醫院整合醫學照護制度之國際經驗與對台灣的啟示

International experience with a hospital medicine care system and lessons for Taiwan

10.6288/TJPH201736106038

黃俊哲(CHUN-CHE HUANG)；譚家惠(ELISE CHIA-HUI TAN)；楊銘欽(MING-CHIN YANG)

醫院整合醫學 ； 醫院整合醫學科醫師 ； 照護制度 ； hospital medicine ； hospitalist ； care system

台灣公共衛生雜誌

36卷5期（2017 / 10 / 15）

427 - 438

繁體中文

醫院整合醫學（Hospital medicine）照護制度是由固定群組的主治醫師，採完整交接班的方式提供住院病人整合醫療照護，並與醫療團隊成員共同照護住院病人，以改善醫院和醫療照護體系執行成效，期藉此能達到促進住院病人安全、提升照護品質和妥善運用醫療資源之目標。美國是最早推行此制度的國家，隨後英國、加拿大、新加坡和日本等國家相繼仿效，並依各國健康照護體系的特色，發展照護模式及規劃專科醫師培育訓練，台灣亦在2015年6月起以試辦計畫方式於部分醫院推行。本文回顧與整理主要國家發展醫院整合醫學照護制度的沿革和實施經驗，期許對台灣發展醫院整合醫學照護制度的啟發。從國際經驗來看，本文建議加強醫院整合醫學科醫師招募、教育訓練和專業發展、提昇醫院高層管理者支持程度，以及提高病人對醫院整合醫學科醫師的認知與態度等因應措施，使台灣能朝發展在地化醫院整合醫學照護制度之目標邁進。

A hospital medicine care system is a type of integrated care for inpatients provided by a fixed group of attending physicians with a complete handover system. They also work with other team members to take care of hospitalized patients in order to improve system performance. The objectives of this system are to promote the safety of inpatients, improve the quality of care, and utilize medical care resources more appropriately. The United States was the first country to implement this system, and was followed by the United Kingdom, Canada, Singapore, and Japan. Each country developed its care system and specialty training programs according to its own conditions. Taiwan also initiated a trial program in some hospitals in June, 2015. This paper reviews the development and practice experience of major countries with hospital medicine care systems, in hope of inspiring the development of hospital medicine in Taiwan. Based on international experience, the authors suggest strengthening the recruitment, training, and career development of hospital medicine specialists, elevating the degree of support from top management, and increasing the recognition by patients that hospital medicine specialists are key factors in helping Taiwan develop its own hospital medicine care system.

