题名

整合多準則決策與資源基礎理論建構行動通訊基地台資源規劃模式之研究

并列篇名

Hybridizing MCDM with Resource-based View toward Resource Planning in Mobile Telecommunications

DOI

10.6160/SYSMR.201806_26(2).0004

作者

周瑋千(Wei-Chien Chou)；李昇暾(Sheng-Tun Li)

关键词

價值鏈 ； 資源基礎觀點 ； 模糊多準則決策 ； 行動通訊基地台 ； Value Chain ； Resource-based View ； Fuzzy Multiple Criteria Decision Making ； Mobile Telecommunications

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

26卷2期（2018 / 06 / 01）

页次

239 - 275

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

隨著行動通訊及裝置設備的普及，全球行動數據流量爆炸性的成長，帶動行動基礎建設與穩定傳輸品質的需求。對電信營運商而言，基地台是維持高速上網與通訊品質的基礎，有效的資源規劃才能維繫企業的永續經營，進而創造最大利潤與競爭力。本研究提出行動通訊資源規劃之模式，藉由價值鏈分析基礎建設服務與支援活動，以資源基礎觀點之特性，萃取決策者的內隱知識，找出重要影響因素，並以模糊多準則決策方法量化評估，將結果分類，由組織的支援活動探討各類基地台資源規劃，以達資源互補及綜效的發揮。本研究為說明模式之可用性，以某大電信公司基地台作為實例驗證對象，根據結果探討行動通訊基地台資源規劃之模式，輔助決策者訂定各類基地台不同的資源規劃標準。
英文摘要

