宏觀鑑定模式在五國實施狀況之探析

The Status of Implementation of Macro-Appraisal Model in the Five Countries

10.6575/JoLIS.2009.70.07

周旻邑(Mei-I Chou)；莊詒婷(I-Ting Chuang)

鑑定 ； 宏觀鑑定 ； Appraisal ； Macro-appraisal

圖書與資訊學刊

70期（2009 / 08 / 01）

93 - 104

繁體中文

宏觀鑑定為加拿大檔案學家庫克(Terry Cook)於1990年所提出，加拿大國家圖書館與檔案館(Library and Archives Canada, LAC)也自1991年開始採用，並已證實其有效性，目前世界各國也陸續採行此法。本文將對加拿大、澳洲、紐西蘭、荷蘭及南非等五國實施宏觀鑑定的原因，以及其因國情不同而制定的準則做概述。最後，針對各國實施後的狀況及學者提出的觀點，提出宏觀鑑定應用在我國的可行性。

The macro-appraisal model was put forward by Canadian archivist Terry Cook in 1990. Library and Archives Canada (LAC) has adopted the model since 1991 and the validity of the model has been verified. This model has also been gradually applied in a number of countries around the world. This paper will focus on the current implementation of macro-appraisal model in Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the Netherlands, and South Africa, discussing why the model has been implemented in these countries and how principles of the model have been adjusted to adapt to different requirements. The discussion of the effects of implementation and the various points of view put forth by scholars will help us evaluate the feasibility of applying the macro-appraisal model in Taiwan.

1. 張聰明(2002)。加拿大檔案保存年限訂定與鑑定之探討。檔案季刊，1(2)，81-93。
   連結：
2. 張聰明(2006)。紐西蘭政府檔案鑑定與清理制度之探討。檔案季刊，5(1)，69-79。
   連結：
3. 薛理桂(2005)。宏觀鑑定模式在我國應用之探討。檔案季刊，4(1)，31-46。
   連結：
4. Cook, T.(2005).Macroappraisal in theory and practice: Origins, characteristics, and implementation in Canada, 1950-2000.Archival Science,5(2-4),101-161.
5. Cook, T.(2004).Macro-appraisal and functional analysis: Documenting governance rather than government.Journal of the Society of Archivists,25(1),5-18.
6. Cunningham, A.,Oswald, R.(2005).Some functions are more equal than others: The development of a macroappraisal strategy for the National Archives of Australia.Archival Science,5(2-4),163-184.
7. Jonker, A. E. M.(2005).Macroappraisal in the Netherlands. The first ten years, 1991-2001, and beyond.Archival Science,5(2-4),203-218.
8. Why Records are Kept: Directions in Appraisal
9. Managing business information: Managing Business Information
10. Robert, J.(2001).One size fits all? The portability of macroappraisal by a comparative analysis of Canada, South Africa, and New Zealand.Archivaria,52,47-68.
11. Roberts, J.(2005).Macroappraisal kiwi style: Reflections on the impact and future of macroappraisal in New Zealand.Archival Science,5(2-4),185-210.
12. 林素甘(2006)。博士論文(博士論文)。臺北市，國立臺灣大學圖書資訊學研究所。
13. 陳美蓉、陸雯玉、郭銘昌(2008)。加拿大國家檔案管理與發展考察報告。檔案管理局考察報告：C09701206。

1. 薛理桂、莊詒婷、周旻邑(2011)。宏觀鑑定在政府機關之實施：以教育部為例。大學圖書館，15(1)，1-18。