题名

The Chinese Lunar New Year and Reverse Disposition Effect

并列篇名

農曆新年與反處置效應

DOI

10.6160/2015.06.01

作者

傅小芃(Hsiao-Peng Fu)；謝舒帆(Shu-Fan Hsieh)

关键词

反處置效應 ； 農曆新年 ； 季節性 ； 假日效應 ； Reverse Disposition Effect ； Chinese Lunar New Year ； Seasonality ； Holiday Effect

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

23卷2期（2015 / 06 / 01）

页次

521 - 561

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

農曆新年在中華文化具有一元復始，萬象更新的象徵。本文假設投資人賣出股票的投資決策，亦受這文化象徵影響。根據Ingersoll & Jin（2013）建立的反處置效應模式，本文假設投資人在年前可能賣出較多帳面虧損的股票，卻賣出較少帳面獲利的股票─一種反處置效應行為。如此，虧損股票在年後可以重新建立部分，好處是新的參考價格可能較舊部位的參考價格為低。於是，增加未來賣出部位時的獲利可能性。也就是在年前認賠，俾股票投資績效在年後展開新局面。本文實證結果和預期相同，即發現購買帳面獲利股票及同時賣出帳面虧損股票的投資策略在年後平均將導致顯著損失。相對而言，該投資策略在年前僅有不顯著的損失。最重要的，該投資策略年後的損失主要來自帳面虧損股票的價格反轉。可見年後帳面虧損股票上漲的幅度較帳面獲利股票為高，同時隱含年前前者較後者面臨較大賣壓。鑑於實務上觀察發現，農曆年前有資金需求強烈的現象，本文假設前期M1B減少的愈嚴重，代表短期資金供給愈不足，則上述反處置效應行為愈強烈。再者，考慮共同基金可能在年底有增加持股（portfolio pumping）的行為，以推升其持股較重股票的股價。此買盤可能會抵銷處置股票的賣盤，故本文假設共同基金持股水準愈高，上述反處置效應愈弱。上述二假設都獲得證實，同時相關結果無法由Fama & French（1993）的風險三因子解釋之。
英文摘要