Due to the rapid developments in the mobile communications, increased penetration rates and essential characteristics of the mobile devices, which enable mobile telecoms industry to carry the effective planning for the resources allocation of the mobile telecommunications. This study aims to shed light on the driving resource planning affecting 4G system of base stations, focus on the sustainable competitive advantage under a turbulent and uncertain environment. Therefore, this study develops a resource-based view planning model using a multi-criteria operational resource evaluation, in which the fuzzy MCDM are adopted to identify the competitive advantage of available resources based on value chain analysis and resource-based theory. A case study is conducted to illustrate how the model can be applied as a tool for exploring the potential competitiveness of the resource planning of the base stations in the mobile telecoms industry. The proposed model may help the mobile telecoms organizations to more effectively manage their base station resources, and thus obtain competitive advantages..
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 洪世章、譚丹琪、廖曉青(2007)。企業成長、策略選擇與策略改變。中山管理評論，15(1)，11-35。
    連結：
  2. 楊宜興、陳虹天(2013)。高值化創新、自有品牌與經營績效：臺灣電子產業之實證研究。中山管理評論，21(4)，853-880。
    連結：
  3. Aaker, D. A.(1989).Managing Assets and Skills: The Key to a Sustainable Competitive Advantage.California Management Review,31(2),91-106.
  4. Ahmed, I.,Mohamed, A.(2014).Hybrid Radio Resource Allocation and Interference Coordination for Type 1a-Relayed Long Term Evolution Uplink.IET Communications,8(11),1928-1937.
  5. Ahmed, Z. R.,Subramaniam, S. K.,Zukarnain, Z. A.,Othman, M.(2014).Best Minimum Summation Scheduler for Long Term Evolution.Wireless Personal Communications,77(3),2271-2289.
  6. Amiri, M. P.(2010).Project Selection for Oil-Fields Development by Using the AHP and Fuzzy TOPSIS Methods.Expert Systems with Applications,37(9),6218-6224.
  7. Andersén, J.(2011).Strategic Resources and Firm Performance.Management Decision,49(1),87-98.
  8. Arend, R. J.,Lévesque, M.(2010).Is the Resource-Based View a Practical Organizational Theory?.Organization Science,21(4),913-930.
  9. Banaitiene, N.,Banaitis, A.,Kaklauskas, A.,Zavadskas, E. K.(2008).Evaluating the Life Cycle of a Building: A Multivariant and Multiple Criteria Approach.Omega,36(3),429-441.
  10. Barnes, S. J.(2001).Big in Japan-i-mode and the Mobile Internet.Journal of Information Technology Theory and Application,3(4),27-32.
  11. Barnes, S. J.(2002).The Mobile Commerce Value Chain: Analysis and Future Development.International Journal of Information Management,22(2),91-108.
  12. Barney, J. B.(1991).Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
  13. Barney, J. B.(2002).Gaining and Sustaining Competitive Advantage.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  14. Barua, A.,Mudunuri, L. S.,Kosheleva, O.(2014).Why Trapezoidal And Triangular Membership Functions Work So Well: Towards A Theoretical Eexplanation.Journal of Uncertain Systems,8(3),164-168.
  15. Beard, J. W.,Sumner, M.(2004).Seeking Strategic Advantage in the Post-Net Era: Viewing ERP Systems from the Resource-Based Perspective.The Journal of Strategic Information Systems,13(2),129-150.
  16. Beg, I.,Rashid, T.(2013).TOPSIS for Hesitant Fuzzy Linguistic Term Sets.International Journal of Intelligent Systems,28(12),1162-1171.
  17. Boran, F. E.,Genç, S.,Kurt, M.,Akay, D.(2009).A Multi-Criteria Intuitionistic Fuzzy Group Decision Making for Supplier Selection with TOPSIS Method.Expert Systems with Applications,36(8),11363-11368.
  18. Buellingen, F.,Woerter, M.(2004).Development Perspectives, Firm Strategies and Applications in Mobile Commerce.Journal of Business Research,57(12),1402-1408.
