急診壅塞的原因與改善策略

Emergency department overcrowding: an overview of critical issues and improvement strategies

10.6288/TJPH.202102_40(1).109124

蔡哲宏(Jeffrey Che-Hung Tsai)；蔡耀德(Yao-Te Tsai)；翁紹仁(Shao-Jen Weng)；劉士嘉(Shih-Chia Liu)

急診 ； 壅塞 ； 醫療品質 ； 病人安全 ； emergency department ； crowding ； medical quality ； patient safety

台灣公共衛生雜誌

40卷1期（2021 / 02 / 26）

8 - 29

繁體中文

本文以文獻回顧方式，就急診壅塞概況（包含台灣現況）、原因與機轉、對醫療品質之衝擊及相關的改善策略等各面向進行討論。作者搜尋1999至2019年急診壅塞的相關文獻，再挑選較具代表性的文章加以整理。文獻整理的結果發現輸入—處理效能—輸出的概念模型可用來分析急診壅塞的原因、所造成的影響及可能的解決辦法。作者另提出急診病人與其他類型的病人會共同競爭醫院的一般病床資源的生態，且以水庫的「水位」來說明急診壅塞如何形成的機轉。造成急診壅塞的成因非常複雜，主要發生在輸出端、醫院系統的問題、以及背後醫療體系與給付制度的生態等多重因素所造成。急診的壅塞的相關指標可由等候時間的延長及空間的擁擠情形分別來定義，其中急診留滯病人數能間接反應急診佔床率的概念。改善急診室壅塞的策略可以由急診流程、醫院管理、社區面等方面來討論。已經造成急診壅塞的醫院，必須注意維持照護品質與病人安全。急診壅塞未來將面臨新的挑戰，包含醫療環境的變化與急診生態與作業模式的改變，所以必須以新的思維面對急診壅塞的情形。醫院管理在處理急診壅塞時可能面臨財務上的阻力，因此政策的介入以提高誘因將更形重要。本文所整理急診壅塞各種相關問題的重要文獻，應對國內有志於進行急診壅塞相關研究的學者有所助益，進一步或可引導未來有效的政策之建議。

This study reviews emergency department (ED) crowding by focusing on the current situations in Taiwan, causes and mechanisms, the impact of ED crowding on health care quality, and improvement strategies. We searched studies addressing ED crowding between 1999 and 2019 and summarized the most representative articles. We found that the input-throughput-output model can help analyze the causes and effects of ED crowding and reveal potential solutions. ED patients must compete for medical resources, such as acute care beds, with non-ED patients, and reservoir level has been used to explain the mechanism of ED crowding. ED crowding stems from multiple complex factors, mainly including output factors, hospital operation systems, and the health care system overall. The indicators of ED crowding are prolonged waiting time and a crowded space. The number of patients in the ED is indirectly correlated with the ED occupancy rate, and is useful to reflect the situation of crowding. Strategies to solve ED crowding include changes in ED operations and hospital management and the use of a community network. ED crowding has been a critical issue for hospitals, and changes in the health care environment and operations have exacerbated this problem; every staff member has to expend considerable effort in dealing with it. Financial pressure might prevent decision-makers from implementing potential solutions; therefore, incentives and government support may be required. We hope that this study provides a useful overview for researchers and policymakers and guides them to make effective policies for addressing ED crowding.

