题名

專案團隊內創意構想守門能耐與體制規則概念建構及量表發展與驗證

并列篇名

The Construct and Questionnaire Development of the Gatekeeping Mechanism inside the Project Team

DOI

10.6160/2012.12.02

作者

項維欣(Wei-Hsin Hsiang)；吳思華(Se-Hwa Wu)；陳意文(Yi-Wen Chen)

关键词

守門 ； 守門能耐 ； 體制規則 ； 量表發展 ； Gatekeeping ； Gatekeeping Capability ； Institutional Routines ； Questionnaire Development

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

20卷4期（2012 / 12 / 01）

页次

1045 - 1104

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

過去創新管理，多以創意者角度思考，鮮以守門觀點探討；創新、研發、創造力理論脈絡，也甚少直接研究守門內涵。因此，本文以Lewin守門理論為基礎，整合演化、技術守門、創造力系統、體制理論，推衍何為創意構想守門，提出其運作包含：守門能耐-贏取信任基礎的能力、提供動機誘因的能力、專業能力；體制規則-評估標準、互動程度等二構念五因子。依此多構念架構，Hinkin（1998）嚴謹發展程序，以三群不同獨立樣本，發展具信效度的量表，驗證專案團隊內創意構想守門概念結構模型的合宜性。而本文除強調以守門角度思考對管理創新的重要性；也提出創意構想守門內涵供經理人設計創意構想守門時，一個有系統的思考框架；而所發展具信效度之量表，亦可作為後續研究的基礎。
英文摘要

