题名

制度工作可行嗎？去制度化前緣的能動性解析

并列篇名

Are Institutional Works Workable? The Anatomy of Agency in the Context of Pre-deinstitutionalization

DOI

10.6160/SYSMR.201903_27(1).0003

作者

涂敏芬(Min-Fen Tu)

关键词

能動性 ； 制度化歷程 ； 制度工作 ； 田野調查 ； 迪化年貨大街 ； Agency ； Institutionalization ； Institutional Work ； Field Study ； Dihua Chinese New Year Bazaar

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

27卷1期（2019 / 03 / 01）

页次

101 - 138

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

「成功」的結果經常是以激勵人心的方式展現在制度改變中，但「沒有成功」的結果或許是更普遍的存在。然而，研究者卻經常忽略能動性展演結果可能是「未竟改革、未盡改變」的遺憾。為解開遺憾背後的模糊起因，本研究援引制度化歷程與制度工作視角，進行結構與行動之間的對話。並以貼附「夜市化」標籤的迪化年貨大街為研究對象，透過參與觀察和歷史民族誌的田野工作，蒐集文本資料進行分析。本研究發現，能動性機制中產生能動性損失，乃是源自於行動者、制度工作與場域脈絡這三要素發生內部解離與偏移。而能動性損失致使無法蓄積足夠的改變動量，徒留一個老病制度停泊在去制度化歷程的前緣。由此，點出理論與實務意涵。
英文摘要

