题名

質量融合：基於複雜科學觀點下的探索

并列篇名

The Mix of Qualitative and Quantitative Methodologies: A Research Exploration Based on Complexity Science

DOI

10.6160/SYSMR.201806_26(2).0006

作者

洪世章(Shih-Chang Hung)；曾詠青(Yung-Ching Tseng)；賴俊彥(Jiun-Yan Lai)

关键词

定量 ； 定性 ； 融合方法 ； 三角驗證 ； 複雜科學 ； Quantitative ； Qualitative ； Mixed Method ； Triangulation ； Complexity Science

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

26卷2期（2018 / 06 / 01）

页次

331 - 360

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本文強調在組織與管理的學術研究中，定量方法有它的優點，定性方法也有它的強項，兩者並非完全互斥，對於特定現象的分析與解讀，可以透過二者之綜效，發揮方法三角驗證的精神，以求得到更全面與系統性的認識。對於不同現象的存在，需要不同的理論與方法解釋的典範思維下，我們指出當實體具有秩序與混沌的二重性時，是最適合採用質量融合的研究方法。據此，本文立基於複雜科學的觀點，發展出一個質量融合的研究大綱，包括：啟動研究、蒐集量化資料、選取適合的量化模型、以定性觀點詮釋複雜系統，以及結束研究等五個步驟。
英文摘要

