题名

企業新聞報導傾向與企業媒體關係管理：財經雜誌TFT-LCD面板廠新聞之內容分析

并列篇名

The Mass Media's Tenor of Business News Reporting and Companies' Media Relations Management: A Content Analysis of Business Magazines' News of TFT-LCD Panel Manufacturers

DOI

10.6160/2011.12.01

作者

盧淵源(Iuan-Yuan Lu)；蘇登呼(Teng-Hu Su)；黃英忠(Ing-Chung Huang)

关键词

媒體關係管理 ； 企業聲望 ； 企業新聞報導傾向 ； 內容分析 ； TFT-LCD面板廠 ； Media relations management ； Corporate reputation ； Tenor of business news reporting ； Content analysis ； TFT-LCD panel manufacturer

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

19卷4期（2011 / 12 / 01）

页次

801 - 832

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

瞭解媒體的企業新聞報導傾向，對企業媒體關係管理與企業聲望經營皆有重要知識價值。相較於公關人員或經理人的個人經驗觀察，對企業新聞內容進行系統性分析能提供較客觀可靠的新聞知識。本研究對國內財經雜誌TFT-LCD面板廠新聞進行內容分析發現，規模愈大的廠商獲得愈多報導，財經雜誌關注廠商的經濟績效表現，報導成功事蹟多於失敗事蹟，對廠商及其高階主管的報導傾向正面友善，尤其是對高階主管。本研究進一步分析報導傾向背後的脈絡關係發現，科技類財經雜誌比綜合類財經雜誌更傾向形塑有利TFT-LCD面板廠的資訊環境。本研究改善過往企業新聞內容研究的知識缺口，有助TFT-LCD面板廠進行更有效的媒體關係管理，對其他企業瞭解媒體之報導傾向亦具參考價值。
英文摘要