The Chinese Lunar New Year (CLNY) traditionally symbolizes a fresh start, including for investment performance. Therefore, we assume the presence of a reverse disposition effect prior to the CLNY in the Taiwanese stock market, that is, investors are more willing to sell losers than winners to reset the reference prices of losers so as to realize gains in future as predicted by Ingersoll & Jin (2013). Consistent with the predictions, we find that the arbitrage portfolios of longing paper-winners and shorting paper-losers generate significantly negative returns in the post-CLNY period but the portfolios yield only weak negative returns in the pre-CLNY period. More importantly, this strong negativity is primarily attributable to a price reversal of losers. Furthermore, we use the lagged change of M1B to inversely proxy for the necessity to sell stocks to satisfy the customary liquidity demands prior to the CLNY and thereby hypothesize an inverse relationship between the money supply and the reverse disposition effect. Moreover, we assume that mutual fund holdings are negatively associated with the effect because (due to year-end portfolio pumping behaviors) mutual funds provide a buying force against the aforementioned selling forces. Consistent with the assumptions, the evidence indicates that a significant negative arbitrage return is observed during the post-CLNY period when there is a decreased lagged change in M1B and for stocks with low or medium levels of mutual fund holdings. The conditional negative arbitrage returns survive tests of the three risk factors identified by Fama & French (1993).
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Kao, C. W.,Wan, J. Y.(2012).An Investigation of the Short Term Interest Rate Indicators: Evidence from Taiwan.Taiwan Journal of Applied Economics,92(3),23-36.
    連結：
  2. Chui, A. C. W., Titman, S., and Wei, K. C. J., 2003, “Momentum, Legal Systems and Ownership Structure: An Analysis of Asian Stock Markets.” Working Paper, University of Texas at Austin
  3. (2013).Handbook of Economics of Finance.
  4. Lastrapes, W. D., 1993, “An Empirical Analysis of Stock Prices and Interest Rate Dynamics: The Role of Money.” Working Paper, University of Georgia
  5. Ben-David, I. and Hirshleifer, D., 2011, “Beyond the Disposition Effect: Do Investors Really Like Realizing Gains More than Losses?” Working Paper, Ohio State University
  6. Kraus, A., Wei, K. C. J., and Yang, Z., 2009, “Determinants of Disposition and Reverse Disposition Effect,” http://ssrn.com/abstract=1369114, accessed on December 12, 2014
  7. Ong, L., 2006, “Seasonalities in China's Stock Markets: Cultural or Structural?” Working Paper, International Monetary Fund
  8. Kuo, M. H., 2008, “How to Measure the Disposition Effect?” Working Paper, Shih Hsin University
  9. Abidin, S., Banchit, A., Sun, S., and Tian, Z., 2012, “Chinese New Year Effects on Stock Returns: Evidence from Asia-Pacific Stock Markets.” Working Paper, University of Waikato
  10. Ahmad, Z.,Hussain, S.(2001).KLSE Long Run Overreaction and the Chinese New Year Effect.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,1(1-2),63-108.
  11. Ariff, M.,Chung, T. F.,Shamsher, M.(2012).Money Supply, Interest Rate, Liquidity and Share Prices: A Test of Their Linkage.Global Finance Journal,23(3),202-220.
  12. Barber, B. M.,Lee, Y. T.,Liu, Y. J.,Odean, T.(2007).Is the Aggregate Investor Reluctant to Realize Losses? Evidence from Taiwan.European Financial Management,13(3),423-447.
  13. Barberis, N.,Xiong, W.(2009).What Drives the Disposition Effect? An Analysis of a Long-Standing Preference-Based Explanation.Journal of Finance,64(2),751-784.
  14. Bermanke, B.,Blinder, A.(1992).The Federal Funds Rate and the Channels of Monetary Transmission.American Economic Reviews,82(4),901-921.
  15. Bhootra, A.,Hur, J.(2012).On the Relationship between Concentration of Prospect Theory/Mental Accounting Investors, Cointegration, and Momentum.Journal of Banking and Finance,36(5),1266-1275.
  16. Blume, M.,Stambaugh, R.(1983).Biases in Computed Returns: An Application to the Size Effect.Journal of Financial Economics,12(3),387-404.
  17. Brown, P.,Chappel, N.,Da Silva Rosa, R.,Walter, T.(2006).The Reach of the Disposition Effect: Large Sample Evidence Across Investor Classes.International Review of Finance,6(1-2),43-78.
  18. Cadsby, C. B.,Ratner, M.(1992).Turn-of-the-month and Pre-Holiday Effects in Sock Returns.Journal of Banking and Finance,16(3),497-509.
  19. Carhart, M. M.,Kaniel, R.,Musto, D. K.,Reed, A. V.(2002).Leaning for the Tape: Evidence of Gaming Behavior in Equity Mutual Funds.Journal of Finance,57(2),661-693.
  20. Chen, G. M.,Kim, K.,Nofsinger, J.,Rui, O.(2007).Trading Performance, Disposition Effect, Overconfidence, Representativeness Bias, and Experience of Emerging Market Investors.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,451(4),425-451.
  21. Chen, T. C.,Chien, C. C.(2011).Size Effect in January and Cultural Influences in an Emerging Stock Market: The Perspective of Behavioral Finance.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,19(2),208-229.
  22. Cheng, T. Y.,Lee, C. I.,Lin, C. H.(2013).An Examination of the Relationship between the Disposition Effect and Gender, Age, the Trade Security, and Bull-bear Market Conditions.Journal of Empirical Finance,21(1),195-213.
  23. Chien, C. C.,Chen, T. C.(2007).The Impact of Lunar New Year on the January Anomaly in Taiwan's Stock Market.Applied Economics Letters,14(14),1075-1077.
  24. Chien, C. C.,Chen, T. C.(2008).Can the January Anomaly in Taiwan's Stock Market be Explained by the Prospect Theory?.Quantitative Finance,8(4),335-339.
  25. Chui, A. C. W.,Titman, S.,Wei, K. C. J.(2010).Individualism and Momentum around the World.Journal of Finance,65(1),361-392.
