Application of the Modified Health Belief Model for Undergoing Oral Mucosal Examination: Comparison of Different Health Risk Groups

運用修正型健康信念模式比較不同健康風險族群接受口腔黏膜檢查之信念與可能性—以台灣無檳社區計畫活動為例

10.6288/TJPH2013-32-04-06

吳美宜(Mei-Yi Wu)；郭鐘隆(Jong-Long Guo)；李明憲(Ming-Shinn Lee)；沈婉平(Wang-Ping Shen)

健康信念模式 ； 口腔黏膜檢查 ； 不同健康風險族群 ； 結構方程模式 ； Health Belief Model ； oral mucosal examination (OME) ； different health risk groups ； Structural Equation Modeling

台灣公共衛生雜誌

32卷4期（2013 / 08 / 15）

358 - 371

英文

目標：口腔黏膜檢查為偵測口腔癌之有效措施，口腔癌為台灣男性第四位之惡性腫瘤，本研究旨在探討具有酒精、檳榔及吸菸等習慣造成罹患口腔癌之不同健康風險族群接受口腔黏膜檢查的社會心理差異。方法：本研究運用修正型健康信念模式探討參與無檳社區活動計劃居民接受口腔黏膜檢查之信念，共有866位完成問卷測量，我們依據參與者是否有喝酒、嚼食檳榔、吸菸等習慣區分為罹患口腔癌之高、中與低風險組，並採用結構方程模式建立及比較三組不同健康風險族群接受口腔黏膜檢查的可能性與影響路徑之差異。結果：證明修正後的健康信念模式對高、中與低風險組模型配適度良好並可解釋三組接受口腔黏膜檢查之可能性分別為50%、37%、30%，且三組在健康信念影響接受口腔黏膜檢查可能性之直接與間接路徑上有顯著差異。結論：不同健康風險族群接受口腔黏膜檢查可能性之健康信念與影響路徑有顯著差異，建議未來教育介入針對不同健康風險族群宜採取不同介入模式以提高無檳社區計畫之有效性。

Objectives: Oral mucosal examination (OME) is an effective measure for detecting oral cancer, which is the fourth leading cause of cancer deaths among males in Taiwan. Despite this fact, there is a lack of literature concerning the likelihood of undergoing an OME among different health risk groups based on individuals’ habits of drinking alcohol, chewing betel quid, and smoking cigarettes. Methods: We applied a modified form of the Health Belief Model (HBM) to explore the likelihood that a sample of individuals participating in a ”Community Free from Betel Quid Chewing” campaign would undergo an OME. Eight-hundred and sixty-six participants completed questionnaires measuring demographic characteristics, alcohol drinking, betel quid chewing, cigarette smoking, health beliefs, cues to action, self-efficacy, and likelihood of undergoing an OME. We used structural equation modeling (SEM) to investigate the direct and indirect paths, to predict the likelihood of undergoing an OME, in three different health risk groups. Classification of participants into groups of high, moderate, and low risk of developing oral cancer was based on the whether or not the participants drank alcohol, chewed betel quid, or smoked cigarettes. Results: The modified HBM demonstrated a good fit among the high, moderate, and low-risk groups, and explained 50%, 37%, and 30% of the variance of undergoing an OME, respectively. The direct and indirect paths influencing the likelihood of undergoing an OME varied significantly among the three groups. Conclusions: Based on the findings, care must be taken when selecting responsive health education for provision to participants with different health beliefs and levels of risks.

