题名

以ADDIE為基礎之職能專家知識地圖建構法

并列篇名

An ADDIE-based Knowledge-Mapping Method for Finding Expert Support to Develop Competency-Based Progr ams

DOI

10.6160/SYSMR.202203_30(2).0001

作者

鄭滄祥(Tsang-Hsiang Cheng)；曾智義(Chih-Yi Tseng)；丁淑方(Shu‐Fang Ting)

关键词

知識地圖 ； 職能導向課程 ； 知識管理 ； 課程品保 ； Knowledge Map ； Competency-Based Program ； Knowledge Management ； Curriculum Quality Assurance

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

30卷2期（2022 / 03 / 01）

页次

259 - 292

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

職能導向課程可用以強化企業與學校對人才的職能培育。勞動部為協助國內企業及學校機構規劃系統化及有效的課程，因而發展一套ADDIE課程設計模型輔助訓練課程地圖設計及搭建職能學習鷹架。為確保訓練課程品質，勞動部也依據ADDIE五大設計構面架構iCAP課程品質認證系統。因推動初期，各機構不易覓得合適的專家提供協助，因此本研究以ADDIE課程品質指標進行知識分類，提出職能專家知識地圖建構法，將課程設計專家知識的分布狀況視覺化。本研究以南部17位職能專家為例，運用知識地圖建構法進行職能專家的知識盤點與評量，進而繪製專家職能領域與層級的知識地圖雛型，讓訓練單位於發展課程時易尋得適合的專家協助，藉以發展高品質的職能導向課程。
英文摘要