The 'successful' result is inspirationally presented in institutional change; however, 'unsuccessful' outcomes are perhaps more prevalent. Yet research has overlooked why and how the regret of 'unfinished revolution and incomplete change' emerges from the agency performing. To unpack the ambiguous causes of this regret, this study adopts the theoretical lens of institutionalization and institutional work to engage in dialogues between structure and action. This study examines the Dihua Chinese New Year Bazaar, critically tagged as a 'night market' in Taipei, and collects data from field study with the guidance of participant observation and historical ethnography. This study reveals that the 'agency loss' emerges because the internal dissociations and discrepancies in actors, actions, and context within the agency mechanism. The agency loss then results in no accumulation of sufficient momentum to change, and keeps a deteriorated institution in the pre-deinstitutionalization stage. In closing, this study discusses theoretical and practical implications.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 方世杰, S. C.,李慶芳, C. F.(2016)。公私部門夥伴關係之特質、整合型研究架構與研究方向。組織與管理，9(2)，1-29。
    連結：
  2. 吳鄭重, C. C.,王伯仁, P. J.(2011)。慶之島的現代奇觀：臺灣新興節慶活動的現象淺描與理論初探。地理研究，54，69-95。
    連結：
  3. 邱淑宜, S. Y.(2016)。城市創意修補及文創工作者的困境－以臺北市為例。都市與計劃，43(1)，1-29。
    連結：
  4. 殷寶寧, P. N.(2016)。創意街區、飲食文化與都市再生：臺北市大稻埕迪化街美食地景與文創轉向。文資學報，10，29-66。
    連結：
  5. 涂敏芬, M. F.,洪世章, S. C.(2012)。有中生有：工研院如何運用B.B.C.策略改造科專制度。管理學報，29(3)，229-254。
    連結：
  6. 蔡依倫, I. L,高明瑞, M. R.(2013)。制度變遷與組織型態創設：身心障礙者社會企業的浮現歷程研究。中山管理評論，21(2)，339-368。
    連結：
  7. 顏亮一, L. Y.(2006)。市民認同、地區發展與都市保存：迪化街個案分析。都市與計劃，33(2)，93-109。
    連結：
  8. Agar, M. H.(1986).Speaking of Ethnography.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  9. Ahmadjian, C. L.,Robinson, P.(2001).Safety in Numbers: Downsizing and the Deinstitutionalization of Permanent Employment in Japan.Administrative Science Quarterly,46(4),622-654.
  10. Alford, R. R.(1998).The Craft of Inquiry: Theories, Methods.New York:Oxford University Press.
  11. Alvesson, M.,Sköldberg, K.(2009).Reflexive Methodology: New Vistas for Qualitative Research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  12. Ankersmit, F.(2013).Representation as A Cognitive Instrument.History and Theory,52(2),171-193.
  13. Ayyagari, M.,Dau, L. A.,Spencer, J.(2015).Strategic Responses to FDI in Emerging Markets: Are Core Members More Responsive than Peripheral Members of Business Groups?.Academy of Management Journal,58(6),1869-1894.
  14. Battilana, J.,Leca, B.,Boxenbaum, E.(2009).How Actors Change Institutions: Towards A Theory of Institutional Entrepreneurship.Academy of Management Annals,3(1),65-107.
  15. Bromley, P.,Powell, W. W.(2012).From Smoke and Mirrors to Walking the Talk: Decoupling in the Contemporary World.Academy of Management Annals,6(1),483-530.
  16. Clegg, S.(ed.),Hardy, C.(ed.),Lawrence, T.(ed.),Nord, W. R.(ed.)(2006).Sage Handbook of Organization Studies.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
  17. Crilly, D.,Zollo, M.,Hansen, M. T.(2012).Faking It or Muddling Through? Understanding Decoupling in Response to Stakeholder Pressures.Academy of Management Journal,55(6),1429-1448.
  18. Cunliffe, A. L.,Alcadipani, R.(2016).The Politics of Access in Fieldwork: Immersion, Backstage Dramas, and Deception.Organizational Research Methods,19(4),535-561.
  19. Dacin, M. T.,Munir, K.,Tracey, P.(2010).Formal Dining at Cambridge Colleges: Linking Ritual Performance and Institutional Maintenance.Academy of Management Journal,53(6),1393-1418.
  20. David, R. J.,Sine, W. D.,Haveman, H. A.(2013).Seizing Opportunity in Emerging Fields: How Institutional Entrepreneurs Legitimated the Professional Form of Management Consulting.Organization Science,24(2),356-377.
  21. Davis, G. F.,Diekmann, K. A.,Tinsley, C. H.(1994).The Decline and Fall of the Conglomerate Firm in the 1980s: The Deinstitutionalization of an Organizational Form.American Sociological Review,59(4),547-570.
  22. Denzin, N. K.(1989).Interpretive Interactionism.Newbury Park:Sage Publications.
  23. DiMaggio, P. J.,Powell, W. W.(1983).The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields.American Sociological Review,48(2),147-160.
