自評健康與社會資本：以國際社會調查計畫資料為本的跨國分析

Self-rated health and social capital: cross-national analysis of international social survey data

10.6288/TJPH.202010_39(5).109020

高美英(Meei-Ying Kao)；吳齊殷(Chyi-In Wu)

健康 ； 社會資本 ； 社會信任 ； 社會參與 ； health ； social capital ； social trust ； social participation

台灣公共衛生雜誌

39卷5期（2020 / 10 / 28）

509 - 521

繁體中文

目標：近年來關於社會資本對健康的影響之探討漸多，許多研究皆指出不同層次的社會資本對健康的效益。然而，大部分的研究結果卻仍然有諸多限制。若無法釐清社會資本的外生性，以及缺乏對社會資本跨脈絡效應的理解等等，這些問題限制了過往研究結果的可推論性。本研究運用大規模的跨國資料，分析個人社會資本在不同非正式與正式的社會資源整合條件下，對健康的影響。方法：使用由全球數十個國家調查機構合作蒐集之跨國調查資料，國際社會調查（International Social Survey），取2007年休閒生活組與2017年網絡組兩筆資料進行分析。結果：個人的社會信任與社會參與皆與健康有正向連結，在「高社會資本國家」或「OECD國家」的社會參與對健康的正面影響更加明顯；而社會信任僅有在「高社會資本國家」對健康有額外的正向效應，在「OECD國家」則無此現象。結論：這個發現有助於我們重新理解不同面向社會資本對健康的作用方式，以及其效應如何受所處社會條件的影響而改變。

Objectives: The impact of social capital on health is increasingly discussed. Many studies have highlighted the health benefits of social capital. However, most research results are affected by limitations. Failure to clarify the exogenous nature of social capital and the cross-contextual effects of social capital may limit the inferences of other research. Therefore, in this study, large-scale multinational data are used to analyze the effect of individual social capital on health in various informal and formal social resource conditions. Methods: Data came from International Social Surveys, which are collected by dozens of national survey agencies worldwide. Data from the 2007 leisure life group and the 2017 network group were used for analysis. Results: Individual social trust and social participation are positively linked to health, and social participation has a more positive effect on health in countries with high social capital or in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries. In countries with high levels of social capital, social trust exerts an additional positive effect on health, but this does not occur in OECD countries. Conclusions: This finding facilitates the reevaluation of how social capital affects health and how its effects depend on social conditions.

1. Bowles, S,Gintis, H(2002).Social capital and community governance.Econ J,112,F419-F436.
2. Cornwell, EY,Waite, LJ(2009).Social disconnectedness, perceived isolation, and health among older adults.J Health Soc Behav,50,31-48.
3. Cramm, JM,van Dijk, HM,Nieboer, AP(2012).The importance of neighborhood social cohesion and social capital for the well being of older adults in the community.Gerontologist,53,142-152.
4. d’Hombres, B,Rocco, L,Suhrcke, M,McKee, M(2010).Does social capital determine health? Evidence from eight transition countries.Health Econ,19,56-74.
5. Delhey, J,Newton, K,Welzel, C(2011).How general is trust in "Most People"? Solving the radius of trust problem.Am Socio Rev,76,786-807.
6. DeSalvo, KB,Jones, TM,Peabody, J(2009).Health care expenditure prediction with a single item, selfrated health measure.Med Care,47,440-447.
7. Durkheim, E(1951).Suicide: A Study in Sociology.Glencoe, Illinois:The Free Press.
8. Fukuyama, F.(1999).The Great Disruption: Human Nature and the Reconstitution of Social Order.New York, NY:The Free Press.
9. Goddard, RD(2003).Relational networks, social trust, and norms: a social capital perspective on students’chances of academic success.Educ Eval Pol Anal,25,59-74.
10. Harpham, T,Grant, E,Thomas, E(2002).Measuring social capital within health surveys: key issues.Health Policy Plan,17,106-111.
11. Iversen, T(2008).An exploratory study of associations between social capital and self-assessed health in Norway.Health Econ Pol Law,3,349-364.
12. Iwase, T,Suzuki, E,Fujiwara, T,Takao, S,Doi, H,Kawachi, I(2012).Do bonding and bridging social capital have differential effects on self-rated health? A community based study in Japan.J Epidemiol Community Health,66,557-562.
13. Kawachi, I,Berkman, LF(2001).Social ties and mental health.J Urban Health,78,458-467.
14. Kennelly, B,O’Shea, E,Garvey, E(2003).Social capital, life expectancy and mortality: a cross-national examination.Soc Sci Med,56,2367-2377.
15. Kim, D,Baum, CF,Ganz, ML,Subramanian, SV,Kawachi, I(2011).The contextual effects of social capital on health: a cross-national instrumental variable analysis.Soc Sci Med,73,1689-1697.
16. Lee, Y(2000).The predictive value of self assessed general, physical, and mental health on functional decline and mortality in older adults.J Epidemiol Community Health,54,123-129.
17. Murayama, H,Fujiwara, Y,Kawachi, I.(2012).Social capital and health: a review of prospective multilevel studies.J Epidemiol,22,179-187.
18. Paccagnella, O(2006).Centering or not centering in multilevel models? The role of the group mean and the assessment of group effects.Eval Rev,30,66-85.
19. Poortinga, W(2006).Social capital: an individual or collective resource for health?.Soc Sci Med,62,292-302.
20. Poortinga, W(2012).Community resilience and health: the role of bonding, bridging, and linking aspects of social capital.Health Place,18,286-295.
21. Putnam, RD(1995).Bowling alone: America’s declining social capital.J Democr,6,65-78.
22. Putnam, RD(2001).Social capital: measurement and consequences.Can J Pol Res,2,41-51.
23. Rocco, L,Suhrcke, M.(2012).Is Social Capital Good for Health? A European Perspective.Copenhagen:WHO Regional Office for Europe.
24. Ronconi, L,Brown, TT,Scheffler, RM(2012).Social capital and self-rated health in Argentina.Health Econ,21,201-208.
25. Satyanath, S,Voigtlaender, N,Voth, HJ(2017).Bowling for fascism: social capital and the rise of the Nazi Party.J Polit Econ,49,478-526.
26. Yip, W,Subramanian, SV,Mitchell, AD,Lee, DTS,Wang, J,Kawachi, I(2007).Does social capital enhance health and well-being? Evidence from rural China.Soc Sci Med,64,35-49.
27. 林萬億, WY(2012).台灣的社會福利：歷史經驗與制度分析.台北=Taipei:五南=WuNan Book Inc.

1. (2024)。自覺更年期症狀、憂鬱與幸福感之關聯：以臺南市民為例。健康促進與衛生教育學報，58，61-89。