In the past, most studies in innovation management have adopted the creator's perspective. Few researchers have adopted a user's or gatekeeper's view. Furthermore, research on gatekeeping in innovation, R&D management, and creativity seldom focus directly on the gatekeeping itself. To fill this gap, this study tries to clarify exactly what gatekeeping is. The study follows the logic of Lewin's gatekeeping theory and introduces the evolution perspective. It also integrates the technology gatekeeper, Csikszentmihaly's system model, and institutional theory to examine gatekeeping in selecting creative ideas. This paper proposes five key factors in the gatekeeping construct: the ability to earn creators' trust, the ability to raise creators' motivation, the selection of professional abilities, standards of evaluation, and the degree of interaction. Then, following Lewin's gatekeeping theory, this study classifies these five factors into two dimensions: the gatekeeping capabilities and institutional routines. Finally, on the basis of this theoretical model and the procedure from Hinkin (1998), this study develops and tests a questionnaire on gatekeeping of creative ideas inside project teams. The results show that the theoretical model is reasonable and that the questionnaire has fair reliability and validity. This research can serve as a foundation for future innovation studies on gatekeeping of creative ideas. It also serves to remind the managers of the importance of gatekeeping and provides a model for managing innovations.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 紀乃文、陳皓怡、楊美玉、鄭妃君、蔡維奇(2008)。個人─工作適配量表發展：多元構面觀點。管理學報，25(5)，577-598。
    連結：
  2. 黃家齊、王思峰(2008)。團隊知識分享轉換能力組合與知識分享、知識創造及創新績效─知識螺旋理論的新觀點驗證。組織與管理，1(1)，39-72。
    連結：
  3. 黃家齊、黃荷婷(2006)。團隊成員目標導向對於自我與集體效能及創新的影響─一個多層次的研究。管理學報，23(3)，327-346。
    連結：
  4. Lewin, K., 1947,“Frontiers in Group Dynamics: II Channels of Group Life, Social Planning and Action Research,” Human Relatioin, Vol. 1, No. 1, 143-153.
  5. Allen, T. J.(1970).Communication Networks in R&D Laboratories.R&D Management,1(1),14-21.
  6. Allen, T. J.,Cohen, S.(1969).Information Flow in R&D Laboratories.Administrative Science Quarterly,14(1),12-19.
  7. Allen, T.,Lee, J.,Denis, M. S.,Tushman, M. L.(1980).R&D Performance as a Function of Internal Communication, Project Management, and the Nature of the Work.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,27(1),2-12.
  8. Allen, T.,Tushman, M. L.,Lee, J.,Denis, M. S.(1979).Technology Transfer as a Function of Position in the Spectrum from Research through Development to Technical Services.Academy of Management Journal,22(4),694-709.
  9. Amabile, T. M.(1985).Motivation and Creativity: Effects of Motivational Orientation on Creative Writers.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,48(2),393-399.
  10. Amabile, T. M.(1983).The Social Psychology of Creativity.New York:Springer-Verlag.
  11. Amabile, T. M.,Goldfarb, P.,Brackfield, S.(1990).Social Influences on Creativity: Evaluation Coaction, and Surveillance.Creativity Research Journal,3(1),6-21.
  12. Amabile, T. M.,Hennessey, B. A.,Grossman, B.(1986).Social Influences on Creativity: The Effects of Contracted-for Reward.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,50(1),14-23.
  13. Amabile, T. M.,Hill, K. G.,Hennessey, B. A.,Tighe, E. M.(1994).The Work Preference Inventory: Assessing Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivational Orientations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,66(5),950-967.
  14. Anderson, J. C.,Gerbing, D. W.(1991).Predicting Performance of Measures in a Confirmatory Factor Analysis with a Pretest Assessment of Their Substantive Validates.Journal of Applied Psychology,76(5),732-740.
  15. Anderson, P.,Tushman, M. L.(1990).Technological Discontinuities and Dominant Designs: A Cyclical Model of Technological Change.Administrative Science Quarterly,35(4),604-633.
  16. Armitage, P.(ed.),Colton, T.(ed.)(1998).Encyclopedia of Biostatistics.London:John Wiley.
  17. Armstrong, J. S.,Overton, T. S.(1977).Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Mail Surveys.Journal of Marketing Research,16(3),396-402.
  18. Barron, F.(1955).The Disposition towards Originality.Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology,51(3),478-485.
