資訊揭露透明度與醫院治理效能：一代健保與二代健保比較研究

Transparency of Information Disclosure and Effectiveness of Hospital Governance: A Comparative Study of the First and Second Generations of Nation Health Insurance

10.6288/TJPH201433102095

嚴玉華(Yu-Hua Yan)；方世杰(Shih-Chieh Fang)

資訊揭露 ； 醫院治理 ； 醫院治理效能 ； information disclosure ； hospital governance ； hospital governance effectiveness

台灣公共衛生雜誌

33卷2期（2014 / 04 / 15）

131 - 147

繁體中文

目標：資訊揭露透明度為醫院治理能效能否發揮之關鍵要素，本研究試圖比較醫院強制性資訊揭露（二代健保）與自願性資訊揭露（一代健保）對於醫院治理效能之關聯性。方法：本研究採用問卷調查，以全國各醫院高階主管為填卷對象，有效問卷196份，以卡方檢定、T檢定、複迴歸及鄒檢定進行研究分析。結果：資訊揭露透明度會影響醫院治理效能，在目前健保制度下，醫院有關違規資訊愈不揭露，則顧客效能愈好；醫療品質及財務報表揭露度愈高，則醫院之學習成長效能愈好。在差異比較分析結果方面，一代健保醫療品質揭露對社會責任效能達到顯著正向效果；二代健保則醫療處置流程透明度愈低，則財務效能愈好。最後，無論是在一代或二代健保，就醫流程揭露及財務報表揭露，皆能正向影響醫院社會責任效能。結論：醫院治理效能顯示願意傳達揭露資訊給利害關係人，則醫院治理效能會較高。提供消費者醫療揭露資訊時，應提高其應用性，以減少處理相關資訊的負擔。

Objectives: Transparent information disclosure is a key factor affecting the effectiveness of hospital governance. This study compared the association between mandatory disclosure (Second Generation National Health Insurance (NHI)) and voluntary disclosure (First Generation NHI) in relation to the effectiveness of hospital governance. Methods: This research was conducted through the questionnaire survey method and the research subjects included senior executives from hospitals nationwide. A total of 196 valid questionnaires were returned. Data collected from the survey were analyzed by the chi-square test, T-test, multiple regression analysis, and Chow Test. Results: The transparency of information disclosure affected the effectiveness of hospital governance. Lower levels of disclosure regarding hospital violations corresponded to greater effectiveness in terms of the management of customer relationships. Higher levels of disclosure about the quality of medical services and hospital financial reports corresponded to greater effectiveness in hospital learning and development. In First Generation NHI, disclosure of the quality of medical services has a significant positive effect on social responsibility, but in Second Generation NHI, lower transparency about the processes of medical management corresponded to greater financial effectiveness. Finally, in both First and Second Generation NHI, disclosure of medical treatment processes and hospital financial reports had a positive effect on the hospital's effectiveness in terms of social responsibility. Conclusions: Hospitals conveying a willingness to disclose information to stakeholders generally had greater effectiveness in hospital governance. When disclosing medical information to consumers, practicality should be monitored, so that the burden of processing the related information is minimized.

