學齡兒童社會信任：家庭與班級層級因素探討

Family and class characteristics associated with social trust among school-aged children

10.6288/TJPH.201912_38(6).108080

簡毓嫺(Yu-Hsian Chien)；王郁婷(Nadia Wang)；王一安(I-An Wang)；蔡貞慧(Jen-Huoy Tsay)；張淑慧(Su-Hui Chang)；陳娟瑜(Chuan-Yu Chen)

社會信任 ； 兒童晚期 ； 多層次 ； 班級 ； 學校 ； social trust ； late childhood ； multilevel ； class ； school

台灣公共衛生雜誌

38卷6期（2019 / 12 / 16）

660 - 672

繁體中文

目標：探討國小學童社會信任分布及相關之家庭與班級層級環境因素。方法：本研究資料來源為台灣北部某縣市「兒童少年身心發展生活需求現況調查」。研究族群為公立小學共2,691位四年級學童，回應率為97.3%。該項行政調查資料採自填式紙筆問卷收集資訊，問卷內容包含有社會信任、個人及家庭狀況、學校及社區環境特性等。統計分析採多層次多元邏輯斯迴歸模型估計不同層級之社會環境因素與兒童晚期社會信任之相關性。結果：父母社經地位和親子關係與學童社會信任有正向相關：父母一位（含）以上非本國籍與學童低社會信任程度有顯著相關（調整勝算比1.36，95%信賴區間1.02-1.80）、感到被家人忽略與學童低社會信任程度有顯著相關（調整勝算比1.61，95%信賴區間1.22-2.11）。父母曾出席親師會與學童高社會信任程度呈正相關的現象出現於父母教育程度相對較高的班級中，而若班級父母教育程度相對較低，父母曾參加過親師會與學童社會信任程度較低相關。結論：個人及學校班級環境皆與學齡孩童的社會信任程度有關，尤其是個人的家庭特性。當社會資本為兒童健康發展的保護因子時，有必要進一步瞭解個體的社會信任於兒童晚期至青春期時的演變以及在家庭、學校與社區等層級中的可修飾環境因子，這將有助於兒童社會資本的正向發展。

Objectives: Social trust, an essential component of social capital, plays a significant role in shaping one's health and well-being. The present study aims to investigate the distribution of social trust in late childhood and associated social factors. Methods: Data were obtained from the Survey of Physical and Mental Development and Living Needs of Children. A total of 2,691 fourth-grade students were ascertained from public elementary schools in one of the northern counties/cities in Taiwan (response rate = 97.3%). Data were collected from a paper-and-pencil self-report questionnaire containing questions about individual demographics, parentchild interaction, community violence exposure, and social trust. Results: Multilevel multinomial logistic regression analyses indicated that parental socioeconomic status (e.g., having at least one immigrant parent (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR] = 1.35, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.02-1.79)) and parent-child relationship (e.g., feeling neglected (aOR = 1.61, 95% = 1.23-2.12)) are strongly correlated with children's low social trust level. The reduced odds of low social trust level associated with parent-teacher meeting attendance was salient only in the classes characterized by higher parental education (p＜0.05). Conclusions: Non-native parents, unfavorable parentchild interaction, and community violence exposure were strongly associated with one's endorsed low social trust in late childhood. Future research is needed to explore how social trust evolves through adolescence and to delineate probable modifiable social factors.