  19. Büyüközkan, G.,Çifçi, G.(2012).A Combined Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy TOPSIS Based Strategic Analysis of Electronic Service Quality in Healthcare Industry.Expert Systems with Applications,39(3),2341-2354.
  20. Carmody, P.(2013).A Knowledge Economy or an Information Society in Africa? Thintegration and the Mobile Phone Revolution.Information Technology for Development,19(1),24-39.
  21. Chamodrakas, I.,Martakos, D.(2011).A Utility-based Fuzzy TOPSIS Method for Energy Efficient Network Selection in Heterogeneous Wireless Networks.Applied Soft Computing,12(7),1929-1938.
  22. Chan, L. K.,Wu, M. L.(2005).A Systematic Approach to Quality Function Deployment with a Full Illustrative Example.Omega,33(2),119-139.
  23. Chen, C. T.(2000).Extensions of the TOPSIS for Group Decision-Making under Fuzzy Environment.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,114(1),1-9.
  24. Chen, P. T.,Cheng, J. Z.(2010).Unlocking the Promise of Mobile Value-Added Services by Applying New Collaborative Business Models.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,77(4),678-693.
  25. Chen, S. M.,Lee, L. W.(2010).Fuzzy Multiple Attributes Group Decision-Making Based on the Interval Type-2 TOPSIS Method.Expert Systems with Applications,37(4),2790-2798.
  26. Chen, Y.,Kilgour, M. D.,Hipel, K. W.(2008).A Case-based Distance Method for Screening in Multiple Criteria Decision Aid.Omega,36(3),373-383.
  27. Chu, T. C.,Lin, Y. C.(2009).An Interval Arithmetic Based Fuzzy TOPSIS Model.Expert Systems with Applications,36(8),10870-10876.
  28. Cricelli, L.,Grimaldi, M.,Levialdi, N.(2011).The Competition among Mobile Network Operators in the Telecommunication Supply Chain.International Journal of Production Economics,131(1),22-29.
  29. Dymova, L.,Sevastjanov, P.,Tikhonenko, A.(2013).An Approach to Generalization of Fuzzy TOPSIS Method.Information Sciences,238(20),149-162.
  30. Emma, M.,Kieran, S.,Vida, M.(2013).An Assessment of Sustainable Housing Affordability Using a Multiple Criteria Decision Making Method.Omega,41(2),270-279.
  31. Feng, B.,Lai, F.(2014).Multi-attribute Group Decision Making with Aspirations: A Case Study.Omega,44,136-147.
  32. Ghasemi-Falavarjani, S.,Nematbakhsh, M.,Shahgholi Ghahfarokhi, B.(2015).Context-aware Multi-objective Resource Allocation in Mobile Cloud.Computers and Electrical Engineering,44,218-240.
  33. Gonzalez, D.,Garcia-Lozano, M.,Ruiz, S.,Lee, D. S.(2014).A Metaheuristic-based Downlink Power Allocation for LTE/LTE-A Cellular Deployments.Wireless Networks,20(6),1369-1386.
  34. Gozalvez, J.(2014).South Korea Launches LTE-Advanced.Vehicular Technology Magazine, IEEE,9(1),10-27.
  35. Grant, R. M.(1991).The Resource Based Theory of Competitive Advantage: Implication for Strategy Formulation.California Management Review,33(3),114-135.
  36. Guo, C.(2007).Is Sustainable Competitive Advantage an Achievable Holy Grail: The Relevance Gap between Academia and Business.Journal of Business and Management,13(2),115-26.
  37. Guo, J.,Bouwman, H.(2016).An Analytical Framework for an M-payment Ecosystem: A Merchants' Perspective.Telecommunications Policy,40(2-3),147-167.
  38. Han, J.,Kamber, M.,Pei, J.(2011).Data Mining: Concepts and Techniques.Morgan Kaufmann.
  39. Hwang, C. L.,Yoon, K.(1981).Multiple Attributes Decision Making Methods and Applications.Berlin, Heidelberg:Springer.
  40. Isiklar, G.,Buyukozkan, G.(2007).Using a Multi-Criteria Decision Making Approach to Evaluate Mobile Phone Alternatives.Computer Standards and Interfaces,29(2),265-274.
  41. Ittner, C. D.,Larcker, D. F.(2003).Coming up Short on Nonfinancial Performance Measurement.Harvard Business Review,81(11),88-95.
  42. Jahanshahloo, G. R.,Lotfi, F. H.,Izadikhah, M.(2006).Extension of the TOPSIS Method for Decision-Making Problems with Fuzzy Data.Applied Mathematics and Computation,181(2),1544-1551.
  43. Javidan, M.(1998).Core Competence: What Does it Mean in Practice?.Long Range Planning,31(1),60-71.