  24. Dorado, S.(2013).Small Groups as Context for Institutional Entrepreneurship: An Exploration of the Emergence of Commercial Microfinance in Bolivia.Organization Studies,34(4),533-557.
  25. Emirbayer, M.,Mische, A.(1998).What is Agency?.American Journal of Sociology,103(4),962-1023.
  26. Fligstein, N.(1997).Social Skill and Institutional Theory.American Behavioral Scientist,40(4),397-405.
  27. Ford, J. D.,Ford, L. W.,D’Amelio, A.(2008).Resistance to Change: The Rest of the Story.Academy of Management Review,33(2),362-377.
  28. Glaser, B. G.,Strauss, A. L.(1967).The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research.New York:Aldine de Gruyter.
  29. Greenwood, R.(ed.),Oliver, C.(ed.),Suddaby, R.(ed.),Sahlin, K.(ed.)(2008).Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism.London:Sage.
  30. Greenwood, R.,Raynard, M.,Kodeih, F.,Micelotta, E. R.,Lounsbury, M.(2011).Institutional Complexity and Organizational Responses.Academy of Management Annals,5(1),317-371.
  31. Heaphy, E. D.(2013).Repairing Breaches with Rules: Maintaining Institutions in the Face of Everyday Disruptions.Organization Science,24(5),1291-1315.
  32. Hoffman, A. J.(1999).Institutional Evolution and Change: Environmentalism and the U.S. Chemical Industry.Academy of Management Journal,42(4),351-371.
  33. Johnson, G.,Langley, A.,Melin, L.,Whittington, R.(2007).Strategy as Practice: Research Directions and Resources.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
  34. Johnson, J. M.(1975).Doing Field Research.New York:Free Press.
  35. Jorgensen, D. L.(1989).Participant Observation: A Methodology for Human Studies.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  36. Kaplan, A.(1964).The Conduct of Inquiry.San Francisco Chandler:Chandler.
  37. Kennedy, M. T.,Fiss, P. C.(2009).Institutionalization, Framing, and Diffusion: The Logic of TQM Adoption and Implementation Decisions among U.S. Hospitals.Academy of Management Journal,52(5),897-918.
  38. Khaire, M.,Wadhwani, R. D.(2010).Changing Landscapes: The Construction of Meaning and Value in A New Market Category—Modern Indian Art.Academy of Management Journal,53(6),1281-1304.
  39. Kipping, M.,Üsdiken, B.(2014).History in Organization and Management Theory: More than Meets the Eye.Academy of Management Annals,8(1),535-588.
  40. Kivleniece, I.,Quelin, B. V.(2012).Creating and Capturing Value in Public-Private Ties: A Private Actor's Perspective.Academy of Management Review,37(2),272-299.
  41. Klag, M.,Langley, A.(2013).Approaching the Conceptual Leap in Qualitative Research.International Journal of Management Reviews,15(2),149-166.
  42. Kunisch, S.,Bartunek, J. M.,Mueller, J.,Huy, Q. N.(2017).Time in Strategic Change Research.Academy of Management Annals,11(2),1005-1064.
  43. Langley, A.,Smallman, C.,Tsoukas, H.,Van de Ven, A. H.(2013).Process Studies of Change in Organization and Management: Unveiling Temporality, Activity, and Flow.Academy of Management Journal,56(1),1-13.
  44. Lawrence, T. B.,Leca, B.,Zilber, T. B.(2013).Institutional Work: Current Research, New Directions and Overlooked Issues.Organization Studies,34(8),1023-1033.
  45. Lawrence, T. B.,Suddaby, R.,Leca, B.(2009).Institutional Work: Actors and Agency in Institutional Studies of Organizations.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  46. Lawrence, T. B.,Winn, M. I.,Jennings, P. D.(2001).The Temporal Dynamics of Institutionalization.Academy of Management Review,26(4),624-644.
  47. Lee, C. K.,Hung, S. C.(2014).Institutional Entrepreneurship in the Informal Economy: China's Shan-Zhai Mobile Phones.Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal,8(1),16-36.
  48. Li, Y.(2017).A Semiotic Theory of Institutionalization.Academy of Management Review,42(3),520-547.
  49. Lofland, J.,Snow, D. A.,Anderson, L.,Lofland, L. H.(2005).Analyzing Social Settings: A Guide to Qualitative Observation and Analysis.Belmont, Calif:Wadsworth Publishing.
  50. Lok, J.,De Rond, M.(2013).On the Plasticity of Institutions: Containing and Restoring Practice Breakdowns at the Cambridge University Boat Club.Academy of Management Journal,56(1),185-207.
