生理、認知、社會衰弱、及多面向衰弱之文獻回顧

Literature review of physical, cognitive, social, and multidimensional frailty

10.6288/TJPH.202208_41(4).111044

劉禮慧(Li-Huei Liu)；張睿詒(Ray-E Chang)

生理衰弱 ； 認知衰弱 ； 社會衰弱 ； 多面向衰弱 ； 衰弱評估工具 ； physical frailty ； cognitive frailty ； social frailty ； multidimensional frailty ； frailty assessment tools

台灣公共衛生雜誌

41卷4期（2022 / 08 / 30）

374 - 382

繁體中文

台灣於2018年正式邁入高齡社會，隨老年人口快速成長，慢性病與功能障礙盛行率急遽上升，失能人口大幅增加，對國家長照體系及財源負擔接帶來很大的挑戰，因此，如何預防長者邁入失能階段、健康老化成為各國關注的議題。衰弱是介於健康與失能之間的連續狀態，具可復原性，可經由有效介入恢復健康狀態，避免長者進入到不可逆的失能期。本文綜覽國內外生理、認知、社會多面向衰弱相關研究，回顧衰弱相關研究的發展現況及提出研究缺口。與國際相較，我國尚缺乏認知、社會、及多面向衰弱相關研究，作者提出三點建議：第一，發展符合台灣民情之社會衰弱量表；第二，增加發展社會衰弱相關研究，如其盛行率、風險因子、與不良健康結果間的關聯等；第三，從多維觀點探討衰弱議題，研析生理、認知、社會衰弱三者互相作用之機轉，並以研究實證多面向衰弱評估量表之信、效度，從更全面的角度評估長者健康，達到預防不良健康結果的作用。

As the elderly population increases in Taiwan, the prevalence of chronic diseases and functional disability has risen sharply. Consequently, long-term care and financial systems can quickly become overburdened. Therefore, preventing disabilities among older adults and ensuring healthy aging are essential. Older adults often experience frailty, which is a predisability state; however, frailty is reversible, and older adults can return to a normal state through interventions. This review analyzed studies on physical, cognitive, social, and multidimensional frailty and provides an overview of research on frailty in Taiwan and abroad. Because additional studies on cognitive, social, and multidimensional frailty should be conducted in Taiwan, this review offers three suggestions: (a) A Taiwanese social frailty assessment tool should be developed; (b) further research on social frailty and its prevalence, risk factors, and relationship to adverse outcomes should be conducted; and (c) the mechanisms among aspects of frailty should be further investigated. Studies should evaluate the reliability and validity of multidimensional frailty assessment tools to screen for frailty among older adults in Taiwan more effectively.