1. Altieri, A.,Bosetti, C.,Gallus, S.(2004).Wine, beer and spirits and risk of oral and pharyngeal cancer: a case-control study from Italy and Switzerland.Oral Oncol,40,904-9.
2. Anderson, J.C.,Gerbing, D.W.(1988).Structural equation modeling in practice. A review and recommended two-step approach.Psychol Bull,103,411-23.
3. Arbuckle, J.L.(2009).Amos™ 18 User's Guide.Chicago, IL:SPSS Inc.
4. Bandura, A.(1977).Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavior change.Psychol Rev,84,191-215.
5. Becker, M.H.,Maiman, L.A.,Kirscht, J.P.,Haefner, D.P.,Drachman, R.H.(1977).The Health Belief Model in the prediction of dietary compliance: a field experiment.J Health Soc Behav,18,348-66.
6. Bernier, J.(ed.)(2011).Head and Neck Cancer: Multimodality Management.New York:Springer.
7. Bradley, J.,Barone, M.,Mahé, C.,Lewis, R.,Luciani, S.(2005).Delivering cervical cancer prevention services in low-resource settings.Int J Gynaecol Obstet,89(Suppl 2),S21-9.
8. Brotherstone, H.,Miles, A.,Robb, K.A.,Atkin, W.,Wardle, J.(2006).The impact of illustrations on public understanding of the aim of cancer screening.Patient Educ Couns,63,328-35.
9. Çapık, C.,Gözüm, S.(2011).Development and validation of health beliefs model scale for prostate cancer screenings (HBM-PCS): evidence from exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses.Eur J Oncol Nurs,15,478-85.
10. Chang, W.C.,Lan, T.H.,Ho, W.C.,Lan, T.Y.(2010).Factors affecting the use of health examinations by the elderly in Taiwan.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,50(Suppl 1),S11-6.
11. Cunningham, S.D.,Kerrigan, D.,Pillay, K.B.,Ellen, J.M.(2005).Understanding the role of perceived severity in STD-related care-seeking delays.J Adolesc Health,37,69-74.
12. Cyr, A.,Dunnagan, T.,Haynes, G.(2010).Efficacy of the health belief model for predicting intention to pursue genetic testing for colorectal cancer.J Genet Couns,19,174-86.
13. Downer, M.C.,Moles, D.R.,Palmer, S.,Speight, P.M.(2006).A systematic review of measures of effectiveness in screening for oral cancer and precancer.Oral Oncol,42,551-60.
14. Elango, K.J.,Anandkrishnan, N.,Suresh, A.,Iyer, S.K.,Ramaiyer, S.K.,Kuriakose, M.A.(2011).Mouth self-examination to improve oral cancer awareness and early detection in a high-risk population.Oral Oncol,47,620-4.
15. Hair, J.F.,Black, W.C.,Babin, B.J.,Anderson, R.E.(2010).Multivariate Data Analysis. A Global Perspective.New Jersey:Pearson Education, Inc.
16. Heggenhougen, K.(ed.),Quah, S.(ed.)(2008).International Encyclopedia of Public Health.San Diego:Academic Press.
17. Hsing, C.Y.,Wong, Y.K.,Wang, C.P.(2011).Comparison between free flap and pectoralis major pedicled flap for reconstruction in oral cavity cancer patients-a quality of life analysis.Oral Oncol,47,522-7.
18. Hu, L.T.,Bentler, P.M.(1999).Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariancestructure analysis. Conventional criteria versus new alternatives.Struct Equation Model,6,1-55.
19. Humphris, G.M.,Freeman, R.,Clarke, H.M.M.(2004).Risk perception of oral cancer in smokers attending primary care: a randomised controlled trial.Oral Oncol,40,916-24.
20. Janz, N.K.,Becker, M.H.(1984).The Health Belief Model: a decade later.Health Educ Q,11,1-47.
21. Jones, R.M.,Devers, K.J.,Kuzel, A.J.,Woolf, S.H.(2010).Patient-reported barriers to colorectal cancer screening: a mixed-methods analysis.Am J Prev Med,38,508-16.
22. Jonnalagadda, S.,Bergamo, C.,Lin, J.J.(2012).Beliefs and attitudes about lung cancer screening among smokers.Lung Cancer,77,526-31.