  51. Maclean, M.,Harvey, C.,Clegg, S. R.(2016).Conceptualizing Historical Organization Studies.Academy of Management Review,41(4),609-632.
  52. Maguire, S.,Hardy, C.(2009).Discourse and Deinstitutionalization: The Decline of DDT.Academy of Management Journal,52(1),148-178.
  53. Meyer, J. W.,Rowan, B.(1977).Institutional Organizations: Structure as Myth and Ceremony.American Journal of Sociology,83(2),340-363.
  54. Meyer, R. E.,Hollerer, M. A.(2010).Meaning Structures in a Contested Issue Field: A Topographic Map of Shareholder Value in Austria.Academy of Management Journal,53(6),1241-1262.
  55. Micelotta, E.,Lounsbury, M.,Greenwood, R.(2017).Pathways of Institutional Change: An Integrative Review and Research Agenda.Journal of Management,43(6),1885-1910.
  56. Mohr, L. B.(1982).Explaining Organizational Behavior.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  57. Oakes, L. S.,Townley, B.,Cooper, D. J.(1998).Business Planning as Pedagogy: Language and Control in A Changing Institutional Field.Administrative Science Quarterly,43(2),257-292.
  58. Oliver, C.(1992).The Antecedents of Deinstitutionalization.Organization Studies,13(4),563-588.
  59. Powell, W. W.(ed.),DiMaggio, P. J.(ed.)(1991).The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis.Chicago:University of Chicago.
  60. Powell, W. W.(ed.),DiMaggio, P. J.(ed.)(1991).The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  61. Quirke, L.(2013).Rogue Resistance: Sidestepping Isomorphic Pressures in A Patchy Institutional Field.Organization Studies,34(11),1675-1699.
  62. Reay, T.,Hinings, C. R.(2005).The Recomposition of an Organizational Field: Health Care in Alberta.Organization Studies,26(3),351-384.
  63. Reay, T.,Hinings, C. R.(2009).Managing the Rivalry of Competing Institutional Logics.Organization Studies,30(6),629-652.
  64. Rottner, R.,Beckman, C.(2012).Making the Invisible Visible: A History of the Spitzer Infrared Telescope Facility [1971-2003].Washington, DC:National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA History Program Office.
  65. Scott, W. R.(2001).Institutions and Organizations.Thousand Oaks, California:Sage Publications.
  66. Seo, M. G.,Creed, W. E. D.(2002).Institutional Contradictions, Praxis, and Institutional Change: A Dialectical Perspective.Academy of Management Review,27(2),222-247.
  67. Tukiainen, S.,Granqvist, N.(2016).Temporary Organizing and Institutional Change.Organization Studies,37(12),1819-1840.
  68. Vaara, E.,Lamberg, J. A.(2016).Taking Historical Embeddedness Seriously: Three Historical Approaches to Advance Strategy Process and Practice Research.Academy of Management Review,41(4),633-657.
  69. Wijen, F.(2014).Means versus Ends in Opaque Institutional Fields: Trading off Compliance and Achievement in Sustainability Standard Adoption.Academy of Management Review,39(3),302-323.
  70. Wijen, F.,Ansari, S.(2007).Overcoming Inaction through Collective Institutional Entrepreneurship: Insights from Regime Theory.Organization Studies,28(7),1079-1100.
  71. Yanow, D.,Tsoukas, H.(2009).What is Reflection-in-Action? A Phenomenological Account.Journal of Management Studies,46(8),1339-1364.
  72. Yue, L. Q.,Luo, J.,Ingram, P.(2013).The Failure of Private Regulation: Elite Control and Market Crises in the Manhattan Banking Industry.Administrative Science Quarterly,58(1),37-68.
  73. Zietsma, C.,Groenewegen, P.,Logue, D. M.,Hinings, C. R. B.(2017).Field or Fields? Building the Scaffolding for Cumulation of Research on Institutional Fields.Academy of Management Annals,11(1),391-450.
  74. Zietsma, C.,Lawrence, T. B.(2010).Institutional Work in the Transformation of an Organizational Field: The Interplay of Boundary Work and Practice Work.Administrative Science Quarterly,55(2),189-221.
  75. Zucker, L. G. (ed.)(1988).Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment.Cambridge, MA:Ballinger.
  76. Zucker, L. G.(ed.)(1988).Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment.Cambridge, MA:Ballinger.
  77. 余舜德, S. D.(1999)。夜市研究與臺灣社會。人類學在臺灣的發展：經驗研究篇，臺北市=Taipei:
  78. 容邵武, S. W.(2013)。文化親密性與社區營造：在地公共性的民族誌研究。臺灣社會學刊，53，55-102。
  79. 戴伯芬, P. F.(1994)。誰做攤販？－臺灣攤販的歷史形構。臺灣社會研究季刊，17，121-148。
被引用次数
  1. 蔡依倫(2021)。延遲改變：永續轉型過程的捍衛制度工作。管理學報，38(4)，411-443。
print cancel