Both quantitative and qualitative methods are important to the analysis of organization and management, and they are certainly not opposed to each other. Increasingly, researchers have called for more attention to the design of method triangulation that has the potential to enhance the reliability and validity of research findings. Given that ontology will determine epistemology, we argue that when the problems or realities demonstrate the characteristics of order-chaos dualism, a mixed method approach is most applicable. Accordingly, in this paper we attempt to develop a program for conducting such research. The program includes five steps: initiating, collecting quantitative data, determining a proper mathematical model, interpreting the complexity qualitatively, and ending the program.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Alvesson, M.,Sköldberg, K.(2000).Reflexive Methodology: New Vitas for Qualitative Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  2. Amaratunga, D.,Baldry, D.,Sarshar, M.,Newton, R.(2002).Quantitative and Qualitative Research in the Built Environment: Application of 'Mixed' Research Approach.Work Study,51(1),17-31.
  3. Anderson, P.,Tushman, M. L.(1990).Technological Discontinuities and Dominant Designs: A Cyclical Model of Technological Change.Administrative Science Quarterly,35(4),604-633.
  4. Ang, S.,Bamberger, P.(2016).The Quantitative Discovery: What is It and How to Get It Published.Academy of Management Discovery,2(1),1-6.
  5. Ashmos, D. P.,Ducheon, D.,McDaniel, R. R.,Huonker, J. W.(2002).What a Mess! Participation as a Simple Managerial Rule to 'Complexify' Organizations.Journal of Management Studies,39(2),189-206.
  6. Astley, W. G.,Van de Ven, A. H.(1983).Central Perspectives and Debates in Organization Theory.Administrative Science Quarterly,28(2),245-273.
  7. Audretsch, D. B.(1991).New-Firm Survival and the Technological Regime.Review of Economics and Statistics,73(3),441-450.
  8. Bacharach, S. B.(1989).Organizational Theories: Some Criteria for Evaluation.Academy of Management Review,14(4),496-515.
  9. Barley, S. R.(1986).Technology as an Occasion for Structuring: Evidence from Observations of CT Scanners and the Social Order of Radiology Departments.Administrative Science Quarterly,31(1),78-108.
  10. Barley, S. R.,Tolbert, P. S.(1997).Institutionalization and Structuration: Studying the Links between Action and Institution.Organization Studies,18(1),93-117.
  11. Battilana, J. B.,Leca, B.,Boxenbaum, E. V. A.(2009).How Actors Change Institutions: Towards a Theory of Institutional Entrepreneurship.Academy of Management Annuals,3(1),65-107.
  12. Behling, O.(1980).The Case for the Natural Science Model for Research in Organizational Behavior and Organization Theory.Academy of Management Review,5(4),483-490.
  13. Beinhocker, E. D.(1997).Strategy at the Edge of Chaos.McKinsey Quarterly,1,24-39.
  14. Berger, P. L.,Luckmann, T.(1966).The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.Garden City, NY:Anchor Books.
  15. Bitektine, A.(2008).Prospective Case Study Design: Qualitative Method for Deductive Theory Testing.Organizational Research Methods,11(1),160-180.
  16. Boes, D. C.,Salas, J. D.(1978).Nonstationarity of the Mean and the Hurst Phenomenon.Water Resources Research,14(1),135-143.
  17. Boisot, M.,Child, J.(1999).Organizations as Adaptive Systems in Complex Environments: The Case of China.Organization Science,10(3),237-252.
  18. Boisot, M.,McKelvey, B.(2010).Integrating Modernist and Postmodernist Perspectives on Organizations: A Complexity Science Bridge.Academy of Management Review,35(3),415-433.
  19. Bourdieu, P.,Wacquant, L. J. D.(1992).An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology.Cambridge, UK:Polity Press.
  20. Box, G. E. P.,Pierce, D. A.(1970).Distributions of Residual Autocorrelations in Autoregressive-Integrated Moving Average Methods.Journal of the American Statistical Association,65(332),1509-1526.
  21. Breslin, D.(2014).Calm in the Storm: Simulating the Management of Organizational Co-Evolution.Futures,57(1),62-77.
  22. Brown, S.,Eisenhardt, K. M.(1998).Competing on the Edge: Strategy as Structured Chaos.Boston, MA:Harvard Business School Press.
  23. Bryman, A.(2006).Integrating Quantitative and Qualitative Research: How is It Done?.Qualitative Research,6(1),97-113.
  24. Burrell, G.,Morgan, G.(1979).Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis: Elements of the Sociology of Corporate Life.London, UK:Heinemann.
  25. Burton, R.,Obel, B.(2011).Computational Modeling for What-Is, What-Might-Be, and What-Should-Be Studies - and Triangulation.Organization Science,22(5),1195-1202.