  19. Barron, F.,Harrington, D. M.(1981).Creativity and Personal Freedom.New York:Van Nostrand.
  20. Basadur, M. S.(2006).The Power of Innovation: How to Make Innovation a Way of Life and Put Creative Solutions to Work.London:Pitman Professional Publishing.
  21. Basadur, M. S.(1992).Managing Creativity: A Japanese Model.Academy of Management Executive,6(2),29-42.
  22. Basadur, M.,Gelade, G. A.(2006).The Role of Knowledge Management in the Innovation Process.Creativity and Innovation Management,15(1),45-62.
  23. Bauer, T. N.,Truxillo, D. M.,Sanchez, R. J.,Craig, J.,Ferrara, P.,Campion, M. A.(2001).Applicant Reactions to Selection: Development of the Selection Procedural Justice Scale (SPJS).Personnel Psychology,54(2),387-419.
  24. Belliveau, P.(ed.),Friffin, A.(ed.),Soremeyer, S.(ed.)(2002).PDMA Toolbook for New Product Development.New York:John Wiley and Sons.
  25. Berger, P. L.,Luckmann, T.(1967).The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.New York:Anchor Books.
  26. Berger, R. M.,Guilford, S. P.,Christensen, P. R.(1957).A Factor Analytic Study of Planning Abilities.Psychological Monographs,71(1),1-29.
  27. Bielby, W. T.,Bielby, D. D.(1994).All Hits Are Flukes: Institutionalized Decision Making and the Rhetoric of Network Prime-time Program Development.American Journal of Sociology,99(5),1287-1313.
  28. Bouty, I.(2000).Interpersonal and Interaction Influences of Informal Resource Exchane between R&D Researchers across Organizational Boundaries.Academy of Management Journal,43(1),50-65.
  29. Burt, R. S.(1992).Structure Holes: The Social Structure of Competition.Cambridge, MA:Havard University Press.
  30. Bystryn, M.(1978).Art Galleries as Gatekeepers: The Case of the Abstract Expressions.Social Research,45(2),390-408.
  31. Campbell, D. T.(1960).Blind Variation and Selective Retention in Creative Thought as in Other Knowledge Processes.Psychological Review,67(6),380-400.
  32. Campbell, D. T.,Fiske, D. W.(1959).Convergent and Discriminant Validation by the Multitrait-multimethod Matrix.Psychological Bulletin,56(2),81-105.
  33. Cardinal, L. B.,Hatfield, D. E.(2000).Internal Knowledge Generation: The Research Laboratory and Innovative Productivity in the Pharmaceutical Industry.Journal of Engineering Technology Management,17(3),247-271.
  34. Cooper, R. G.(1993).Winning at New Product: Accelerating the Process from Idea to Launch. Reading.New York:Perseus Books.
  35. Cooper, R.,Edgett, S.,Kleinschmidt, E.(2002).Optimizing the Stage-gate Process: What Best Practice Companies are Doing-part II.Research-Technology Management,45(6),43-49.
  36. Cooper, R.,Edgett, S.,Kleinschmidt, E.(2002).Optimizing the Stage-gate Process: What Best Practice Companies are Doing-part I.Research-Technology Management,45(5),21-27.
  37. Crocker, L.,Algina, J.(1986).Introduction to Classical and Modern Test Theory.New York:Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.
  38. Delmestri, G.,Montanari, F.,Usai, A.(2005).Reputation and Strength of Ties in Predicting Commerical Success and Artistic Merit of Independents in the Italian Feature Film Industry.Journal of Management and Studies,42(5),975-1002.
  39. Diez, M. A.(2001).The Evaluation of Regional Innovation and Cluster Policies: Toward a Participatory Approach.European Planning Studies,9(7),907-923.
  40. Dimaggio, P. J.(1977).Market Structures, the Creative Process, and Popular Culture.Journal of Popular Culture,11(2),436-452.
  41. Dimaggio, P. J.,Powell, W. W.(1983).The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields.American Sociological Review,48(2),147-160.
  42. Doerner, D.,Schaub, H.(1994).Errors in Planning and Decision Making and the Nature of Huamn Information Processing.Applied Psychology: An International Review,43(4),433-453.
  43. Drazin, R.,Schoonhoven, C. B.(1996).Community, Population, and Organization Effects on Innovation: A Multilevel Perspective.Academy of Management Journal,39(5),1065-1083.
  44. Driks, K. T.(2000).Trust in Leadership and Team Performance: Evidence from NCCU Basketball.Journal of Applied Psychology,85(6),1004-1012.
  45. Elsbach, K. D.(2003).How to Pitch a Brilliant Idea.Harvard Business Review,81(9),117-123.
  46. Elsbach, K. D.,Kramer, R. M.(2003).Assessing Creativity in Hollywood Pitch Meetings: Evidence for a Dual-Process Model of Creativity Judgments.Academy of Management Journal,46(3),283-301.
