“相關”與“模糊”在資訊檢索領域中關係驗證與分析

Verification and Analysis of the Notions of "Relevant" and "Fuzzy" in Information Retrieval

10.6575/JoLIS.2007.60.03

李煜基(Yu-Ji Li)；洪一梅(I-Mei Hung)

書目計量 ； 相關理論 ； 模糊理論 ； 資訊檢索 ； Bibliometrics ； Relevant theory ； Fuzzy theory ； Information retrieval

圖書與資訊學刊

60期（2007 / 02 / 01）

28 - 48

繁體中文

在資訊檢索中，「相關理論」是重要的基礎概念；而在資訊檢索的技術發展中，「模糊理論」亦是重要的議題。本文除針對此二種理論進行深入介紹與概念內涵比較解析外，並以文獻計量方法驗證二者的應用核心領域，及進行二者的關聯研究。文末嘗試依據上述結果，推測「相關」及「模糊」在「資訊檢索」領域中可能的應用發展趨勢。

The ”Relevant Theory” and the ”Fuzzy Theory” are two important topics in Information Retrieval (IR). In addition to thoroughly explicating the two theories, this paper adopts the method of bibliometrics to verify and analyze the respective core fields of applications and the connection between the two notions of ”relevant” and ”fuzzy.” Furthermore, this study also suggests probable extensive applications of the two theories in the future trends of information retrieval.

1. 林信成、蕭勝文(2003)。模糊詮釋資料及其在圖書館分類編目之應用。教育資料與圖書館學，41(1)，61-76。
   連結：
2. Bateman, J.,American Society for Information Science(1998).Changes in relevance criteria: A longitudinal study.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
3. Bateman, J.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1998).Changes in relevance criteria: A longitudinal study.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
4. Bookstein, A.(1981).A comparison of two systems of weighted Boolean retrieval.Journal of the American society for Information Science,July,275-279.
5. Brooks, T. A.,American Society for Information Science(1998).The semantic distance model of relevance assessment.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
6. Brooks, T. A.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1998).The semantic distance model of relevance assessment.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
7. Buell, D. A.(1985).A problem in information retrieval with fuzzy sets.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,36(6),398-401.
8. Cooper, W. S.(1971).A definition of relevance for information retrieval.Information Storage & Retrieval,7,19-37.
9. Hailer, S.(1992).Psychological relevance and information science.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,43(9),602-615.
10. Jacquette, D.(2002).A companion to philosophical logic.Malden, Mass:Blackwell.
11. Jacquette, D.(2002).A companion to philosophical logic.Malden, Mass.:Blackwell.
12. MacCall, S. L.,American Society for Information Science(1998).Relevance reliability in cyberspace: Toward measurement theory for internet information retrieval.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
13. MacCall, S. L.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1998).Relevance reliability in cyberspace: Toward measurement theory for internet information retrieval.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
14. Mares, D.(2004).Relevant logic: A philosophical interpretation.Cambridge:The Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge.
15. Mares, D.(2004).Relevant logic: A philosophical interpretation,Cambridge:
16. Mohammadian, M.(1999).Computational intelligence for modeling, control & automation: Evolutionary computation & frizzy logic for intelligent control, knowledge acquisition & information retrieval.Netherlands:IOS Press.
17. Mohammadian, M.(1999).Computational intelligence for modeling, control | automation: Evolutionary computation | fuzzy logic for intelligent control, knowledge acquisition | information retrieval.Netherlands:IOS Press.
18. Petry, F. E.,Buckles, B. P.,Prabbu, D.,American Society for Information Science(1993).Fuzzy information retrieval using genetic algorithms and relevance feedback.Proceedings of the 56th annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
19. Petry, F. E.,Buckles, B. P.,Prabbu, D.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1993).Fuzzy information retrieval using genetic algorithms and relevance feedback.Proceedings of the 56th annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
20. Saracevic, T.(1970).The concept of ``Relevance`` in information science: A historical review.New York:Bowker.
21. Saracevic, T.(1970).Introduction to Information Science.New York:Bowker.
22. Saracevic, T.,American Society for Information Science(1976).Modeling interaction in information retrieval (IR): A review and proposal.Proceedings of the 59th annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
23. Saracevic, T.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1996).Modeling interaction in information retrieval (IR): A review and proposal.Proceedings of the 59th annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
24. Saracevic, T.,Voigt, M.J.(Eds.),Harris, M. H.(Eds.)(1996).Relevance: A review of the literature and a framework for thinking on the Notion in information science.Advances in librarianship,6,81-139.
25. Saracevic, T.,Voigt, M.J.,Harris, M. H. (Ed.)(1976).Advances in librarianship.New York:Academic Press.
26. Schamber, L.,Eisenberg, M. B.,Nilan, M. S.(1990).A re-examination of relevance: Toward a dynamic, situational definition.Information Processing & Management,26(6),755-776.
27. Singh, S.,Dey, L.(2005).A rough-fuzzy document grading system for customized text information retrieval.Information Processing and Management,41,195-216.
28. Spink, A.,Greisdorf, H.,Bateman, J.,American Society for Information Science(1998).Examining different regions of relevance: From highly relevant to not relevant.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
29. Spink, A.,Greisdorf, H.,Bateman, J.,American Society for Information Science (Ed.)(1998).Examining different regions of relevance: From highly relevant to not relevant.Proceedings of the 61st annual meeting of the American Society for Information Science,Medford, NJ:
30. Tseng, Y. H.(1998).Solving vocabulary problems with interactive query expansion.Journal of Library & Information Science,24(1),1-18.
31. White, H. D.,McCain, K. W.(1998).Visualizing a discipline: An author co-citation analysis of information science, 1972-1995.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,49(4),327-355.
32. Wilson, P.(1973).Situational relevance.Information Processing & Management,9,457-471.
33. Wilson, P.(1978).Some fundamental concepts of information retrieval.Drexel Library Quarterly,14(2),10-24.
34. 王玫(1995)。現代情報檢索理論特性述略。圖書與情報，4，7-9,16。
35. 曾元顯、林瑜一(1998)。模糊搜尋、相關詞提示與相關詞回饋在OPAC系統中的成效評估。中國圖書館學會會報，61，103-125。
36. 黃慕萱(1996)。資訊檢索之五大基本概念探討。圖書與資訊學刊，19，7-21。
37. 黃慕萱(1996)。資訊檢索中「相關」概念之研究。臺北市:臺灣學生。