供應鏈的協同作業及組織特微對供應鏈管理績效之影響

The Effect of Collaboration and Organizational Characteristics on Performance of Supply Chain Management

10.6160/2008.03.01

張心馨(Hsin-Hsin Chang)；張淑昭(Su-Chao Chang)；東惠瑛(Hui-Eng Tong)

供應鏈管理 ； 協同作業 ； 價值鏈體系 ； Supply Chain Management ； Collaboration ； Value Chain Net

中山管理評論

16卷1期（2008 / 03 / 01）

9 - 49

繁體中文

企業為緊密結合整體供應鏈體系成員的資源，將彼此之間各環節的活動透過流程管控、資訊分享及協同合作等，來促成整體供應鏈管理價值網的競合體系。但供應鏈體系中各個產業的組織文化、管理風格、協同運作模式及資訊架構各有差異，相同的方案應用在不同的組織其實施成效不盡相同。準此，本研究目的涵括：供應鏈管理與協同作業實況、供應鏈的環境因素對協同作業的影響，以及組織特徵對協同合作與供應鏈績效的干擾效果。研究首先採用質性分析，以確定研究變數，接著再進行量性分析。個案研究發現供應鏈之下游大廠經常主導產業之協同運作，供應鏈體系成員之合作緊密程度與績效有明顯的關連。計量分析發現企業在預期競爭的心理，為了增加市場反應力會促使協同運作更靈活，對供應鏈管理績效有正向顯著影響。不同的企業組織特徵對協同作業與供應鏈績效亦有顯著干擾作用，但仍缺乏協同合作的共識與自律。此外，特別重視人力資源的企業，其供應鏈績效較佳。

In order to establish a superior co-competition system with the integration of supply chain resources, enterprises control business process, information sharing and collaboration to contribute in the network of supply chain management (SCM). Each enterprise in the network supply chain system comprises different of organizational culture, management style, collaboration mode and framework of IT. Hence, same strategy applies to different enterprises might lead to different performances. Therefore, this study aims to examine current business environment especially to test the factors of environment in SCM that would affect collaboration, and subsequently examines the moderating effect of organizational characteristics toward collaboration and performance of supply chain. The methodology of this study comprises both qualitative and quantitative analysis. Qualitative section is to determine variables by conducting case study; quantitative is to analyze the collected data by using questionnaire. In the case study, the author founds downstream prevailing enterprises in the supply chain often led the collaboration operation; the perfornance in the network members was highly related to how close they worked together. According to the quantitative analysis, in order to enhance the ability of market reaction and competitiveness, enterprises preferred flexibility in collaboration and it significantly had positive affect to the performance of SCM. The moderating effect of different organizational characteristics toward the collaboration and performance of SCM also showed statistically significant, but still lacked of self-discipline and consensus on collaboration. Furthermore, enterprises which particularly emphasized on human resource showed better performance of SCM.

