性與正當性：魏瑪時代的施米特、凱爾森與海勒。北京:商務印書館。
301. 謝和耐、耿昇譯(2013)。中國與基督教：中西文化的首次撞擊。北京:商務印書館。
302. 鍾惺、李先耕標校、崔重慶標校(1992)。隱軒秀集。上海:上海古籍出版社。
303. 魏義霞(2011)。平等與啟蒙：從明清之際到五四運動。北京:中華書局。
304. 羅賓，莉蘭、王小章譯、周江平譯、蕭福堂譯(1991)。尋找友情：人類共同生活的基石。北京:知識出版社。
305. 譚嗣同、何執編(2012)。譚嗣同集。長沙:岳麓書社。
306. 騰尼斯，斐迪南、林榮遠譯(2010)。共同體與社會：純粹社會學的基本概念。北京:北京大學出版社。

1. 詹前倬(2017)。中晚明儒者友誼研究。史原，復刊8期=29期，227-251。
2. 詹前倬(2019)。書評：評Anna M. Shields, One Who Knows Me: Friendship and Literary Culture in Mid-Tang China。漢學研究，37(3)，273-279。
3. (2021)。「男人是這樣煉成的」：各生命階段直男同性友誼中的男子氣概建構初探。中華傳播學刊，39，231-268。