  47. Erkko, A.(1998).Evaluation of RTD in Regional Systems of Innovation.European Planning Studies,6(2),131-141.
  48. Feist, G. J.(1998).A Meta-Analysis of Personality in Scientific and Artistic Creativity.Personality and Social Psychology Review,2(4),290-309.
  49. Fleming, L.,Waguespack, D. M.(2007).Brokerage, Boundary, Spanning, and Leadership in Open Innovation Community.Organizaiton Science,18(2),165-180.
  50. Florida, R.(2002).The Rise of the Creative Class: And How it's Transforming Work, Leisure, Community and Everyday Life.New York:Basic Books.
  51. Flynn, M.,Dooley, L.,O''Sullivan, D.,Cormican, K.(2003).Idea Management for Organization Innovation.International Journal of Innovation Management,7(4),417-442.
  52. Ford, C.(1996).A Theory of Individual Creative Action in Multiple Social Domains.Academy of Management Review,21(4),1112-1142.
  53. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Evaluation Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
  54. Galbraith, J. R.(1982).Designing the Innovation Organizations.Organizational Dynamics,11(1),5-25.
  55. Gardner, H.(1993).Creating Minds.New York:Basic Books.
  56. Glynn, M. A.(1996).Innovative Genius: A Framework for Relating Individual and Organizational Intelligences to Innovation.Academy of Management Review,21(4),1081-1111.
  57. Gold, B.(1988).Charting a Cours to Superior Technology Evaluation.Sloan Management Review,30(1),19-27.
  58. Griffin, A.,Page, A. L.(1993).An Interim Report on Measuring Product Development Success and Failure.Journal of Product Innovation Management,10(4),291-308.
  59. Hair, J. F.(1998).Multivariate Data Analysis.New York:Prentice-Hall.
  60. Hammond, K. J.(1990).Case-based Planning: A Framework for Planning from Experience.Cognitive Science,14(4),385-443.
  61. Hershey, D. A.,Walsh, D. A.,Read, S. J.,Chulef, A. S.(1990).The Effects of Expertise on Financial Problem Solving: Evidence for Goal Directed Problem Solving Scripts.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Process,46(1),77-101.
  62. Heslop, L.,McGregor, E.,Griffith, M.(2001).Development of A Technology Readiness Assessment Measure: The Cloverleaf Model of Technology Transfer.Journal of Technology Transfer,26(4),369-384.
  63. Hibbert, L.(2001).Winners and Losers in the Art of Pitching for Business.Professional Engineering,14(4),15-16.
  64. Hinkin, T. R.(1998).A Brief Tutorial on the Development of Measures for Use in Survey Questionnaires.Organizational Research Methods,1(1),104-121.
  65. Hirsch, P. M.(1972).Processing Fads and Fashions: An Organization-set Analysis of Cultural Industry Systems.American Journal of Sociology,77(4),639-659.
  66. Hitt, M. A.,Hoskisson, R. E.,Johnson, R. A.,Moesel, D. D.(1996).The Market for Corporate Control and Firm Innovation.Academy of Management Journal,20(4),767-798.
  67. Kasof, J.(1996).Explaining Creativity: the Attributional Perspective.Creativity Research Journal,8(4),311-366.
  68. Kasof, J.(1995).Social Determinants of Creativity: Status Expectations and the Evaluation of Original Products.Advances in Group Process,12(2),167-220.
  69. Kasof, J.(1993).Six Bias in the Naming of Stimulus Person.Psychological Bulletin,113(1),140-163.
  70. Katz, A.,Giacommelli, L.(1982).The Subjective Nature of Creativity Judgments.Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society,20(1),17-20.
  71. Katz, D.(1964).The Motivational Basis of Organizational Behavior.Behavioral Science,9(2),131-146.
  72. Katz, D.,Kahn, R. L.(1978).The Social Psychology of Organizations.New York:Wiley.
  73. Katz, R.,Tushman, M.(1979).Communication Patterns, Project Performance, and Task Characteristics: An Empirical Evaluation and Integration in an R&D Setting.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,23(2),139-162.
  74. Kitchell, S.(1995).Corporate Culture, Environmental Adaptation, and Innovative Adaptation: A Qualitative/Quantitative Approach.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,23(2),192-205.
  75. Kubey, R.,Reed, L.,Csikszentmihalyi, M.(1996).Experience Sampling Method Applications to Communication Research Questions.Journal of Communication,46(2),99-105.
  76. Lambert, D. M.,Harrington, T. C.(1990).Measuring Nonresponse Bias in Customer Service Mail Surveys.Journal of Business Logistics,11(2),5-25.