1. 鄭惠玲, HL,江東亮, TL(2002)。台灣的社會資本與自評健康。台灣衛誌，21，289-295。
   連結：
2. Abbott, S,Freeth, D(2008).Social capital and health: starting to make sense of the role of generalized trust and reciprocity.J Health Psychol,13,874-883.
3. Abdelzadeh, A,Lundberg, E(2017).Solid or flexible? Social trust from early adolescence to young adulthood.Scan Polit Stud,40,207-227.
4. Alesina, A,La Ferrara, E(2002).Who trusts others?.J Publ Econ,85,207-234.
5. Åslund, C,Nilsson, KW(2013).Social capital in relation to alcohol consumption, smoking, and illicit drug use among adolescents: a cross-sectional study in Sweden.Int J Equity Healt,12,33.
6. Bernath, MS,Feshbach, ND(1995).Children's trust: theory, assessment, development, and research directions.Appl Prev Psychol,4,1-19.
7. Betts, LR,Rotenberg, KJ,Trueman, M(2009).The early childhood generalized trust belief scale.Early Child Res Q,24,175-185.
8. Bradley, RH,Corwyn, RF(2002).Socioeconomic status and child development.Annu Rev Psychol,53,371-399.
9. Brandt, MJ,Wetherell, G,Henry, P(2015).Changes in income predict change in social trust: a longitudinal analysis.Polit Psychol,36,761-768.
10. Bronfenbrenner, U.(1979).The Ecology of Human Development.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
11. Comer, JP,Haynes, NM(1991).Parent involvement in schools: an ecological approach.Elementary Sch J,91,271-277.
12. Dinesen, PT(2010).Upbringing, early experiences of discrimination and social identity: explaining generalised trust among immigrants in Denmark.Scand Polit Stud,33,93-111.
13. Dinesen, PT(2012).Does generalized (dis) trust travel? Examining the impact of cultural heritage and destination- country environment on trust of immigrants.Polit Psychol,33,495-511.
14. Dinesen, PT.(2012).Parental transmission of trust or perceptions of institutional fairness: generalized trust of non-western immigrants in a high-trust society.Comp Polit,44,273-289.
15. Dinesen, PT,Sønderskov, KM(2015).Ethnic diversity and social trust: evidence from the micro-context.Am Sociol Rev,80,550-573.
16. DiPrete, TA,Forristal, JD(1994).Multilevel models: methods and substance.Annu Rev Sociol,20,331-357.
17. Flanagan, C,Stout, M(2010).Developmental patterns of social trust between early and late adolescence: age and school climate effects.J Res Adolesc,20,748-773.
18. Fowler, PJ,Tompsett, CJ,Braciszewski, JM,JacquesTiura, AJ,Baltes, BB(2009).Community violence: a metaanalysis on the effect of exposure and mental health outcomes of children and adolescents.Dev Psychopathol,21,227-259.
19. Glaeser, EL,Laibson, DI,Scheinkman, JA,Soutter, CL(2000).Measuring trust.Q J Econ,115,811-846.
20. Glanville, JL,Paxton, P(2007).How do we learn to trust? A confirmatory tetrad analysis of the sources of generalized trust.Soc Psychol Q,70,230-242.
21. Gunnarson, C,Loxbo, K(2012).School and the promotion of generalised trust: experiences from Sicily.J Trust Res,2,171-201.
22. Hamamura, T(2012).Social class predicts generalized trust but only in wealthy societies.J Cross Cult Psychol,43,498-509.
23. Hox, JJ,Moerbeek, M,van de Schoot, R(2017).Multilevel Analysis: Techniques and Applications.New York, NY:Routledge.
24. Imber, S(1973).Relationship of trust to academic performance.J Pers Soc Psychol,28,145-150.
25. Kawachi, I(ed.),Subramanian, S(ed.),Kim, D(ed.)(2008).Social Capital and Health.New York, NY:Springer.
26. Kawachi, I,Kennedy, BP,Lochner, K,Prothrow-Stith, D.(1997).Social capital, income inequality, and mortality.Am J Public Health,87,1491-1498.
27. Kawachi, I,Kim, D,Coutts, A,Subramanian, SV(2004).Commentary: reconciling the three accounts of social capital.Int J Epidemiol,33,682-690+700-704.
28. Larson, R,Richards, MH(1991).Daily companionship in late childhood and early adolescence: changing developmental contexts.Child Dev,62,284-300.
29. Lieberman, M,Doyle, AB,Markiewicz, D(1999).Developmental patterns in security of attachment to mother and father in late childhood and early adolescence: associations with peer relations.Child Dev,70,202-213.