1. Affleck, A,Parks, P,Drummond, A,Rowe, BH,Ovens, HJ(2013).Emergency department overcrowding and access block.CJEM,15,359-384.
2. Ahn, JY,Ryoo, HW,Park, J(2016).New intervention model of regional transfer network system to alleviate crowding of regional emergency medical center.J Korean Med Sci,31,806-813.
3. American College of Emergency Physicians(2011).Definition of boarded patient. Policy statement.Ann Emerg Med,57,548.
4. American College of Emergency Physicians=ACEP(2013).Policy statements.Ann Emerg Med,61,726-727.
5. Arkun, A,Briggs, WM,Patel, S,Datillo, PA,Bove, J,Birkhahn, RH(2010).Emergency department crowding: factors influencing flow.West J Emerg Med,11,10-15.
6. Arya, R,Wei, G,McCoy, JV,Crane, J,Ohman-Strickland, P,Eisenstein, RM(2013).Decreasing length of stay in the emergency department with a split emergency severity index 3 patient flow model.Acad Emerg Med,20,1171-1179.
7. Asplin, BR,Magid, DJ(2007).If you want to fix crowding, start by fixing your hospital.Ann Emerg Med,49,273-274.
8. Asplin, BR,Magid, DJ,Rhodes, KV,Solberg, LI,Lurie, N,Camargo, CA(2003).A conceptual model of emergency department crowding.Ann Emerg Med,42,173-180.
9. Blom, MC,Jonsson, F,Landin-Olsson, M,Ivarsson, K(2014).The probability of patients being admitted from the emergency department is negatively correlated to in-hospital bed occupancy - a registry study.Int J Emerg Med,7,8.
10. Briones, A,Markoff, B,Kathuria, N(2010).A model of a hospitalist role in the care of admitted patients in the emergency department.J Hosp Med,5,360-364.
11. Cameron, P,Scown, P,Campbell, D(2002).Managing access block.Aust Health Rev,25,59-68.
12. Cameron, PA,Joseph, AP,McCarthy, SM(2009).Access block can be managed.Med J Aust,190,364-368.
13. Cardoso, LT,Grion, CM,Matsuo, T(2011).Impact of delayed admission to intensive care units on mortality of critically ill patients: a cohort study.Crit Care,15,R28.
14. Chadaga, SR,Shockley, L,Keniston, A(2012).Hospitalist-led medicine emergency department team: associations with throughput, timeliness of patient care, and satisfaction.J Hosp Med,7,562-566.
15. Chan, H,Lo, S,Lee, L(2014).Lean techniques for the improvement of patients’ flow in emergency department.World J Emerg Med,5,24-28.
16. Chan, SS,Cheung, NK,Graham, CA,Rainer, TH(2015).Strategies and solutions to alleviate access block and overcrowding in emergency departments.Hong Kong Med J,21,345-352.
17. Chang, AM,Cohen, DJ,Lin, A(2018).Hospital strategies for reducing emergency department crowding: a mixed-methods study.Ann Emerg Med,71,497-505.
18. Chiu, IM,Lin, YR,Syue, YJ,Kung, CT,Wu, KH,Li, CJ(2018).The influence of crowding on clinical practice in the emergency department.Am J Emerg Med,36,56-60.
19. Considine, J,Kropman, M,Kelly, E,Winter, C(2008).Effect of emergency department fast track on emergency department length of stay: a case-control study.Emerg Med J,25,815-819.
20. Crawford, K,Morphet, J,Jones, T,Innes, K,Griffiths, D,Williams, A(2014).Initiatives to reduce overcrowding and access block in Australian emergency departments: a literature review.Collegian,21,359-366.
21. Derlet, R,Richards, J,Kravitz, R(2001).Frequent overcrowding in U.S. emergency departments.Acad Emerg Med,8,151-155.
22. Derlet, RW,Richards, JR(2000).Overcrowding in the nation’s emergency departments: complex causes and disturbing effects.Ann Emerg Med,35,63-68.
23. Di Somma, S,Paladino, L,Vaughan, L,Lalle, I,Magrini, L,Magnanti, M(2015).Overcrowding in emergency department: an international issue.Intern Emerg Med,10,171-175.
24. Ding, R,McCarthy, ML,Li, G,Kirsch, TD,Jung, JJ,Kelen, GD(2006).Patients who leave without being seen: their characteristics and history of emergency department use.Ann Emerg Med,48,686-693.
25. Drummond, AJ(2002).No room at the inn: overcrowding in Ontario’s emergency departments.CJEM,4,91-97.
26. Duguay, C,Chetouane, F(2007).Modeling and improving emergency department systems using discrete event simulation.Simulation,83,311-320.
27. Dunn, R(2003).Reduced access block causes shorter emergency department waiting times: an historical control observational study.Emerg Med,15,232-238.