  77. Lewin, K.(1951).Field Theory in Social Science: Selected Theoretical Papers.New York:Harper.
  78. Liden, R. C.,Maslyn, J. M.(1998).Multidimensionality of Leader-Member Exchange: An Empirical Assessment through Scale Development.Journal of Management,24(1),43-72.
  79. Lonergan, D.,Scott, C.,Ginamarie, M.,Mumford, M. D.(2004).Evaluative Aspects of Creative Thought: Effects of Appraisal and Revision Standards.Creativity Research Journal,16(2-3),231-246.
  80. Maguire, S.,Hardy, C.,Lawrence, T. B.(2004).Institutional Entrepreneurship in Emerging Fields: HIV/AIDS Treatment Advocacy in Canada.Academy of Management Journal,47(5),657-679.
  81. Mauws, M. K.(2000).But is it Art? Decision Making and Discursive Resources in the Field of Cultural Production.The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science,36(2),229-244.
  82. Mayer, R.,Davis, J.,Schoorman, F.(1995).A Integration Model of Organization Trust.Academy of Management Review,20(3),709-734.
  83. Meyersib, D.,Weicj, K.,Karmer, R.(1996).Swift Trust and Temporary Groups.Trust in Organizations: Frontiers of Theory and Research,Calif, UK:
  84. Mumford, M. D.(2000).Managing Creative People: Strategies and Tactics for Innovation.Human Resource Management Review,10(3),313-351.
  85. Mumford, M. D.(2001).Something Old, Something New: Revisiting Guilford's Conception of Creative Problem Solving.Creativity Research Journal,13(3-4),267-276.
  86. Mumford, M. D.,Lonergan, D. C.,Scott, G. M.(2002).Evaluating Creative Ideas: Process, Standards, and Context.Critical Inquiry,22(1),21-30.
  87. Mumford, M. D.,Marks, M. A.,Connelly, M. S.,Zaccaro, S. J.,Johnson, J. F.(1998).Domain-Based Scoring of Divergent Thinking Tests: Validation Evidence in an Occupational Sample.Creativity Research Journal,11(2),151-163.
  88. Mumford, M. D.,Schultz, R. M.,Van, D.(2001).Performance in Planning & Processes, Requirements, and Others.Review of General Psychology,5(3),213-240.
  89. Nimmo, D.(ed.)(1979).Communications Yearbook.Piscataway, NJ:Transactioin.
  90. Nisbett, R.,Ross, L.(1980).Human Interface: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgement.New York:Prentice-Hall.
  91. Opshal, R. L.,Dunnette, M. D.(1966).The Role of Financial Compensation in Industrial Motivation.Psychological Bulletin,66(2),94-118.
  92. Osterlund, J.(1995).Individual Competence and Group Behavior within a Living System.Behavioral Science,40(1),7-15.
  93. Peierl, A. M.(ed.),Anand, N.(ed.)(2002).Career Creativity: Explorations in the Remarking of Work.New York:Oxford University Press.
  94. Politis, J. D.(2003).The Connection between Trust and Knowledge Management: What are its Implications for Team Performance.Journal of Knowledge Management,7(5),55-66.
  95. Powell, W. W.(1978).Publishers' Decision-making: What Criteria do they Use in Deciding which Books to Publish.Social Research,45(2),227-252.
  96. Roberts, E. B.,Fusfeld, A. R.(1981).Staffing the Innovative Technology-based Organization.Sloan Management Review,22(3),19-35.
  97. Rothenberg, A.(1990).Creativity and Madness.Baltimore, MD:Johns Hopkins University Press.
  98. Rothenberg, A.,Greenberg, B.(1976).The Index of Scientific Writings on Creativity: Grenal, 1566-1974.Hamden, CT:Archon Books.
  99. Rothenberg, A.,Greenberg, B.(1974).The Index of Scientific Writings on Creativity: Creative Men and Women.Hamden, CT:Archon Books.
  100. Runco, M. A.(ed.)(1994).Problem Finding, Problem Solving, and Creativity.Norwood, NJ:Ablex Norwood.
  101. Runco, M. A.,Basadur, M.(1990).Assessing Ideational and Evaluative Skill and Creative Styles and Attitudes.Proceedings of the International Engineering and Management Conference,Santa Clara, USA:
  102. Runco, M. A.,Smith, W. R.(1992).Interpersonal and Intrapersonal Evaluations of Creative Ideas.Personality and Individual Differences,13(3),295-302.
  103. Runco, M. A.,Vega, L.(1990).Evaluating the Creativity of Children's Ideas.Journal of Social Behavior and Personality,5(5),439-452.
  104. Schwab, D. P.(2005).Research Methods for Organizational Studies.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  105. Sharma, A.(1999).Central Dilemmas of Managing Innovation in Lage Firms.California Management Review,41(3),146-163.
  106. Simonton, D. K.(1991).Emergence and Realization of Genius: The Lives and Workd of 120 Classical Composers.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,61(5),829-840.