  26. Chalmers, A. F.(1999).What is this Thing Called Science?.Buckingham, UK:Open University Press.
  27. Cheng, Y. C.,Van de Ven, A. H.(1996).Learning the Innovation Journey: Order out of Chaos?.Organization Science,7(6),593-614.
  28. Christensen, C. M.(1997).The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail.Boston, MA:Harvard Business School Press.
  29. Cizek, G. J.(ed.)(1999).Handbook of Educational Policy.San Diego, CA:Academic Press.
  30. Clegg, S. R.(ed.),Hardy, C.(ed.),Lawrence, T. B.(ed.),Nord, W. R.(ed.)(2006).The SAGE Handbook of Organization Studies.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  31. Coffey, A.,Atkinson, P.(1996).Making Sense of Qualitative Data: Complementary Research Strategies.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  32. Cook, T. D.,Campbell, D. T.(1979).Quasi-Experimentation: Design & Analysis Issues for Field Settings.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin.
  33. Creswell, J. W.,Clark, V. L. P.(2007).Designing and Conducting Mixed Methods Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  34. Crutchfield, J. P.,Farmer, J. D.,Packard, N. H.,Shaw, R. S.(1986).Chaos.Scientific American,254(2),46-57.
  35. Daft, R. L.(1983).Learning the Craft of Organizational Research.Academy of Management Review,8(4),539-546.
  36. Davis, J. P.,Eisenhardt, K. M.,Bingham, C. B.(2009).Optimal Structure, Market Dynamism, and the Strategy of Simple Rules.Administrative Science Quarterly,54(3),413-452.
  37. deMarrais, K. B.(1998).Inside Stories: Qualitative Research Reflections.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  38. Denzin, N.(1970).The Research Act: A Theoretical Introduction to Sociological Methods.New York:McGraw Hill.
  39. Denzin, N. K.(ed.),Lincoln, Y. S.(ed.)(1994).The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  40. Denzin, N. K.(ed.),Lincoln, Y. S.(ed.)(1994).The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  41. Denzin, N. K.,Lincoln, Y. S.(1994).The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  42. Diesing, P.(1966).Objectivism vs. Subjectivism in the Social Science.Philosophy of Science,33(1/2),124-133.
  43. DiMaggio, P. J.(1995).Comments on 'What Theory is Not'.Administrative Science Quarterly,40(3),391-397.
  44. Dolan, S. L.,Garcia, S.,Auerbach, A.(2003).Understanding and Managing Chaos in Organisations.International Journal of Management,20(1),23-35.
  45. Dooley, K. J.,Van de Ven, A. H.(1999).Explaining Complex Organizational Dynamics.Organization Science,10(3),358-372.
  46. Dosi, G.(1982).Technological Paradigms and Technological Trajectories: A Suggested Interpretation of the Determinants and Directions of Technical Change.Research Policy,11(3),147-162.
  47. Dover, G.,Lawrence, T.(2010).A Gap Year for Institutional Theory: Integrating the Study of Institutional Work and Participatory Action Research.Journal of Management Inquiry,19(4),305-316.
  48. Dubinskas, F. A.(1994).On the Edge of Chaos: A Metaphor for Transformative Change.Journal of Management Inquiry,3(4),355-366.
  49. Dyer, W. G.,Wilkins, A. L.(1991).Better Stories, not Better Constructs, to Generate Better Theory: A Rejoinder to Eisenhardt.Academy of Management Review,16(3),613-619.
  50. Eamshaw, J. C.,Haughey, D.(1993).Lyapunov Exponents for Pedestrians.American Journal of Physics,61(5),401-407.
  51. Eisenhardt, K. M.(1989).Building Theories from Case Study Research.Academy of Management Review,14(4),532-550.
  52. Eisenhardt, K. M.,Graebner, M. E.(2007).Theory Building from Cases: Opportunities and Challenges.Academy of Management Journal,50(1),25-32.
  53. Evered, R.,Louis, M. R.(1981).Alternative Perspectives in the Organizational Sciences: 'Inquiry from the Inside' and 'Inquiry from the Outside'.Academy of Management Review,6(3),385-395.
  54. Fremeth, A. R.,Holburn, G. L. F.,Richter, B. K.(2016).Bridging Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Organizational Research: Applications of Synthetic Control Methodology in the U.S. Automobile Industry.Organization Science,27(2),462-482.
  55. Gadamer, H. G.(1975).Truth and Method.New York:Continuum.
  56. Garud, R.,Gehman, J.,Kumaraswamy, A.(2011).Complexity Arrangements for Sustained Innovation: Lessons from 3M Corporation.Organization Studies,32(6),737-767.
  57. Geels, F. W.(2004).From Sectoral Systems of Innovation to Socio-Technical Systems: Insights about Dynamics and Change from Sociology and Institutional Theory.Research Policy,33(6/7),897-920.