1. 文羽苹、黃旭明、江東亮(2012)。台灣醫療保健支出成長率的分析：醫療通膨，質量與公平性。台灣衛誌，31，1-10。
   連結：
2. 何怡澄(2012)。台灣醫院網頁公開揭露財務資訊決定因素。台灣衛誌，31，136-51。
   連結：
3. 汪秀玲、黃俊英(2010)。醫院策略強調對醫師專業自主影響之跨層次分析：層級線性模式的應用。人力資源管理學報，10，33-54。
   連結：
4. 周惠櫻、鄧昇謨(2011)。台灣醫院對利害關係人企業社會責任之初探。醫務管理期刊，12，206-19。
   連結：
5. 林江亮、李岫穎(2008)。影響非營利組織網站資揭露程度之研究。人文及社會科學集刊，20，327-56。
   連結：
6. 林鳳儀、蘇信安(2012)。自願性資訊揭露與強制性資訊揭露之盈餘管理。管理學報，28，345-59。
   連結：
7. 莊正民、方世杰(2013)。「組織內與組織間治理」的本質與策略意涵。台大管理論叢，23，1-24。
   連結：
8. 郭振雄、何怡澄、羅德城(2006)。非營利醫院的負債融資與社區公益活動。台灣衛誌，25，440-8。
   連結：
9. 歐進士、趙令海、洪嘉聲、林惠美(2012)。實施全民健康保險對醫院經營效率影響之研究。台大管理論叢，22，253-75。
   連結：
10. 嚴玉華、楊鎮維(2013)。醫院治理機制與效能之研究。台大管理論叢，23，57-82。
    連結：
11. 衛生福利部中央健康保險署：「醫院總額研商議事會議」第59次會議資料。http://www.nhi.gov.tw。引用2013/10/27。National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). The materials of the 59th hospital global budget discussion meeting. Available at: http://www.nhi.gov.tw. Accessed October 27, 2013. [In Chinese]
12. Angst, CM,Agarwal, R,Gao, G,Khuntia, J,McCullough, J.(2014).Information technology and voluntary quality disclosure by hospitals.Decis Support Syst,57,367-75.
13. Cheng, SH,Song, HY(2004).Physician performance information and consumer choice: a survey of subjects with the freedom to choose between doctors.Qual Saf Health Care,3,98-101.
14. Chow, GC(1960).Tests of equality between sets of coefficients in two linear regressions.Econometrica,28,591-605.
15. Culica, D,Prezio, E.(2009).Hospital board infrastructure and functions: the role of governance in financial performance.Int J Environ Res Public Health,6,862-73.
16. DiMaggio, PJ.(1988).Interest and agent in institutional theory.Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment,Cambridge, MA:
17. Doshi, AR,Dowell, GWS,Toffel, MW.(2013).How firms respond to mandatory information disclosure.Strat Manag J,34,1209-31.
18. Gelb, DS,Strawser, JA(2001).Corporate social responsibility and financial disclosures: an alternative explanation for increased disclosure.J Bus Ethics,33,1-13.
19. Greenstone, M,Oyer, P,Vissing-Jorgensen, A.(2006).Mandated disclosure, stock returns, and the 1964 Security Act Amendments.Q J Econ,121,399-460.
20. Greenwood, R,Hinings, CR(1996).Understanding radical organizational change: bringing together the old and the new institutionalism.Acad Manage Rev,21,1022-54.
21. Griffith, JR,Alexander, JA,Jelink, RC(2002).Measuring comparative hospital performance.J Healthc Manag,47,41-57.
22. Griffith, JR,White, KR(2002).The Well-Managed Healthcare Organization.Chicago:Health Administration Press.
23. Grossa, R,Tabenkin, H,Brammli-Greenberg, S.(2007).Factors affecting primary care physicians' perceptions of health system reform in Israel: professional autonomy versus organizational affiliation.Soc Sci Med,64,1450-62.
24. Hair, JF,Black, WC,Babin, BJ,Anderson, RE(2009).Multivariate Data Analysis.New Jersey:Prentice Hall.
25. Hibbard, JH,Jewett, JJ.(1997).Will quality report cards help consumers.Health Aff (Millwood),16,218-28.
26. Hibbard, JH,Stockard, J,Tusler, M.(2003).Does publicizing hospital performance stimulate quality improvement efforts?.Health Aff (Millwood),22,84-94.
27. Jha, AK,Orav, EJ,Epstein, AM(2011).Low-quality, highcost hospitals, mainly in South, care for sharply higher shares of elderly black, Hispanic, and medicaid patients.Health Aff (Millwood),30,1904-11.