1. 方佩欣, PH,張睿詒, RE(2020)。高齡社區長者社會衰弱之範域文獻回顧。台灣衛誌，39，112-128。
   連結：
2. 鐘子婷, ZT,陳端容, DR,陳秀熙, HH(2020)。社區長者身、心、社會衰弱量表之切點初探：以台北兩行政區為例。台灣衛誌，39，671-685。
   連結：
3. Ament, BHL,de Vugt, ME,Verhey, FRJ,Kempen, GIJM(2014).Are physically frail older persons more at risk of adverse outcomes if they also suffer from cognitive, social, and psychological frailty?.Eur J Ageing,11,213-219.
4. Andrew, MK,Keefe, JM(2014).Social vulnerability from a social ecology perspective: a cohort study of older adults from the National Population Health Survey of Canada.BMC Geriatr,14,90.
5. Armitage, R,Nellums, LB(2020).COVID-19 and the consequences of isolating the elderly.Lancet Public Health,5,e256.
6. Bessa, B,Ribeiro, O,Coelho, T(2018).Assessing the social dimension of frailty in old age: a systematic review.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,78,101-113.
7. Brooke, J,Jackson, D(2020).Older people and COVID-19: isolation, risk and ageism.J Clin Nurs,29,2044-2046.
8. Bunt, S,Steverink, N,Andrew, MK,Schans, CPV,Hobbelen, H(2017).Cross-cultural adaptation of the social vulnerability index for use in the dutch context.Int J Environ Res Public Health,14,1387.
9. Bunt, S,Steverink, N,Olthof, J,van der Schans, CP,Hobbelen, JSM(2017).Social frailty in older adults: a scoping review.Eur J Ageing,14,323-334.
10. Chen, TB,Yiao, SY,Sun, Y(2017).Comorbidity and dementia: a nationwide survey in Taiwan.PLoS One,12,e0175475.
11. Chen, X,Mao, G,Leng, SX(2014).Frailty syndrome: an overview.Clin Interv Aging,9,433-441.
12. Chiao, C,Weng, LJ,Botticello, AL(2011).Social participation reduces depressive symptoms among older adults: an 18-year longitudinal analysis in Taiwan.BMC Public Health,11,292.
13. Chou, MY,Nishita, Y,Nakagawa, T(2019).Role of gait speed and grip strength in predicting 10-year cognitive decline among community-dwelling older people.BMC Geriatr,19,186.
14. Clegg, A,Young, J,Iliffe, S,Rikkert, MO,Rockwood, K(2013).Frailty in elderly people.Lancet,381,752-762.
15. Dai, Y,Zhang, CY,Zhang, BQ,Li, Z,Jiang, C,Huang, HL(2016).Social support and the self-rated health of older people: a comparative study in Tainan Taiwan and Fuzhou Fujian province.Medicine,95,e3881.
16. Dent, E,Kowal, P,Hoogendijk, EO(2016).Frailty measurement in research and clinical practice: a review.Eur J Intern Med,31,3-10.
17. Ensrud, KE,Ewing, SK,Taylor, BC(2008).Comparison of 2 frailty indexes for prediction of falls, disability, fractures, and death in older women.Arch Intern Med,168,382-389.
18. Feng, L,Zin Nyunt, MS,Gao, Q,Feng, L,Yap, KB,Ng, TP(2017).Cognitive frailty and adverse health outcomes: findings from the Singapore Longitudinal Ageing Studies (SLAS).J Am Med Dir Assoc,18,252-258.
19. Fitten, LJ(2015).Psychological frailty in the aging patient.Nestle Nutr Inst Workshop Ser,83,45-53.
20. Folstein, MF,Folstein, SE,McHugh, PR(1975)."Mini-mental state". A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician.J Psychiatr Res,12,189-198.
21. Fried, LP,Tangen, CM,Walston, J(2001).Frailty in older adults: evidence for a phenotype.J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci,56,M146-M156.
22. Gobbens, RJ,Boersma, P,Uchmanowicz, I,Santiago, LM(2020).The Tilburg Frailty Indicator (TFI): new evidence for its validity.Clin Interv Aging,15,265-274.
23. Gobbens, RJ,Luijkx, KG,Wijnen-Sponselee, MT,Schols, JM(2010).In search of an integral conceptual definition of frailty: opinions of experts.J Am Med Dir Assoc,11,338-343.
24. Gobbens, RJ,van Assen, MA(2014).The prediction of quality of life by physical, psychological and social components of frailty in community-dwelling older people.Qual Life Res,23,2289-2300.