  26. Cici, G.(2012).The Prevalence of the Disposition Effect in Mutual Funds' Trades.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,47(4),795-820.
  27. Claessens, S.,Dasgupta, S.,Glen, J.(1995).Return Behaviour in Emerging Stock Markets.World Bank Economic Review,9(1),131-151.
  28. Coval, J. D.,Shumway, T.(2005).Do Behavioral Biases Affect Prices?.Journal of Finance,60(1),1-34.
  29. Elfakhani, S.,Zaher, T.(1998).Differential Information Hypothesis, Firm Neglect and the Small Firm Size Effect.Journal of Financial and Strategic Decisions,11(1),29-40.
  30. Fama, F.,French, K.(1993).Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds.Journal of Financial Economics,33(1),3-56.
  31. Feng, L.,Seasholes, M. S.(2005).Do Investor Sophistication and Trading Experience Eliminate Behavioral Biases in Financial Markets?.Review of Finance,9(3),305-351.
  32. Frazzini, A.(2006).The Disposition Effect and Underreactioin to News.Journal of Finance,61(4),2017-2046.
  33. Gao, L.,Kling, G.(2005).Calendar Effects in Chinese Stock Market.Annuals of Economics and Finance,6(1),75-88.
  34. Genesove, D.,Mayer, C.(2001).Loss Aversion and Seller Behavior: Evidence from the Housing Market.Quarterly Journal of Economics,116(4),1233-1260.
  35. Gordon, D. B.,Leeper, E. M.(1994).The Dynamic Impacts of Monetary Policy: An Exercise in Tentative Identification.Journal of Political Economics,102(6),1228-1247.
  36. Grinblatt, M.,Han, B.(2005).Prospect Theory, Mental Accounting, and Momentum.Journal of Financial Economics,78(2),311-339.
  37. Grinblatt, M.,Keloharju, M.(2001).What Makes Investors Trade?.Journal of Finance,56(2),589-616.
  38. Heath, C.,Huddart, S.,Lang, M.(1999).Psychological Factors and Stock Option Exercise.Quarterly Journal of Economics,114(2),601-627.
  39. Ho, Y.(1983).Money Supply and Equity Prices: An Empirical Note on Far Eastern Countries.Economic Letters,11(1-2),161-165.
  40. Ho, Y. K.(1990).Stock Return Seasonalities in Asia Pacific Markets.Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting,2(1),47-77.
  41. Hu, G.,McLean, R. D.,Pontiff, J.,Wang, Q.(2014).The Year-End Trading Activities of Institutional Investors: Evidence from Daily Trades.Review of Financial Studies,27(5),1593-1614.
  42. Ingersoll, J. E.,Jin, L. J.(2013).Realization Utility with Reference-Dependent Preferences.Review of Financial Studies,26(3),723-767.
  43. Keim, D. B.(1983).Size-related Anomalies and Stock Return Seasonality: Further Empirical Evidence.Journal of Financial Economics,12(1),12-32.
  44. Krueger, T. M.,Johnson, K. H.(1991).An Analysis of Anomaly Sensitivity to Market Conditions Using Linear and Nonlinear Techniques.Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics,30(1),3-27.
  45. Kumar, A.,Lee, C. M. C.(2006).Retail Investor Sentiment and Return Comovements.Journal of Finance,61(5),2451-2486.
  46. Kwon, C. S.,Shin, T. S.(1999).Cointegration and Causality between Macroeconomic Variables and Stock Market Returns.Global Finance Journal,10(1),71-81.
  47. Lastrapes, W. D.(1998).International Evidence on Equity Prices, Interest Rates and Money.Journal of International Money and Finance,17(3),377-406.
  48. Li, Y.,Yang, L.(2013).Prospect Theory, the Disposition Effect, and Asset Prices.Journal of Financial Economics,107(3),715-739.
  49. McGuinness, P. B.(2005).A Re-Examination of the Holiday Effect in Stock Returns: The Case of Hong Kong.Applied Financial Economics,15(16),1107-1123.
  50. McGuinness, P. B.,Harris, D. F.(2011).Comparison of the 'Turn-of-the-month' and Lunar New Year Return Effects in Three Chinese markets: Hong Kong, Shanghai and Shenzhen.Applied Financial Economics,21(13),917-929.
  51. Mougoue, M.(1996).Seasonalities in the Taiwanese Stock Market.American Business Review,14(2),73-79.
  52. Ng, L.,Wang, Q.(2004).Institutional Trading and the Turn-of-the-year Effect.Journal of Financial Economics,74(2),343-366.
  53. Odean, T.(1998).Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses?.Journal of Finance,53(5),1775-1798.
  54. Reinganum, M. R.(1983).The Anomalous Stock Market Behavior of Small Firms in January: Empirical Tests for Tax-loss-selling Effects.Journal of Financial Economics,12(1),89-104.
  55. Rogalski, R. J.,Tinic, S. M.(1986).The January Size Effect: Anomaly or Risk Mismeasurement?.Financial Analysts Journal,42(6),63-70.
  56. Roll, R.(1983).Vas ist Das? The Turn-of-the-year Effect and the Return Premia of Small Firms.Journal of Portfolio Management,9(2),18-28.
  57. Shapira, Z.,Venezia, I.(2001).Patterns of Behavior of Professionally Managed and Independent Investors.Journal of Banking and Finance,25(8),1573-1587.
  58. Shefrin, H.,Statman, M.(1985).The Disposition to Sell Winners too Early and Ride Losers too Long: Theory and Evidence.Journal of Finance,40(3),777-790.
  59. Talpsepp, T.(2011).Reverse Disposition Effect of Foreign Investors.Journal of Behavioral Finance,12(4),183-200.
  60. Tong, W. H. S.(1992).An Analysis of the January Effect of United States, Taiwan and South Korean Stock Markets.Asia Pacific Journal of Management,9(2),189-207.
  61. Wong, P. L.,Neoh, S. K.,Lee, H. K.,Thong, S. T.(1990).Seasonality in the Malaysian Stock Market.Asia Pacific Journal of Management,7(2),43-62.
  62. Wu, Y.(2001).Exchange Rates, Stock Prices, and Money Markets: Evidence from Singapore.Journal of Asian Economics,12(3),445-458.
  63. Yen, G.,Lee, C. F.,Chen, C. L.,Lin, W. C.(2001).On the Chinese Lunar New Year Effect in Six Asian Stock Markets: An Empirical Analysis (1991-2000).Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets and Policies,4(1),436-478.
  64. Yen, G.,Shyy, G.(1993).Chinese New Year Effect in Asian Stock Markets.NTU Management Review,4(1),417-436.
print cancel