醫師面對老年病人時之電子病歷交換資訊需求與意願的初探研究

A preliminary study of the information needed in Electronic Medical Records exchange and physicians' usage intention when treating elderly patients

10.6288/TJPH201736106023

佘明玲(Ming-Ling Sher)；翁儷禎(Li-Jen Weng)

電子病歷 ； 電子病歷資訊 ； 電子化醫療資訊 ； 電子病歷交換 ； 健康資訊交換 ； electronic medical records (EMR) ； information of EMR ； electronic medical information ； EMR exchange ； health information exchange

台灣公共衛生雜誌

36卷3期（2017 / 06 / 15）

288 - 300

繁體中文

目標：從需求面探討面對老年病人時醫師需要其他機構電子病歷的項目，及其對醫師使用電子病歷交換之意願與可能性的影響。方法：由文獻歸納電子病歷交換需求項目，以德菲法修改問卷，再對某醫療體系之醫師進行調查。復以因素分析探討電子病歷需求之因素，並以之對醫師使用電子病歷交換之意願與在不同診療途徑之使用可能性進行複迴歸分析。結果：電子病歷交換資訊需求之因素分析呈現四因素，醫師需求依次為：個人特殊病史，檢驗檢查報告，療程變化記錄，家系資料與照護記錄。個人特殊病史有助於增進醫師取用意願與在住院和急診時取用電子病歷交換之可能性，家系資料與照護記錄則可增進醫師於預防保健時取用電子病歷之可能性。結論：醫師面對老年病人最需要的病歷內容非現行電子病歷交換平台之主要項目。建議電子病歷交換宜以使用者需求為出發點，將來可考慮自健保資訊系統自動擷取醫師所需之重要項目，或由醫師協助彙整提報，以增進電子病歷交換之臨床應用價值。

Objectives: This study explored the information in Electronic Medical Records (EMR) exchange that physicians need when dealing with elderly patients, and the relationship between information needed and physicians' intention to use EMR exchange in clinical settings. Methods: A questionnaire containing items of EMR exchanges crucial in the treatment of elderly patients was constructed based on a literature review, revised by the Delphi method, and distributed to physicians in a medical care system. Factors underlying the items were revealed by factor analysis and subject to multiple regression analysis to determine their relationships with physicians' intention to use EMR exchange. Results: Four factors listed in a descending order of necessity for treating elderly patients were identified: Patient's Special History, Laboratory and Radiology Reports, Progress Notes, and Family Data and Healthcare Records. Patient's Special History could facilitate physicians' intention to use EMR exchange and the likelihood of adopting EMR exchange for in-patient and emergency care, while Family Data and Healthcare Records may enhance the possibility of using EMR exchange for preventive care. Conclusions: The information most needed in EMR exchange when treating elderly patients is not among the main retrieval items provided by the current EMR exchange platform. It is recommended that the information physicians need should be the major concern when designing an EMR exchange system. The items that physicians need the most can be retrieved automatically from National Health Insurance information systems or provided by physicians in order to enhance the clinical value of EMR exchange in the future.

1. 黃興進、張怡秋、高正雄、吳彬安、黃穗秋：衛生福利部九十四年度醫療院所病歷電子化現況調查。台北：衛生福利部，2005。 Hwang HG, Chang IC, Kao CH, Wu PA, Huang SC. 2005 Ministry of Health and Welfare Survey of the Status of Medical Record Computerization at Medical Care Institutions Nationwide. Taipei: Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan), 2005. [In Chinese]
2. 衛生福利部電子病歷交換中心：提供電子病歷交換醫院。https://eec.mohw.gov.tw/?PAGE=EMRH。引用2016/04/02。 Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Hospitals providing electronic medical records exchange. Available at: https://eec.mohw.gov. tw/?PAGE=EMRH. Accessed April 2, 2016. [In Chi­nese]
3. Carter, JH(2008).Electronic Health Record? Electronic Health Records: A Guide for Clinicians and Administrators.Philadelphia, PA:ACP Press.
4. De, Boeck, P,Wilson, M,Acton, GS(2005).A conceptual and psychometric framework for distinguishing catego­ries and dimensions.Psychol Rev,112,129-58.
5. Eden, KB,Totten, AM,Kassakian, SZ(2016).Barriers and facilitators to exchanging health information: a systematic review.Int J Med Inform,88,44-51.
6. Li, YC,Yen, JC,Chiu, WT,Jian, WS,Syed-Abdul, S,Hsu, MH(2015).Building a national electronic medical record exchange system - experiences in Taiwan.Comput Methods Programs Biomed,121,14-20.
7. Lorenzi, NM,Riley, RT,Blyth, AJ,Southon, G,Dixon, BJ(1997).Antecedents of the people and organizational aspects of medical informatics.J Am Med Inform Assoc,4,79-93.
8. Nelson, SD,Del, FG,Hanseler, H,Crouch, BI,Cum­mins, MR(2016).Software prototyping: a case report of refining user requirements for a health information exchange dashboard.Appl Clin Inform,7,22-32.
9. Ross, SE,Schilling, LM,Fernald, DH,Davidson, AJ,West, DR(2010).Health information exchange in small-to-medium sized family medicine practices: motivators, barriers, and potential facilitators of adoption.Int J Med Inf,79,123-9.
10. Vest, JR,Zhao, H,Jaspserson, J,Gamm, LD,Ohsfeldt, RL(2011).Factors motivating and affecting health infor­mation exchange usage.J Am Med Inform Assoc,18,143-9.
11. Waegemann, CP(1996).The five levels of electronic health records.MD Comput,13,199-203.
12. 呂宗學、蘇慧貞(2013)。海量資料分析在醫療照護領域的應用。台灣醫學，17，652-61。
13. 范碧玉、周文鈺、張晏晏(2010)。台灣POMR病歷記錄系統認知及實施概況初探分析。病歷資訊管理，9，51-71。
14. 徐嫦娥、簡郁沛(2010)。電子病歷之發展及法規政策。病歷資訊管理，9，1-18。
15. 章英華編、傅仰止編、瞿海源編(1995)。社會調查與分析。台北=Taipei:中央研究院民族學研究所=Institute of Ethnology, Academia Sinica。
16. 黃興進、佘明玲、劉忠峰(2006)。醫療資訊管理。嘉義=Chiayi:台灣健康資訊管理學會=Taiwan Health Information Management Association。
17. 葉碧玉、吳月宏(1990)。有效的病歷記載─問題導向病歷。病歷管理。新北市=New Taipei City:合記圖書=Ho-Chi Publishing Co.。
18. 劉立、楊漢(2013)。醫療與雲端之四─健康雲成功背後的巨量資料。醫院雙月刊，46，1-11。
19. 蔡鳳凰、黃勢璋(2015)。健康雲驅動雲端新商機。經濟前瞻，161，41-5。

1. 戴志融、蕭宇涵、蔡興治、陳厚全、徐永年、李孟智、王懿範(2017)。衛政與社政整合之理念、模式與先驅計畫。醫學與健康期刊，6(2)，1-16。
2. 黃興進,翁儷禎,佘明玲(2019)。影響老年病人就診科別醫師使用電子病歷交換意願因素之初探研究。台灣公共衛生雜誌，38(4)，416-430。