The knowledge of mass media's tenor of business news reporting is important for the company's media relations management and reputation. Comparing with the knowledge from public relations practitioners or managers' personal experiences, systematic analysis of business news can provide more objective and reliable knowledge. This study used 'content analysis' to analyze news of Taiwan's TFT-LCD panel manufacturers from five representative business magazines in Taiwan. The results showed that business magazines gave larger TFT-LCD panel manufacturers more coverage, highlighted TFT-LCD panel manufacturers' economic performances and successes, and constructed a friendly information environment to TFT-LCD panel manufacturers, especially for their top managers. This study further analyzed the context of the tenor of news reporting and found IT industries-oriented business magazine' was more friendly to TFT-LCD panel manufacturers than 'general business magazine'. This study improves the knowledge gap left by previous studies. The findings are helpful for TFT-LCD panel manufacturers to improve their media relations management, and also meaningful for companies from different industries to understand more about the mass media's tenor of business news reporting.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Adams, W. C.(1995).Marrying the Functions: The Importance of Media Relations in Public Affairs Planning.Public Relations Quarterly,40(3),7-11.
  2. Alvarez, J. L.,Mazza, C.,Pedersen, J. S.(2005).The Role of Mass Media in the Consumption of Management Knowledge.Scandinavian Journal of Management,21(2),127-132.
  3. Alvesson, M.(1990).Organization: From Substance to Image?.Organization Studies,11(3),373-394.
  4. Bansal, P.,Clelland, I.(2004).Talking Trash: Legitimacy, Impression Management, and Unsystematic Risk in the Context of the Natural Environment.Academy of Management Journal,47(1),93-103.
  5. Barney, J.(1991).Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
  6. Barney, J.,Wright, M.,Ketchen, D. J., Jr.(2001).The Resource-based View of the Firm: Ten Years after 1991.Journal of Management,27(6),625-641.
  7. Berkowitza, D.,Lee, J.(2004).Media Relations in Korea: Cheong between Journalist and Public Relations Practitioner.Public Relations Review,30(4),431-437.
  8. Bland, M.,Theaker, A.,Wragg, D.(1996).Effective Media Relations: How to Get Results.London:Institute of Public Relations.
  9. Bradley, R. L.(2004).The Connection between Public Relations and Competitive Advantage.Public Relations Quarterly,49(4),7-10.
  10. Brown, N.,Deegan, C.(1998).The Public Disclosure of Environmental Performance Information: A Dual Test of Media Agenda-setting Theory and Legitimacy Theory.Accounting and Business research,29(1),21-41.
  11. Carroll, C. E.,McCombs, M.(2003).Agenda-setting Effects of Business News on the Public's Images and Opinions about Major Corporations.Corporate Reputation Review,6(1),36-46.
  12. Chen, C. C.,Meindl, J. R.(1991).The Construction of Leadership Images in the Popular Press: The Case of Donald Burr and People Express.Administrative Sciences Quarterly,36(4),521-551.
  13. Cho, S.(2006).The Power of Public Relations in Media Relations: A National Survey of Health PR Practitioners.Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly,83(3),563-580.
  14. Comrie, M.(1997).Media Tactics in New Zealand's Crown Health Enterprises.Public Relations Review,23(2),161-176.
  15. Deephouse, D. L.(2000).Media Reputation as a Strategic Resource: An Integration of Mass Communication and Resource-based Theories.Journal of Management,26(6),1091-1112.
  16. Deephouse, D. L.(1996).Does Isomorphism Legitimate?.Academy of Management Journal,39(4),1024-1039.
  17. Desiere, S. E.,Sha, B. L.(2007).Exploring the Development of an Organizational Approach to Media Relationships.Public Relations Review,33(1),96-98.
  18. Eccles, R. G.,Vollbracht, M.(2006).Media Reputation of the Insurance Industry: An Urgent Call for Strategic Communication Management.The Geneva Papers,31(3),395-408.
  19. Elsbach, K. D.(1994).Managing Organizational Legitimacy in the California Cattle Industry: The Construction and Effectiveness of Verb Accounts.Administrative Sciences Quarterly,39(1),57-88.