  107. Simonton, D. K.(1976).Biographical Determinants of Achieved Eminence: A Multivariate Approach to the Cox Data.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,33(2),218-226.
  108. Simonton, D. K.(1977).Creativity Productivity, Age, and Stress: A Biographical Time-Series Analysis of 10 Classical Composers.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,35(11),791-804.
  109. Simonton, D. K.(1992).The Social Context of Career Success and Course for 2,026 Scientists and Inventors.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,18(3),452-563.
  110. Simonton, D. K.(1985).Quality, Quantity, and Age: The Careers of Ten Distinguished Psychologists.International Journal of Aging and Human Development,21(4),241-254.
  111. Simonton, D. K.(1977).Eminence, Creativity, and Geographical Marginality: A Recursive Structural Equation Model.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,38(11),805-816.
  112. Simonton, D. K.(1992).Leaders of American Psychology, 1879-1967: Career Development, Creative Output, and Professional Achievement.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,62(1),5-17.
  113. Simonton, D. K.(1979).Multiple Discovery and Invention: Zeitgeist, Genius, or Chance.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,37(9),1603-1616.
  114. Simonton, D. K.(1981).The Library Laboratory: Archival Data in Personality and Social Psychology.Review of Personality and Social Psychology,2(3),217-243.
  115. Spencer, J. W.(2003).Global Gatekeeping, Representation, and Network Structure: A Longitudinal Analysis of Regional and Global Knowledge Diffusion Networks.Journal of International Business Studies,34(5),428-442.
  116. Starkey, K.,Barnatt, C.,Tempest, S.(2000).Beyond Networks and Hierarchies: Latent Organizations in the U.K. Television Industry.Organization Science,11(3),299-305.
  117. Staw, B. M.(ed.),Cummings, L. L.(ed.)(1980).Research in Organization Behavior.New York:Elservier Science.
  118. Stenberg, R. J.(1985).Implicit Theories of Intelligence, Creativity, and Wisdom.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,49(3),607-627.
  119. Stenberg, R. J.(ed.)(1988).The Nature of Creativity: Contemporary Psychological Perspective.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  120. Sternberg, R. J.(ed.)(1999).The Handbook of Creativity.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  121. Stross, R.(2000).The True Story of the Six Tall Man Who Baked ebay, Webvan, and Other Billion-Dollar Start-Ups.New York:Crown Books.
  122. Tasi, W.(2002).Social Structure of Coopetition within a multiunit organization: Coordination, Competition, and Intraorganizational Knowledge Sharing.Organization Science,13(2),179-190.
  123. Thomas, J. B.,Clark, S. M.,Gioia, D. A.(1993).Strategic Sensemaking and Organizational Performance: Linkages among Scanning, Interpretation, Action, and Outcomes.Academy of Management Journal,36(2),239-270.
  124. Torrance, E. P.(1966).The Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking: Norms-Technical Manual.Lexington, MA:Personnel Press.
  125. Van de Van, A. H.(1986).Central Problem in the Management of Innovation.Management Science,32(5),590-607.
  126. Van de Van, A. H.,Delbecq, A. L.(1971).Nominal Versus Interacting Group Process for Committee Decision-making Effectiveness.Academy of Management Journal,14(2),203-212.
  127. Vand de Van, A. H.(ed.),Angle, H. L.(ed.),Poole, M. S.(ed.)(2000).Research on the Management Innovation-the Minnesota Studies.New York:Oxford University Press.
  128. Wehner, L.,Csikszentmihalyi, M.,Magyari-Beck, I.(1991).Current Approaches Used in Studying Creativity: An Exploratory Investigation.Creativity Research Journal,4(3),261-271.
  129. Weigelt, K.,Camerer, C.(1988).Reputation and Corporate Strategy: a Review of Recent Theory and Applications.Strategic Management Journal,9(5),443-454.
  130. Weisberg, R. W.(1986).Creativity: Genius and Other Myths.New York:Freeman.
  131. 杜明城譯、Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly(1999)。創造力。台北:時報文化。
  132. 杜默譯、Moody, Glyn(2001)。Linux傳奇─讓比爾蓋茲坐立難安的天才。台北:時報文化。
  133. 邱皓政(2006)。量化研究與統計分析：SPSS中文視窗版資料分析範例解析。台北:五南圖書。
  134. 郭雅琪(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立高雄第一科技大學企業管理研究所。
  135. 黃芳銘(2007)。結構方程模式：理論與應用。台北:五南圖書出版公司。
print cancel