25. Gobbens, RJ,van Assen, MA,Luijkx, KG,WijnenSponselee, MT,Schols, JM(2010).The Tilburg Frailty Indicator: psychometric properties.J Am Med Dir Assoc,11,344-355.
26. Gobbens, RJJ,van Assen, MALM(2017).Associations between multidimensional frailty and quality of life among Dutch older people.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,73,69-76.
27. Gobbens, RJJ,van der Ploeg, T.(2021).The development of multidimensional frailty over seven years a longitudinal study among Dutch community-dwelling older people using the Tilburg Frailty Indicator.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,95,104393.
28. He, B,Ma, Y,Wang, C(2019).Prevalence and risk factors for frailty among community-dwelling older people in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis.J Nutr Health Aging,23,442-450.
29. Kelaiditi, E,Cesari, M,Canevelli, M(2013).Cognitive frailty: rational and definition from an (I.A.N.A./I.A.G.G.) international consensus group.J Nutr Health Aging,17,726-734.
30. Ko, H,Jung, S(2021).Association of social frailty with physical health, cognitive function, psychological health, and life satisfaction in community-dwelling older Koreans.Int J Environ Res Public Health,18,818.
31. Kuo, KM,Talley, PC,Kuzuya, M,Huang, CH(2019).Development of a clinical support system for identifying social frailty.Int J Med Inform,132,103979.
32. Liguori, I,Russo, G,Bulli, G(2020).Validation of "(fr)AGILE": a quick tool to identify multidimensional frailty in the elderly.BMC Geriatr,20,375.
33. Lin, CH,Liu, CY,Rong, JR(2021).Psychometric properties of the Taiwanese version of the tilburg frailty indicator for community-dwelling older adults.Healthcare,9,1193.
34. Lin, Y(2020).The flexibility and reversibility of cognitive frailty.Alzheimers Dement,16,e039886.
35. Ma, L,Sun, F,Tang, Z(2018).Social frailty is associated with physical functioning, cognition, and depression, and predicts mortality.J Nutr Health Aging,22,989-995.
36. Makizako, H,Shimada, H,Doi, T(2018).Social frailty leads to the development of physical frailty among physically non-frail adults: a four-year follow-up longitudinal cohort study.Int J Environ Res Public Health,15,490.
37. Makizako, H,Shimada, H,Tsutsumimoto, K(2015).Social frailty in community-dwelling older adults as a risk factor for disability.J Am Med Dir Assoc,16,1003.e7-1003.e11.
38. McKelvie, M,Donnelly, M,O’Reilly, D,Cruise, S(2021).P35 Psychological frailty and social frailty in older adults: a scoping review. SSM Annual Scientific Meeting.J Epidemiol Community Health,75(Suppl 1),A58.
39. Mitnitski, AB,Mogilner, AJ,Rockwood, K(2001).Accumulation of deficits as a proxy measure of aging.ScientificWorldJournal,1,323-336.
40. Nasreddine, ZS,Phillips, NA,Bédirian, V(2005).The Montreal Cognitive Assessment, MoCA: a brief screening tool for mild cognitive impairment.J Am Geriatr Soc,53,695-699.
41. Niederstrasser, NG,Rogers, NT,Bandelow, S(2019).Determinants of frailty development and progression using a multidimensional frailty index: evidence from the English longitudinal study of ageing.PLoS One,14,e0223799.
42. Panza, F,Lozupone, M,Solfrizzi, V(2018).Different cognitive frailty models and health- and cognitive-related outcomes in older age: from epidemiology to prevention.Alzheimers Dis,62,993-1012.
43. Robertson, DA,Savva, GM,Kenny, RA(2013).Frailty and cognitive impairment--a review of the evidence and causal mechanisms.Ageing Res Rev,12,840-851.
44. Roppolo, M,Mulasso, A,Gobbens, RJ,Mosso, CO,Rabaglietti, E(2015).A comparison between uni- and multidimensional frailty measures: prevalence, functional status, and relationships with disability.Clin Interv Aging,10,1669-1678.
45. Ruan, Q,Yu, Z,Chen, M,Bao, Z,Li, J,He, W(2015).Cognitive frailty, a novel target for the prevention of elderly dependency.Ageing Res Rev,20,1-10.