  58. Geertz, C.(1983).Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology.New York:Basic Books.
  59. Gephart, R. P.(2004).Qualitative Research and the Academy of Management Journal.Academy of Management Journal,47(4),454-462.
  60. Gephart, R. P.(2006).Ethnostatistics and Organizational Research Methodologies.Organizational Research Methods,9(4),417-431.
  61. Gephart, R. P.(1993).The Textual Approach: Risk and Blame in Disaster Sensemaking.Academy of Management Journal,36(3),1465-1514.
  62. Gerring, J.(2004).What is a Case Study and What is it Good for?.American Political Science Review,98(2),341-354.
  63. Geyer, R.(2003).Beyond the Third Way: The Science of Complexity and the Politics of Choice.British Journal of Politics and International Relations,5(2),237-257.
  64. Gibbert, M.,Ruigrok, W.,Wicki, B.(2008).What Passes as a Rigorous Case Study?.Strategic Management Journal,29(13),1465-1474.
  65. Giddens, A.(1984).The Construction of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration.Cambridge, UK:Polity Press.
  66. Gioia, D.,Pitre, E.(1990).Multiparadigm Perspectives on Theory Building.Academy of Management Review,15(4),584-602.
  67. Gleick, J.(1987).Chaos: Making a New Science.New York:Viking Books.
  68. Golden-Biddle, K.,Locke, K.(1993).Appealing Work: An Investigation of How Ethnographic Texts Convince.Organization Science,4(4),595-616.
  69. Granger, C. W. J.(1981).Some Properties of Time Series Data and Their Use in Econometric Model Specification.Journal of Econometrics,16(1),121-130.
  70. Grassberger, P.,Procaccia, I.(1983).Measuring the Strangeness of Strange Attractor.Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena,9(1/2),189-208.
  71. Gregersen, H.,Sailer, I.(1993).Chaos Theory and its Implications for Social Science Research.Human Relations,46(7),777-802.
  72. Habermas, J.(1972).Knowledge and Human Interests: A General Perspective.London, UK:Heinermann.
  73. Hargadon, A. B.,Douglas, Y.(2001).When Innovations Meet Institutions: Edison and the Design of the Electric Light.Administrative Science Quarterly,46(3),476-501.
  74. Hassard, J.(1991).Multiple Paradigms and Organizational Analysis: A Case Study.Organization Studies,12(2),275-299.
  75. Hassard, J.,Cox, J. W.(2013).Can Sociological Paradigms Still Inform Organizational Analysis? A Paradigm Model for Post-Paradigm Times.Organization Studies,34(11),1701-1728.
  76. Hung, S. C.(2004).Explaining the Process of Innovation: The Dynamic Reconciliation of Action and Structure.Human Relation,57(11),1479-1497.
  77. Hung, S. C.,Tu, M. F.(2014).Is Small Actually Big? The Chaos of Technological Change.Research Policy,43(7),1227-1238.
  78. Jackson, N.,Carter, P.(1991).In Defence of Paradigm Incommensurability.Organization Studies,12(1),109-127.
  79. Jayanthi, S.,Sinha, K. K.(1998).Innovation Implementation in High Technology Manufacturing: A Chaos-Theoretic Empirical Analysis.Journal of Operations Management,16(4),471-494.
  80. Jick, T. D.(1979).Mixing Qualitative and Quantitative Methods: Triangulation in Action.Administrative Science Quarterly,24(4),602-611.
  81. Johns, G.(2006).The Essential Impact of Context on Organizational Behavior.Academy of Management Review,31(2),386-408.
  82. Johnson, R. B.,Onwuegbuzie, A. J.,Turner, L. A.(2007).Toward a Definition of Mixed Methods Research.Journal of Mixed Methods Research,1(2),112-133.
  83. Kaplan, B.,Duchon, D.(1988).Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Information Systems Research: A Case Study.MIS Quarterly,12(4),571-586.
  84. Kauffman, S.(1993).The Origins of Order: Self Organization and Selection in Evolution.New York:Oxford University Press.
  85. Kauffman, S. A.(1995).Technology and Evolution: Escaping the Red Queen Effect.McKinsey Quarterly,1,119-129.
  86. Kauffman, S. A.,Johnsen, S.(1991).Coevolution to the Edge of Chaos: Coupled Fitness Landscapes, Poised States, and Coevolutionary Avalanches.Journal of Theoretical Biology,149(4),467-505.
  87. Ketterer, J. J.(2006).Chaos and Complexity: The Uses of the Foremost Metaphor of the New Millennium.International Management Review,2(3),34-55.
  88. Koput, K. W.(1997).A Chaotic Model of Innovative Search: Some Answers, Many Questions.Organization Science,8(5),528-542.
  89. Kuhn, T. S.(1962).The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Chicago, IL:The University of Chicago Press.
  90. Langley, A.(1999).Strategies for Theorizing from Process Data.Academy of Management Review,24(4),691-710.
  91. Larsson, R.(1993).Case Study Methodology: Quantitative Analysis of Patterns Across Case Studies.Academy of Management Journal,36(6),1515-1546.
