Macroeconomic conditions and Internet search for end-of-life care: an analysis using Google Trends

經濟景氣與生命末期照護相關字詞搜尋之關係探討－以Google趨勢分析

10.6288/TJPH.201902_38(1).107051

吳丕玉(PI-YU WU)；王鶴偉(HO-WEI WANG)；陳端容(DUAN-RUNG CHEN)

Google Trends ； end-of-life care ； macroeconomics ； economic recession ； Google趨勢 ； 臨終照護 ； 總體經濟 ； 經濟衰退

台灣公共衛生雜誌

38卷1期（2019 / 02 / 22）

31 - 41

英文

Objectives: End-of-life (EOL) care imposes a significant financial burden on most caregivers, but the relationship between macroeconomic conditions and people's EOL care awareness remains unknown. This study employed Google Trends (GT) to explore the association between Internet search for EOL care and macroeconomic conditions. Methods: The weekly average Taiwan Stock Exchange (TWSE) weighted index from January 2008 to December 2013 was used as the macroeconomic index. Local Google searches for EOL care-related keywords from January 2008 to December 2015 were downloaded from GT. A series of correlation analyses was performed on the TWSE and the GT for each keyword at the concurrent time and at 3, 6, and 9 months later to ascertain the nowcasting and forecasting effect. Results: The GT indices for EOL care-related keywords were negatively correlated with the concurrent and previous TWSE indices. For each keyword, either the 6-month or 9-month forecasting effect was higher than the concurrent nowcasting effect, suggesting that worse economic conditions (lower TWSE) might be a factor associated with people's awareness of advanced EOL care. Conclusions: To better understand how people may be more sensitive to circumstances related to EOL care decisions, macroeconomic conditions and the implications of Internet search behavior should be further considered.

目標：照護生命末期的家人對許多照護者而言會造成龐大的經濟壓力，經濟景氣變壞是否與增加人們關心生命末期照護的訊息，尚未有探討。本研究藉由Google趨勢收集的資料，探討生命末期照護相關字詞搜尋狀況與經濟景氣之關係。方法：自雅虎財經網站下載2008年1月至2013年12月間的每週台灣加權股價指數作為經濟景氣的指標。從Google趨勢的網站下載台灣2008年1月至2015年12月間生命末期照護相關字詞的搜尋強度。分析方式為對各個關鍵字搜尋指數進行與台股大盤指數間的相關性分析，除了同期間指數與關鍵字搜尋指數的比較外，也分別對股價指數與各個關鍵字3,6,9個月後的關鍵字搜尋指數做相關分析，以探討股價對關鍵字搜尋具有同期效應或領先預測的效應。結果：整體而言，生命末期照護相關字詞的Google搜尋趨勢與反映經濟景氣的股市大盤指數間呈現負相關。股市大盤的股價走勢與其後的6個月後或9個月後的末期照護相關字詞相關性較為顯著，顯示當大環境經濟不理想時，人們對於生命末期病人照護的關切增加，人們想要了解安寧緩和療護的照護方式的搜尋行為也越多。結論：總體經濟景氣的變化與人們的網路搜尋行為有一定的關係，間接可幫助了解經濟環境與個人的臨終照護決策的相關性。