28. Elder, E,Johnston, AN,Crilly, J(2015).Review article: systematic review of three key strategies designed to improve patient flow through the emergency department.Emerg Med Australas,27,394-404.
29. Fatovich, DM,Nagree, Y,Sprivulis, P(2005).Access block causes emergency department overcrowding and ambulance diversion in Perth, Western Australia.Emerg Med J,22,351-354.
30. Forero, R,McCarthy, S,Hillman, K(2011).Access block and emergency department overcrowding.Crit Care,15,216.
31. Forster, AJ,Stiell, I,Wells, G,Lee, AJ,van Walraven, C(2003).The effect of hospital occupancy on emergency department length of stay and patient disposition.Acad Emerg Med,10,127-133.
32. Graff, L(1999).Overcrowding in the ED: an international symptom of health care system failure.Am J Emerg Med,17,208-209.
33. Hong, YC,Chou, MH,Liu, EH(2009).The effect of prolonged ED stay on outcome in patients with necrotizing fasciitis.Am J Emerg Med,27,385-390.
34. Honigman, LS,Wiler, JL,Rooks, S,Ginde, AA(2013).National study of non-urgent emergency department visits and associated resource utilization.West J Emerg Med,14,609-616.
35. Hsu, CM,Liang, LL,Chang, YT,Juang, WC(2019).Emergency department overcrowding: quality improvement in a Taiwan Medical Center.J Formos Med,118,186-193.
36. Hwang, U,McCarthy, ML,Aronsky, D(2011).Measures of crowding in the emergency department: a systematic review.Acad Emerg Med,18,527-538.
37. Institute of Medicine=IOM(2006).Hospital-Based Emergency Care: At the Breaking Point.Washington, DC:The National Academies Press.
38. Javidan AP HK, Higginson I, Jones P, et al. Report from the emergency department crowding and access block task force. International Federation for Emergency Medicine 2020 June. Available at: https://www.ifem.cc/resource-library/. Accessed September 23, 2020.
39. Jones, PG,Olsen, S(2011).Point prevalence of access block and overcrowding in New Zealand emergency departments in 2010 and their relationship to the ‘Shorter Stays in ED’ target.Emerg Med Australas,23,587-592.
40. Kelen, GD,McCarthy, ML(2006).The science of surge.Acad Emerg Med,13,1089-1094.
41. Kellermann, AL(2006).Crisis in the emergency department.N Engl J Med,355,1300-1303.
42. Khare, RK,Powell, ES,Reinhardt, G,Lucenti, M(2009).Adding more beds to the emergency department or reducing admitted patient boarding times: which has a more significant influence on emergency department congestion?.Ann Emerg Med,53,575-585.
43. Kobayashi, KJ,Knuesel, SJ,White, BA(2020).Impact on length of stay of a hospital medicine emergency department boarder service.J Hosp Med,15,147-153.
44. Kocher, KE,Asplin, BR(2012).Emergency department crowding 2.0: coping with a dysfunctional system.Ann Emerg Med,60,687-691.
45. Kocher, KE,Shane, SA,Venkatesh, AK,Aronsky, D,Asplin, BR,Rathlev, NK(2011).Interventions to safeguard system effectiveness during periods of emergency department crowding.Acad Emerg Med,18,1313-1317.
46. LaCalle, E,Rabin, E(2010).Frequent users of emergency departments: the myths, the data, and the policy implications.Ann Emerg Med,56,42-48.
47. Lee, CC,Lee, NY,Chuang, MC,Chen, PL,Chang, CM,Ko, WC(2012).The impact of overcrowding on the bacterial contamination of blood cultures in the ED.Am J Emerg Med,30,839-845.
48. Lindner, G,Woitok, BK(2020).Emergency department overcrowding: analysis and strategies to manage an international phenomenon.Wien Klin Wochenschr
49. Liu, SW,Thomas, SH,Gordon, JA,Hamedani, AG,Weissman, JS(2009).A pilot study examining undesirable events among emergency department-boarded patients awaiting inpatientbeds.Ann Emerg Med,54,381-385.
50. Lynn, SG,Kellermann, AL(1991).Critical decision making: managing the emergency department in an overcrowded hospital.Ann Emerg Med,20,287-292.
51. McCarthy, ML,Aronsky, D,Jones, ID(2008).The emergency department occupancy rate: a simple measure of emergency department crowding?.Ann Emerg Med,51,15-24+24.e1-2.
52. McCarthy, ML,Aronsky, D,Kelen, GD(2006).The measurement of daily surge and its relevance to disaster preparedness.Acad Emerg Med,13,1138-1141.
53. Moskop, JC,Sklar, DP,Geiderman, JM,Schears, RM,Bookman, KJ(2009).Emergency department crowding, part 2-barriers to reform and strategies to overcome them.Ann Emerg Med,53,612-617.