30. Liu, Y,Fei, L,Sun, X(2018).Parental rearing behaviors and adolescent's social trust: roles of adolescent self-esteem and class justice climate.J Child Fam Stud,27,1415-1427.
31. Ljunge, M(2014).Trust issues: evidence on the intergenerational trust transmission among children of immigrants.J Econ Behav Organ,106,175-196.
32. Lo, Y,Chen, WT,Wang, IA,Liu, CY,Chen, WJ,Chen, CY(2019).Family and school social capitals in late childhood predict youthful drinking behaviors and problems.Drug Alcohol Depend,204,107482.
33. Lundborg, P.(2005).Social capital and substance use among Swedish adolescents - an explorative study.Soc Sci Med,61,1151-1158.
34. Margolin, G,Gordis, EB(2000).The effects of family and community violence on children.Annu Rev Psychol,51,445-479.
35. McNeal, RB Jr(2001).Differential effects of parental involvement on cognitive and behavioral outcomes by socioeconomic status.J Soc Econ,30,171-179.
36. Oskarsson, S,Thisted Dinesen, P,Dawes, CT,Johannesson, M,Magnusson, PKE(2017).Education and social trust: testing a causal hypothesis using the discordant twin design.Polit Psychol,38,515-531.
37. Putnam, RD(2001).Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York, NY:Simon and Schuster.
38. Reeskens, T,Hooghe, M(2008).Cross-cultural measurement equivalence of generalized trust. Evidence from the European Social Survey (2002 and 2004).Soc Indic Res,85,515-532.
39. Rotenberg, KJ,Fox, C,Green, S(2005).Construction and validation of a children's interpersonal trust belief scale.Br J Dev Psychol,23,271-293.
40. Rotter, JB(1971).Generalized expectancies for interpersonal trust.Am Psychol,26,443-452.
41. Rotter, JB(1967).A new scale for the measurement of interpersonal trust.J Pers,35,651-665.
42. Salmi, V,Smolej, M,Kivivuori, J(2007).Crime victimization, exposure to crime news and social trust among adolescents.Young,15,255-272.
43. Shen, AC,Feng, JY,Feng, JY(2019).Who gets protection? A national study of multiple victimization and child protection among Taiwanese children.J Interpers Violence,34,3737-3761.
44. Sherrod, LR(ed.),TorneyPurta, J(ed.),Flanagan, CA(ed.)(2010).Handbook of Research on Civic Engagement in Youth.Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
45. Stolle, D,Soroka, S,Johnston, R.(2008).When does diversity erode trust? Neighborhood diversity, interpersonal trust and the mediating effect of social interactions.Polit Stud,56,57-75.
46. Subramanian, SV,Kim, DJ,Kawachi, I.(2002).Social trust and self-rated health in US communities: a multilevel analysis.J Urban Health,79(4 Suppl 1),S21-S34.
47. Takakura, M.(2011).Does social trust at school affect students’ smoking and drinking behavior in Japan?.Soc Sci Med,72,299-306.
48. Tolsma, J,van der Meer, T,Gesthuizen, M(2009).The impact of neighbourhood and municipality characteristics on social cohesion in the Netherlands.Acta Politica,44,286-313.
49. Uslaner, EM(2002).The Moral Foundations of Trust.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
50. Uslaner, EM(2008).Where you stand depends upon where your grandparents sat: the inheritability of generalized trust.Public Opin Q,72,725-740.
51. van Lange, PAM(ed.),Rockenbach, B(ed.),Yamagishi, T(ed.)(2017).Trust in Social Dilemmas.In Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
52. Welch, MR,Rivera, RE,Conway, BP,Yonkoski, J,Lupton, PM,Giancola, R(2005).Determinants and consequences of social trust.Sociol Inq,75,453-473.
53. Wray-Lake, L,Flanagan, CA(2012).Parenting practices and the development of adolescents’ social trust.J Adolesc,35,549-560.
54. Yamagishi, T.(1986).The provision of a sanctioning system as a public good.J Pers Soc Psychol,51,110-116.
55. Yamagishi, T,Yamagishi, M(1994).Trust and commitment in the United States and Japan.Motiv Emot,18,129-166.
56. Ying, L,Ma, F,Huang, H,Guo, X,Chen, C,Xu, F(2015).Parental monitoring, parent-adolescent communication, and adolescents’ trust in their parents in China.PLoS One,10,e0134730.

1. 陳佳欣(2023)。臺灣國小數學低成就學生之數學成就影響因素研究。教育學誌，49，107-128。