23. Kao, S.Y.,Chen, Y.W.,Chang, K.W.,Liu, T.Y.(2009).Detection and screening of oral cancer and pre-cancerous lesions.J Chin Med Assoc,72,227-33.
24. Kline, R.B.(2005).Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling.New York:Guilford Press.
25. Ko, Y.C.,Huang, Y.L.,Lee, C.H.,Chen, M.J.,Lin, L.M.,Tsai, C.C.(1995).Betel quid chewing, cigarette smoking and alcohol consumption related to oral cancer in Taiwan.J Oral Pathol Med,24,450-3.
26. Llewellyn, C.D.,Linklater, K.,Bell, J.,Johnson, N.W.,Warnakulasuriya, S.(2004).An analysis of risk factors for oral cancer in young people: a case-control study.Oral Oncol,40,304-13.
27. McNamara, K.K.,Martin, B.D.,Evans, E.W.,Kalmar, J.R.(2012).The role of direct visual fluorescent examination (VELscope) in routine screening for potentially malignant oral mucosal lesions.Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol,114,636-43.
28. Miedema, B.,Tatemichi, S.(2003).Breast and cervical cancer screening for women between 50 and 69 years of age: what prompts women to screen?.Womens Health Issues,13,180-4.
29. Montgomery, K.,Smith-Glasgow, M.E.(2012).Human papillomavirus and cervical cancer knowledge, health beliefs, and preventive practices in 2 age cohorts: a comparison study.Gend Med,9(1 Suppl),S55-66.
30. Moon, S.,Kim, S.H.,Kim, M.J.(2011).Perceived cognitive function and related factors in Korean women with breast cancer.Asian Nurs Res,5,141-50.
31. Pons-Vigués, M.,Puigpinós-Riera, R.,Rodríguez, D.(2012).Country of origin and prevention of breast cancer: beliefs, knowledge and barriers.Health Place,18,1270-81.
32. Rosenstock, I.M.(1974).Historical origins of the health belief model.Health Educ Monogr,2,1-8.
33. Rosenstock, I.M.,Strecher, V.J.,Becher, M.H.(1988).Social learning theory and the Health Belief Model.Health Educ Q,15,175-83.
34. Secginli, S.,Nahcivan, N.O.(2006).Factors associated with breast cancer screening behaviours in a sample of Turkish women: a questionnaire survey.Int J Nurs Stud,43,161-71.
35. Shen, W.P.、Lu, C.M.、Yu, L.H.、Kao, Y.H.、Huang, C.M.(2010)。Applied health belief model to explore adult's oral screen behavior and influencing factors。J Healthy Life Successful Aging，2，12-25。
36. Tan, B.S.,Ng, K.H.,Esa, R.(2001).Health beliefs in oral cancer:Malaysian estate Indian scenario.Patient Educ Couns,42,205-11.
37. Tomarken, A.J.,Waller, N.G.(2005).Structural equation modeling: strengths, limitations, and misconceptions.Annu Rev Clin Psychol,1,31-65.
38. Tramacere, I.,Negri, E.,Bagnardi, V.(2010).A meta-analysis of alcohol drinking and oral and pharyngeal cancers. Part 1: overall results and dose-risk relation.Oral Oncol,46,497-503.
39. Tsai, W.C.,Wu, M.T.,Wang, G.J.(2012).Chewing areca nut increases the risk of coronary artery disease in taiwanese men: a case-control study.BMC Public Health,12,162.
40. van Leeuwen, P.J.,Connolly, D.,Gavin, A.(2010).Prostate cancer mortality in screen and clinically detected prostate cancer: estimating the screening benefit.Eur J Cancer,46,377-83.
41. Wang, Y.H.,Kung, P.T.,Tsai, W.C.,Tai, C.J.,Liu, S.A.,Tsai, M.H.(2012).Effects of multidisciplinary care on the survival of patients with oral cavity cancer in Taiwan.Oral Oncol,48,803-10.
42. Yen, A.M.,Chen, S.C.,Chen, T.H.(2007).Dose-response relationships of oral habits associated with the risk of oral pre-malignant lesions among men who chew betel quid.Oral Oncol,43,634-8.
43. Zavras, A.I.,Douglass, C.W.,Joshipura, K.(2001).Smoking and alcohol in the etiology of oral cancer: gender-specific risk profiles in the south of Greece.Oral Oncol,37,28-35.

1. 楊淑玲,施俊名(2019)。運用健康信念模式分析大學女生接種人類乳突病毒疫苗之意願。性學研究，9(2)，47-62。