28. Leatherman, S,McCarthy, D.(1999).Public disclosure of health care performance reports: experience, evidence and issues for policy.Int J Qual Health Care,11,93-8.
29. Lu, JR,Hsiao, WC(2003).Does universal health insurance make health careunaffordable? Lessons from Taiwan.Health Aff (Millwood),22,77-88.
30. Mallin, C.(2002).The relationship between corporate governance, transparency and financial disclosure.Corp Govern Int Rev,10,253-5.
31. McDonald, RE,Srinivasan, N.(2004).Technological innovations in hospitals: what kind of competitive advantage does adoption lead to?.Int J Technol Manag,28,103-17.
32. Murphy, C,O'Donohoe S.(2006).Hospital governance: an insight from the south east of Ireland.Proceedings of the Irish Accounting & Finance Association Annual Conference,Ireland:
33. Prybil, L,Levey, S,Peterson, R(2009).Governance in High-Performing Community Health Systems. A Report on Trustee and CEO Views.Chicago:Grant Thornton LLP.
34. Sridhar, D,Khagram, S,Pang, T.(2009).Are existing governance structures equipped to deal with today's global health challenges-towards systematic coherence in scaling up.Global Health Governance,2,1-25.
35. Stivers, BP,Joyce, T.(2000).Building a balanced performance management system.SAM Adv Manag J,65,22-9.
36. Swayne, LE,Duncan, WJ,Ginter, PM(2013).Strategic Management of Health Care Management.Malden:Blackwell Publishers.
37. Weil, D,Fung, A,Graham, M,Fagotto, E.(2006).The effectiveness of regulatory disclosure policies.J Policy Anal Manage,25,155-81.
38. Wocher, J.(2004).Hospital governance and the balanced scorecard-new concepts for Japanese hospitals?.Jpn Hosp,23,38-9.
39. Yan, YH,Hsu, SF,Yang, CW,Fang, SC(2010).Agency problems in hospitals participating in self-management project under global budget system in Taiwan.Health Policy,94,135-43.
40. Yang, J,Zhao, J,Zhai, Y.(2013).The effectiveness of public hospital governance model evaluation and analysis.Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Systems Engineering and Modeling (ICSEM),Beijing, China:
41. 王怡人(2011)。邁向二代健保新紀元─全民健康保險法100年1月修正重點介紹。醫事法學，18，89-95。
42. 王河清、童超塵(2001)。運用平衡計分卡建構新策略管理制度─以醫療產業為例。醫院，34，7-15。
43. 吳文祥、林進財、彭廣興(2009)。醫院因應總額預算支付制度之適應策略評選─以新竹市醫院為例。健康管理學刊，7，79-92。
44. 吳安妮(2005)。策略地圖之精髓與運用。馬偕院訊，25，3-12。
45. 吳肖琪、吳義勇、朱慧凡(2002)。我國醫院醫療品質指標使用之情形。醫療品質雜誌，2，1-14。
46. 李佳容、林進財、譚醒朝、張曉芬(2010)。台灣地區財團法人醫院財務績效之評估。健康管理學刊，8，199-208。
47. 林佳靜、張曉芬、譚醒朝、譚家惠(2005)。醫院對平衡計分卡之認知與現況分析。健康管理學刊，3，1-17。
48. 高鳳儀、吳孟嬪、蔡欣玲、邱艶芬(2008)。護理人員對2007年版台灣醫院評鑑標準之認知、態度與行為。北市醫學雜誌，5，593-608。
49. 張朝凱、王一中(2010)。評估總額預算下眼科醫師做為醫療供給者的行為變化─從競爭的公眾悲劇轉為合作的納許平衡。中眼醫誌，49，1-7。
50. 陳巧珊、程于珊、許怡欣(2008)。運用資料包絡分析法探討署立醫院、縣市立醫院及其委託經營醫院經營效率。澄清醫護管理雜誌，4，7-13。
51. 陳孝平(2011)。百年轉折看健保─「一代」的總結與「二代」的發軔。社區發展，133，233-52。
52. 陳英傑、陳英豪(2006)。應用病患滿意度概念於醫療服務品質之探析。品質月刊，44，14-7。
53. 陳澤義、陳啟斌(2011)。企業診斷與績效評估─平衡計分卡之運用。台北=Taipei:華泰文化=Hwa Tai Publising。
54. 劉美玉、許輔宸、郭素娥、張肅婷(2008)。門診病患滿意度之分析探討。中山醫學雜誌，19，209-20。
55. 盧瑞芬、謝啟瑞(2012)。醫療經濟學。台北=Taipei:學富出版社=Pro-Ed Publishing Company。
56. 蘇勳璧、彭朱如、鄧振華(2001)。不同等級醫院其資源優勢、策略優勢與績效之關係。醫務管理期刊，2，93-109。

1. 邱銘心,林家圻(2019)。網路醫師資訊之內容分析研究。教育資料與圖書館學，56(2)，163-199。
2. 汪秀玲(2019)。台灣醫院企業社會責任報告之職業安全衛生實踐和揭露。勞動及職業安全衛生研究季刊，27(2)，116-132。