  44. Kannan, D.,Jabbour, A. B. L. S.,Jabbour, C. J. C.(2014).Selecting Green Suppliers Based on GSCM Practices: Using Fuzzy TOPSIS Applied to a Brazilian Electronics Company.European Journal of Operational Research,233(2),432-447.
  45. Kelemenis, A.,Askounis, D.(2010).A New TOPSIS-Based Multi Criteria Approach to Personnel Selection.Expert Systems with Applications,37(7),4999-5008.
  46. Kelemenis, A.,Ergazakis, K.,Askounis, D.(2011).Support Managers' Selection Using an Extension of Fuzzy TOPSIS.Expert Systems with Applications,38(3),2774-2782.
  47. Khalili-Damghani, K.,Sadi-Nezhad, S.,Tavana, M.(2013).Solving Multi-Period Project Selection Problems with Fuzzy Goal Programming Based on TOPSIS and a Fuzzy Preference Relation.Information Sciences,252,42-61.
  48. Khorshidi, R.,Hassani, A.,Honarbakhsh Rauof, A.,Emamy, M.(2013).Selection of an Optimal Refinement Condition to Achieve Maximum Tensile Properties of Al-15%Mg2Si Composite Based on TOPSIS Method.Materials and Design,46,442-450.
  49. Klein, A.,Jakopin, N.(2014).Consumers' Willingness-to-pay for Mobile Telecommunication Service Bundles.Telematics and Informatics,31(3),410-421.
  50. Knott, Paul J.(2015).Does VRIO Help Managers Evaluate a Firm's Resources?.Management Decision,53(8),1806-1822.
  51. Kraaijenbrink, J.,Spender, J. C.,Groen, A. J.(2010).The Resource-Based View: A Review and Assessment of Its Critiques.Journal of Management,36(1),349-72.
  52. Kumar, A.,Jain, V.,Kumar, S.(2014).A Comprehensive Environment Friendly Approach For Supplier Selection.Omega,42(1),109-123.
  53. Kuo, Y. F.,Chen, P. C.(2006).Selection of Mobile Value-Added Services for System Operators Using Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation.Expert Systems with Applications,30(4),612-620.
  54. Kuo, Y. F.,Yu, C. W.(2006).3G Telecommunication Operators' Challenges and Roles: A Perspective of Mobile Commerce Value Chain.Technovation,26(12),1347-1356.
  55. Lee, D. H.,Park, D.(1997).An Efficient Algorithm for Fuzzy Weighted Average.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,87(1),39-45.
  56. Lee, J.,Kim, J. C.,Lim, J.(2016).Globalization and Divergent Paths of Industrial Development: Mobile Phone Manufacturing in China, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan.Journal of Contemporary Asia,46(2),222-246.
  57. Li, D. F.(2007).Compromise Ratio Method for Fuzzy Multi-Attribute Group Decision Making.Applied Soft Computing,7(3),807-817.
  58. Li, D. F.(2007).A Fuzzy Closeness Approach to Fuzzy Multi-Attribute Decision Making.Fuzzy Optimization and Decision Making,6(3),237-254.
  59. Li, F.,Whalley(2002).Deconstruction of the Telecommunications Industry: From Value Chains to Value Networks.Telecommunications Policy,26(9),451-472.
  60. Li, H.,Adeli, H.,Sun, J.,Han, J. G.(2011).Hybridizing Principles of TOPSIS with Case-based. Reasoning for Business Failure Prediction.Computers & Operations Research,38(2),409-419.
  61. Li, S. T.,Chou, W. C.(2014).Power Planning in ICT Infrastructure: An Approach of Multi-criteria Operational Performance Evaluation.Omega,49,134-148.
  62. Liao, C. N.(2013).An Evaluation Model using Fuzzy TOPSIS and Goal Programming for TOM Consultant Selection.Journal of Testing and Evaluation,41(1),122-130.
  63. Lin, C.,Tsai, H. L.,Wu, Y. J.,Kiang, M.(2012).A Fuzzy Quantitative VRIO-Based Framework for Evaluating Organizational Activities.Management Decision,50(8),1396-1411.
  64. Luo, S.,Dong, M.,Ota, K.,Wu, J.,Li, J.(2015).A Security Assessment Mechanism for Software-Defined Networking-Based Mobile Networks.Sensors,15(12),31843-31858.
  65. Mahdavi, I.,Heidarzade, A.,Sadeghpour-Gildeh, B.,Mahdavi-Amiri, N.(2009).A General Fuzzy TOPSIS Model in Multiple Criteria Decision Making.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,45(3),406-420.