54. Moskop, JC,Sklar, DP,Geiderman, JM,Schears, RM,Bookman, KJ(2009).Emergency department crowding, part 1--concept, causes, and moral consequences.Ann Emerg Med,53,605-611.
55. Ng, CJ,Yen, ZS,Tsai, JC(2011).Validation of the Taiwan triage and acuity scale: a new computerised five-level triage system.Emerg Med J,28,1026-1031.
56. Ng, D,Vail, G,Thomas, S,Schmidt, N(2010).Applying the lean principles of the Toyota production system to reduce wait times in the emergency department.CJEM,12,50-57.
57. Pines, JM,Hilton, JA,Weber, EJ(2011).International perspectives on emergency department crowding.Acad Emerg Med,18,1358-1370.
58. Pines, JM,Iyer, S,Disbot, M,Hollander, JE,Shofer, FS,Datner, EM(2008).The effect of emergency department crowding on patient satisfaction for admitted patients.Acad Emerg Med,15,825-831.
59. Pines, JM,McCarthy, ML.(2011).Executive summary: interventions to improve quality in the crowded emergency department.Acad Emerg Med,18,1229-1233.
60. Pines, JM,Pilgrim, RL,Schneider, SM,Siegel, B,Viccellio, P(2011).Practical implications of implementing emergency department crowding interventions: summary of a moderated panel.Acad Emerg Med,18,1278-1282.
61. Pitts, SR,Pines, JM,Handrigan, MT,Kellermann, AL(2012).National trends in emergency department occupancy, 2001 to 2008: effect of inpatient admissions versus emergency department practice intensity.Ann Emerg Med,60,679-686.
62. Rabin, E,Kocher, K,McClelland, M(2012).Solutions to emergency department ‘boarding’ and crowding are underused and may need to be legislated.Health Aff,31,1757-1766.
63. Rathlev, NK,Chessare, J,Olshaker, J(2007).Time series analysis of variables associated with daily mean emergency department length of stay.Ann Emerg Med,49,265-271.
64. Richards, JR,Navarro, ML,Derlet, RW(2000).Survey of directors of emergency departments in California on overcrowding.West J Med,172,385-388.
65. Richardson, DB(2006).Increase in patient mortality at 10 days associated with emergency department overcrowding.Med J Aust,184,213-216.
66. Schanzer, DL,Schwartz, B(2013).Impact of seasonal and pandemic influenza on emergency department visits, 2003-2010, Ontario, Canada.Acad Emerg Med,20,388-397.
67. Schull, MJ,Kiss, A,Szalai, JP(2007).The effect of low-complexity patients on emergency department waiting times.Ann Emerg Med,49,257-264+264.e1.
68. Schull, MJ,Mamdani, MM,Fang, J(2004).Community influenza outbreaks and emergency department ambulance diversion.Ann Emerg Med,44,61-67.
69. Schull, MJ,Slaughter, PM,Redelmeier, DA(2002).Urban emergency department overcrowding: defining the problem and eliminating misconceptions.CJEM,4,76-83.
70. Shih, FY,Ma, MH,Chen, SC(1999).ED overcrowding in Taiwan: facts and strategies.Am J Emerg Med,17,198-202.
71. Spaite, DW,Bartholomeaux, F,Guisto, J(2002).Rapid process redesign in a university-based emergency department: decreasing waiting time intervals and improving patient satisfaction.Ann Emerg Med,39,168-177.
72. Sprivulis, P,Grainger, S,Nagree, Y(2005).Ambulance diversion is not associated with low acuity patients attending Perth metropolitan emergency departments.Emerg Med Australas,17,11-15.
73. Sprivulis, PC,Da Silva, JA,Jacobs, IG,Frazer, AR,Jelinek, GA(2006).The association between hospital overcrowding and mortality among patients admitted via Western Australian emergency departments.Med J Aust,184,208-212.
74. Tsai, CH,Wu, CL,Yao, Y,Chang, CS,Sheu, WHH(2017).ISQUA17-1593 effective internal and external strategies to decrease overcrowding and access block in emergency department.Int J Qual Health Care,29(Suppl 1),51-52.
75. Tsai, JC,Weng, SJ,Liu, SC(2020).Adjusting daily inpatient bed allocation to smooth emergency department occupancy variation.Healthcare,8,78.
76. Tsai, JCH,Liang, YW,Pearson, WS(2010).Utilization of emergency department in patients with non-urgent medical problems: patient preference and emergency department convenience.J Formos Med Assoc,109,533-542.
77. Tsai, MT,Yen, YL,Su, CM(2016).The influence of emergency department crowding on the efficiency of care for acute stroke patients.Int J Qual Health Care,28,774-778.