1. 國立台灣大學健康政策與管理研究所：專責一般醫療主治醫師照護制度推廣輔導計畫。http://www.hospitalist.tw/。引用2016/12/18。Institute of Health Policy and Management, National Taiwan University. Promotion and assistance program for hospitalist system. Available at: http://www.hospitalist.tw/. Accessed December 18, 2016. [In Chinese]
2. 衛生福利部：衛福部將推動Hospitalist照護制度，開啟醫療照護新紀元。http://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-16-18939-1.html。引用2017/7/10。Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Ministry of Health and Welfare will build the hospitalist care system: to create a new era of medical care. Available at: http://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-16-18939-1.html. Accessed July 10, 2017. [In Chinese]
3. Society of Hospital Medicine. Definition of a hospitalist and hospital medicine. Society of Hospital Medicine, 2015. Available at: https://www.hospitalmedicine.org/Web/About_SHM/Hospitalist_Definition/About_SHM/Industry/Hospital_Medicine_Hospital_Definition.aspx?hkey=fb083d78-95b8-4539-9c5b-58d4424877aa. Accessed November 11, 2016
4. Society of Hospital Medicine. Education: learning opportunities. Society of Hospital Medicine, 2017. Available at: http://www.hospitalmedicine.org/Web/Education/Web/Education/Education_Landing_Page.aspx?hkey=20fb2a7e-28fe-4358-b06f-3ce5eb60e85b. Accessed March 1, 2017.
5. Peckham C. Medscape hospitalist compensation report 2016. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/features/slideshow/compensation/2016/hospitalist. Accessed July 18, 2017
6. Rubin R. 5 essentials for a successful hospitalist program. S tuder Group, 2015. Available at: https://www.studergroup.com/resources/newsmedia/healthcare-publications-resources/insights/february-2015/5-essentials-for-a-successfulhospitalist-program. Accessed November 30, 2016.
7. Yousefi V. What's in a name - defining hospitalists in Canada? Available at: http://healthydebate.ca/opinions/whats-in-a-name-defining-hospitalists-incanada Accessed November 18, 2016
8. 潘恆之：Hospitalist的定位、價值與發展策略—從法人醫院談起。http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/201510280151019.pdf。引用2017/03/28。Pan HC. The position, value and development strategy of hospitalists: beginning from the non-for-profit hospital. Available at: http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/201510280151019.pdf. Accessed March 28, 2017. [In Chinese]
9. 蔡易婷：台中榮總整合醫療照護病房成果報告。http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/2016373132558.pdf。引用2017/03/28。Tsai YT. Brief report of the hospital medicine ward of the Taichung Veterans General Hospital. Available at: http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/2016373132558.pdf. Accessed March 28, 2017. [In Chinese]
10. 許甯傑：台大整合醫療照護病房成果簡報。http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/201637313275.pdf。引用2017/03/28。Hsu NC. Brief report of the hospital medicine ward of the National Taiwan University Hospital. Available at: http://www.hospitalist.tw/file/201637313275.pdf. Accessed March 28, 2017. [In Chinese]
11. Byrne, D,Silke, B(2011).Acute medical units: review of evidence.Eur J Intern Med,22,344-7.
12. Harris, A,Carney, K,Volpicelli, FM(2017).Value in hospital medicine.Hosp Med Clin,6,131-45.
13. Hock, Lee K,Yang, Y,Soong, Yang K,Chi, Ong B,Seong, Ng H(2011).Bringing generalists into the hospital: outcomes of a family medicine hospitalist model in Singapore.J Hosp Med,6,115-21.
14. Ishiyama, T(2015).Critical roles of "J-Hospitalist".J Gen Fam Med,16,153-7.
15. Kuo, YF,Sharma, G,Freeman, JL,Goodwin, JS(2009).Growth in the care of older patients by hospitalists in the United States.N Engl J Med,360,1102-12.
16. Lee, KH(2008).The hospitalist movement - a complex adaptive response to fragmentation of care in hospitals.Ann Acad Med Singapore,37,145-50.
17. Messler, J,Whitcomb, WF(2015).A history of the hospitalist movement.Obstet Gynecol Clin North Am,42,419-32.
18. O'Leary, KJ,Lindquist, LA,Colone, MA,Haviley, C,Thompson, JA,Baker, DW(2008).Effect of a hospitalistcare coordinator team on a nonteaching hospitalist service.J Hosp Med,3,103-9.
19. Rachoin, JS,Skaf, J,Cerceo, E(2012).The impact of hospitalists on length of stay and costs: systematic review and meta-analysis.Am J Manag Care,18,e23-30.
20. Royal College of Physicians=RCP(2007).Acute Medical Care. The Right Person, in the Right Setting-First Time. Report of the Acute Medicine Task Force.London:RCP.
21. Soong, C,Fan, E,Howell, EE(2009).Characteristics of hospitalists and hospitalist programs in the United States and Canada.J Clin Outcomes Manag,16,69-74.
22. Thomas, S. L.(2013).Family medicine specialty in Singapore.J Family Med Prim Care,2,135-40.
23. Wachter, RM(1999).An introduction to the hospitalist model.Ann Intern Med,130,338-42.
24. Wachter, RM,Bell, D(2012).Renaissance of hospital generalists.BMJ,344,e652.
25. Wachter, RM,Goldman, L(1996).The emerging role of "hospitalists" in the American health care system.N Engl J Med,335,514-7.
26. Wachter, RM,Goldman, L(2016).Zero to 50,000 - the 20th anniversary of the hospitalist.N Engl J Med,375,1009-11.
27. Yousefi, V,Chong, CA(2013).Does implementation of a hospitalist program in a Canadian community hospital improve measures of quality of care and utilization? An observational comparative analysis of hospitalists vs. traditional care providers.BMC Health Serv Res,13,204.
28. Yousefi, V,Evans, M(2011).Hospital medicine maturity framework: proposing a novel framework for defining stages of hospital medicine in Canada.Healthc Q,14,67-73.
29. Yousefi, V,Wilton, D(2011).Re-designing hospital care: learning from the experience of hospital medicine in Canada.J Global Health Care Systems,1,1-10.
30. 小泉俊三(2011)。病院合（日本型ホスピタリスト）の現と近未像— を基盤とした合科として。日内会誌，100，3687-93。
31. 林高章、翁子傑、黃信凱(2014)。由整合照護及駐院主治醫師（HOS）的觀點，改善奇美醫院急診的新嚐試。醫療品質雜誌，8，93-6。
32. 黃信凱、吳孟杰、張純誠(2016)。從奇美醫院急診的疾病特性分析及病患擁擠情形，看駐院主治醫師制度的實施成效。台灣醫界，59，54-7。

1. 洪純隆、汪秀玲(2018)。醫院整合醫學照護制度（Hospitalist）對住院照護品質的影響，台灣文獻綜論。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，37(5)，499-513。
2. 黃俊達,陳強儀,周曉禎,卜宜芝(2020)。醫院整合醫學照護制度與專科護理師的角色。領導護理，21(2)，1-9。