Competence-oriented curriculum contributes to the cultivation of professional competence in a Taiwan's cooperation and educational institutions. Taiwan's Ministry of Labor has developed the ADDIE curriculum model tailored to the needs for creating systematic and effective training programs. The application of the new model assists curriculum planner to create appropriate learning scaffolds for trainees. To ensure the quality of the training programs, the Ministry of Labor has also designed the iCAP course quality certification system based on the ADDIE model that helps educational institutions develop competency-based programs (CBPs). As it is challenging to find experts of the field in the early stages of CBPs curriculum design, this study aims to propose an ADDIE-based knowledge-mapping method that helps to show the distribution of expert knowledge for course design counseling. This study also presents the application of the proposed knowledge-mapping method to build a prototype of competency-based knowledge map with the participation of 17 experts from southern Taiwan. We hope that each training unit can easily grasp the distribution of experts’ knowledge on CBPs curriculum design and obtain appropriate course consultation and assistance to develop high-quality CBPs.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 林怡君, Y. C.,范凱棠, K. T.,陳心懿, S. Y.,李郁澄, Y.,C.(2014)。台灣人力資源專業人員訓練設計職能量表發展。交大管理學報，34(1)，141-176。
    連結：
  2. 潘瑛如, Y. R.,李隆盛, L. S.,黃藍瑩, L. Y.(2014)。科技大學學生共通職能表現及其對課程地圖的意涵。課程與教學季刊，17(3)，61-84。
    連結：
  3. Akhavan, P.,Pezeshkan, A.(2013).Developing A Knowledge Map-Driven Framework for Human Resources Strategy Formulation: A Knowledge-Based IT Company Case Study in Iran.Journal of Knowledge-based Innovation in China,5(3),234-261.
  4. Allen, W. C.(2006).Overview and Evolution of The ADDIE Training System.Advances in Developing Human Resources,8(4),430-441.
  5. Allen, W. C.,Swanson, R. A.(2006).Systematic Training-Straightforward and Effective.Advances in Developing Human Resources,8(4),427-429.
  6. Arthur, W. J.,Bennett, W. J.,Edens, P. S.,Bell, S. T.(2003).Effectiveness of Training in Organizations: A Meta-Analysis of Design and Evaluation Features.Journal of Applied Psychology,88(2),234-245.
  7. Balaid, A.,Rozan, M. Z. A.,Hikmi, S. N.,Memon, J.(2016).Knowledge Maps: A Systematic Literature Review and Directions for Future Research.International Journal of Information Management,36(3),451-475.
  8. Bargent, J., 2002, "11 Steps to Building a Knowledge Map," http://providersedge.com/docs/km_articles/11_Steps_to_Building_a_K_Map.pdf, accessed on February 23, 2018.
  9. Barrie, S.(2007).A Conceptual Framework for the Teaching and Learning of Generic Graduate Attributes.Studies in Higher Education,32(4),439-458.
  10. Branch, R.(2009).Instructional Design: The ADDIE approach.New York:Springer.
  11. Brauer, S.(2021).Towards Competence-oriented Higher Education: A Systematic Literature Review of the Different Perspectives on Successful Exit Profiles.Education + Training,63(9),1376-1390.
  12. Campion, M. A.,Fink, A. A.,Ruggeberg, B. J.,Carr, L.,Phillips, G. M.,Odman, R. B.(2011).Doing Competencies Well: Best Practices in Competency Modeling.Personnel Psychology,64(1),225-262.
  13. Dick, W.,Carey, L.(2011).The Systematic Design of Instruction.Dallas Texas:Harper Collins.
  14. Eppler, M. J.(2006).A Comparison between Concept Maps, Mind Maps, Conceptual Diagrams, and Visual Metaphors as Complementary Tools for Knowledge Construction and Sharing.Information Visualization,5,202-210.
  15. Eppler, M. J.(2001).Making Knowledge Visible through Intranet Knowledge Maps: Concepts, Elements, Cases.Proceedings of the 34th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences,Hawaii, USA.:
  16. Eppler, M. J.,Mengis, J.(2004).The Concept of Information Overload: A Review of Literature from Organization Science, Accounting, Marketing, MIS, and Related Disciplines.The Information Society,20(5),325-344.
  17. Eppler, M. J.,Simon, H. A.(2008).A Process-Based Classification of Knowledge Maps and Application Examples.Knowledge and Process Management,15(1),59-71.
  18. Ermine, J.,Boughzala, I.,Tounkara, T.(2006).Critical Knowledge Map as A Decision Tool for Knowledge Transfer Actions.Electronic Journal of Knowledge Management,4,129-140.
  19. Gagné, R. M.,Wager, W. W.,Golas, K. C.,Keller, J. M.(2005).Principles of Instructional Design.Belmont, CA:Wadsworth/Thompson Learning.
  20. Haller, H.,Abecker, A.(2010).Designing A Knowledge Mapping Tool for Knowledge Workers.Proceedings of the 14th Knowledge-based and Intelligent Information and Engineering Systems,Cardiff, UK:
  21. Hao, J.,Yan, Y.,Gong, L.,Wang, G.,Lin, J.(2014).Knowledge Map-Based Method for Domain Knowledge Browsing.Decision Support Systems,61,106-114.
  22. Hartman, F. Z.,Bann, C.,Barton, B.,Pearce, K.(2016).Making A Difference: Faculty Development in Competency Based Education.Higher Learning Commission Annual Conference 2016,Chicago, USA:
  23. Holmboe, E. S.,Ward, D. S.,Reznick, R. K.,Katsufrakis, P. J.,Leslie, K. M.,Patel, V. L.,Nelson, E. A.(2011).Faculty Development in Assessment: The Missing Link in Competency-Based Medical Education.Academic Medicine,86(4),460-467.
  24. Jacobs, R. L.(2006).ISO 10015-The Trend of Training Quality.Training Magazine,43(8),2-4.