1. Artola, C,Pinto, F,de Pedraza García, P(2015).Can internet searches forecast tourism inflows?.Int J Manpow,36,103-116.
2. Butler, M,Ratner, E,McCreedy, E,Shippee, N,Kane, RL(2014).Decision aids for advance care planning: an overview of the state of the science.Ann Intern Med,161,408-418.
3. Carrière-Swallow, Y,Labbé, F(2013).Nowcasting with Google trends in an emerging market.J Forecast,32,289-298.
4. Cavazos-Rehg, PA,Krauss, MJ,Sowles, S(2016).A content analysis of depression-related tweets.Comput Human Behav,54,351-357.
5. Cho, S,Sohn, CH,Jo, MW(2013).Correlation between national influenza surveillance data and Google trends in South Korea.PLoS One,8,e81422.
6. Choi, H,Varian, H(2012).Predicting the present with Google trends.Econ Rec,88,2-9.
7. Comincioli, B(1996).The stock market as a leading indicator: an application of granger causality.University Avenue Undergraduate J Econ,1
8. Curtis, JR,Engelberg, RA,Bensink, ME,Ramsey, SD(2012).End-of-life care in the intensive care unit: can we simultaneously increase quality and reduce costs?.Am J Respir Crit Care Med,186,587-592.
9. Ferrara, L,Marsilli, C(2013).Financial variables as leading indicators of GDP growth: evidence from a MIDAS approach during the Great Recession.Appl Econ Lett,20,233-237.
10. Fleming, DA(2003).The burden of caregiving at the end-of-life.Mo Med,100,82-86.
11. Gardiner, C,Brereton, L,Frey, R,Wilkinson-Meyers, L,Gott, M(2014).Exploring the financial impact of caring for family members receiving palliative and end-of-life care: a systematic review of the literature.Palliat Med,28,375-390.
12. Hanratty, B,Holland, P,Jacoby, A,Whitehead, M(2007).Financiai stress and strain associated with terminal cancer - a review of the evidence.Palliat Med,21,595-607.
13. Ho, ZJ,Krishna, LK,Yee, CP(2010).Chinese familial tradition and Western influence: a case study in singapore on decision making at the end of life.J Pain Symptom Manage,40,932-937.
14. InsightXplorer. A review of Taiwan̓s internet usage in 2015. Available at: http://www.ixresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/report/InsightXplorer%20Biweekly%20Report_20160301.pdf. Accessed June 15, 2018. [In Chinese]
15. Karaca-Mandic, P,Yoo, SJC,Sommers, BD(2013).Recession led to a decline in out-of-pocket spending for children with special health care needs.Health Aff,32,1054-1062.
16. Karnizova, L,Khan, H(2015).The stock market and the consumer confidence channel: evidence from Canada.Empir Econ,49,551-573.
17. Krishna, L(2011).The position of the family of palliative care patients within the decision-making process at the end of life in Singapore.Ethics Med,27,183-190.
18. Lee, JE,Shin, DW,Cho, J(2015).Caregiver burden, patients’ self-perceived burden, and preference for palliative care among cancer patients and caregivers.Psychooncology,24,1545-1551.
19. McCarthy, MJ(2010).Internet monitoring of suicide risk in the population.J Affect Disord,122,277-279.
20. Mills, S,Mills, J.(2016).Future directions for community engagement as a public health approach to palliative care in Australia.Progr Palliat Care,24,15-18.
21. Mishara, BL,Weisstub, DN(2013).Premises and evidence in the rhetoric of assisted suicide and euthanasia.Int J Law Psychiatry,36,427-435.
22. National Bureau of Economic Research. Business Cycle Dating Committee, 2010. https://www.nber.org/cycles/sept2010.pdf. Accessed June 15, 2018.
23. Nuti, SV,Wayda, B,Ranasinghe, I(2014).The use of Google trends in health care research: a systematic review.PLoS One,9,e109583.
24. Pereira, J,Bruera, E(1998).The Internet as a resource for palliative care and hospice: a review and proposals.J Pain Symptom Manage,16,59-68.
25. Periyakoil, P.(2013).Using social media tools to build an active and effective social media presence about palliative care.J Palliat Med,16,599-600.
26. Preis, T,Susannah Moat, H,Eugene, SH(2013).Quantifying trading behavior in financial markets using google trends.Sci Rep,3,1684.
27. Shao, YY,Hsiue, EH,Hsu, CH(2017).National policies fostering hospice care increased hospice utilization and reduced the invasiveness of end-of-life care for cancer patients.Oncologist,22,843-849.
28. Su, YT(2008).Looking beyond retirement: patterns and predictors of formal end-of-life planning among retirement age individuals.J Fam Econ Issues,29,654-673.
29. Sueki, H(2011).Does the volume of Internet searches using suicide-related search terms influence the suicide death rate: data from 2004 to 2009 in Japan.Psychiatry Clin Neurosci,65,392-394.
30. Taiwan Network Information Center (TWNIC). A survey on broadb and internet usage in Taiwan. Available at: https://www.twnic.net.tw/download/200307/20160922d.pdf. 2016. Accessed June 15, 2018.
31. Tang, ST,Liu, TW,Tsai, CM,Wang, CH,Chang, GC,Liu, LN(2008).Patient awareness of prognosis, patientfamily caregiver congruence on the preferred place of death, and caregiving burden of families contribute to the quality of life for terminally ill cancer patients in Taiwan.Psychooncology,17,1202-1209.
32. Taubert, M,Watts, G,Boland, J,Radbruch, L(2014).Palliative social media.BMJ Support Palliat Care,4,13-18.
33. Tilden, VP,Tolle, SW,Drach, LL,Perrin, NA(2004).Out-of-hospital death: advance care planning, decedent symptoms, and caregiver burden.J Am Geriatr Soc,52,532-539.
34. Tucker-Seeley, RD,Abel, GA,Uno, H,Prigerson, H(2015).Financial hardship and the intensity of medical care received near death.Psychooncology,24,572-578.
35. Wang, HW,Chen, DR,Yu, HW,Chen, YM(2015).Forecasting the incidence of dementia and dementia-related outpatient visits with Google trends: evidence from Taiwan.J Med Internet Res,17,e264.
36. Yu, JS,Hassan, MK,Sanchez, B(2012).A re-examination of financial development, stock markets development and economic growth.Appl Econ,44,3479-3489.
37. Yu, M,Guerriere, DN,Coyte, PC(2015).Societal costs of home and hospital end-of-life care for palliative care patients in Ontario, Canada.Health Soc Care Community,23,605-618.