  66. Mahdavi, I.,Mahdavi-Amiri, N.,Heidarzade, A.,Nourifar, R.(2008).Designing a Model of Fuzzy TOPSIS in Multiple Criteria Decision Making.Applied Mathematics and Computation,206(2),607-617.
  67. Malathy, E. M.,Vijayalakshmi, M.(2015).Knapsack - TOPSIS Technique for Vertical Handover in a Heterogeneous Wireless Network.Plos One,10(8),1-16.
  68. Marchant, T.(2007).A Measurement-Theoretic Axiomatization of Trapezoidal Membership Functions.IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems,15(2),238-242.
  69. Mayor, M. G. -O.,Davó, N. B.(2016).Competitive Advantages of the Mobile Phone Operators in the Asia Pacific Region: Analysis from the Strategic Groups Approach.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management,28(5),541-554.
  70. Meng, Y.,Li, J. D.,Li, H. Y.(2014).Efficient Resource Allocation Scheme for Multi-Service Based on Interference Mitigation in LTE-Advanced Networks.Science China Information Sciences,57(8),1-11.
  71. Newbert, S. L.(2007).Empirical Research on the Resource-Based View of the Firm: An Assessment and Suggestions for Future Research.Strategic Management Journal,28(2),121-46.
  72. Olla, P.,Patel, N. V.(2002).A Value Chain Model for Mobile Data Service Providers.Telecommunications Policy,26(9-10),551-571.
  73. Önüt, S.,Kara, S. S.,Işik, E.(2009).Long Term Supplier Selection Using A Combined Fuzzy MCDM Approach: A Case Study for A Telecommunication Company.Expert Systems with Applications,36(2),3887-3895.
  74. Opricovic, S.,Tzeng, G. H.(2004).Compromise Solution by MCDM Methods: A Comparative Analysis of VIKOR and TOPSIS.European Journal of Operational Research,156(2),445-455.
  75. Pagani, M.,Fine, C. H.(2008).Value Network Dynamics in 3G-4G Wireless Communications: A Systems Thinking Approach to Strategic Value Assessment.Journal of Business Research,61(11),1102-1112.
  76. Park, E.,Del Pobil, A. P.(2013).Modeling the User Acceptance of Long-Term Evolution (LTE) Services.Annals of Telecommunications,68(5),307-315.
  77. Parkan, C.,Wu, M. U.(1999).Measurement of the Performance of an Investment Bank Using the Operational Competitiveness Rating Procedure.Omega,27(2),201-217.
  78. Peppard, J.,Rylander, A.(2006).From Value Chain to Value Network: Lessons for Mobile Operators.European Management Journal,24(2),128-141.
  79. Peteraf, M. A.(1993).The Cornerstones of Competitive Advantage: A Resource-Based View.Strategic Management Journal,14(3),179-191.
  80. Picoto, W. N.,Bélanger, F.,Palma-dos-Reis, A.(2014).An Organizational Perspective on M-Business: Usage Factors and Value Determination.European Journal of Information Systems,23(5),571-592.
  81. Porter, M. E.(1985).Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance.New York:The Free Press.
  82. Prahalad, C. K.,Hamel, G.(1990).The Core Competence of the Corporation.Harvard Business Review,68(3),79-91.
  83. Reed, R.,DeFillippi, R. J.(1990).Causal Ambiguity, Barriers to Imitation, and Sustainable Competitive Advantage.The Academy of Management Review,15(1),88-102.
  84. Roghanian, E.,Rahimi, J.,Ansari, A.(2010).Comparison of First Aggregation and Last Aggregation in Fuzzy Group TOPSIS.Applied Mathematical Modelling,34(12),3754-3766.
  85. Rouhani, S.,Ghazanfari, M.,Jafari, M.(2012).Evaluation Model of Business Intelligence for Enterprise Systems Using Fuzzy TOPSIS.Expert Systems with Applications,39(3),3764-3771.
  86. Sabat, H. K.(2002).The Evolving Mobile Wireless Value Chain and Market Structure.Telecommunications Policy,26(9-10),505-535.
  87. Sadi-Nezhad, S.,Damghani, K. K.(2010).Application of a Fuzzy TOPSIS Method Base on Modified Preference Ratio and Fuzzy Distance Measurement in Assessment of Traffic Police Centers Performance.Applied Soft Computing,10(4),1028-1039.
  88. Sevastjanov, P.,Dymova, L.(2009).Stock Screening with Use of Multiple Criteria Decision Making and Optimization.Omega,37(3),659-671.