  20. Fombrun, C.,Shanley, M.(1990).What's in a Name? Reputation Building and Corporate Strategy.Academy of Management Journal,33(2),233-258.
  21. Gaines-Ross, L.(2000).CEO Reputation: A Key Factor in Shareholder Value.Corporate Reputation Review,3(4),366-370.
  22. Garnett, J. L.,Kouzmin, A.(2007).Communicating throughout Katrina: Competing and Complementary Conceptual Lenses on Crisis Communication.Public Administration Review,67(1),171-188.
  23. George, D.,Mallery, P.(2007).SPSS for Windows Step by Step: A Simple Guide and Reference.Cambridge, MA:Pearson.
  24. Gitlin, T.(1980).The Whole World is Watching: Mass Media in the Making and Unmaking of the New Left.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
  25. Gotsi, M.,Wilson, A. M.(2001).Corporate Reputation: Seeking a Definition.Corporate Communication,6(1),24-30.
  26. Gray, E. R.,Balmer, J. M. T.(1998).Managing Corporate Image and Corporate Reputation.Long Range Planning,31(5),695-702.
  27. Grunig, J. E.(1990).Theory and Practice of Interactive Media Relations.Public Relations Quarterly,35(3),18-23.
  28. Hayward, M. L. A.,Rindova, V. P.,Pollock, T. G.(2004).Believing One's Own Press: The Causes and Consequences of CEO Celebrity.Strategic Management Journal,25(7),637-653.
  29. Holsti, O. R.(1969).Content Analysis for the Social Sciences and Humanities.Cambridge, MA:Addison-Wesley.
  30. Jens, P.,Brooks, R.,Nicoletti, G.,Russell, R.(2006).Media Coverage and Biotechnology IPOs: Some Australian Evidence.Journal of Commercial Biotechnology,13(1),43-47.
  31. Jo, S.,Kim, Y.(2004).Media of Personal Relations? Exploring Media Relations Dimensions in South Korea.Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly,81(2),292-306.
  32. Kelly, W.,Masumoto, T.,Gibson, D.(2002).Kisha Kurabu and Koho: Japanese Media Relations and Public Relations.Public Relations Review,28(3),265-281.
  33. Kent, M. L.,Taylor, M.(2003).Maximizing Media Relations: A Web Site Checklist.Public Relations Quarterly,48(1),14-18.
  34. Kerlinger, F. N.,Lee, H. B.(2000).Foundations of Behavioral Research.Belmont, CA:Wadsworth.
  35. Kiousis, S.,Popescu, C.,Mitrook, M.(2007).Understanding Influence on Corporate Reputation: An Examination of Public Relations Efforts, Media Coverage, Public Opinion, and Financial Performance from an Agenda-building and Agenda-setting Perspective.Journal of Public Relations Research,19(2),147-165.
  36. Kjær, P.,Langer, R.(2005).Infused with News Value: Management, Managerial Knowledge and the Institutionalization of Business News.Scandinavian Journal of Management,21(2),209-233.
  37. Kosicki, G. M.(1993).Problems and Opportunities in Agenda-setting Research.Journal of Communication,43(2),100-127.
  38. Krippendorff, K.(1980).Content Analysis: An Introduction to its Methodology.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  39. Kuntzman, G.(1995).A Real Reporter's Guide to Media Relations.Public Relations Tactics,2(9),1-10.
  40. Lamertz, K.,Baum, J. A. C.(1998).The Legitimacy of Organizational Downsizing in Canada: An Analysis of Explanatory Media Accounts.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,15(1),93-107.
  41. Levin, L. A.,Behrens, S. J.(2003).From Swoosh to Swoon: Linguistic Analysis of Nike's Changing Image.Business Communication Quarterly,66(3),52-65.
  42. Lindenmann, W. K.(1994).Improving Your Media Relations with Research.Public Relations Tactics,1(3),1-10.
  43. Lubbers, C. A.(2005).Media Relations in the Travel and Tourism Industry: A Coorientation Analysis.Journal of Hospitality and Leisure Marketing,12(1-2),41-55.
  44. Luesby, L.(2001).The Word on Business: It's an Information Economy: Be a Smart Informer.London:Prentice Hall.
  45. Martin, C. R.,Oshagan, H.(1997).Disciplining the Workforce: The News Media Frame a General Motors Plant Closing.Communication Research,24(6),669-697.
  46. Mazza, C.,Alvarez, J. L.(2000).Haute Couture and Prêt-a-porter: The Popular Press and the Diffusion of Management Practices.Organization Studies,21(3),567-588.
  47. McCombs, M.,Shaw, D.(1972).The Agenda-setting Function of Mess Media.Public Opinion Quarterly,36(2),176-187.