  92. Lassack, M. R.(1997).Of Chaos and Complexity: Managerial Insights from a New Science.Management Decision,35(3),205-218.
  93. Lee, H. L.,Padmanabhan, V.,Whang, S.(1997).Information Distortion in a Supply Chain: The Bullwhip Effect.Management Science,43(4),546-558.
  94. Leonard-Barton, D.(1990).A Dual Methodology for Case Studies: Synergistic Use of a Longitudinal Single Site with Replicated Multiple Sites.Organization Science,1(3),248-266.
  95. Levy, D.(1994).Chaos Theory and Strategy: Theory, Application, and Managerial Implications.Strategic Management Journal,15(2),167-178.
  96. Lewis, M. W.,Grimes, A. J.(1999).Metatriangulation: Building Theory from Multiple Paradigms.Academy of Management Review,24(4),672-690.
  97. Li, T. Y.,Yorke, J. A.(1975).Period Three Implies Chaos.The American Mathematical Monthly,82(10),985-992.
  98. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic Inquiry.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
  99. Lorenz, E.(1972).Lorenz, E., 1972, “Predictability: Does the Flap of a Butterfly's Wings in Brazil Set Off a Tornado in Texas,” American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1st, Washington, DC..
  100. Lorenz, E.(1963).Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow.Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences,20(2),130-141.
  101. Luthans, F.,Davis, T. R. V.(1982).An Idiographic Approach to Organizational Behavior Research: The Use of Single Case Experimental Designs and Direct Measures.Academy of Management Review,7(3),380-391.
  102. Malerba, F.,Orsenigo, L.(1993).Technological Regimes and Firm Behavior.Industrial and Corporate Change,2(1),45-71.
  103. March, J. G.(1991).Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning.Organization Science,2(1),71-87.
  104. Masterman, M.(1970).The Nature of a Paradigm.Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge: Volume 4: Proceedings of the International Colloquium in the Philosophy of Science, London, 1965,Cambridge, UK:
  105. Mathews, K. M.,White, M. C.,Long, R. G.(1999).Why Study the Complexity Sciences in the Social Sciences?.Human Relations,52(4),439-462.
  106. Mesa, O. J.,Poveda, G.(1993).The Hurst Effect: The Scale of Fluctuation Approach.Water Resources Research,29(12),3995-4002.
  107. Miles, M. B.(1979).Qualitative Data as an Attractive Nuisance: The Problem of Analysis.Administrative Science Quarterly,24(4),590-601.
  108. Mintzberg, H.(1979).An Emerging Strategy of 'Direct' Research.Administrative Science Quarterly,24(4),590-589.
  109. Modell, S.(2010).Bridging the Paradigm Divide in Management Accounting Research: The Role of Mixed Methods Approaches.Management Accounting Research,21(2),124-129.
  110. Monge, P. R.(1990).Theoretical and Analytical Issues in Studying Organizational Processes.Organization Science,1(4),406-430.
  111. Morçöl, G.(2001).What is Complexity Science? Postmodernist or Postpositivist?.Emergence,3(1),104-119.
  112. Morçöl, G.(2006).A New Systems Thinking: Implications of the Sciences of Complexity for Public and Administration.Public Administration Quarterly,29(3-4),297-320.
  113. Morel, B.,Ramanujam, R.(1999).Through the Looking Glass of Complexity: The Dynamics of Organizations as Adaptive and Evolving Systems.Organization Science,10(3),278-293.
  114. Morgan, G.,Smircich, L.(1980).The Case for Qualitative Research.Acamey of Management Review,5(4),491-500.
  115. Morris, M. W.,Leung, K.,Ames, D.,Lickel, B.(1999).Views from Inside and Outside: Integrating Emic and Etic Insights about Culture and Justice Judgment.Academy of Management Review,24(4),781-796.
  116. Nelson, R. R.,Winter, S. G.(1982).An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change.Cambridge, MA:The Belknap Press.
  117. Noor, K. B. M.(2008).Case Study: A Strategic Research Methodology.American Journal of Applied Sciences,5(11),1602-1604.
  118. Pascale, R. T.(1999).Surfing the Edge of Chaos.Sloan Management Review,40(3),83-94.
  119. Pettigrew, A.(1985).The Awakening Giant: Continuity and Change in Imperial Chemical Industries.Oxford, UK:Blackwell.
  120. Pettigrew, A. M.,Woodman, R. W.,Cameron, K. S.(2001).Studying Organizational Change and Development: Challenges for Future Research.Academy of Management Review,44(4),697-713.
  121. Pike, K. L.(1967).Language in Relation to a Unified Theory of the Structure of Human Behavior.The Hague, Netherlands:Mouton.
  122. Plowman, D. A.,Baker, L. T.,Beck, T. E.,Kulkarni, M.,Solansky, S. T.,Travis, D. V.(2007).Radical Change Accidentally: The Emergence and Amplification of Small Change.Academy of Management Journal,50(3),515-543.
