Portfolio Insurance in the Long Term Asset Management

投資組合保險在長期資產管理中的應用

10.6545/JFS.2013.21(3).4

李懷義(Huai-I Lee)；何怡滿(Emily Ho)；謝宗佑(Tzung-Yuan Hsieh)；許溪南(Hsi-Nan Hsu)

投資組合保險 ； 長期資產管理 ； 損失趨避 ； 風險趨避 ； 權變制輪式要保額度投資組合保險策略 ； Portfolio insurance ； long-term asset management ； loss aversion ； risk

財務金融學刊

21卷3期（2013 / 09 / 30）

97 - 123

英文

本文證明以選擇權為基礎的投資組合保險對長期資產管理無效，並建議改用固定比例投資組合保險策略。同時，以損失趨避理論為基礎，提出權變制輪式要保額度投資組合保險策略。模擬與實證的結果顯示所建議的保險策略在長期資產管理上的表現要優於固定比例投資組合保險和滾動式固定比例投資組合保險策略。

Portfolio insurance is widely applied in asset management; however, the empirical evidence demonstrates that the performance of current portfolio insurance strategies is not as useful as expected for the long-term asset management purpose. This paper proves the failure of the option based portfolio insurance (OBPI) strategy as the long-term asset management purpose, and proposes a contingent ratcheted-floor variable proportion portfolio insurance (CRF-VPPI) strategy, which is based on the implication of loss aversion, as a competing strategy for the purpose of long-term asset management. Monte Carlo simulations and empirical analysis demonstrates that the proposed CRF-VPPI outperforms the CPPI and the rolling-CPPI.

1. Plantinga, Auke, Robert V. D. Meer, and Frank Sortino, 2001, The impact of downside risk on risk-adjusted performance of mutual funds in the Euronext markets, Working paper
2. Bakshi, Gurdip,Cao, Charles,Chen, Zhiwu(1997).Empirical performance of alternative option pricing models.Journal of Finance,52,2003-2049.
3. Barber, Brad,Odean, Terrance(2001).Boys will be boys: gender, overconfidence and common stock investment.Quarterly Journal of Economics,116,261-292.
4. Barber, Brad,Odean, Terrance(2002).Online investors: do the slow die first?.Review of Financial Studies,15,455-487.
5. Benartizi, Shlomo,Thaler, Richard H.(1995).Myopic loss aversion and the equity premium puzzle.Quarterly Journal of Economics,110,73-92.
6. Berkelaar, Arjan B.,Kouwenberg, Roy,Post, Thierry(2004).Optimal portfolio choice under loss aversion.The Review of Economics and Statistics,86,973-987.
7. Black, Fisher,Perold, Andre F.(1992).Theory of constant proportion portfolio insurance.Journal of Economic Dynamic and Control,16,403-426.
8. Black, Fisher,Scholes, Myron(1973).The pricing of options and corporate liabilities.Journal of Political Economy,81,637-654.
9. Boyle, Phelim P.(1977).Options: a Monte Carlo approach.Journal of Financial Economics,4,323-338.
10. Brennan, Michael J.,Schwartz, Eduardo S.(1989).Portfolio insurance and financial market equilibrium.Journal of Business,62,455-472.
11. Cox, John C.,Ingersoll, Jonathan E.,Ross, Stephen A.(1985).An Intertemporal General Equilibrium Model of Asset Prices.Econometrica,53,363-384.
12. Do, Binh Huu,Faff, Robert W.(2004).Do futures-based strategies enhance dynamic portfolio insurance?.The Journal of Futures Markets,24,591-608.
13. Estep, Tony,Kritzman, Mark(1988).TIPP: insurance without complexity.Journal of Portfolio Management,14,38-42.
14. Etzioni, Ethan S.(1986).Rebalance disciplines for portfolio insurance.Journal of Portfolio Management,13,59-62.
15. Hull, John C.(2006).Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall, Inc..
16. Hull, John,White, Alan(1987).The pricing of options on assets with stochastic volatilities.Journal of Finance,42,281-300.
17. Ibbotson, Roger G.,Sinquefield, Rex A.(1989).Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation: Historical Returns.The Research Foundation of The Institute of Chartered Financial Analysts.
18. Jacobs, Bruce I.(1984).Is Portfolio Insurance Appropriate for the Long-Term Investor?.Newart, JN:Prudential Asset Management.
19. Jacobs, Bruce I.(1983).The portfolio insurance puzzle.Pension and Investment Age,1983(August 22)
20. Kahneman, Daniel,Tversky, Amos(1979).Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk.Econometrica,47,263-291.
21. Kritzman, Mark,Rich, Don(2002).The mismeasurement of risk.Financial Analysts Journal,58,91-99.
22. Lee, Huai-I,Chiang, Min-Hsien,Hsu, Hsinan(2008).A new choice of dynamic asset management: the variable proportion portfolio insurance.Applied Economics,40,2135-2146.
23. Leggio, Karyl B.,Lien, Donald(2003).An empirical examination of the effectiveness of dollar-cost averaging using downside risk performance measures.Journal of Economics and Finance,27,211-223.
24. Leibowitz, Martin L.,Kogelman, Stanley(1991).Asset allocation under shortfall constraints.Journal of Portfolio Management,17,18-24.
25. Lien, Donald(2002).A note on the relationship between some risk-adjusted performance measures.Journal of Futures Markets,22,483-495.
26. Merton, Robert C.(1976).Option pricing when underlying stock returns are discontinuous.Journal of Financial Economics,3,125-144.
27. Merton, Robert C.(1973).Theory of Rational Option Pricing.Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science,4,141-183.
28. Roy, A. D.(1952).Safety-first and the holding of assets.Econometrica,20,431-449.
29. Scott, Louis O.(1997).Pricing stock options in a jump-diffusion model with stochastic volatility and interest rates: applications of Fourier inversion methods.Mathematical Finance,7,413-424.
30. Sortino, Frank,Price Lee N.(1994).Performance measurement in a downside risk framework.Journal of Investing,3,59-64.
31. Thaler, Richard H.,Tversky, Amos,Kahneman, Daniel,Schwartz, Alan(1997).The Effect of Myopia and Loss Aversion on Risk Taking: An Experimental Test.Quarterly Journal of Economics,112,647-661.
32. Tversky, Amos,Kahneman, Daniel(1992).Advances in prospect theory: cumulative representation of uncertainty.Journal of Risk and Uncertainty,5,297-323.
33. Wilcox, Jarrod(2003).Harry Markowitz and the discretionary wealth hypothesis.Journal of Portfolio management,29,58-65.

1. (2018)。投資組合保險發展的回顧與展望。臺灣銀行季刊，69(2)，109-130。