  48. McManus, J. H.(1994).Market-driven Journalism: Let the Citizen Beware?.Beverly Hills, CA:Longman.
  49. Park, D. J.,Berger, B. K.(2004).The Presentation of CEOs in the Press, 1990-2000: Increasing Salience, Positive Valence, and a Focus on Competency and Personal Dimensions of Image.Journal of Public Relations Research,16(1),93-125.
  50. Pollock, T. G.,Rindova, V. P.(2003).Media Legitimation Effects in the Market for Initial Public Offering.Academy of Management Journal,46(5),631-642.
  51. Rinallo, D.,Basuroy, S.(2009).Does Advertising Spending Influences Media Coverage of the Advertiser?.Journal of Marketing,73(6),33-46.
  52. Shin, J. H.,Cameron, G. T.(2003).The Potential of Online Media: A Coorientational Analysis of Conflict between PR Professionals and Journalists in South Korea.Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly,80(3),583-602.
  53. Sinaga, S.,Callison, C.(2008).Credibility of PR Practitioners: The Impact of Professional Journalism Background on Trustworthiness, Expertness, and Homophily Evaluations.Public Relations Review,34(3),291-293.
  54. Sonnenfeld, S.(1994).Media Policy: What Media Policy?.Harvard Business Review,72(4),18-32.
  55. Strang, D.,Macy, M. W.(2001).In Search of Excellence: Fads, Success Stories, and Adaptive Emulation.American Journal of Sociology,107(1),147-182.
  56. Tucker, L. R.(1998).The Framing of Calvin Klein: A frame Analysis of Media Discourse about the August 1995 Calvin Klein Jeans Advertising Campaign.Critical Studies in Mass Communication,15(2),141-157.
  57. Weaver, D.,Elliott, S. N.(1985).Who Gets the Agenda for the Media? A Study of Local Agenda Building.Journalism Quarterly,62(2),87-94.
  58. Weber, R. P.(1985).Basic Content Analysis.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  59. Wernerfelt, B.(1984).A Resource-based View of the Firm.Strategic Management Journal,5(2),171-180.
  60. Wigley, S.,Zhang, W.(2009).PR Gets Personal: A Framing Analysis of Coverage Before and After a Source's Criticism of the Media.Public Relations Review,35(3),304-306.
  61. Wry, T.,Deephouse, D. L.,McNamara, G.(2006).Substantive and Evaluative Media Reputations Among and Within Cognitive Strategic Groups.Corporate Reputation Review,9(4),225-242.
  62. Wu, M. Y.(2004).Public Relations in Taiwan: A 2005 Version.Public Relations Quarterly,49(4),19-21.
  63. Yoon, Y.(2005).A Scale for Measuring Media Relations Efforts.Public Relations Review,31(3),434-436.
  64. Zhang, J.,Swanson, D.(2006).Analysis of News Media's Representation of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR).Public Relations Quarterly,51(2),13-17.
  65. 王石番(1991)。傳播內容分析法：理論與實證。台北:幼獅文化事業公司。
  66. 李昭安(2006)。由《商業週刊》封面故事看財經雜誌對成功者形象的再現。2006年中華傳播學會年會「數位化時代的媒體生態、教育與倫理」研討會
  67. 林詩宜、羅世宏(2004)。從博達案新聞報導探討數位時代財經記者的報導規範。淡江大學2004年「知識、創新、傳播」學術研討會論文集
  68. 姚惠忠(2006)。公共關係學：原理與實務。台北:五南書局。
  69. 孫秀蕙(1997)。公共關係：理論、策略與研究實例。台北:正中書局。
  70. 張依依(2007)。公共關係理論的演進與變遷。台北:五南書局。
  71. 陳韜文編(1997)。大眾傳播與市場經濟。香港:爐鋒學會。
  72. 臧國仁、鍾蔚文(1997)。框架概念與公共關係策略：有關運用媒體框架的探析。廣告學研究，9，99-130。
  73. 編輯部(2005)。台灣媒體廣告營收大調查（雜誌篇）：雜誌百變，專案招財源。動腦雜誌，349，76-81。
  74. 編輯部(2003)。台灣媒體專輯（雜誌篇）：想賺廣告費？先比企劃案！。動腦雜誌，327，44-53。
  75. 編輯部(2006)。2005台灣媒體廣告營收調查（雜誌）：生小孩拓財源，雜誌專刊當道。動腦雜誌，361，66-75。
  76. 編輯部(2004)。台灣媒體總體檢（雜誌篇）：十八般武藝都使上吧！。動腦雜誌，338，60-68。
  77. 蔡敦浩(2009)。企業概論。台中:滄海書局。
  78. 羅文坤(1998)。媒體對企業形象之影響。民意研究季刊，205，41-66。
被引用次数
  1. Wei, Yu-Chen,Wang, Dan-Leng,Lu, Yang-Cheng,Chen, Jen-Nan(2018).The Impact of Media Reputation on Stock Market and Financial Performance of Corporate Social Responsibility Winner.臺大管理論叢,28(1),87-140.
  2. 董夢杭,寇家瑜(2018)。再探企業政治連結的價值：企業醜聞中的政商關係。管理學報，35(4)，481-501。
  3. 蘇登呼(2014)。中小型地方美食業者之媒體公關核心工作－業者與記者觀點比較。管理實務與理論研究，8(4)，35-52。
  4. 蘇中信(2012)。價格調整策略的分析：以台灣宜家家居為例。國立虎尾科技大學學報，31(1)，19-42。
  5. 周冠男、池祥萱、王韻怡(2016)。行為財務學文獻回顧與展望：台灣市場之研究。經濟論文叢刊，44(1)，1-55。
  6. (2013)。限制競爭或妨礙公平競爭之虞及其法律效果關連性之評價─公平會案例之驗證。公平交易季刊，21(2)，77-122。
  7. (2015)。公平交易法對於價格垂直限制與非價格垂直限制之評價。公平交易季刊，23(1)，153-196。
  8. (2015)。連鎖加盟業主經營行為處分案件內容結構分析。公平交易季刊，23(2)，1-38。
  9. (2016)。專利警告函資訊內容與法律責任之關聯：專利權類型的干擾效果。公平交易季刊，24(3)，135-172。
  10. (2018)。企業政治連結的兩難：以奇美在台灣與大陸的政治策略為例。產業與管理論壇，20(3)，1-9。
print cancel