  89. Sharma, S.,Balan, S.(2013).An Integrative Supplier Selection Model Using Taguchi Loss Function, TOPSIS and Multi Criteria Goal Programming.Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing,24(6),1123-1130.
  90. Shih, H. S.,Wang, C. H.,Lee, E. S.(2004).A Multiattribute GDSS for Aiding Problem-Solving.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,39(11-12),1397-1412.
  91. Søilen, K. S.,Kovacevic, M. A.,Jallouli. R.(2012).Key Success Factors for Ericsson Mobile Platforms Using the Value Grid Model.Journal of Business Research,65(9),1335-1345.
  92. Srivastava, P.,Frankwick, G. L.(2011).Environment, Management Attitude, and Organizational Learning in Alliances.Management Decision,49(1),156-166.
  93. Steinbock, D.(2003).Globalization of Wireless Value System: from Geographic to Strategic Advantages.Telecommunications Policy,27(3-4),207-235.
  94. Sun, C. C.,Lin, G. T. R.(2009).Using Fuzzy TOPSIS Method for Evaluating the Competitive Advantages of Shopping Websites.Expert Systems with Applications,36(9),11764-11771.
  95. Torfi, F.,Farahani, R. Z.,Rezapour, S.(2010).Fuzzy AHP To Determine The Relative Weights of Evaluation Criteria And Fuzzy TOPSIS to Rank The Alternatives.Applied Soft Computing,10(2),520-528.
  96. Tseng, F. M.,Chiu, Y. J.,Chen, J. S.(2009).Measuring Business Performance in The High-Tech Manufacturing Industry: A Case Study of Taiwan's Large-Sized TFT-LCD Panel Companie.Omega,37(3),686-697.
  97. Vahdani, B.,Meysam Mousavib, S.,Hashemib, H.,Mousakhanic, M.,Tavakkoli-Moghaddamd, R.(2013).A New Compromise Solution Method for Fuzzy Group Decision-making Problems with an Application to the Contractor Selection.Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence,26(2),779-788.
  98. Wernerfelt, B.(1984).A Resource-Based View of the Firm.Strategic Management Journal,5(2),171-180.
  99. Yang, C.,Fu, G. L.,Tzeng, G. H.(2005).Creating a Win-Win in the Telecommunications Industry: The Relationship between MVONs and MNOs in Taiwan.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,22(4),316-328.
  100. Yong, D.(2006).Plant Location Selection Based on Fuzzy TOPSIS.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,28(7),839-844.
  101. Yu, H. C.,Lee, Z. Y.,Chang, S. C.(2005).Using a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision Making Approach To Evaluate Alternative Licensing Mechanisms.Information and Management,42(4),517-531.
  102. Yurdakul, M.,Tansel, I. Y.(2009).Analysis of the Benefit Generated by Using Fuzzy Numbers in a TOPSIS Model Developed for Machine Tool Selection Problems.Journal of Materials Processing Technology,209(1),310-317.
  103. Zanakis, S. H.,Solomon, A.,Wishart, N.,Dublish, S.(1998).Multi-Attribute Decision Making: A Simulation Comparison of Select Methods.European Journal of Operational Research,107(3),507-529.
  104. Zhang, Z.,Liang, X. J.(2011).Business Ecosystem Strategies of Mobile Network Operators in the 3G Era: The Case of China Mobile.Telecommunications Policy,35(2),156-171.
  105. Zopounidis, C.(1999).Multi-criteria Decision Aid in Financial Management.European Journal of Operational Research,119,404-415.
  106. Zouggari, A.,Benyoucef, L.(2012).Simulation Based Fuzzy TOPSIS Approach for Group Multi-criteria Supplier Selection Problem.Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence,25(3),507-519.
  107. 國家通訊傳播委員會， 2015 ，「103 年行動通信基地臺站址數統計表」，http://www.ncc.gov.tw/chinese/news.aspx?site_content_sn=1237&is_history=0, accessed on May 20, 2016. (National Communications Commission, 2015, “Statistical Report of Public Land for Base Stations in 2014,” http://www.ncc.gov.tw/chinese/news.aspx?site_content_sn=1237&is_history=0, accessed on May 20, 2016.)
  108. 張心馨(2005)。建構無線通信產業發展行動上網和行動商務之價值網體系─探討日本行動市場的營運模式與策略分析。中山管理評論，13(2)，299-348。
被引用次数
  1. 葉子明,孫嘉正(2022)。運用Normalization、TOPSIS與EDAS比較供應商定期績效評核之研究。品質學報，29(2)，151-175。
  2. (2022)。從資源基礎理論探究非營利組織之社會責任活動—以財團法人聯新文教基金會為例。產業與管理論壇，24(2)，34-67。
print cancel