1. Baliga, J.(2001).Supply chain collaboration will determine future success.Semiconductor International,1,81-86.
2. Barry, S.(2001).Information sharing in global supply chain systems.Journal of Global Information Technology Management,4(3),27-50.
3. Beamon, B. M.(1999).Measuring supply chain performance.International Journal of Operations and Production Management,19(3),275-292.
4. Bernard, J. L.(2002).Compliance, collaboration, and technology.Supply Chain Management Review,Sept./Oct.,8-9.
5. Bhatangar, R.,Charndra, P.(1993).Models for multi-plant coordination.European Journal of Operational Research,67,141-160.
6. Bowersox, D. J.(1990).The strategic benefits of logistics alliances.Harvard Business Review,68(4),36-43.
7. Brad, R. F.(2000).Implementing supply chain management.Production and Inventory Management Journal,2,64-67.
8. Brewer, P. C.,Spreh, T. W.(2000).Using the balanced scorecard to measure supply chain performance.Journal of Business Logistics,21(1),75-93.
9. Buxmann, P.,Ahsen, A.,Diaz, L. M.,Wolf, K.(2004).Usage arid evaluation of SCM software.Information Systems Journal,14(3),295-309.
10. Cagliano, R.,Spina, G.(2003).E-business strategy: how companies are shaping their supply chain through the Intermet.International Journal of Operations and Production Management,23(10),1142-1162.
11. Centola, C.(2004).Collaborative commerce for non-technical industries: is it worth the investment.International Journal of Information Management,24,433-440.
12. Chang, H. H.(2003).A model of computerization on manufacturing systems: an international study.Information & Management,39(7),605-624.
13. Chang, H. H.(2005).The influence of continuous improvement and performance factors in TQM organ izations.Total Quality Management and Business Excellence,16(3),413-437.
14. Chang, H. H.(2006).Technical and Management Perceptions of Enterprise Information Systems Importance, Implementation, and Benefits.Information Systems Journal,16(3),263-292.
15. Chellappa, R. K.,Pavlou, P. A.(2002).Perceived information security, financial liability and consumer trust in electronic commerce transaction.Logistics Information Management,15(5/6),358-368.
16. Chiu, M. L.(2002).An organizational view of design communication, in design collaboration.Design Studies,23(2),187-210.
17. Chopra, S.,Meinol, P.(2001).Supply Chain Management: Strategy, Planning and Operations.Prentice-Hall.
18. Choy, K. L.,Lee, W. B.,Lo, V.(2003).An intelligent supplier relationship management system for selecting and benchmarking suppliers.International Journal of Technology Management,26(7),717-742.
19. Christopher, M.,Ryals, L.(1999).Supply chain strategy: its impact on shareholder value.International Journal of Logistics Management,10(1),1-10.
20. Cookson, C.,Delatire, J. A.(2001).Collaborative manufacturing: a new supply chain opportunity.Supply Chain Management Review Global Supplement,1/2,10-14.
21. Cooper, M. C.,Lambert, D. M.,Pagh, J. D.(1998).SCM: Implementation Issues and Research Opportunities.International Journal of Logistics Management,9(2),1-19.
22. Corbett, C.J., Blackburn, J.D.,Van Wassenhove, L.N.(1999).Partnerships to improve supply chains.Sloan Management Review,40(4),71-82.
23. Delloitte & Touche
24. Eisenhardt, K.M.(1989).Building theories from case study research.Academy of Management Review,14(4),532-550.
25. Fagerstrom, B.,Jackson, M.(2002).Efficient Collaborations between Main and Sub-suppliers.Computer in Industry,49,25-35.
26. Fisher, M. L.(1997).What is the right supply chain for your product.Harvard Business Review,75(2),105-116.
27. Froblich, M.T.(2002).E-integration in the supply chain: Barriers and performance.Decision Sciences,33(4),537-556.
28. Ganesan, S.(1994).Determinants of long-term orientation in buyer-seller relationship.Journal of Marketing,58(2),1-19.
29. Garavelli, A. C.,Gorgoglione, M.,Scozzi, B.(2002).Managing Konwledge transfer by knowledge techologies.Technovation,22,269-279.
30. Gunasekaran, A.,Patel, C.,Tirtiroglu, E.(2002).Performance measures and metrics in a supply chain environment.International Journal of Operations and Production Management,21(1/2),71.