46. Sacha, M,Sacha, J,Wieczorowska-Tobis, K(2020).Multidimensional and physical frailty in elderly people: participation in senior oganizations does not prevent social frailty and most prevalent psychological deficits.Front Public Health,8,276.
47. Shimada, H,Lee, S,Doi, T,Bae, S,Tsutsumimoto, K,Arai, H(2019).Prevalence of psychological frailty in Japan: NCGG-SGS as a Japanese national cohort study.J Clin Med,8,1554.
48. Shimada, H,Makizako, H,Lee, S(2016).Impact of cognitive frailty on daily activities in older persons.J Nutr Health Aging,20,729-735.
49. Shin, J,Kim, M,Choi, J(2021).Development and validation of a multidimensional frailty scale for clinical geriatric assessment.J Nutr Health Aging,25,938-943.
50. Steverink, N,Slaets, J,Schuurmans, H,Martyna, L(2001).Measuring frailty: developing and testing the GFI (Groningen Frailty Indicator).Gerontologist,41,236-237.
51. Sun, Y,Lee, HJ,Yang, SC(2014).A nationwide survey of mild cognitive impairment and dementia, including very mild dementia, in Taiwan.PLoS One,9,e100303.
52. Teo, N,Gao, Q,Nyunt, MSZ,Wee, SL,Ng, TP(2017).Social frailty and functional disability: findings from the Singapore longitudinal ageing studies.J Am Med Dir Assoc,18,637.e13-637.e19.
53. Teo, N,Yeo, PS,Gao, Q(2019).A bio-psycho-social approach for frailty amongst Singaporean Chinese community-dwelling older adults - evidence from the Singapore Longitudinal Aging Study.BMC Geriatr,19,350.
54. Trzepacz, PT,Hochstetler, H,Wang, S,Walker, B,Saykin, AJ,Alzheimer’s disease neuroimaging initiative(2015).Relationship between the Montreal Cognitive Assessment and Mini-Mental State Examination for assessment of mild cognitive impairment in older adults.BMC Geriatr,15,107.
55. Tsai, CF,Lee, WJ,Wang, SJ,Shia, BC,Nasreddine, Z,Fuh, JL(2012).Psychometrics of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) and its subscales: validation of the Taiwanese version of the MoCA and an item response theory analysis.Int Psychogeriatr,24,651-658.
56. Tseng, SH,Liu, LK,Peng, LN,Wang, PN,Loh, CH,Chen, LK(2019).Development and validation of a tool to screen for cognitive frailty among community-dwelling elders.J Nutr Health Aging,23,904-909.
57. Tsutsumimoto, K,Doi, T,Makizako, H(2017).Association of social frailty with both cognitive and physical deficits among older people.J Am Med Dir Assoc,18,603-607.
58. van der Vorst, A,Op Het Veld, LPM,De Witte, N,Schols, JMGA,Kempen, GIJM,Zijlstra, GAR(2018).The impact of multidimensional frailty on dependency in activities of daily living and the moderating effects of protective factors.Arch Gerontol Geriatr,78,255-260.
59. Wu, YH,Liu, LK,Chen, WT(2015).Cognitive function in individuals with physical frailty but without dementia or cognitive complaints: results from the I-Lan longitudinal aging study.J Am Med Dir Assoc,16,899.e9-899.e16.
60. Yamada, M,Arai, H(2018).Social frailty predicts incident disability and mortality among community-dwelling Japanese older adults.J Am Med Dir Assoc,19,1099-1103.
61. Yoo, M,Kim, S,Kim, BS(2019).Moderate hearing loss is related with social frailty in a community-dwelling older adults: the Korean Frailty and Aging Cohort Study (KFACS).Arch Gerontol Geriatr,83,126-130.
62. 吳雅汝, YJ,周怡君, YC,詹鼎正, DC(2014)。文獻回顧—肌少症與衰弱症。內科學誌，25，131-136。
63. 陳殷正, YC(2020)。台北=Taipei，國立台灣大學健康政策與管理研究所=Institute of Health Policy and Management, National Taiwan University。
64. 衛生福利部：長期照顧十年計畫2.0（106-115年）。https://1966.gov.tw/LTC/cp-4001-42414-201.html。引用2022/03/16。 Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). The ten-year long term care plan 2.0 (2017-2026). Available at: https://1966.gov.tw/LTC/cp-4001-42414-201.html. Accessed March 16, 2022. [In Chinese]