78. van Veelen, MJ,van den Brand, CL,Reijnen, R,van der Linden, MC(2016).Effects of a general practitioner cooperative co-located with an emergency department on patient throughput.World J Emerg Med,7,270-273.
79. Weng, TC,Huang, CC,Zhang, CC(2017).Application of integrated medical care model (hospitalist) in emergency department and its efficiency and outcome: 4 years’ experience in Taiwan.Health Care Current Reviews,5,211.
80. White, BA,Biddinger, PD,Chang, Y,Grabowski, B,Carignan, S,Brown, DF(2013).Boarding inpatients in the emergency department increases discharged patient length of stay.J Emerg Med,44,230-235.
81. Yarmohammadian, MH,Rezaei, F,Haghshenas, A,Tavakoli, N(2017).Overcrowding in emergency departments: a review of strategies to decrease future challenges.J Res Med Sci,22,23.
82. 方震中, CC(2016)。急診壅塞解決之道。健康世界，472，12-17。
83. 李佳欣：流感塞爆急診！喬到一張病床為什麼這麼難？https://www.commonhealth.com.tw/article/article.action?nid=71260。引用2020/08/15。Li CH. Influenza patients overcrowding emergency department! Why is it so hard to get a bed in the hospital? Available at: https://www.commonhealth.com.tw/article/article.action?nid=71260. Accessed August 15, 2020. [In Chinese]
84. 李佳欣, CH(2015)。4大壅塞急診，如何自救？。康健雜誌，205
85. 胡勝川, SC(2015).診人文與經營管理.台北=Taipei:金名圖書有限公司=Kingdom Publishing.
86. 許銘能：急診壅塞分析及對策。https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-3079-d8ff7291-e302-4a8f-a2a5-8208c4a1ada2.html。引用2020/09/23。Shiu MN. Emergency department overcrowding analyses and responses. Available at: https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-3079-d8ff7291-e302-4a8f-a2a5-8208c4a1ada2.html. Accessed September 23, 2020. [In Chinese]
87. 陳維恭, WG(2017)。急診壅塞的雞尾酒療法。台灣醫界，60，39-41。
88. 蔡光超, KC(2019)。台北=Taipei，國立台灣大學政治學研究所=Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University。
89. 衛生福利部：多管齊下提升急診醫療照護適當性，盼各界攜手同努力。https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-2624-19541-1.html。引用2020/09/23。Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Improving the adequacy for emergency department medical care requires efforts from all sectors. Available at: https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-2624-19541-1.html. Accessed September 23, 2020. [In Chinese]
90. 衛生福利部：轉診網絡奏效，四醫學中心急診置留已改善。https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-2651-19685-1.html。引用2020/09/23。Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Referral network worked. Length of stay at the emergency department of four medical centers reduced.Available at: https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-2651-19685-1.html. Accessed September 23, 2020. [In Chinese]
91. 衛生福利部中央健康保險署：急診壅塞及轉診專案報告。https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-3080-ef7bd611-aaeb-4046-b29a-8ee80649bf55.html。引用2020/08/15。National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Special project report on emergency department overcrowding and referral. Available at: https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-3080-ef7bd611-aaeb-4046-b29a-8ee80649bf55.html. Accessed August 15, 2020. [In Chinese]
92. 衛生福利部中央健康保險署：全民健康保險醫療品質資訊公開網。https://www.nhi.gov.tw/AmountInfoWeb/iDesc.aspx?rtype=2&Q5C2_ID=1652。引用2020/08/15。 National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Medical quality information open web. Available at: https://www.nhi.gov.tw/AmountInfoWeb/iDesc.aspx?rtype=2&Q5C2_ID=1652. Accessed August 15, 2020. [In Chinese]
93. 衛生福利部中央健康保險署：全民健康保險醫療品質資訊公開網。https://www.nhi.gov.tw/AmountInfoWeb/index.html。引用2020/08/15。National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). National Health Insurance medical quality information open network.Available at: https://www.nhi.gov.tw/AmountInfoWeb/index.html. Accessed August 15, 2020. [In Chinese]
94. 衛生福利部統計處：108年醫療機構現況及服務量統計年報。https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DOS/lp-4931-113.html。引用2020/08/15。 Department of Statistics, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Annual report on the status of medical organizations and hospitals’ medical service volume statistics. Available at: https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/DOS/lp-4931-113.html. Accessed August 15, 2020. [In Chinese]

1. 陳怡君(Yi-Chun Chen);楊蓓菁(Bey-Jing Yang);謝明儒(Ming-Ju Hsieh);童麗淇(Li-Chi Tung);郭怜秀(Ling-Hsiu Kuo)(2022)。改善病人轉診流程以推動急診病人分流。台灣醫學。26(6)。731-739。