31. Handfield, R. B.,Nichols, E. L.(1999).Introduction to Supply Chain Management.Prentice-Hall.
32. Hult, G. T.,Ketchen, D. J.,Slater, S. F.(2004).Information processing, knowledge development, and strategic supply chains performance.Academy of Management Journal,47(2),241-253.
33. Kaplan, R. S.,Norton, D. P.(1996).Using the Balanced Scorecard as a Strategic Management System.Harvard Business Review,Jan.-Feb,75-85.
34. Kaplan, R. S.,Norton, D. P.(1993).Putting the Balanced Scorecard to work.Harvard Business Review,Sept.-Oct.,134-147.
35. Kaplan, R. S.,Norton, D. P.(1992).The Balanced Scorecard measures that drive performance.Harvard Business Review,January-February,71-79.
36. Kirisci, P. T.(2002).Can Web Services enhance collaborative business? Web Services as an efficient business integration paradigm.Bremen Institute of Industrial Technology and Applied Work Sciences.
37. Landry, J. T.(1998).Supply Chain Management: the value of trust.Harvard Business Review,76(1),18-19.
38. Lee, H. L.,Billington, C.(1995).The evolution of supply chain management models and practice at Hewlett-Packard.Interfaces,25(5),42-63.
39. Lee, S. C.,Pak, B. Y.,Lee, H. G.(2003).Business valise of B2B electronic commerce: the critical role of inter-firm collaboration.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2,350-361.
40. Liker, J. K.,Choi, T. Y.(2004).Building deep supplier relationships.Harvard Business Review,Dec.,104-113.
41. Maloni, M. J.,Benton, W. C.(1997).Supply chain partnerships: opportunities for operations research.European Journal of Operational Research,101(3),419-429.
42. McDonough, E. F.,Kahnb, K. B.,Barczaka, G.(2001).An investigation of the use of global, virtual, and collocated now product development teams.Journal of Product Innovation Management,18,110-120.
43. Meta Group(2001).The Meta Group Industry Reports.MI:Malts Group.
44. Minner, S.(2003).Multiple-supplier inventory models in SCM: A review.International Journal of Production Economics,81/82,265-279.
45. Monczka, R. M.,Petersen K. J.,Handfield, R. B.,Ragatz, G. L.(1998).Success factors in strategic supplier alliances: the buying company perspective.Decision Sciences,29(3),553-577.
46. Narus, J. A.,Anderson, J. C.(1996).Rethinking distribution: adaptive channels.Harvard Business Review,74(4),112-120.
47. Neely, A.,Gregory, M.,Platts, K.(1995).Performance measurement system design.International Journal of Operations and Produetion Management,14(4),80-116.
48. Noordewier, T.,George, J.,Nevin, J.(1990).Performance outcomes of purchasing arrangement in Industry buyer-vendor relationships.Journal of Marketing,54(4),80-93.
49. Olsona, E. M.,Walker, O. C.,Ruekertc, R. W.,Bonnerd, J. M.(2001).Patterns of cooperation during new product development among marketing, operations and R&D.Journal of Product Innovation Management,18,258-271.
50. Paul, D.L.,McDaniel R.R.(2004).A field study of the effect of interpersonal trust on virtual collaborative relationship performance.MIS Quarterly,28(2),183-227.
51. Quayle, M.(2002).Supplier development and SCM in SMF.International Journal of Technology Management,23(1-3),172-188.
52. Quinn, F. J.(1998).Building a world-class supply chain.Logistics Management and Distribution Report,37(6),38-44.
53. Simatupang, M.,Sridharan R.(2002).The collaborative supply chain.International Journal of Logistics Management,3(1),15-30.
54. Simon, C.,Pietro, R.,Mihalis, G.(2000).SCM: an analytical framework for critical literature review.European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,6(1),67-83.
55. High tech OEM industry solutions-SRM
56. Thomas, D. J.,Griffin, P. M.(1996).Coordination supply chain management.European Journal of Operational Research,94(1),1-15.
57. Towill, D. R.(1997).The seamless supply chain: the predator`s strategic advanatage.International Journal of Technology Management,13(1),37-56.
58. Yin, R.K.(2003).Case Study Research: Design and Methods.CA:Sage.

1. 黃雅然,邱紹群(2021)。中衛體系資訊共享與關係治理之效益。管理實務與理論研究，15(2)，33-51。
2. 李怡慧、Panteli, Niki(2015)。嚴慄的夥伴：虛擬溝通中被隱藏的衝突。中山管理評論，23(1)，185-224。
3. 詹凌菁、彭火樹、郭翠菱、吳安妮(2016)。臺灣會計領域研究之回顧與展望。管理學報，33(1)，139-187。