  123. Popper, K.(1972).Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach.Oxford, UK:Clarendon Press.
  124. Popper, K.(1959).The Logic of Scientific Discovery.London, UK:Hutchinson.
  125. Radzicki, M. J.(1990).Institutional Dynamics, Deterministic Chaos, and Self-Organizing Systems.Journal of Economic Issues,24(1),57-102.
  126. Ragin, C. C.,Becker, H. S.(1992).What is a Case? Exploring the Foundations of Social Inquiry.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  127. Rao, H.(1994).The Social Construction of Reputation: Certification Contests, Legitimation, and the Survival of Organizations in the American Automobile Industry: 1895-1912.Strategic Management Journal,15(S1),29-44.
  128. Ritzer, G.(1975).Sociology: A Multiple Paradigm Science.The American Sociologist,10(3),156-167.
  129. Sale, J. E.,Lohfeld, L. H.,Brazil, K.(2002).Revisiting the Quantitative-Qualitative Debate: Implications for Mixed-Methods Research.Quality & Quantity,36(1),43-53.
  130. Scheier, C.,Tschacher, W.(1996).Appropriate Algorithms for Nonlinear Time Series Analysis in Psychology.Nonlinear Dynamics in Human Behavior,River Edge, NJ:
  131. Schindehutte, M.,Morris, M. H.(2009).Advancing Strategic Entrepreneurship Research: The Role of Complexity Science in Shifting the Paradigm.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,33(1),241-276.
  132. Shah, S. K.,Corley, K. G.(2006).Building Better Theory by Bridging the Quantitative-Qualitative Divide.Journal of Management Studies,43(8),1821-1835.
  133. Shaw, I.(ed.),Briar-Lawson, K.(ed.),Orme, J.(ed.),Ruckdeschel, R.(ed.)(2010).The SAGE Handbook of Social Work Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  134. Siggelkow, N.(2007).Persuasion with Case Studies.Academy of Management Journal,50(1),20-24.
  135. Smith, J. K.,Heshusius, L.(1986).Closing Down the Conversation: The End of the Quantitative-Qualitative Debate among Educational Inquirers.Educational Researcher,15(1),4-12.
  136. Spradley, J. P.(1980).Participant Observation.New York:Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
  137. Strauss, A.,Corbin, J. M.(1990).Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  138. Sutton, R. I.,Staw, B. M.(1995).What Theory is Not.Administrative Science Quarterly,40(3),371-384.
  139. Tashakkori, A.,Creswell, J. W.(2007).The New Era of Mixed Methods.Journal of Mixed Methods Research,1(1),3-7.
  140. Tashakkori, A.,Teddlie, C. B.(1998).Mixed Methodology: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches.London, UK:Sage.
  141. Teece, D. J.(1986).Profiting from Technological Innovation: Implications for Integration, Collaboration, Licensing and Public Policy.Research Policy,15(6),285-305.
  142. Thiétart, R. A.,Forgues, B.(1997).Action, Structure and Chaos.Organization Studies,18(1),119-143.
  143. Trochim, W. M. K.(1989).Outcome Pattern Matching and Program Theory.Evaluation and Program Planning,12(4),355-366.
  144. Utterback, J. M.,Abernathy, W. J.(1975).A Dynamic Model of Process and Product Innovation.Omega,3(6),639-656.
  145. Van de Ven, A. H.(1986).Central Problems in the Management of Innovation.Management Science,32(5),590-607.
  146. Van Maanen, J.(ed.)(1998).Qualitative Studies of Organizations.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  147. van Staveren, I.(1999).Chaos Theory and Institutional Economics: Metaphor or Model?.Journal of Economic Issues,33(1),141.
  148. Varho, V.,Tapio, P.(2013).Combining the Qualitative and Quantitative with the Q2 Scenario Technique: The Case of Transport and Climate.Technological Forecasting & Social Change,80(4),611-630.
  149. Venkatesh, V.,Brown, S. A.,Bala, H.(2013).Bridging the Qualitative-Quantitative Divide: Guidelines for Conducting Mixed Methods Research in Information Systems.MIS Quarterly,37(1),21-54.
  150. Vicenzi, R.,Adkins, G.(2000).A Tool for Assessing Organizational Vitality in an Era of Complexity.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,64(1),101-113.
  151. Waldrop, M. M.(1993).Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos.New York:Simon & Schuster.
  152. Whittington, R.(1988).Environmental Structure and Theories of Strategic Choice.Journal of Management Studies,25(6),521-536.
  153. Wolf, A.,Swift, J. B.,Swinney, H. L.,Vastano, J. A.(1985).Determining Lyapunov Exponents from a Time Series.Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena,16(3),285-317.
  154. Yin, R. K.(1984).Case Study Research: Design and Methods.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
print cancel