他山之石－由美國愛滋病個案管理制度談台灣“愛滋病個案管理師計畫”

The "HIV Case Management Program" in Taiwan: A Discussion Based on Experience with HIV Case Management in the United States

10.6288/TJPH2010-29-01-01

邱珠敏(Chu-Ming Chiu)；黃彥芳(Yen-Fang Huang)；楊靖慧(Chin-Hui Yang)；陳穎慧(Ying-Hwei Chen)；林頂(Ting Lin)

愛滋病 ； 個案管理 ； 高風險行為 ； 社區組織模式 ； HIV/AIDS ； case management ； high-risk behavior ； Community-Based Organization model

台灣公共衛生雜誌

29卷1期（2010 / 02 / 01）

1 - 7

繁體中文

愛滋病防治為目前全球所面臨之重要議題，世界各國積極尋求有效愛滋防治策略及方法，愛滋病個案管理制度即為其中公認有效之方法。美國為世界上最早推行愛滋病個案管理制度的國家，其推展實施愛滋病個案管理約有23年的歷史。台灣自2007年起全面推廣愛滋病個案管理計畫，目前仍屬初期發展階段，與美國之愛滋病個案管理制度相較，二者之間有差異性存在，包括：個管組織結構、個案收案條件、個管單位屬性、個管師資格及條件、個管執行內容以及個管執行場域等層面之差異。作者建議將愛滋高風險行為者納入個管收案對象，進行「預防性個案管理」，以及早導正該類族群之危險行為，另建議扶植國內愛滋防治民間團體，發展社區組織(Community-Based Organization, CBO)個案管理模式，可先透過試辦計畫進行前驅性研究，以尋求建立愛滋病個案管理多元化之照護模式。此外，於個管計畫執行過程中，應重視及落實個管計畫執行結果評值之重要性。

Countries around the world have been searching for effective strategies to prevent HIV/AIDS. Among all the existing strategies, HIV case management appears to be the most effective. The United States was the first country to implement HIV case management twenty-three years ago. In Taiwan, HIV case management has been carried out since January 2007. When comparing our HIV case management with that of the United States, we discovered differences in organizational structure, client eligibility, apply unit eligibility, case manager qualifications, and the content of and areas for case management. We therefore have the following suggestions: first, to categorize people with high-risk behavior as a 'preventative case management' group for early correction of that behavior; second, to develop a pilot Community-Based Organization (CBO) HIV case management model to provide HIV clients with more choices; third, to emphasize evaluation of case management throughout the process.

1. Barney DD,Rosenthal CC,Speier TL.(2004).Components of successful HIV/AIDS case management in Alaska Native villages.AIDS Educ Prev,16,202-217.
2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention(1997).HIV Prevention Case Management: Literature Review and Current Practice.Atlanta, USA:Department of Health and Human Services.
3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention(1993).HIV prevention through case management for HIV-infected persons-selected sites, United States, 1989-1992.MMWR,42,448-9, 455-456.
4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention(1997).HIV Prevention Case Management: Guidance.Atlanta, USA:Department of Health and Human Services.
5. Craw JA,Gardner LI,Marks G(2008).Brief strengths-based case management promotes entry into HIV medical Care.J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr,47,597-606.
6. Crepaz N,Hart T,Marks G.(2004).Highly active antiretroviral therapy and sexual risk behavior. A meta-analytic review.JAMA,292,224-236.
7. Elford J,Hart G.(2005).HAART, viral load and sexual risk behavior.AIDS,205-207.
8. Gardner LI,Metsch LR,Anderson-Mahoney P(2005).Efficacy of a brief case management intervention to link recently diagnosed HIV-infected persons to care.AIDS,19,423-431.
9. Gasiorowicz M,Llanas MR,DiFranceisco W(2005).Reductions in transmission risk behavior in HIV-positive clients receiving prevention case management services: findings from a community demonstration project.AIDS Edu Prev,17,40-52.
10. USA. The HIV/AIDS program
11. Kats MH,Schwarcs SK,Kellogg TA(2002).Impact of highly active antiretroviral treatment on HIV seroincidence among men who have sex with men: San Francisco.Am J Publ Health,92,388-394.
12. Katz MH,Cunningham WE,Fleishman JA(2001).Effect of case management on unmet needs and utilization of medical care and medications among HIV-Infected persons.Am Coll of Physicians,135,557-565.
13. Kushel MB,Colfax G,Ragland K,Heineman A,Palacio H,Bangsberg DR.(2006).Case management is associated with improved antiretroviral adherence and CD + cell counts in homeless and marginally housed individuals with HIV infection.Clin Infect Dis,43,34-42.
14. Mor V,Fleishman JA,Piette JD,Allen SM.(1993).Developing AIDS community service consortia.Health Aff,12,186-199.
15. Mor V,Piette J,Fleishman J.(1989).Community-based case management for persons with AIDS.Health Aff,8,139-153.
16. HIV case management: a review of the literature
17. New York Department of Health AIDS Institute(2006).Standards for HIV/AIDS Case Management.Albany, NY:New York Department of Health.
18. Piette J,Fleishman JA,Mor V,Dill A.(1990).A comparison of hospital and community case management programs for persons with AIDS.Med Care,28,746-755.
19. Purcell DW,DeGroff AS,Wolitski RJ.(1998).HIV prevention case management: current practice and future directions.Health Soc Work,23,282-289.
20. Schwarzenegger A,Belshé K,Shewry S.(2006).Economic Evaluation of California's Prevention Case Management Intervention for HIV-Positive and HIV-Negative Persons: The HIV Transmission Prevention Project (HTPP).California, USA:California Department of Health Services.
21. Sorensen JL,Dilley J,London J,Okin RL,Delucchi KL,Phibbs CS.(2003).Case management for substance abusers with HIV/AIDS: a randomized clinical trial.Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse,29,133-150.
22. Sowell RL.(1995).Community-based HIV case management: challenges and opportunities.J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care,6,33-40.
23. Report on the global AIDS epidemic
24. Virginia Department of Health(2007).HIV/AIDS Case Management Standards.Richmond, VA:Virginia Department of Health.
25. 行政院衛生署疾病管制局(2007)。愛滋病個案管理師計畫書。台北:衛生署疾病管制局。
26. 柯乃熒、劉曉穎、賴霈妤、李欣純、柯文謙(2006)。HIV個案管理模式及其成效評估。感染控制雜誌，16，237-245。

1. 黃道明(2014)。列管制度下的醫療治理「人類免疫缺乏病毒傳染防治及感染者權益保障條例」與新道德威權。臺灣社會研究季刊，94，107-145。
2. 李郁強(2015)。論對疑似人類免疫缺乏病毒感染者採驗之法規範。法令月刊，66(3)，91-119。
3. 謝佳吟,蔡承熹,劉麗芳,劉曉穎,陳嬿今,柯乃熒(2015)。以修正型德菲法建立台灣愛滋個管師角色與愛滋護理照顧之核心能力。護理雜誌，62(4)，63-72。
4. (2022)。身家調查？揭露身分？—— 愛滋感染者接觸者追蹤之公衛權力界限與法制改革建議。政大法學評論，168，187-248。