  25. Jafari, M., Akhavan, P., and Bourouni, A., 2009, "A Framework for The Selection of Knowledge Mapping Techniques," http://www.tlainc.com/articl180.htm/, accessed on February 23, 2018.
  26. Kim, S.,Suh, E.,Hwang, H.(2003).Building The Knowledge Map: An Industrial Case Study.Journal of Knowledge Management,7(2),34-45.
  27. Leyer, M.,Schneider, C.,Claus, N.(2016).Would You Like to Know Who Knows? Connecting Employees Based on Process-Oriented Knowledge Mapping.Decision Support Systems,87,94-104.
  28. Liebowitz, J.,Rubenstein-Montano, B.,McCaw, D.,Buchwalter, J.,Browning, C.(2000).The Knowledge Audit.Knowledge and Process Management,7(1),3-10.
  29. Lin, F.,Hsueh, C.(2006).Knowledge Map Creation and Maintenance for Virtual Communities of Practice.Information Processing & Management,42(2),551-568.
  30. Lin, Y. C.,Jacobs, R. L.(2008).The Perceptions of Human Resource Development Professionals in Taiwan Regarding Their Working Relationships With Subject Matter Experts (SMES) During The Training Design Process.Human Resource Development International,11(3),237-252.
  31. Liu, D. R.,Ke, C. K.,Lee, J. Y.,Lee, C. F.(2008).Knowledge Maps for Composite E-Services: A Mining-Based System Platform Coupling with Recommendations.Expert Systems with Applications,34(1),700-716.
  32. Liu, L.,Li, J.,Lv, C.(2009).A Method for Enterprise Knowledge Map Construction Based on Social Classification.Systems Research and Behavioral Science,205(2),541-551.
  33. Liu, P.,Li, X.(2011).The Application of Expertise Knowledge Map in Human Resource Management.Proceedings of 2011 International Conference on Management and Service Science (MASS),Wuhan, China:
  34. Logan, D.,Caldwell, F.(2000).Knowledge Mapping: Five Key Dimensions to Consider.California:Gartner Group.
  35. Mansingh, G.,Osei-Bryson, K. M.(2009).Building Ontology-Based Knowledge Maps to Assist Knowledge Process Outsourcing Decisions.Knowledge Management Research & Practice,7(1),37-51.
  36. Mirabile, R. J.(1997).Everything You Wanted to Know About Competency Modeling.Training & Development,51(8),73-77.
  37. Noe, R. A.(2012).Employee Training and Development.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  38. Probst, G.,Raub, S.,Romhardt, K.(2000).Managing Knowledge-Building Blocks for Success.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
  39. Rao, L.,Mansingh, G.,Osei-Bryson, K. M.(2012).Building Ontology Based Knowledge Maps to Assist Business Process Re-Engineering.Decision Support Systems,52(3),577-589.
  40. Salas, E.,Stagl, K. C.(2015).Design Training Systematically and Follow the Science of Training.Handbook of Principle of Organizational Behavior,UK:
  41. Van Daal, B.,de Haas, M.,Weggeman, M.(1998).The Knowledge Matrix: A Participatory Method for Individual Knowledge Gap Determination.Knowledge and Process Management,5(4),255-263.
  42. Vestal, W.(2005).Knowledge Mapping: The Essentials for Success.Houston, TX:APQC Publications.
  43. Watthananona J,Mingkhwanb, A.(2012).Optimizing Knowledge Management Using Knowledge Map.Procedia Engineering,32,1169-1177.
  44. Wexler, M. N.(2001).The Who, What and Why of Knowledge Mapping.Journal of Knowledge Management,5(3),249-264.
  45. Yang, C.,Liu, Z.,Wang, H.,Shen, J.(2013).Reusing Design Knowledge Based on Design Cases and Knowledge Map.International Journal of Technology and Design Education,23(4),1063-1077.
  46. Yasin, F.,Egbu, C.(2011).Critical Steps to Knowledge Mapping in Facilities Management Organization.Proceedings of 27th Annual ARCOM Conference,Bristol, UK:
  47. Zhao, G.,Miao, P.,Guan, Y.(2013).Construction of Intelligence Knowledge Map for Complex Product Development.Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review,6(3),82-87.
  48. 林東清, D. C.(2009).知識管理.臺北=Taipei:智勝出版社=Best-Wise Publishing Co., Ltd..
  49. 勞動部勞動力發展署，2017，「職能基準發展指引」，https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Knowledge/Knowledge_downLoad.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018. (Workforce Development Agency, Ministry of Labor, 2017, “Guidelines for Development of Competency Standard,” https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Knowledge/Knowledge_downLoad.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018.)
  50. 勞動部勞動力發展署，2014a，「職能導向課程品質管理認證說明」，https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Quality/quality_course.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018. (Workforce Development Agency, Ministry of Labor, 2014a, “Instruction for Quality Management of Competency-based Programs Certification,” https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Quality/quality_course.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018.)
  51. 勞動部勞動力發展署，2014b，「職能導向課程發展指引」，https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Knowledge/Knowledge_downLoad.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018. (Workforce Development Agency, Ministry of Labor, 2014b, “Guidelines for Development of Competency-based Programs,” https://icap.wda.gov.tw/Knowledge/Knowledge_downLoad.aspx, accessed on February 23, 2018.)
  52. 臺灣教育傳播暨科技學會（編）(2009).教育科技−理論與實務.臺北=Taipei:學富文化=Pro-Ed Inc..
  53. 賴昶樺, C. H.(2013)。賴昶樺，2013，推動職能發展及應用，職能導向課程品質認證暨補助草案說明會資料，台南。(Lai, C. H., 2013, “Promotion on Development and Application of Professional Competency,” Seminar document in Quality Certification and Subsidy for Competency-Based Program, Tainan.)。
print cancel